View Full Version : Missing Georgia hiker--Meredith Emerson, 24
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 09:23 AM
Search Resumes Today For Missing Georgia Hiker
UNION COUNTY, Ga. -- The search resumes Thursday morning in Union County for a missing hiker and her dog.
Friends believe Meredith Emerson, 24, from Gwinnett County, spent Tuesday and Wednesday night outside in the cold north Georgia mountains. Temperatures reached into the teens both nights.
Emerson's friends said she went hiking with her dog on Blood Mountain Trail Tuesday. Authorities said they have located Emerson's car and her dog's leash, but they have found no sign of Emerson or her black Lab.
Police also found a police baton and a pair of sunglasses near Emerson's car.
Another hiker told officials he saw a man with a similar baton clipped to his belt hiking on the same trail that Emerson took.
Read on: http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
Taximom
01-03-2008, 09:29 AM
Does anyone know what that significance of the baton means? Is that something all hikers carry?
I hope she and her dog are ok.
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 09:33 AM
Does anyone know what that significance of the baton means? Is that something all hikers carry?
I hope she and her dog are ok.
From what I know, it is not a common tool to bring hiking. But I could be wrong. Might people carry one to fend off bears? I can't think of any other purpose it may serve.
By the way, some of the news stories I've read say that they indeed found a dog collar, but are not sure if it belonged to Meredith's dog or not. The article linked above states that the dog collar did belong to Meredith's dog, but other stories say different.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 09:59 AM
They found a dog collar and water bottle but aren't sure if it is hers. Sub-freezing temperatures in the mountains...I hope they find her today.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
Pandora
01-03-2008, 10:07 AM
Does anyone know what that significance of the baton means? Is that something all hikers carry?
I hope she and her dog are ok.
Meredith had a blue belt, so it may have been something she felt comfortable using to defend herself or her dog. Of course, it could also be something she threw for the dog to fetch. (Weird, but not out of the realm of possibility.)
christine2448
01-03-2008, 10:16 AM
Her car was found in the trailhead parking lot, covered in snow. But there was no sign of Meredith or her dog.
While the sheriff's department and GEMA are handing it as a missing persons' case, there are some details that have friends concerned. According to her roommate, a former police officer hiking on the trail on Tuesday said he recalled seeing her and her dog and that he also noticed a man on the trail that gave him an uneasy feeling. That man was carrying a police baton.
The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.
All of that information is being checked into and the former officer returned to the scene Thursday morning to help pinpoint the area where he saw the suspicious man.
http://www.11alive.com/news/article_news.aspx?storyid=108958
Taximom
01-03-2008, 10:45 AM
This young dog owner is missing in GA too. Are they close in location?
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?t=58041
christine2448
01-03-2008, 11:01 AM
According to workers at the Visitors Center, someone saw Emerson coming down the mountain, trailed by someone with a police baton.
WXIA reports a hiker turned in a dog leash, two water bottles and a police baton to the Visitors Center. Emerson's car was also found. According to WXIA, the significance of the findings was not realized until later; authorities do not know the identity of the hiker who turned in the belongings but they would like to speak to him because he may have seen something.
According to WXIA, despite the finding of the police baton, the Union County Sheriff's Department is considering this a missing person search, not a criminal investigation.
http://www.9news.com/news/local/article.aspx?storyid=83799
Reported a bit differently here.
Also, several articles on the net are saying NO FOUL PLAY SUSPECTED...huh?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 11:05 AM
Also, several articles on the net are saying NO FOUL PLAY SUSPECTED...huh?
I agree with you, christine. I've read all the news reports on this and they seem somewhat contradictory. When you have a witness saying he saw a man with a police baton on the trail and that baton is later found with some of Meredith's belongings, why would foul play be ruled out here? The authorities seems to want to project that this is just a missing persons case, not a criminal situation. Perhaps they want to draw someone out, give him a false sense of security?
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 11:16 AM
I agree with you, christine. I've read all the news reports on this and they seem somewhat contradictory. When you have a witness saying he saw a man with a police baton on the trail and that baton is later found with some of Meredith's belongings, why would foul play be ruled out here? The authorities seems to want to project that this is just a missing persons case, not a criminal situation. Perhaps they want to draw someone out, give him a false sense of security?
I agree with both of you...something is really odd here.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 11:49 AM
AJC is confirming that it is Meredith's water bottle and dog leash.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 11:57 AM
Now saying that GBI has joined the search. This must mean they expect some foul play.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 12:08 PM
I don't hike - go through the trails maybe, but not like that - So forgive my ignorace =)
But - is having your dog off lead something that is normal to do? Does it depend on the dog etc? Not sure what type of certificate she's holding in the one pic released of her and her dog, but I was thinking she's done some type of training with it (dog).
Has anyone searched petfinder or called the local shelters in that area to see if they've had a "drop off" or a pickup complaint of a dead animal that matches her dog's description?
I know it seems I'm focusing on the dog. BUT if I were going to do something, The dog would be the first thing that would be "dealt" with. That's just based on personal history w/ My dog though. If it came down to it, I know/seen what he'll do/ is capable of.
Or am I "barking up the wrong tree" here?
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 12:12 PM
Officials are looking for a person of interest seen descending the trail at the same time as Meredith. He is described as a white male between 50-60 years old with bad teeth.
I hope someone saw what type of vehicles were around at the time. This sounds like an abduction for sure.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 12:29 PM
Updated news report. Looking for a man with a red retriever named Danny seen talking to Meredith.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 12:40 PM
Updated news report. Looking for a man with a red retriever named Danny seen talking to Meredith.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
Never heard of a 'red retriever'. Maybe it was an Irish Setter? What other types of dogs are red-colored? I hope the police are doing a cross-check of dog license records in the area.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 12:46 PM
Never heard of a 'red retriever'. Maybe it was an Irish Setter? What other types of dogs are red-colored? I hope the police are doing a cross-check of dog license records in the area.
If this guy was local it seems someone would recognize the description of him and his dog. I don't think dog licenses are required for ownership in Georgia but I stand to be corrected.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 01:00 PM
A darker haired golden retriever, lighter type chocolate lab, anytype of a mixed breed. (Lab/whatever cross) Irish Setters,
When I googled "red retreiver" I came up with this image -
http://www.grangeville.us/idahocounty/police/animalcontrol/2007/03/red-retriever-type-dog-found-on-s-c-st.htm
http://www.grangeville.us/idahocounty/police/animalcontrol/2007/03/red-retriever-type-dog-found-on-s-c-st.htm
No doggie expert here - but the one in the pic looks to be a golden mix of some sort. Could be totally offbase but maybe this is similiar to what the person was trying to describe to LE?
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 01:09 PM
A darker haired golden retriever, lighter type chocolate lab, anytype of a mixed breed. (Lab/whatever cross) Irish Setters,
When I googled "red retreiver" I came up with this image -
http://www.grangeville.us/idahocounty/police/animalcontrol/2007/03/red-retriever-type-dog-found-on-s-c-st.htm
file:///C:/DOCUME%7E1/OWNER%7E1.LIL/LOCALS%7E1/Temp/moz-screenshot-3.jpghttp://www.grangeville.us/idahocounty/police/animalcontrol/2007/03/red-retriever-type-dog-found-on-s-c-st.htm
No doggie expert here - but the one in the pic looks to be a golden mix of some sort. Could be totally offbase but maybe this is the person was trying to describe to LE?
Not being an expert on dogs, I would say that if I had to give a description of that dog in the pic.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 01:11 PM
Here is what concerns me.We have an ex-police officer turning in miscellaneous "trail-trash" to a shopkeeper before there is any indication of any kind of crime. One of the items is a police baton. This ex-officer also happens to have witnessed the now missing girl talking with...are you ready?..."a weathered looking man with a dog named Danny". Sounds like a character in a scary story to me. Kind of like the characters who "kidnapped" the run-away bride, or the black man with the knit cap who "carjacked" Susan Smith and her babies. The more natural reaction for a cop who sees a young lady in the wilderness, talking to a suspicious-looking much older man would be to speak to both of them to get a feel for the situation. A casual hello, enjoying your hike?...you live around here?...ever hiked such and such trail?...Maybe even an offer to accompany the young lady to her vehicle.I just think it is weird that the ex-cop saw this situation, apparently did not investigate further with even a casual bit of conversation, yet he sees fit to collect evidence of a crime before the girl was reported missing and turn it in to a store employee rather than LE.If I were a young lady hiking in the wilderness, I would probably not give that doggie looking old man more than a casual nod, much less become engaged in conversation with him. I might however, trust a cop to escort me safely to my car.It will be interesting to see if this girl or her dog are found with wounds from a police baton.If anyone can get the name of this ex-cop, it could be very enlightening, or at least provide a means to eliminate him as a suspect, which he still is, in my mind.Susan
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 01:12 PM
A golden retriever sometimes has reddish hair.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 01:18 PM
Susan, I understand what you are saying and it could still be a possibility but the wsb article above said that "Hikers" saw her talking to this older man. Meaning more than one person. Also, the person who found the baton etc. turned it in to the Visitor Center. As the story gets updated a few more things become apparent than the first story.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 01:19 PM
I don't hike - go through the trails maybe, but not like that - So forgive my ignorace =)
But - is having your dog off lead something that is normal to do? Does it depend on the dog etc? Not sure what type of certificate she's holding in the one pic released of her and her dog, but I was thinking she's done some type of training with it (dog).
Has anyone searched petfinder or called the local shelters in that area to see if they've had a "drop off" or a pickup complaint of a dead animal that matches her dog's description?
I know it seems I'm focusing on the dog. BUT if I were going to do something, The dog would be the first thing that would be "dealt" with. That's just based on personal history w/ My dog though. If it came down to it, I know/seen what he'll do/ is capable of.
Or am I "barking up the wrong tree" here?
I used to hike and camp a lot before I developed a foot problem. You never take your dog off their leash. And for the most part, victims of foul play usually don't have a dog with them. Dogs are a deterent to two legged creatures. However, they attract four legged ones because they view dogs as a food source. For that reason it's not a good idea to hike with a dog at all.
The LE friend and the sighting of the other person is just too wierd for words. Finding the batton, water bottles and leash is very strange. In all my years of hiking and walking trails, I've never found a batton or seen one on another person. And I've never seen a leash or collar laying around.
Two things come to mind. They were attacked by an animal and she let her dog off the leash and bacame prey herself as well. Or her dog went into water because she let him off the leash and got into trouble going after the dog.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 01:24 PM
I used to hike and camp a lot before I developed a foot problem. You never take your dog off their leash. And for the most part, victims of foul play usually don't have a dog with them. Dogs are a deterent to two legged creatures. However, they attract four legged ones because they view dogs as a food source. For that reason it's not a good idea to hike with a dog at all.
The LE friend and the sighting of the other person is just too wierd for words. Finding the batton, water bottles and leash is very strange. In all my years of hiking and walking trails, I've never found a batton or seen one on another person. And I've never seen a leash or collar laying around.
Two things come to mind. They were attacked by an animal and she let her dog off the leash and bacame prey herself as well. Or her dog went into water because she let him off the leash and got into trouble going after the dog.
Thanks for the insight on the hiking with animals!
Maybe I misunderstood, I *thought* the baton and stuff was located right by her car. Is there a body of water or anything near her vehicle that she would have let the dog go to? On one of the links there was an updated pic, looks like the "Puppy" isn't a puppy any longer...I'm hoping for the best with this one, but I feel the worst may have happened unfortunately.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 01:30 PM
SuziQ wrote:Two things come to mind. They were attacked by an animal and she let her dog off the leash and bacame prey herself as well. Or her dog went into water because she let him off the leash and got into trouble going after the dog.----------------------------------------------------------------Those sound like good possibilities to me, but it still seems like a strange coincidence about the baton and sunglasses near her car. A baton and sunglasses are two things that could make a person appear to be a cop, and why were they near her car?I need to learn a few things before I go hiking with my dog. I would have probably let her off the leash because she enjoyes running so much. I can see now that it would not be a good idea!
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 01:31 PM
Jinxie, I'm confused as to some of the facts as well. They are different in each article. I could see a leash being taken off, but the collar? One of the reasons I never take my dog off a leash is they could spot a rabbit or something and just take off after it. Even the best trained dogs do this, and there is no prayer in the world of stopping or catching up to them.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 01:33 PM
Updated article 1:20 Eastern.
Other hikers describe the man as white between 50-60 years old with a reddish dog. He is also described as having on a yellow jacket with a large backpack and some kind of sheath attached to his leg.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 01:34 PM
SuziQ wrote:Two things come to mind. They were attacked by an animal and she let her dog off the leash and bacame prey herself as well. Or her dog went into water because she let him off the leash and got into trouble going after the dog.----------------------------------------------------------------Those sound like good possibilities to me, but it still seems like a strange coincidence about the baton and sunglasses near her car. A baton and sunglasses are two things that could make a person appear to be a cop, and why were they near her car?I need to learn a few things before I go hiking with my dog. I would have probably let her off the leash because she enjoyes running so much. I can see now that it would not be a good idea!
Accidents do happen all the time, but it's the human element here that bothers me. If the items were found near her car at the trailhead, then I doubt she was attacked by an animal. And do we really know if more than one person spotted the baton toting person? Every article is different.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 01:37 PM
When using a leash with my lab mix, I attache it to a harness rather than the collar, so it won't hurt her neck. I have to watch out to be sure I get the harness all of the way past the collar so they won't get tangled. I can see how, if I were holding the leash attached to the harness, and someone tried to hurt me, my dog would jump on them, and they might grab her collar and pull it off in the struggle. Susan
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 01:41 PM
Jinxie, I'm confused as to some of the facts as well. They are different in each article. I could see a leash being taken off, but the collar? One of the reasons I never take my dog off a leash is they could spot a rabbit or something and just take off after it. Even the best trained dogs do this, and there is no prayer in the world of stopping or catching up to them.
After talking talking dh's head off about this case he brought up a friend of ours who used to hike w/ her dog. She used to use a slip collar on her in case while exploring she would get caught on something. Does anyone know if they've released what type of collar/leash etc.
Also, does anyone know if they've tried to track the baton down? Sometimes only certain companies only deal w/ certain "brands" or will sell only to certain companies/areas. I understand he could have picked it up anywhere, and it may in fact not be a "true" police baton.
Has anyone else seen where it was stated the person they are looking for (not suspect yet, but I guess maybe a person of interest at this point?) had a large sheath attached to his side/leg? Could there be two different people and because of what this guy had on his leg the assumption is being that he is one and the same? I haven't seen anything stated about him wearing sunglasses, and it seems to me that it would be unlikely they would just "fall out" if he weren't wearing them. (going on thing, i would think they would be in a backpack etc)
BUT at the same time, if someone is noticing he's missing teeth, why wouldn't they notice he was wearing sunglasses?
I'm not trying to take away interest in finding either party, just trying to figure out if they are looking at the right (guy)for the right reasons.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 01:41 PM
When using a leash with my lab mix, I attache it to a harness rather than the collar, so it won't hurt her neck. I have to watch out to be sure I get the harness all of the way past the collar so they won't get tangled. I can see how, if I were holding the leash attached to the harness, and someone tried to hurt me, my dog would jump on them, and they might grab her collar and pull it off in the struggle. Susan
I agree that the collar being off would indicate a struggle. I've gone through that just trying to get my dogs into the vet!
I can't get WSB to open for me. But it sounds like there is more than just the LE officer that witnessed the other guy. Another thing that bothers me is if she made it back to the trailhead, then she probably isn't lost as she was probably on her way home. Really not much trouble to get into at a trailhead.
ThoughtFox
01-03-2008, 01:44 PM
Union County is in the mountains and it has been freezing the past few days - I mean bitter cold and wind.
All the big animals are in hibernation. Snakes and Bears would not be out and about this time of year, which usually makes this a good time to go hiking. Except that most people wouldn't go out when snow is forecast in the mountains and the temperature is dropping.
Someone might have a baton to fight off dogs or wild boars, and then there are foxes and bobcats which are much smaller. Otherwise, there is no real reason to arm yourself in that area.
That wasn't just any trail either, but the Appalachian Trail. That is a very rugged part of the Trail, with ridges that go up and down, and those valleys would get dark early and very cold. It's wild there.
However this (http://www.9news.com/news/local/article.aspx?storyid=83799) article says she was from Colorado, which is probably why she wasn't afraid to hike there. Going there alone was probably not a good idea, though, because it is remote, and the trails are empty this time of year.
This isn't just a walking trail, but wilderness, so I'm not surprised she let the dog off the leash. Perhaps she had one of those harnesses with an attached collar, and that's what they might be talking about. I doubt the actual collar was found, unless that dog is like mine and tries to slip out of the collar if you grab hold of it? (Sorry - I see some of the rest of you already posted that idea!)
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 01:48 PM
Accidents do happen all the time, but it's the human element here that bothers me. If the items were found near her car at the trailhead, then I doubt she was attacked by an animal. And do we really know if more than one person spotted the baton toting person? Every article is different.
I can see how, in situations such as this, eye-witness accounts can get jumbled together. Say, several hickers recall a mid-fifties man with a dog, one remembers the backpack, another hears him call out to the dog by name. I wonder if the bit about the baton came from the cop or if others saw a sheath only, which could have contained any number of things...baton, knife, flashlight, pepper spray etc.I'd still like some names, if anyone comes across any. My thinking on the ex-cop was that if he did anything to her with the baton and knew she would eventually be found, it would seem smart to say he saw her with someone he knew others would remember on the trail, such as a drifter he's seen before.Also, why is he "ex"?...Retired, fired, pursueing a more profitable career?Susan
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 01:49 PM
Union County is in the mountains and it has been freezing the past few days - I mean bitter cold and wind.
All the big animals are in hibernation. Snakes and Bears would not be out and about this time of year, which usually makes this a good time to go hiking. Except that most people wouldn't go out when snow is forecast in the mountains and the temperature is dropping.
Someone might have a baton to fight off dogs or wild boars, and then there are foxes and bobcats which are much smaller. Otherwise, there is no real reason to arm yourself in that area.
That wasn't just any trail either, but the Appalachian Trail. That is a very rugged part of the Trail, with ridges that go up and down, and those valleys would get dark early and very cold. It's wild there.
However this (http://www.9news.com/news/local/article.aspx?storyid=83799) article says she was from Colorado, which is probably why she wasn't afraid to hike there. Going there alone was probably not a good idea, though, because it is remote, and the trails are empty this time of year.
This isn't just a walking trail, but wilderness, so I'm not surprised she let the dog off the leash. Perhaps she had one of those harnesses with an attached collar, and that's what they might be talking about. I doubt the actual collar was found, unless that dog is like mine and tries to slip out of the collar if you grab hold of it? (Sorry - I see some of the rest of you already posted that idea!)
Thoughtfox -
Thanks for the headsup about the area - puts things a bit more into perspective now that I can sort of imagine the type of trails/areas this is in. I was thinking it was more along the lines of groomed trails but "in the wilderness" if that makes sense?
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 01:51 PM
The kind of collar/leash would indicate if it could have even come off in a struggle or not. I've seen alot of people use break-away collars on active dogs.
I don't know what kind of wildlife is in that area at all. Out west the biggest threat at this time of year is mountain lions. But they usually leave an obvious trail. So I'm pretty sure authorities have ruled that out by now.
This whole case is creepy and doesn't look good, IMO.
christine2448
01-03-2008, 01:55 PM
Susan, I understand what you are saying and it could still be a possibility but the wsb article above said that "Hikers" saw her talking to this older man. Meaning more than one person. Also, the person who found the baton etc. turned it in to the Visitor Center. As the story gets updated a few more things become apparent than the first story.
In one article I posted it stated that the WORKERS at the VISITOR center saw this man talking w/her I believe..I will go get it..but there are several reporting and reporting differently:
According to workers at the Visitors Center, someone saw Emerson coming down the mountain, trailed by someone with a police baton.
WXIA reports a hiker turned in a dog leash, two water bottles and a police baton to the Visitors Center. Emerson's car was also found. According to WXIA, the significance of the findings was not realized until later; authorities do not know the identity of the hiker who turned in the belongings but they would like to speak to him because he may have seen something.
According to WXIA, despite the finding of the police baton, the Union County Sheriff's Department is considering this a missing person search, not a criminal investigation.
http://www.9news.com/news/local/arti...?storyid=83799 (http://www.9news.com/news/local/article.aspx?storyid=83799)
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 01:56 PM
Im confused - the (ex)cop (sideline why is he an ex? retirement? fired? quit? etc?)
Did he turn in the stuff before she "went missing" and then came back around when it was reported she was? Or was the stuff turned in AFTER she was reported missing?
Sorry if I appear "not with it" but something is really bugging me here, and I can't quite put my finger on it yet. Just that "feeling" anyone else?
christine2448
01-03-2008, 01:57 PM
SuziQ wrote:Two things come to mind. They were attacked by an animal and she let her dog off the leash and bacame prey herself as well. Or her dog went into water because she let him off the leash and got into trouble going after the dog.----------------------------------------------------------------Those sound like good possibilities to me, but it still seems like a strange coincidence about the baton and sunglasses near her car. A baton and sunglasses are two things that could make a person appear to be a cop, and why were they near her car?I need to learn a few things before I go hiking with my dog. I would have probably let her off the leash because she enjoyes running so much. I can see now that it would not be a good idea!
And they are MALE sunglasses. Not for a lady.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 02:01 PM
Im confused - the (ex)cop (sideline why is he an ex? retirement? fired? quit? etc?)
Did he turn in the stuff before she "went missing" and then came back around when it was reported she was? Or was the stuff turned in AFTER she was reported missing?
Sorry if I appear "not with it" but something is really bugging me here, and I can't quite put my finger on it yet. Just that "feeling" anyone else?
I want to know more about this witness.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 02:06 PM
Is the below quote the last sighting of them?
The man was accompanied by a dog, a "dark reddish-colored retriever," who answered to the name Danny, she said. She said at one point, Emerson and the man both let their dogs run free, then followed the two dogs as they ran up the mountain.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/03/missing.hiker/index.html
ThoughtFox
01-03-2008, 02:07 PM
Maps from Google Earth - you can see that this is out in the middle of nowhere. The visitors center must be the roof to the right of the parking area. Blood Mountain Trail seems to split off the main Appy Trail.
Edited to Add: These pics are obviously from the summer. In winter, there would be much less leaf cover, even though I'm sure some of those are pine and cedar trees. Mostly they would be deciduous and would just be bare branches in winter.
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v624/sip44/AppalachianTrail-MeredithEmerson-1.jpg
http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v624/sip44/AppalachianTrail-MeredithEmersonMap.jpg
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 02:10 PM
I didn't see this before. I just added Meredith to the Missing forum. Meredith is the best friend of a poster I know on another board. As you can imagine, she is frantic with worry.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 02:15 PM
Is the below quote the last sighting of them?
The man was accompanied by a dog, a "dark reddish-colored retriever," who answered to the name Danny, she said. She said at one point, Emerson and the man both let their dogs run free, then followed the two dogs as they ran up the mountain.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/03/missing.hiker/index.html
Now this article says her mittens and sunglasses (not confirmed by police) were found near the baton and water bottle and leash.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 02:16 PM
Misterallgood....Huff are you here?
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 02:21 PM
I didn't see this before. I just added Meredith to the Missing forum. Meredith is the best friend of a poster I know on another board. As you can imagine, she is frantic with worry.
Great, thanks KrisNine!Why don't you invite your friend to join us at WS? I'm sorry she has to deal with the limbo of not knowing what happened to her friend! If it were me, I would want to be brainstorming for ideas of how to find the Danny-dog guy.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 02:24 PM
If the dentally-challenged-doggie-fellow frequents that area, people in supply stores or diners must remember him. Maybe someone who lives in the area could call around and ask?
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 02:29 PM
Great, thanks KrisNine!Why don't you invite your friend to join us at WS? I'm sorry she has to deal with the limbo of not knowing what happened to her friend! If it were me, I would want to be brainstorming for ideas of how to find the Danny-dog guy.
I invited her to come over :) Her husband has been searching yesterday and today.
She said Meredith is very sweet and friendly. She would probably chat with someone who has a dog, since her own dog is very outgoing.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 02:33 PM
Im home today if anyone wants me to call around to places down there. Not familiar w/ the area by anymeans, but if someone can give me some direction, I'm more than happy to do whatever I can to help. I know someone (sorry can't recall who atm) talked about calling diners etc. Should I call the animal shelters down in the area? Local vets? Diners? Local mom and pop stores?
christine2448
01-03-2008, 02:35 PM
The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.
REporting on Alive 11 Atlanta
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 02:36 PM
Last Modified: 1/3/2008 9:54:53 AMAccording to her roommate, a former police officer hiking on the trail on Tuesday said he recalled seeing her and her dog and that he also noticed a man on the trail that gave him an uneasy feeling. That man was carrying a police baton.The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.All of that information is being checked into and the former officer returned to the scene Thursday morning to help pinpoint the area where he saw the suspicious man.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 02:37 PM
Ella is trained and microchipped. If she ends up in a shelter, she will be traced back to Meredith.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 02:38 PM
Im home today if anyone wants me to call around to places down there. Not familiar w/ the area by anymeans, but if someone can give me some direction, I'm more than happy to do whatever I can to help. I know someone (sorry can't recall who atm) talked about calling diners etc. Should I call the animal shelters down in the area? Local vets? Diners? Local mom and pop stores?
If you input the name of the trail into Google maps, it will pull up the location, then at the top click on find businesses on map, and input, restaurants, or whatever type of business you are looking for. It should pull up the names, addresses and phone numbers. I think that's how to do all that anyways.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 02:38 PM
From the 11alive article linked previously:Last Modified: 1/3/2008 9:54:53 AMAccording to her roommate, a former police officer hiking on the trail on Tuesday said he recalled seeing her and her dog and that he also noticed a man on the trail that gave him an uneasy feeling. That man was carrying a police baton.The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.All of that information is being checked into and the former officer returned to the scene Thursday morning to help pinpoint the area where he saw the suspicious man. -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------We need this man's name and where he used to police.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 02:39 PM
New, recent pic of Ella
http://www.foxnews.com/images/333974/1_22_emerson_ella.jpg
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 02:40 PM
In all the media reports that have come out, has an exact location been disclosed of where items were found? And where exactly Emerson and this guy were when they were talking and proceeded to follow the dogs up the mountain?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 02:40 PM
People don't hike the Appalachian Trail with dogs, do they? One of the articles (http://www.myfoxaustin.com/myfox/pages/News/Detail?contentId=5384057&version=1&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=3.3.1) described the male hiker's backpack as "very large". To me, that sounds like it may have been the type of backpack that an AT hiker may use. I've never heard of an AT hiker with a dog, but that doesn't mean people don't do it.
Trino
01-03-2008, 02:43 PM
I have hiked portions of the Appalachian Trail around NC and TN - pretty rugged - although not this particular section, but most of the southern portion of the AT is fairly rugged, not unheard of to have an unlicensed dog, let your dog off a leash, and not unheard of to meet some strange bedfellows along the way. The AT has day hikers, week hikers, and through hikers. There probably are also those who just hike to who-knows-where.
The AT is not today what it once was. While my husband and I did not carry a weapon, there are those who do, albeit illegally a gun. Knives are common, although a sheath knife - seems the "suspect" had one - would IMO be overdone. Although I don't know that my husband and I were afraid, we felt a bit uneasy sharing park-constructed lean-to's with other campers. (There are not always tent camping places.)
It seems this woman was prepared, knew what she was doing. I'm guessing she did not fall prey to nature but to a two-legged culprit.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 02:48 PM
People don't hike the Appalachian Trail with dogs, do they? One of the articles (http://www.myfoxaustin.com/myfox/pages/News/Detail?contentId=5384057&version=1&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=3.3.1) described the male hiker's backpack as "very large". To me, that sounds like it may have been the type of backpack that an AT hiker may use. I've never heard of an AT hiker with a dog, but that doesn't mean people don't do it.
Again, I haven't hiked like this - what's the difference between a "regular" hikder backpack and an AT (I'm guessing that is for Appy Trail right?) backpack?
Since media reports stated that she was prepared for this hike. Is it safe to assume she too would have a backpack on her person?
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 02:48 PM
According to the below linked article, Dandy guy was possibly driving a 2000/2001 white minivan, poss Ga. plates.
(snip)
Police have confirmed that a water bottle and a leash found in the area belonged to Emerson, Verdone said.
Emerson's roommate, Julia Karrenbauer, told CNN on Thursday that Emerson's sunglasses and mittens were found in the area, as was a baton.
Police are not confirming the roomates information.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/03/missing.hiker/index.html
happy2bn10ec
01-03-2008, 02:48 PM
People don't hike the Appalachian Trail with dogs, do they? One of the articles (http://www.myfoxaustin.com/myfox/pages/News/Detail?contentId=5384057&version=1&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=3.3.1) described the male hiker's backpack as "very large". To me, that sounds like it may have been the type of backpack that an AT hiker may use. I've never heard of an AT hiker with a dog, but that doesn't mean people don't do it.
http://www.appalachiantrail.org/site/c.jkLXJ8MQKtH/b.809945/k.C824/FAQ.htm
Can I bring my dog?
Dogs are permitted along most of the Trail, but they impose additional responsibilities on hikers who bring them along. If you want to hike with your dog, be considerate of others (and your dog) by planning carefully, educating yourself about local regulations, and keeping your dog controlled at all times. Dogs are not allowed in the Great Smoky Mountains National Park in Tennessee and North Carolina, Baxter State Park in Maine, and the Trailside Museum and Wildlife Center in Bear Mountain State Park, New York. Dogs are required to be on a leash on all National Park Service-administered lands—or more than 40 percent of the entire A.T. More: Hiking with Dogs (http://www.appalachiantrail.org/hikingwithdogs).
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 02:49 PM
If you input the name of the trail into Google maps, it will pull up the location, then at the top click on find businesses on map, and input, restaurants, or whatever type of business you are looking for. It should pull up the names, addresses and phone numbers. I think that's how to do all that anyways.
Okie I'll try that out and see where I get ....
But Has anyone found a better description? I mean, seriously, A weathered man with missing teeth can be anyone of a number of people right?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 02:49 PM
People don't hike the Appalachian Trail with dogs, do they? One of the articles (http://www.myfoxaustin.com/myfox/pages/News/Detail?contentId=5384057&version=1&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=3.3.1) described the male hiker's backpack as "very large". To me, that sounds like it may have been the type of backpack that an AT hiker may use. I've never heard of an AT hiker with a dog, but that doesn't mean people don't do it.
I'm going to respond to my own post. It seems that hiking with one's dog on the AT is not unusual at all. Over at http://www.trailjournals.com, it seems like there are quite a few people who bring their dogs with them (at least part of the way). The website may be useful and I've been looking through it for the past 10 minutes. Basically, people who are hiking the AT post entries and photos about their trip, many of them posting as they go when they stop in towns with internet access. Perhaps someone else encountered this male hiker and wrote about it or even took a picture? There are quite a few people currently hiking the trail, especially in the Georgia area since they would be ending their southbound trek from Maine (where they would have started in the late summer, early fall).
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 02:51 PM
According to the below linked article, Dandy guy was possibly driving a 2000/2001 white minivan, poss Ga. plates.
(snip)
Police have confirmed that a water bottle and a leash found in the area belonged to Emerson, Verdone said.
Emerson's roommate, Julia Karrenbauer, told CNN on Thursday that Emerson's sunglasses and mittens were found in the area, as was a baton.
Police are not confirming the roomates information.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/03/missing.hiker/index.html
Have we gotten confirmation/news yet on exactly where the items were found? I've seen some reports say on/near the trail, and other articles state by her vehicle.
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 03:04 PM
This young dog owner is missing in GA too. Are they close in location?
http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?t=58041
Local news reported today that Cayle was known to be bipolar. Some seem to think this may have something to do with her disappearance, as there were other reports of her behaving strangely, lately. I'm not so sure, myself. Even bipolar people in a manic phase or deep in depression will typically shut their doors and keep their pets in. And over the course of the last 20 years, there have been at least 3 unsolved murders in Athens of women who fit Cayle's description.
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 03:06 PM
Misterallgood....Huff are you here?
Got your message. Been working on something else. I'm reading these posts now.
Thanx,
Steve/Mr. A
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 03:10 PM
Thanks Steve, very interesting and scary. What bothers me is Cayle left everything behind.
Jinxie, no confirmation of where any of the items were found or where the sightings took place, that I can find. It seems the info regarding the ex-le ofcr is from what the roomate stated and from a shop owner and who knows where they got their info. The baton, mittens and Emerson's sunglasses could be rumor at this point. Who knows?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 03:31 PM
A new report states that the dog's name was 'Dandy', not 'Danny', and the man may have had no teeth at all. People reported seeing Meredith speaking with the man several times the day she disappeared.
http://www.wbir.com/news/regional/story.aspx?storyid=53050&provider=rss
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 03:45 PM
A new report states that the dog's name was 'Dandy', not 'Danny', and the man may have had no teeth at all. People reported seeing Meredith speaking with the man several times the day she disappeared.
http://www.wbir.com/news/regional/story.aspx?storyid=53050&provider=rss
Snip from the above article
Authorities said the man in question had a large, reddish-colored dog with him that answered to the name of "Dandy." Emerson and the man's dogs ran up the mountains near Dahlonega together, and the two were seen following their dogs Tuesday, witnesses told authorities. The man in question was spotted again Wednesday morning.
So if Im understanding this right, he was seen AFTER her car was reported to LE by the park employee right? I dunno, I can't see someone being uneasy/scared continuing to talk/hang out with someone kwim? And from the sounds of it, while not friends or probably even knowing eachother, well she let her dog go with his and play etc.(NO Im not saying/blaming her at ALL) Just stating that from what's being reported, she seemed to be "comfortable a bit with im.)Also, a 60 year old man would be no match (But again, I can be looking at this all wrong) for a girl who had all that going for her (according to family/friends reports) Noone else has come forward except the EX officer to state it looked odd/funny feeling etc correct?
I think they should be looking a little closer at a certain someone. Still have my fingers crossed that she twisted an ankle or something and will be found in a very short period of time!
Have there been dogs or anything out that have picked up her/her dogs scent. Is it possible for a dog to search for another dog like that? I mean, I know a dog can obviously "smell" another dog. But I didn't know if it would be something that would throw a dog "off course" so to speak.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 03:50 PM
According to her friend, Ella would not leave Meredith's side. However, if for some reason she did, the dog is chipped and can be traced to Meredith if Ella ends up in a shelter or at a vets office.
ETA - I realized I've already posted about the microchip...sorry
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 03:58 PM
According to her friend, Ella would not leave Meredith's side. However, if for some reason she did, the dog is chipped and can be traced to Meredith if Ella ends up in a shelter or at a vets office.
ETA - I realized I've already posted about the microchip...sorry
I know dogs can be traced back via microchip, but do all shelters (is this a rural area? It looks heavily forested etc, but that' doesn't always mean it's rural right?) have the scanners? If someone were to bring in a dead/almost dead animal do they scan those for chips too? Or only "strays"?
I'm on petfinder currently looking at postings for georgia - I know where I live, you'll frequently see posts about "Seen X animal meeting X description Running through the woods/acreage located in X area."
Likeliness is next to nil I know, but figure if the dog won't leave her side, and someone ends up finding the dog/turning it in/remembering seeing a glimpse of it somewhere, well maybe it's another stone that can be unturned.
I wish I were closer, not sure what it is about this one, but Im becoming quickly "obsessed" with it. Can't stop hitting the refresh pages here and on the news sites.
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 03:58 PM
Snip from the above article
Authorities said the man in question had a large, reddish-colored dog with him that answered to the name of "Dandy." Emerson and the man's dogs ran up the mountains near Dahlonega together, and the two were seen following their dogs Tuesday, witnesses told authorities. The man in question was spotted again Wednesday morning.
So if Im understanding this right, he was seen AFTER her car was reported to LE by the park employee right? I dunno, I can't see someone being uneasy/scared continuing to talk/hang out with someone kwim? And from the sounds of it, while not friends or probably even knowing eachother, well she let her dog go with his and play etc.(NO Im not saying/blaming her at ALL) Just stating that from what's being reported, she seemed to be "comfortable a bit with im.)Also, a 60 year old man would be no match (But again, I can be looking at this all wrong) for a girl who had all that going for her (according to family/friends reports) Noone else has come forward except the EX officer to state it looked odd/funny feeling etc correct?
(1) Why would someone who had committed a crime hang around the area long enough to be seen the next day? He must know how distinctive he is, with a yellow jacket and red dog. This probably means he was (a) uninvolved in Meredith's disappearance; (b) one of those criminals who enjoy hanging out to watch LE investigate their crimes; or (c) mentally unstable.
(2) Meredith may have been able to overtake a 60-year-old, but not likely a 60-year-old armed with some sort of weapon. The best protection she had with her was her dog.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 04:01 PM
Hopefully, all of the local shelters, vets, groomers have been notified.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 04:07 PM
[quote=cwiz24;1889171](1) Why would someone who had committed a crime hang around the area long enough to be seen the next day? He must know how distinctive he is, with a yellow jacket and red dog. This probably means he was (a) uninvolved in Meredith's disappearance; (b) one of those criminals who enjoy hanging out to watch LE investigate their crimes; or (c) mentally unstable./quote
Exactly!!!! (Couple of questions concerning him about him maybe being uninvolved at this point) If as its been stated he was there for a "couple/few days" other than seeing LE and the like, is it possible he may not know she's missing hence why he has Not come forward yet? OR if he's on another part of the trail, would he even know about LE being in the area they were originally in? (I thought I read the trail was like 6 miles, but I'm guessing if it's part of the AT that people are speaking of, it goes a much, much greater distance?
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 04:10 PM
I wonder if this guy (with the dog) lives out of his van?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 04:11 PM
I think Meredith was seen on Freeman Trail, which is a 6-mile long offshoot of the AT. The AT stretches from Maine to Georgia and Blood Mountain is not far from where the trail begins/ends in GA.
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 04:24 PM
I've written a brief blog entry about this -- nothing in it that'd be new to you all:
http://www.truecrimeweblog.com/2008/01/mysteriously-missing-from-blood.html
I will, however, be updating it as needed.
I'm contemplating heading up there, but don't know that I'll be able to. Especially since I might have to drive a white minivan, and even though I'm only 40 and have red hair, that'd still get me stopped at this point in the investigation, dontcha think?
Steve/Mr. A
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 04:25 PM
Appalachian Trail enthusiasts have been following this story and have been posting about it here: http://www.whiteblaze.net/forum/showthread.php?t=31279
If anyone would reconize the POI, it would probably be these folks.
Beyond Belief
01-03-2008, 04:31 PM
Didn't she have a cell phone? Its PING time..........
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 04:33 PM
I've written a brief blog entry about this -- nothing in it that'd be new to you all:
http://www.truecrimeweblog.com/2008/01/mysteriously-missing-from-blood.html
I will, however, be updating it as needed.
I'm contemplating heading up there, but don't know that I'll be able to. Especially since I might have to drive a white minivan, and even though I'm only 40 and have red hair, that'd still get me stopped at this point in the investigation, dontcha think?
Steve/Mr. A
For gods sake, don't take a red haired dog with you. :eek:
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 04:34 PM
Didn't she have a cell phone? Its PING time..........
let me go find a comment on Topix. A friend said it was fully charged and that Emerson went alone because she had an arguments with her hiking buddy. Things that make you go hmmmm.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 04:35 PM
Didn't she have a cell phone? Its PING time..........
I don't know if she had the phone with her, or if it was at home or in the car.
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 04:36 PM
Appalachian Trail enthusiasts have been following this story and have been posting about it here: http://www.whiteblaze.net/forum/showthread.php?t=31279
If anyone would reconize the POI, it would probably be these folks.
Thanks, cwiz24 -- I linked that thread from my blog post, just now.
Steve/Mr. A
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 04:36 PM
let me go find a comment on Topix. A friend said it was fully charged and that Emerson went alone because she had an arguments with her hiking buddy. Things that make you go hmmmm.
Another thing that struck me: Huff's newest entry (see post above) gives a link to her Myspace (which is private). But her mood is described as 'pissed off'. Last accessed the day before she disappeared.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 04:39 PM
Steve,
Thanks for getting this up on your site.
And to both you and Cwiz- Great link - Im on page two and can't believe the details/insight the folks have about the area/trail and just general info. Looks like I have about 9 more pages to go on the thread over there, if I find anything interesting, I'll post it here. That's ok right - just as long as I give the proper linking?
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 04:39 PM
Interesting comments on Topix:
Mere being a good friend of mine I can say a few things in her defense: 1)She had hiked that trail before and knew it well. 2)She had a fully charged cell phone and Ella with her, along with all the appropriate equipment 3)She had no previously planned to go alone, but had an argument with her hiking buddy earlier that day, which may have clouded her judgment when she decided to go alone.
4)She went out at noon, on a sunny day, one the most well-traveled path there. It isn't like she was out alone walking her dog at night, something I see women doing every day.
Mere is one of the most intelligent women I know. She is smart, self-possessed, and independant. I was upset, too, when I found out she went alone. They even called me, since we like to get our dogs together, to see if I had gone with her.
******
come on people ,look at what is happing,white van dogs and a connection to uga, do you think something more scary is going on ,how about the rapes this fall around uga ? all involved a white van ,what about the 29 year old woman who has gone missing in athens last week? i beleive they said a white van was in athe area then also!
http://www.topix.net/forum/source/wxia/TFV655A9SHV07T215/p2
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 04:44 PM
The media must get their story straight about the POI. Was he wearing a yellow jacket or carrying a yellow backpack? I've seen both reported.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 04:44 PM
Appalachian Trail enthusiasts have been following this story and have been posting about it here: http://www.whiteblaze.net/forum/showthread.php?t=31279
If anyone would reconize the POI, it would probably be these folks.
Great find on that link! They would be in the know. The site is bogged down and I can't get in. I also can't get into Abc or Cbs atlanta. Anyone else having that problem?
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 04:44 PM
Suze,
Im not entirely sure about the other situation you mention - BUT when you put it like that I have to step back and look at the old man again. Just wondering, even though it's a bit tall, it seems he would be awfully scrawny/frail doesn't it? Would a man of those stats have the strength?
It sounds as she was well prepared obviously - anyone know anything about the cell in question? Has it been found in her car? Or would her only being a "missing person" at this point create issues in obtaining proper paperwork to look at the incoming/outgoing call detail from her provider? Has anyone seen any coordinates of where the stuff was found compared to where has been known (or at least recalled to be known)/seen on the trail?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 04:48 PM
Great find on that link! They would be in the know. The site is bogged down and I can't get in. I also can't get into Abc or Cbs atlanta. Anyone else having that problem?
No problem getting onto CBS Atlanta. In fact, their story up now introduces Meredith's boyfriend (the first I'd heard of him) as Steve Segars.
The article also states that the baton was an ASP baton: http://www.asp-net.com/batons.html
"the most tactically sophisticated impact weapon currently available to law enforcement personnel."
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 04:51 PM
For gods sake, don't take a red haired dog with you. :eek:
Forgot to mention that I have a mouthful of teeth, too. But I haven't owned a red dog for more than 25 years, so I'm good. I also own a 16-year-old Acura that's dark blue. I just don't know if it'd run in weather this cold. At least run well.
I don't think my editors at Radar would be interested in a story like this, but if you all can think of a magazine where I might try and pitch an editor, pm me or reach me via my blog. (http://truecrimeweblogcontact.googlepages.com/home)
Thx,
Steve/Mr. A
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 04:52 PM
Great find on that link! They would be in the know. The site is bogged down and I can't get in. I also can't get into Abc or Cbs atlanta. Anyone else having that problem?
Im on the hikers site now - it was SLOW to load, but am having no problem loading the new pages.
http://www.whiteblaze.net/forum/showthread.php?t=31279&page=3
There's a link to page 3 of the thread, if you copy that and it takes (loads) delete the number "3" at the very end and put "1" there instead....It will take you to the 1st page of it. (Apologies if you already know that, it was a little trick DH taught me not too long ago)
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 04:58 PM
Forgot to mention that I have a mouthful of teeth, too. But I haven't owned a red dog for more than 25 years, so I'm good. I also own a 16-year-old Acura that's dark blue. I just don't know if it'd run in weather this cold. At least run well.
I don't think my editors at Radar would be interested in a story like this, but if you all can think of a magazine where I might try and pitch an editor, pm me or reach me via my blog. (http://truecrimeweblogcontact.googlepages.com/home)
Thx,
Steve/Mr. A
Lol, I know you know how eye witnesses are. The red haired dog with the dude in the white van, will turn into the red haired dude in the white van. If you take the van make sure you smile and show alot of teeth. :D
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 05:01 PM
Someone on the hiker's forum (whiteblaze forums I believe) brought up a good point. If this person did in fact do something to her on the trail - he would have had to drag her etc away/off the trail (a bit graphic i know)
Again, I can't picture a 60 year old man only weighing (by description) 160 doing that while having two dogs around. (Could be wrong, but I can't see him faking it w/ his dog as the descriptions are and then harming it) BUT -going on the idea above wouldn't that be easy for a trained S/R dog to pick up if they were put in the correct area?
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 05:41 PM
Someone on the hiker's forum (whiteblaze forums I believe) brought up a good point. If this person did in fact do something to her on the trail - he would have had to drag her etc away/off the trail (a bit graphic i know)
Again, I can't picture a 60 year old man only weighing (by description) 160 doing that while having two dogs around. (Could be wrong, but I can't see him faking it w/ his dog as the descriptions are and then harming it) BUT -going on the idea above wouldn't that be easy for a trained S/R dog to pick up if they were put in the correct area?
If the dude is a killer who lives off the land I'm sure he'd have no problem making dividing her in to more manageable pieces.
TGIRecovered
01-03-2008, 05:44 PM
Forgot to mention that I have a mouthful of teeth, too. But I haven't owned a red dog for more than 25 years, so I'm good. I also own a 16-year-old Acura that's dark blue. I just don't know if it'd run in weather this cold. At least run well.
I don't think my editors at Radar would be interested in a story like this, but if you all can think of a magazine where I might try and pitch an editor, pm me or reach me via my blog. (http://truecrimeweblogcontact.googlepages.com/home)
Thx,
Steve/Mr. A
Might be interesting to borrow a red dog, or some red dog hairs for the passenger seat...see if GBI's on their toes! Don't know how you'd pass for 60 though.
Don't worry Steve, we'd vouch for ya'!
Wish I could go.
Susan
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 05:52 PM
If the dude is a killer who lives off the land I'm sure he'd have no problem making dividing her in to more manageable pieces.
I agree but even with that scenario, there still should be some type of sign correct? Especially if there is snow on the ground. But here's where my thoughts are going -
If the area is as isolated/unpopulated as Im reading, a bunch of footprints/signs of a struggle/heavy traffic I'd imagine would be seen.
IF (again that nasty two letter word lol) it's managed to be stumbled upon by those searching.
Pharlap
01-03-2008, 05:57 PM
Bears shouldn't be around now, but can they?
Thinking outside the box......:twocents:
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 06:45 PM
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
Snip -
Police say they want to talk to Gary Michael Hilton about missing hiker Meredith Emerson.
Late Thursday officials said they believe the man seen with Emerson was Gary Michael Hilton, a DeKalb County resident. Union County officials are asking anyone with information on Hilton's whereabouts to give them a call. It's possible Hilton is driving a 2000-2001 white Chevy Astro van with DeKalb County plate AFQ 1310.
Pic is at link
Im going to try to copy/paste it though
http://www.wsbtv.com/2008/0103/14973830.jpg
I did a quick search on Georgia Dept of Corrections site, played w/ the name a bit, and didn't pull anything up. BUT if this guy is a regular hiker not from the area, that wouldn't surprise me much. Wondering if I should check the states that the trail runs through? Anyone know them off the top of their heads w/o looking at the maps?
People in that area - PLEASE keep your eyes open for this vehicle, if nothing else, he can provide insight to what part of the trail they were on etc.
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 06:51 PM
Slideshow of the search:
http://projects.ajc.com/gallery/view/metro/gwinnett/0103missing/
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 06:58 PM
Here's a website:
http://www.helpfindmeredith.com/
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 07:08 PM
Slideshow of the search:
http://projects.ajc.com/gallery/view/metro/gwinnett/0103missing/
im just getting a blank page :(
KrisNine
01-03-2008, 07:14 PM
^^that's weird. I just clicked the link again and got the slideshow. It's 7 pictures from ajc.com
I'll see if I can find another link.
The friend of Meredith's said that there are dogs searching on the mountain now. Her husband is still there and their other friends have been sent home for the evening.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 07:57 PM
New update from ajc. Her boss is saying best case scenario she is not on that mountain. Don't know why but it isn't sounding good.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 08:04 PM
Now they have a pic of the person of interest and want to talk with him.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 08:08 PM
This is extremely important as this may well have been an abduction. If anyone recognizes this man please call GBI or the police in Union County. Her life could be in the balance.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:22 PM
This is extremely important as this may well have been an abduction. If anyone recognizes this man please call GBI or the police in Union County. Her life could be in the balance.
Concerned -
On page 4 of the thread there's a pic of him too.
There is also another plate number they've released as well as the county the plates/tags are registered to -
Snip -
Police said he was last seen driving a white Chevy Astro van. Hilton has a 1996 white van with license plate number 76APZ and a 2001 white van with plate number AFQ1310, both DeKalb County registered, police said.
I agree anyone out there who lives in the area or surrounding area please please please keep your eyes open!
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:28 PM
They are discussing this currently on the show if anyone is interested in watching it. I missed the first half hour or so of the show, but will do some quick notes on the rest.
I have a gut feeling she was taken away from the trail. Most abductors/rapists are not going to do what they do in a very uncomfortable environment, right? And if it was that cold there at the time, he probably took her somewhere else. Also why else would the police baton and sunglasses be left by her car? I wish they had said- were the items placed there neatly or did it seem like they were tossed on the ground in a hurry (as if a struggle had taken place)? That to me seems very important. Also, was it ever determined if they were her sunglasses? And have they done a background check on him? Does he have a record?
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:34 PM
Roommate is reporting that she's been hiking the trail for 3 years and was only supposed to be out for a day hike. She did know it was going to be windy. States that searchers have been searching more treacherous terrain off the trails (typing and listening so this isn't verbatim)
Roommate is saying she's smart, and is aware of the dangers of strangers etc. Has a great mind, and would realize if something was out of sort. (concerning her conversations with the person of interest)
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:39 PM
Union county has had dogs up there starting downhill and going north. Most other searches have started north coming downhill.
Nobody has been able to locate her cell phone and/or ID, they can't confirm or deny whether she had them on her person, but they have not been found in or around the car or at her home. Phone is currently going to voicemail. Stating with it being off, did someone take it, turn it off, and dump it, or it simply a factor of it being out of range/no signal.
Talking about the POI - He's a resident of an Atlanta suburb. They discovered him by the plate number that someone turned in. The picture released via the media is his current driver's license. He is NOT a suspect, but a person of interest.
Asking everyone to be on the lookout for both/either vehicle since it could be out of the area/state by now.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 08:40 PM
Roommate is reporting that she's been hiking the trail for 3 years and was only supposed to be out for a day hike. She did know it was going to be windy. States that searchers have been searching more treacherous terrain off the trails (typing and listening so this isn't verbatim)
Roommate is saying she's smart, and is aware of the dangers of strangers etc. Has a great mind, and would realize if something was out of sort. (concerning her conversations with the person of interest)
The baton referenced would be a debilitating blow if it was used even to the most experienced. What if she was wisked away in the van after he clubbed her? This means searchers are risking their own health and safety. I think it extremely important that they are looking for this Hilton man. I would be surprised if the searches on the mountain continue tomorrow given this info.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:45 PM
on commercial break right now -
but a couple articles are stating that investigators in another case in NC about a missing couple (one was found the other wasn't? Not familiar but maybe someone else is) the suspect that was recorded on video pulling money out of there account was wearing a yellow jacket.
The POI in Meredith's case was also wearing a yellow jacket w/ black patches.
Nothing certain, but being looked at.
Off of commercial break -
Sad to think you can't even go for a hike in a beautiful wooded park now, w/o some scumbag attacking you. Women especially, should never ever ever EVER go alone!!!
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 08:49 PM
They are doing a 24 hour search now. The alerted the GBI and they have taken possession of Meridith's car.
Talking about the dogs. Since there are two other dogs involved they think/are hopeful that the dogs will pick up on one of them. Also looking for dog tracks.
Large reddish dog - stating setter/lab/mix etc. No definete breed known at this time.
Thinking that until tonight, POI may not have been aware he is being looked for...Stating he will hopefully contact police guilty or not, because everyone knows he is being looked for.
**note Im sorry I didn't grab names of those that were on the show. But when I'm stating "they" Im talking about the people being interviewed on the show**
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 08:54 PM
Sad to think you can't even go for a hike in a beautiful wooded park now, w/o some scumbag attacking you. Women especially, should never ever ever EVER go alone!!!
It happened in Cobb County too. They caught the guy but the victim was murdered.
Mygirlsadie
01-03-2008, 08:55 PM
I agree with you Reb. It is very sad... I am female and I love to go on long walks alone with my dog. It's my time alone and I enjoy it. Unfortunately I am too scared to do that anymore. Hmmm are the criminals winning here?!
Sad to think you can't even go for a hike in a beautiful wooded park now, w/o some scumbag attacking you. Women especially, should never ever ever EVER go alone!!!
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 08:56 PM
I found this regarding the phone. If it was charged, it should not have gone straight to voicemail right?:
http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/myfox/pages/Home/Detail?contentId=5381924&version=12&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=1.1.1
When Emerson did not show up for work on Wednesday, her roommate said she knew something was wrong.
“That’s when I immediately knew because she would never miss work,” said Julia Karren Baur.
When Emerson's friends tried to call her, her cell phone went straight to voicemail so they decided to go search the woods for her.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 09:00 PM
I found this regarding the phone. If it was charged, it should not have gone straight to voicemail right?:
http://www.myfoxatlanta.com/myfox/pages/Home/Detail?contentId=5381924&version=12&locale=EN-US&layoutCode=TSTY&pageId=1.1.1
When Emerson did not show up for work on Wednesday, her roommate said she knew something was wrong.
“That’s when I immediately knew because she would never miss work,” said Julia Karren Baur.
When Emerson's friends tried to call her, her cell phone went straight to voicemail so they decided to go search the woods for her.
When they were discussing it on nancy, they stated that if someone turned the phone off and/or dumped it would be one scenario OR it could be that she is somewhere on the mountain where no signal would occur. I know when I moved up here from the city, my cell lost signal and while it still worked for people to call me, it would go straight to voicemail vs ringing through etc.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 09:03 PM
I'm wondering who and how the connection was made to Hilton. The reason I say this is we would remember something in hindsight, but would we remember a license plate number? What prompted someone to note the license plate number to begin with and why? What did they see and where? A van involved in a case like this is never good. The van(s) have to be licensed to an address. And yet, LE still can't find him?
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 09:09 PM
Not sure if this is fact or not, but on nancy's show, they were talking about the traced him back via plate/tag not sure if it was a partial or what. They don't know if he knew originally that LE was looking for him. Hoping that he will contact LE now that his name/info has been released. As I stated earlier, the pic released of him is supposedly his current License photo.
On another note -
Someone by the name "Thefirstdiane" posted this On steve's site in the comment section. Not sure again, if it's fact or not. But seen it, and thought it was interesting. I'm going to google the counties mentioned and see if their court cases are online and see if anything else comes up. Here's what the poster left
Hilton has old theft charges in Dekalb and solictation in Cobb County.
I know that it would be tenuous, but has anyone in LE contacted the vets in the County the POI lives in to see if anyone has treated the dog or one that matches the name/description? I know that when I worked at a vets long ago, we could search different ways, owners name, pets name, breed, phone number etc. If someone hasn't done this, I'll do it and just forward anything to LE down there.
Solicitation is looking for a prostitute or a similiar situation right?
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 09:25 PM
While searching the counties mentioned and surrounding counties here's what Ifound so far
http://www.ojs.dekalbga.org/servlet/page?_pageid=65,289&_dad=portal30&_schema=PORTAL30&dcms.exact_last=ON&dcms.spriden_id=%40241260&dcms.case_type=&dcms.to_date=12%2F31%2F2090&dcms.from_date=01%2F01%2F1900&dcms.last_name=HILTON&dcms.first_name=GARY&dcms.case_status=ALL&dcms.cort_code=&dcms.soundex=&dcms.case_id=01V75298&dcms.ent_code=COURTS&dcms.pstart=0
Case regarding him and a towing company. Looks like it was about an abandoned vehicle. Unfortunately when I click the link to his name which sometimes pulls up contact info (it has spaces listed for email/phone/address) there is nothing.
(I was actually going to call if a number is listed to let him know that he's being looked for LOL)
I can't seem to locate an online case search for Cobb county. Found the site, but can't seem to search, If anyone figures out how, will you please run this person's name to see what - if anything pops up about him?
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 09:48 PM
Not sure if this is fact or not, but on nancy's show, they were talking about the traced him back via plate/tag not sure if it was a partial or what. They don't know if he knew originally that LE was looking for him. Hoping that he will contact LE now that his name/info has been released. As I stated earlier, the pic released of him is supposedly his current License photo.
On another note -
Someone by the name "Thefirstdiane" posted this On steve's site in the comment section. Not sure again, if it's fact or not. But seen it, and thought it was interesting. I'm going to google the counties mentioned and see if their court cases are online and see if anything else comes up. Here's what the poster left
Hilton has old theft charges in Dekalb and solictation in Cobb County.
I know that it would be tenuous, but has anyone in LE contacted the vets in the County the POI lives in to see if anyone has treated the dog or one that matches the name/description? I know that when I worked at a vets long ago, we could search different ways, owners name, pets name, breed, phone number etc. If someone hasn't done this, I'll do it and just forward anything to LE down there.
Solicitation is looking for a prostitute or a similiar situation right?
Diane's incredibly reliable, so always pay attention when she has such posts up. Solicitation is him looking to pay a prostitute, that's right.
Steve/Mr. A
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 09:50 PM
I found this. I'll include the link but they usually don't work. 21 counts and a search warrant for solicitation? This is from 1994:
http://www.cobbsuperiorcourtclerk.org/scripts/courtscr.dll/CriminalDetail?caseno=94900196&source=/CriminalByName
Criminal Case Number: 94900196 - 07 (http://www.cobbsuperiorcourtclerk.org/scripts/courtsfi.dll/FinesByCase?caseno=94900196&source=/CriminalByName&color=6) Case Type: INDICTMENTSTATE v HILTON GARY MICHAELJudge: HINES Filing Date: 01/20/1994
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 09:53 PM
Fines Gary paid for solicitation:
http://www.cobbsuperiorcourtclerk.org/scripts/courtsfi.dll/FinesDetail?caseno=94900196-1&source=/FinesByName
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 10:13 PM
It so appears he is a sexual predator. I hope Meredith is OK but it isn't looking good for that.
misterallgood
01-03-2008, 10:13 PM
All, I heard from a friend of Meredith's (proved it, too). She said that she'd watched the Nancy Grace show and they'd muddled the details of the story a little, "especially about whether or not a baton was found and turned in with the leash and water bottles."
This person spoke with the Mountain Crossing shop employee yesterday. The baton was definitely turned in by a hiker along with the bottles, leash, and men's sunglasses.
Meredith's friend also said that as far as she knew there were 5 people who saw Meredith either speaking with or near someone fitting Hilton's description. A mutual friend of my source's and Meredith's was also hiking the trail around 10 on the morning of the 1st and saw Hilton "hanging around with his dog in the trailhead parking lot..."
My source happened to be a regular reader of my blog, so it must have been really strange to see her friend in an entry there.
Steve/Mr. A
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:15 PM
Abandoned vehicle case in DeKalb County:
http://tinyurl.com/2fjvvr
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 10:17 PM
Abandoned vehicle case in DeKalb County:
http://tinyurl.com/2fjvvr
Can't access link
txsvicki
01-03-2008, 10:18 PM
It happened in Cobb County too. They caught the guy but the victim was murdered.
Do you mean the case where the elderly lady was murdered on the trail and her husband is missing, then the suspect showed up at an ATM wearing the husband's yellow jacket with duct tape around the waist?
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:20 PM
Theft by deception and posession of marijuana:
http://tinyurl.com/23v5wk
Theft by taking:
http://tinyurl.com/2czm25
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:21 PM
Can't access link
It's still opening for me. What kind of page are you getting?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 10:23 PM
It's still opening for me. What kind of page are you getting?
It's a sign-in page for an Oracle database.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 10:25 PM
Do you mean the case where the elderly lady was murdered on the trail and her husband is missing, then the suspect showed up at an ATM wearing the husband's yellow jacket with duct tape around the waist?
yes! i think thats it! they didn't mention it was the husbands jacket though.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:25 PM
It's a sign-in page for an Oracle database.
Dang, I was afraid that would happen. I don't want to copy and paste the info, just in case it's not him and just in case he's not criminally involved in this case.
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 10:27 PM
yes! i think thats it!
I don't think they found that guy yet (the victim or the perp). the female victim has been found dead.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:27 PM
Should I copy and past the info if it lets me?
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 10:28 PM
Dang, I was afraid that would happen. I don't want to copy and paste the info, just in case it's not him and just in case he's not criminally involved in this case.
Good point. I would wait too until we have more info from LE.
concernedperson
01-03-2008, 10:29 PM
This case gets more strange by the minute.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/03/missinghiker_0104_web.html
cwiz24
01-03-2008, 10:30 PM
Should I copy and past the info if it lets me?
I wouldn't. Innocent until proven guilty (or at least until the majority of evidence points to him). Others may feel differently, but WS is a well-read website by media and family members. Good find, though!!
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:32 PM
I'm going to copy and past to word for future reference. But I'm finding alot of stuff on this guy. Seems to have kept his nose clean the past 10 years or so. Or he got smarter. Let's just say LE is probably aware of this guy. Since 1979 thefts of several types, hit and run, arson, drug posession,
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 10:41 PM
This case gets more strange by the minute.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/03/missinghiker_0104_web.html
This is what I was talking about when I caught the glimpses of there being a "possible" link!!!
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 10:42 PM
I'm going to copy and past to word for future reference. But I'm finding alot of stuff on this guy. Seems to have kept his nose clean the past 10 years or so. Or he got smarter. Let's just say LE is probably aware of this guy. Since 1979 thefts of several types, hit and run, arson, drug posession,
Suz, can you direct me on where to go/what I did wrong to access the site? I couldn't find anywhere to seach just the general links...Thanks in advance!
MrsG728
01-03-2008, 10:47 PM
Sounds like they're gathering evidence on this Hilton guy possibly being a serial killer.
They should send a decoy onto the trail to see if he appears.... I am keeping close tabs on this story. I am wondering where the dog is...
MG
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 10:50 PM
Suz, can you direct me on where to go/what I did wrong to access the site? I couldn't find anywhere to seach just the general links...Thanks in advance!
I think I just got lucky and went to the right place. I'm copying everything to Word right now as things seem to go poof. I'll come back when I'm done (I've only searched two counties so far) and figure out how to get everyone the info without getting into trouble. BRB.
PS. This case is getting scary, IMO.
ETA: I bet GBI locks his records soon.
happy2bn10ec
01-03-2008, 10:53 PM
I live within minutes of the AT in three different directions and very near Damascus, VA (supposedly the only town directly on the Trail) where they have Trail Days every May. I have gotten to know several thru-hikers at the campground where we stay. This is just awful - if there is any possiblity of her not being a victim of foul play, I don't see how anyone could survive with the weather the last few days where she is.
I don't really have anything to add except I wish I could go help search.
Spazkat9696
01-03-2008, 10:57 PM
This is looking bad. I had hoped she had just gotten lost, but now I'm fearing the worst.
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 10:59 PM
I think I just got lucky and went to the right place. I'm copying everything to Word right now as things seem to go poof. I'll come back when I'm done (I've only searched two counties so far) and figure out how to get everyone the info without getting into trouble. BRB.
PS. This case is getting scary, IMO.
ETA: I bet GBI locks his records soon.
Suze,
When you get back and see this please check your pm's!
Thanks,
Lisa
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 11:34 PM
My source happened to be a regular reader of my blog, so it must have been really strange to see her friend in an entry there.
Steve/Mr. A
That's actually a fear of mine and probably for many of your readers! Thanks for the info. So if this guy was still hanging around the next morning, and if he's involved, then whatever happened probably happened very near there. I would think he'd be crazy to hang around that long.
I wonder if Hilton and the baton dude is one and the same.
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 11:42 PM
A link to a blog about the Bryant's, picture and timeline included. Very cute couple.
http://www.dreamindemon.com/2007/11/18/irene-bryant-murdered-john-bryant-missing/
John Bryant's FBI page:
http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/bryant_jd.htm
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 11:50 PM
I found a link to the Bryant case ATM/Yellow jacket pics at the InSession board:
http://www.wyff4.com/slideshow/news/14585610/detail.html
Here is the link to InSession:
http://boards.insessiontrials.com/showthread.php?threadid=317986
SuziQ
01-03-2008, 11:56 PM
A ton of info, pics and videos on the Bryant case at this link:
http://www.wyff4.com/news/14585002/detail.html
JinxieJada
01-03-2008, 11:58 PM
A link to a blog about the Bryant's, picture and timeline included. Very cute couple.
http://www.dreamindemon.com/2007/11/18/irene-bryant-murdered-john-bryant-missing/
John Bryant's FBI page:
http://www.fbi.gov/wanted/kidnap/bryant_jd.htm
This is the couple that have the possible yellow jacket link right? Wanting to make sure I keep it all straight in my head. It's on info overload at the moment!:crazy:
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 12:02 AM
This is the couple that have the possible yellow jacket link right? Wanting to make sure I keep it all straight in my head. It's on info overload at the moment!:crazy:
Yes, the Bryant's. Here is another link with great info:
http://www.citizen-times.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20071114/NEWS01/71113131/1260
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 12:10 AM
Looking at this case objectively, it doesn't not seem strange to me that Meredith would be seen talking and hiking with Gary Hilton (61 years old; he may have stamina, more so than strength if he is an avid hiker). I've went hiking before (never alone) and i've brought my dog many times (she is one that i would never let off the leash). On many hikes, we've encountered others hiking with dogs also, some taking a spot right next to us to swim with their dogs. I could see Meredith having a conversation with Hilton, as they both had there dogs in common and for conversation. Many people let their dogs off the leash hiking, yet never take the collar off. If the dog is welled trained enough, they let them off the leash.
I've also seen many people carry things sticklike in nature hiking (even many cases walking down the street) in case they have to fend off an attacker or animal attacking.
Hilton's garb doesn't seem unrealistic to me. It sounds like having been an avid hiker, he set out preparing for all sorts of scenarios. The backpack seems to be described as the large camping/hiking style ones that almost have the metal rack for your back and a sleeping bag attachment. The yellow jacket (also common in the elderly's couple case) is practical to wear while hiking, as it provides high visibility in case of bad weather or hunters. Would a person suspect in both cases be stupid enough to wear a similiar jacket? Hilton has a rap sheet, yet has been clean for the past 10 years. With him having a backpack that large on and his age and stature (6 feet yet 160lbs, is smaller size for his frame) i don't imagine it would be easy for him to win a fight against Meredith weighted down. Hilton was also lingering around that area, many people would have spotted him in bright yellow and with his dog. It's not like he was trying to blend in or not be spotted. He appeared not to care. Anything is possible, i'm just throwing some things out into the open here.
Then there's the ex cop witness. He got a funny feeling about seeing Meredith and Hilton hiking together. Well from his cop experience, wouldn't it make sense to trail them or engage in conversation and hike with them if he was so suspicious about them? I agree with Reb on this..
Then to top things off later the ex cop witness finds the items at the scene and turns them in. Did he not think for a second after his gut was at first telling him something wasn't right that he was destroying a potential crime scene? Not to mention did he have gloves on or was he barehanded, as his prints would then be on the evidence turned in, or could have messed up the prints already on the items found. The baton found was ASP available only to law enforcement. Also, at what points did the excop witness see Meredith and the hiker? If he saw them while hiking, got an uneasy feeling since the man was carrying a police baton and was obviously not a cop, why didn't he follow them??!! Then when returns to the parking area he sees the items by the car. Did anyone else see Hilton with a baton? Any other witnesses?
I don't believe Meredith is still on the mountain. With Ella's leash being found near the car and the water bottle.. She seems to love Ella, and i doubt she would just leave the leash behind, and then start hiking. I think whoever kidnapped her, waited until she got to the car, grabbed her, either set Ella off the leash.. I am glad to hear Ella is microchipped, i think Ella is a huge part of this case and will help solve it. I wonder if Meredith was abducted and is somewhere around the county area, will Ella attempt to make it to her? Being a dog owner myself, there is such devotion..
I know that the yellow jackets are similiar in the two cases; yet would a person involved in both stick around the same area and wear the same style/color jacket? That seems like pure stupidity to me.
Then we have the ex cop muddling up the crime scene when he thought it suspicious to begin with..
Something doesn't fit here..
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 12:11 AM
From the below link regarding Hilton's residence:
Authorities in DeKalb County, however, said Hilton is not believed to reside in the county.
http://www.cnn.com/2008/US/01/03/missing.hiker/index.html
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 12:15 AM
Witnesses in Emerson's case should be able to quickly id or not, the jacket in the Bryant case. And from what I gather, Emerson's dog was well trained, to be a therapy dog in fact.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 12:18 AM
Looking at this case objectively, it doesn't not seem strange to me that Meredith would be seen talking and hiking with Gary Hilton (61 years old; he may have stamina, more so than strength if he is an avid hiker). I've went hiking before (never alone) and i've brought my dog many times (she is one that i would never let off the leash). On many hikes, we've encountered others hiking with dogs also, some taking a spot right next to us to swim with their dogs. I could see Meredith having a conversation with Hilton, as they both had there dogs in common and for conversation. Many people let their dogs off the leash hiking, yet never take the collar off. If the dog is welled trained enough, they let them off the leash.
I've also seen many people carry things sticklike in nature hiking (even many cases walking down the street) in case they have to fend off an attacker or animal attacking.
Hilton's garb doesn't seem unrealistic to me. It sounds like having been an avid hiker, he set out preparing for all sorts of scenarios. The backpack seems to be described as the large camping/hiking style ones that almost have the metal rack for your back and a sleeping bag attachment. The yellow jacket (also common in the elderly's couple case) is practical to wear while hiking, as it provides high visibility in case of bad weather or hunters. Would a person suspect in both cases be stupid enough to wear a similiar jacket? Hilton has a rap sheet, yet has been clean for the past 10 years. With him having a backpack that large on and his age and stature (6 feet yet 160lbs, is smaller size for his frame) i don't imagine it would be easy for him to win a fight against Meredith weighted down. Hilton was also lingering around that area, many people would have spotted him in bright yellow and with his dog. It's not like he was trying to blend in or not be spotted. He appeared not to care. Anything is possible, i'm just throwing some things out into the open here.
Then there's the ex cop witness. He got a funny feeling about seeing Meredith and Hilton hiking together. Well from his cop experience, wouldn't it make sense to trail them or engage in conversation and hike with them if he was so suspicious about them? I agree with Reb on this..
Then to top things off later the ex cop witness finds the items at the scene and turns them in. Did he not think for a second after his gut was at first telling him something wasn't right that he was destroying a potential crime scene? Not to mention did he have gloves on or was he barehanded, as his prints would then be on the evidence turned in, or could have messed up the prints already on the items found. The baton found was ASP available only to law enforcement. Also, at what points did the excop witness see Meredith and the hiker? If he saw them while hiking, got an uneasy feeling since the man was carrying a police baton and was obviously not a cop, why didn't he follow them??!! Then when returns to the parking area he sees the items by the car. Did anyone else see Hilton with a baton? Any other witnesses?
I don't believe Meredith is still on the mountain. With Ella's leash being found near the car and the water bottle.. She seems to love Ella, and i doubt she would just leave the leash behind, and then start hiking. I think whoever kidnapped her, waited until she got to the car, grabbed her, either set Ella off the leash.. I am glad to hear Ella is microchipped, i think Ella is a huge part of this case and will help solve it. I wonder if Meredith was abducted and is somewhere around the county area, will Ella attempt to make it to her? Being a dog owner myself, there is such devotion..
I know that the yellow jackets are similiar in the two cases; yet would a person involved in both stick around the same area and wear the same style/color jacket? That seems like pure stupidity to me.
Then we have the ex cop muddling up the crime scene when he thought it suspicious to begin with..
Something doesn't fit here..
some very good thoughts. I also think ella will be a key factor in Meredith's being found/discovered. The rest I'm still not sure about one way or another. I will find it odd if someone does not hear from this man very, very, soon, considering he is all over the media right now. SOMEONE has to know him somewhere. (caps for emphasis not shouting) And those someone's should have at least one way to get in contact with this person.
If he does in fact come forward (and I have every toe and finger crossed that he does, and it was just a meetup on the trail between dog owners/hikers etc) whether he was involved negatively or not, I think he can provide valuable insight about the situation.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 12:22 AM
I don't think it's the same jacket, if i recall an article said the one Hilton had, had black elbow patches on it; as opposed to the one in the surveillance videos stills that didn't appear to have black patches. I'm sure they could be sewed on, yet i doubt anyone would go through the trouble.
This case is so mind boggling..
I really wish it was a case where they could just find her and Ella safe under a manmade shelter she to stay out of the storm..
I really think Ella will help, if Meredith was abducted which appears the case at this point, i doubt the suspect would have brought Ella also. Is Ella out there somewhere right now, tracking her mother? Dogs have been know to travel states to return to owners. Even if Ella has never been to where Meredith is, she might still be able to get to her with success. She's well trained, SuziQ, said she's a therapy dog, the bond is so strong between dog and owner also..
I'm praying...
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 12:26 AM
Witnesses in Emerson's case should be able to quickly id or not, the jacket in the Bryant case. And from what I gather, Emerson's dog was well trained, to be a therapy dog in fact.
I don't know either way on the cases being related BUT, I did see the surveillance photos and to me the person in them seems like it is a younger person. They almost look like they are throwing their posture off a bit (It seems they are hunched "down" a bit at the knee and waist if that makes sense?) and they seem a bit taller than 5'10.
But it could also be that I'm just trying to be optimistic and don't want to face that they (crimes) may be related. Im still hoping that it was nothing more than innocent chatter amongst a couple of people that had common interests. I know it doesn't look that way at the moment. but we can always hope....right?
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 12:28 AM
some very good thoughts. I also think ella will be a key factor in Meredith's being found/discovered. The rest I'm still not sure about one way or another. I will find it odd if someone does not hear from this man very, very, soon, considering he is all over the media right now. SOMEONE has to know him somewhere. (caps for emphasis not shouting) And those someone's should have at least one way to get in contact with this person.
If he does in fact come forward (and I have every toe and finger crossed that he does, and it was just a meetup on the trail between dog owners/hikers etc) whether he was involved negatively or not, I think he can provide valuable insight about the situation.
Jada, it sounds like he's a drifter, maybe he's living out of his vans in a lot somewhere or random areas where he won't get kicked out of for being a car transient.. I hope they find him, so if anything we can at least get his take on this whole situation.. He's got ties to Ga, he had to live in Ga to have the license there; maybe he got down on his luck so is living out of his vans. If he is transient, then it is very possible he has no idea people are looking for him. If he has a van campsite in some rural area, then he's not going to have a tv and get the newspapers.
Are there places in the county where transients are permitted to camp, or wouldn't be kicked out, or any areas he would stay where the people wouldn't notice or care? ..guessing he's living out of his van..
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 12:32 AM
Jada, it sounds like he's a drifter, maybe he's living out of his vans in a lot somewhere or random areas where he won't get kicked out of for being a car transient.. I hope they find him, so if anything we can at least get his take on this whole situation.. He's got ties to Ga, he had to live in Ga to have the license there; maybe he got down on his luck so is living out of his vans. If he is transient, then it is very possible he has no idea people are looking for him. If he has a van campsite in some rural area, then he's not going to have a tv and get the newspapers.
Are there places in the county where transients are permitted to camp, or wouldn't be kicked out, or any areas he would stay where the people wouldn't notice or care? ..guessing he's living out of his van..
There is an address in Marietta (sp?) that has appeared a couple of different times throughout the years w/ him being registered to. If anyone is familiar w/ the area. How far away is that to where he was seen hiking/talking to meredith? If it's a semi far distance - is it possible he went on the trail for a couple days (as witnesses described his pack would generally be used for) and was in transit back to that area when the description (not his identity) was released?
Trying to play devils advocate w/ myself so I don't slaughter/convict this guy w/o "due process" so to speak. I think it looks very bad for him based on his past record/events. BUT there is still an inkling of me that just doesn't see it happening. (Just based on age/physical description compared to Meredith's etc, interactions based on witness accounts, the only one I've seen negatively was the ex-cops, the rest if I've read them correctly, only confirm that she was spotted talking to him, with their dogs etc. If one were going to do harm to someone, wouldn't you NOT want to be seen by everyone and their brother so to speak?)
Another scenario someone brought up, is, aren't hikers etc told if you're injured/lost/whatnot to "shelter in place" Is it possible they are sheltered somewhere on the trail, and playing by that rule? Could it be an innocent interaction and she just got hit w/ the weather her temp dropped (I understand she was dressed for the weather etc) and she became disorientated? Not likely, but even experienced people can run into issues right?
**When I mention "You" I'm not referring to anyone/calling anyone out individually, just using it for the general context**
Elphaba
01-04-2008, 12:34 AM
The dog: has LE made a point of getting her pic and description out? she could easily be taken in by someone thinking she was a stray, if they saw her wandering around. Sure, the microchip is in her, but not a whole lot of people that take in strays head straight to the vet with them. If they could run a picture of Ella asking the community if they have seen or come across a wandering dog that could be her, during the news spots about Meredith, it could be helpful.
Or maybe they are doing it... but I haven't seen anything indepth like what I am referring to in the news reports I have read and seen.
MountainMama
01-04-2008, 12:40 AM
Let me throw out a few possible scenarios here:
1. Meredith was going hiking with someone else on New Years Day. They got into a fight. Are you picturing a female "someone else" here, cause I'm sure as heck not. Sounds to me like this companion was a male. Who knows how bad the fight was, maybe this person went after her to continue the fight and things got out of hand.
2. Maybe after the fight, her judgement was clouded and she didn't use the same caution in talking to Hilton as she normally would.
3. She had let her dog go off leash. Maybe the dog spotted a rabbit or squirrel and took off, she ran after the dog and was injured. This would explain why the dog hasn't been found, often dogs will stay by their owners till the end.
4. Its not entirely uncommon for hikers to go missing. She could just be lost.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 12:42 AM
The dog: has LE made a point of getting her pic and description out? she could easily be taken in by someone thinking she was a stray, if they saw her wandering around. Sure, the microchip is in her, but not a whole lot of people that take in strays head straight to the vet with them. If they could run a picture of Ella asking the community if they have seen or come across a wandering dog that could be her, during the news spots about Meredith, it could be helpful.
Or maybe they are doing it... but I haven't seen anything indepth like what I am referring to in the news reports I have read and seen.
I did it on my myspace bulletin, but Other than some random mentions being in detail, I haven't seen an outlet focus "solely" on the dog. There was a search done on petfinder and the areas craiglist site, earlier just to see if anything had been posted about a dog picked up, or seen running in the area, but so far nothing, has been posted. :(
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 12:44 AM
Jada, in reviewing the yellow jacket surveillance video stills again, at first i thought it was a younger person, also. Especially the first photo, the second photo still makes me rethink that..
Link to photo stills again:
http://www.wyff4.com/slideshow/news/14585610/detail.html
The person seems to be keeping his head down as to see where he's walking and be less identifiable. Is there any way LE can measure that exact ATM and then estimate the person's height from that? I think that would be a good bet. If the person straightened their posture, i believe their chin would be above the height of the atm.
So if LE measure it from the ground up (atm resting on curb) then we can at least have an estimate of the height. Or if any locals on here can do that?
What if it is completely random a scenario; say someone who was present around the hiking area saw Hilton and that he was wearing a yellow jacket, and was aware of the other case, took advantage of witnesses seeing Hilton and Meredith together, and then figured that would provide himself an alibi (not alibi my brain is racked; yet they would think the man in yellow is culprit as in the Bryant's case due to the jackets), thus throwing suspicion off the real culprit..?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:08 AM
Meo,
I agree he's keeping his head down. But then again, it's pretty common knowledge that atm's have cameras so it is probably a preemptive measure on his part. Still struggling with the age thing, not really sure. I do agree he's messing with his posture. He appears to be almost bending his knees a bit/hunching down. Same thing w/ the head. If you look at it, it's like he's pulling into himself a bit...Not sure of another way to put it lol.
I do agree w/ you on the yellow coat thing..can't figure out someone being that dumb either LOL!
txsvicki
01-04-2008, 01:17 AM
If the yellow jacketed man did something to Emerson and the elderly couple, he must have first gained a little bit of trust by acting like a simple older man who had hiking and dogs in common. At least enough trust to get near or behind in order to inflict a head injury. Even if it wasn't this way, I don't think Emerson could fight off a six foot man sucessfully. She's pretty small, the same height and weight as me, and there's no way I could. Fight yes, but not win.
kyresearcher
01-04-2008, 01:18 AM
MeoW333, in the pictures at the ATM the yellow jacket appears to have silver duct tape around the waist. Why would anyone place the tape there? Could it be he had a backpack on and this helped to conceal it by keeping the jacket closer to the body? This just breaks my heart that anyone can't even go for a hike without someone hurting them, hopefully this won't be the case and she will be found but I bet something happened to her when she got back to her car and was attempting to leave the trail-head.
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 01:32 AM
I've been reviewing Gary Hilton's solicitation arrest. How does one get charged 21 counts for a single incident? I also noticed that they were negotiated guilty pleas. Which probably means that the original crimes were more serious. I'm also looking at another doc I don't want to link yet, the below link says defendant not arrested. But it looks like he was in jail for a few days after he plead guilty. And how does someone go from being a career criminal for 15 years or so and then stop?
http://www.cobbsuperiorcourtclerk.org/scripts/courtscr.dll/CriminalDocketDetail?caseno=94900196&source=/FinesByName&color=1&D=2
Eta: And are there usually victim impact statements (7 of them) for a solicitation charge?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:37 AM
If the yellow jacketed man did something to Emerson and the elderly couple, he must have first gained a little bit of trust by acting like a simple older man who had hiking and dogs in common. At least enough trust to get near or behind in order to inflict a head injury. Even if it wasn't this way, I don't think Emerson could fight off a six foot man sucessfully. She's pretty small, the same height and weight as me, and there's no way I could. Fight yes, but not win.
DH and I were discussing this earlier. If GMH did have something to do with this...picture this. ME is going to her car, GMH has his mini van parked next to her car. A mini would shadow over a cavalier I believe. She was bent down/over putting stuff in the car, and she gets a knock to the head. Not enough to seriously harm her, but enough to stun etc. The rest is anyone's guess.
I think it's plausible HOWEVER - If there was snow fallen, shouldn't that have shown up? DH brought up a counter to that one. What about if it snowed that night, but not that day? Activity would have occured during daylight hours. It sounds like this area is pretty populated for being unpopulated ( I hope ya'll understand what I mean by that) Wouldn't someone have seem something like that occuring and think it's odd?
Far fetched? Most definetly? Possible, We've seen wilder things happen. Likely, not really. But we were trying to figure out why the baton would be dropped, and esp. dropped near her car. (Seen reports of both, it being on the trail and the car so been bouncing both around)
Hoping with them searching more through the night we'll have great news in the morning.
L
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:45 AM
In the ATM pictures there is silver duct tape, wrapped around the waist area of the jacket. Also that the duct tape was placed around the yellow jacket in order to distort the person's shape so it would appear other that what it was. It was done hastily, messily taped around the jacket once they had it on. This duct tape wasn't on there for reflective purposes at night. And as Jada says, if you look at the stills he is hunching his shoulders and bending his knees alittle in order to disguise his posture.
I don't think the person had a backpack on in those video stills. Then he would have looked like a hunchpack in a yellow jacket..
In Meredith's case, having been seen talking to Hilton, who was seen wearing a larger size backpack (i'm thinking the really big ones with the metal frame sometimes, that have the spot for the roled up sleeping bag and all- hardcore outdoor camping hiking enthusiast's type backpacks.
I am trying to think outside the box on this case, and not be quickly connecting it to the Bryants. I don't know for sure that the cases involve the same suspect. I doubt it's the same yellow jacket involved in both cases. In Meredith's case it was said in one article that Hilton had black elbow patches on his yellow jacket. (some jacket types have supported elbows, that would be the patches).
I don't want to focus on Hilton as the only person of interest, i think there may be more elements involved in this case.. also focusing on one, (especially with the similiarities of the yellow jacket wearing with the 2 different cases) it can be quick to jump the gun. It may not have been Hilton at all, or it may have, it could have been someone else hiking that day that after seeing Hilton leave, decided to take advantage of what they saw as the potential to have blame placed on someone else, more straggly looking, bad teeth, and once again, wearing a yellow jacket. Hilton didn't seem worried about people seeing him there. He wore bright yellow that stood out, had on a large hiking gear backpack, and a red dog with him. In my opinion he doesn't seem to have been nervous or cared if people saw him, which obviously they would have. He made no attempt to blend it. It doesn't rule him out, yet what if someone else was there that knew he was a transient? Should we consider him missing endangered also?
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 01:51 AM
Meow, all good points. I thought about Hilton being a vic but the fact his van is gone, leads me away from that. But then there could be a carjacking angle. I would also think that Hilton would be wearing a heavier Jacket at this time of year. And the one in the ATM pics looks like a windbreaker. I can't get past Hilton's rap sheet, it's pretty lengthy. To me he would be more of a perp than a vic, IMO.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:54 AM
Did any witnesses see the minivan parked next to Meredith's car? I don't recall, although i may have missed it in all the confusion of the articles. If the mini van was parked next to her car, what side of her car was it parked on? and also what side of her car were the items on the ground on? I'm guessing the minivan has a side sliding door. When i get into my car with my dog, i let her jump in first through the driver's side door, then i get it once she is in. I'm not sure if Meredith took the same course of action (Ella being more trained than my dog) or if she had Ella ride in the back of the car. Either way, she would be facing the car bending down slightly to make sure Ella got in and over to the passenger side at least, was settled in, maybe she was giving her a drink of water? On which side of the vehicle was there more activity of people in general? Would the van have parked to block that side from view and is that the side the sliding door is on or no? Was it backed in? Is there witnesses who saw exactly where both cars were parked?
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:58 AM
Hilton's rap sheet is the only thing that gives him the guilt angle, the prostitution solicitation mainly. We hardly know much about him aside from the rap sheet. He behaved for the past ten years. Did he have sexual problems as he got older and stopped soliciting for prostitutes? We don't know..
That could be a good or a bad thing depending on how you look at it.. I don't like to judge people on past crimes, yet the prostitution bit and the amount of counts is odd.
I was thinking maybe Hilton was wearing a windbreaker over a jacket or layers of clothing..
We need more info..
txsvicki
01-04-2008, 02:20 AM
I read somewhere else, but didn't link, that Hilton has two vehicles. Does anyone know anything about this?
dimples37398
01-04-2008, 04:47 AM
I remember on the news video somewhere, I think it was the one posted about the name of the poi being released......they said he had 2 vehicles that are white minivans. One was a 2003 or something then the other was a little older or something.
They were both white minivans the same make. Aerostar if I am not mistaken.
Kel
Bobbisangel
01-04-2008, 07:30 AM
On Nancy Grace tonight it said that he had the one white van...2003. I wonder if the yellow jacket could have been a rain slicker? A lot of people wear them when the weather is unpredictabale. He could have a yellow slicker on and have sweaters or even a heavy jacket underneath it.
On Nancy it said that the older man and the young lady were seen walking and talking together but the past cop felt uneasy. They could have just been walking and talking together. The ex-cop finding the belongings and taking them to that store instead of to LE makes me uneasy. It was said though that he just though they were things that he thought someone had lost...as people do...and things are taken to the store in that area so that people can retrieve them. He didn't connect the belongings until he watched the news later and then he went to the police. Wonder how long he was a cop and why he left the force.
So the older man had sold himself years ago? Did he sell himself to other men?
He's probably afraid to go to LE because of his past and afraid that he will become a suspect instead of a person of interest...which is really the same!
I hope that she has taken refuge somewhere in the woods and is just waiting for someone to come rescue her. She has a green? belt in karate and is very strong her roommate said. She hikes and runs all of the time. But like someone said...if someone hit her over the head her strength and green belt aren't going to do her any good. I wish that women would stop hiking, running, jogging and walking by themselves! Her dog has been trained to be nice and not to attack people her roommate said.
They have been searching all night and will keep on into tomorrow. Her dad is there now and he is a avid hiker too. I hope and pray that she is found and that no one has harmed her.
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 08:40 AM
Friday, 7:54 Update
He does has two vehicles registered to him in Dekalb County. One is a white Chevy Astro...2001 and the other is also a white van...no other description.
Police searched during the night with heat sensors etc.
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 09:19 AM
(snip)
It's possible Hilton is driving a 2000-2001 white Chevy Astro van with DeKalb County plate AFQ 1310.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 09:41 AM
Good morning everyone -
Dang, I was really hoping I would wake up to a "they found her injured w/ ella by her side, they were SIP (sheltered in place)" Guess that didn't occur eh?
I glanced at the new posts and see it's come up about the vehicles -here's a snip that describes both along w/ tag numbers.
Police said he was last spotted driving a white Chevrolet Astro van with license plate number 76APZ. He also has a 2001 white van with plate number AFQ1310; both vehicles are registered in DeKalb County, police said.
Im not sure how georgia works - Is your vehicle registered to the county you reside in? Is it something you must update when you move? (My reason for asking is, I see they (media etc) keep stating they are registered in DeKalb county, but Police come right back and state they don't believe he resides in the county.
Concern on some sites, is it shouldn't only be locals on the look out for this vehicle. Not knowing exactly what this persons intent (if any) he could be anywhere by now w/ her or at least him and the vehicles are. Therefore EVERYONE PLEASE!! keep your eyes open for the vehicles POI above!!
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 09:43 AM
Presser right now on CNN Live. Describing the search units that are in place. There are so many people, it makes me think they have reason to believe she is still on the mountain somewhere.
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 09:44 AM
http://www.ojs.dekalbga.org/
I hope this link works. It will ask you to choose a type of User. I chose other individual. The tabs at the top of the page you will be taken to are the searches available. Make sure you change the case status or inmate status to "all", and leave the date range blank.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 09:49 AM
darn - must have missed most of it. I had to download an update :furious:
I did hear that they came down off the mountain at about 6 am. And the SO is compiling a list of volunteers, as well as several tips rolled in about GMH.
Can anyone inform me if there were any other points made other than what I seen?
Thanks!
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 09:50 AM
9 degrees without wind chill last night in the area. Cold is affecting some of the search teams.
LE is looking into why the witness felt the need to take down Hilton's license plate.
15 teams involved in SAR effort. Searching off trails in in ravines, caves.
Spokesperson had not heard anything about a connection to the Bryant case. The reporter's question was the first she had heard of the connection, so it doesn't appear LE is looking into this possibility.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 09:52 AM
Next press conference at 11:30 am EST.
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 09:59 AM
I wonder if they have found out who the hiking partner was supposed to be that she got into an argument with??
I believe if something was done to her while on the trail, injured or possibly killed they would have found something by now......
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:01 AM
I wonder if they have found out who the hiking partner was supposed to be that she got into an argument with??
I believe if something was done to her while on the trail, injured or possibly killed they would have found something by now......
I totally agree. It's only a 6-mile long trail and with dog search teams especially, you would have thought they'd found something by now. But they have 15 SAR teams comprised of between 2-11 persons each, so they have some reason to think she's out there somewhere. I wish they'd share that reason with us.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:05 AM
What I can't get through my head is this:
It appears that the trail area was relatively crowded that day, given all the eyewitnesses that saw the van, saw Hilton and Meredith speaking, etc, that a 60-year-old man getting a grown woman into a van (whether or not she was incapacitated in some way) would be incredibly difficult without being spotted. Plus, add in the possibility that an angry dog (Ella) was involved, you would think someone would have heard barking. Unless, of course, the dog was incapacitated as well. It just doesn't fully add up to me. Something's off.
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 10:08 AM
has anything else about the boyfriend of Meredith been mentioned? problems w/the relationship, etc. ???
and Ella the dog may have been fine if she was playing another dog - might not have realized anything was wrong - I have 2 black labs and if there are other dogs around they could care less about me - they want to play!
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:12 AM
has anything else about the boyfriend of Meredith been mentioned? problems w/the relationship, etc. ???
and Ella the dog may have been fine if she was playing another dog - might not have realized anything was wrong - I have 2 black labs and if there are other dogs around they could care less about me - they want to play!
The only media mention of Emerson's boyfriend is here: http://www.cbs46.com/news/14967983/detail.html?rss=lnta&psp=news and nothing but his name and a quote is given. Kind of odd, but LE must have no reason to think he had anything to do with her disappearance.
I don't have dogs, but I sometimes think that dogs sense tension and fear, especially from their owners and may react, especially a dog like Ella that seems to be very devoted to Meredith.
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 10:18 AM
9 degrees without wind chill last night in the area. Cold is affecting some of the search teams.
LE is looking into why the witness felt the need to take down Hilton's license plate.
15 teams involved in SAR effort. Searching off trails in in ravines, caves.
Spokesperson had not heard anything about a connection to the Bryant case. The reporter's question was the first she had heard of the connection, so it doesn't appear LE is looking into this possibility.
That was what I asked yesterday. What was hinky enough that they made a note of the license plate?
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 10:20 AM
The only media mention of Emerson's boyfriend is here: http://www.cbs46.com/news/14967983/detail.html?rss=lnta&psp=news and nothing but his name and a quote is given. Kind of odd, but LE must have no reason to think he had anything to do with her disappearance.
I don't have dogs, but I sometimes think that dogs sense tension and fear, especially from their owners and may react, especially a dog like Ella that seems to be very devoted to Meredith.
True....maybe if he did something it was when the dogs ran off together as they were going after them - then he rounded them up and got them in the van????
gosh I hate this! my husband and I used to hike all the time in WV and always came across very nice and friendly people - i never once felt scared....I live in Huntington WV so I am also into the Leah Hickman case! So scary!!!!!!!
Another thing that crossed my mind - if this guy looked weathered and like he had been on the trail - why would he have a car there?? or was he maybe returning from a long hike?
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:26 AM
Another thing that crossed my mind - if this guy looked weathered and like he had been on the trail - why would he have a car there?? or was he maybe returning from a long hike?
Excellent point, Jenny. I hadn't thought of that.
Here's a question for anyone following this case: are the person spotted with the leg sheath/baton and Gary Michael Hilton the same person? I'm a little confused on that point. If Hilton wasn't the same guy with the baton, and the baton was found with Meredith's belongings later on, why is LE focused on Hilton?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 10:28 AM
I thought I read/heard something about a partial tag/plate matched picked up by sometype of camera/survelliance etc? I probably misheard, but that's what I thought, and it made sense, because I couldn't figure out how they came to find him out that quickly.
BUT on another note? I have written down plate numbers on vehicles that "just didn't seem right" but didn't know if it was me being overly paranoid etc. I'll write down plate number, brf description of vehicle as well as a brf (basically size//wght/race and sometimes clothing if it's out of the ordinary)
Never had to use them luckily, but maybe it was something like that for someone? I can't figure out how the person put GMH in with the mini van directly, unless he was seen entering/exiting it?
That's why I thought the partial plate thing rang true...can deduce from there an owners description based on who it is registered to. Could have came up a dead end (Him driving someone else's vehicle etc) But they seem to have "lucked" out for lack of better phrasing.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 10:33 AM
Excellent point, Jenny. I hadn't thought of that.
Here's a question for anyone following this case: are the person spotted with the leg sheath/baton and Gary Michael Hilton the same person? I'm a little confused on that point. If Hilton wasn't the same guy with the baton, and the baton was found with Meredith's belongings later on, why is LE focused on Hilton?
I thought they were focused on him more because he was the last person seen w/ her...Not necessarily as "What the hell did you do with her?" But more of a "What were your conversations about, did she talk about going anywhere else on the trail, do you know what her plans were, her state of mind etc"
But everything I've read has stated he's NOT a suspect (although, we know how quickly that can change!) but a person of an interest to see if speaking w/ him can give insight on where she might have went to. IE did they discuss a trail, he mentioned one and she did the thing of "Ooh, I'll have to check that out sometime" etc.
My concern is, if she was angry for whatever reason, vs going back, did she extend her trip a bit..take a different trail etc, and did in fact get injured/stranded, with the weather moving in. However, since she was not in communication w/ anyone, noone knows the change in location, and therefore isn't searching in the correct area...
(I'll sometimes extend my trip somewhere by running into a couple different stores, take a different route home etc, to "delay" whatever it is that is aggravating/upsetting me. Since hiking seemed to be a big thing to her, I"m wondering if it wasn't some sort of "release" and she would do more of it, especially if she were having a good time, enjoying the day, doing some thinking and so on.) Again, please noone interpret this as I'm stating she did something wrong or whatnot..Im just trying to give a bit background to further explain my concern from the previous paragraph.
Hope someone decipher all that - it's a bit of a run on. Haven't had morning caffeine/nicotine just yet!!!:D
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:33 AM
I thought I read/heard something about a partial tag/plate matched picked up by sometype of camera/survelliance etc? I probably misheard, but that's what I thought, and it made sense, because I couldn't figure out how they came to find him out that quickly.
BUT on another note? I have written down plate numbers on vehicles that "just didn't seem right" but didn't know if it was me being overly paranoid etc. I'll write down plate number, brf description of vehicle as well as a brf (basically size//wght/race and sometimes clothing if it's out of the ordinary)
I've done that too. Sometimes, something doesn't seem right to me about a specific vehicle. But I too have never had to use that knowledge so far.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:36 AM
I thought they were focused on him more because he was the last person seen w/ her...
Right, but what about the guy with the baton? Are they the same person?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 10:47 AM
I don't know..I haven't found confirmation of that one way or the other. I know it's being stated he (GMH) did have a sheath attached to his leg. But it could have held a flashlight, mace, a knife, a baton, who knows?
I find it weird that another poster stated they were ASB/ASP (I can't recall, but a three letter combo like that) which is only police issue I think they stated.
Hmm Ex cop and only police issued items found.
What were the sunglasses like - were they typical cop sunglasses to?
Run with me for just one sec. This cop has stated he felt funny, but doesn't do anything? Not even follow them up or wait for them to come down? Nada?
He turns items in, but still doesn't do anything?
Lets see, he sees the two of them together, sees her go up the mountain etc. He has an automatic fall guy now. Other people have seen them (GMH and ME) together, it didn't sound like he (GMH) tried to disguise that.
The ExCop turned the items in right? Well, perfect explanation for fingerprints and such to be on the items. Even his spit if need be (Dirty glasses say, someone tried to look through them, no water easily accessable, "HockTwooey - spit on the glasses, wipe it off, and oh, wow, I can see.
If they were used in any event of a crime, remember he just turned them in. I'd love to see a picture and have a name of the person. Have we ever figured out why he's an ex?
I think GMH has alot stacked against him. And I see to a certain extent that he could. BUT I keep going back to the physical characteristics of both parties. He was a frail (statue) 60 year old man. he only outweighed her by 40 lbs. She is a physically active/fit person. Has been trained in Martial arts, and had her best friend with GOOD teeth by her side.
Im having serious issues trying to picture it.
On the other hand? An excop? Should be fit, trained in defensive/offensive type moves. Would have access to a police issue baton, even handcuffs, mace, lots of little tricks to take a person down. Hmmm a taser? those seem to be the thing of choice w/ some nowadays. Even w/ being an ex, in most situations, they won't have a problem w/ a ccw from my understanding. Not pointing fingers at anyone..Just creating a "Run With Me" scenario.
Anyone else see the path? Or do I need to backtrack and walk?
No disrespect and if it is too out there I have no issue deleting/editing. Just please pm and don't put it here ^^
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 10:49 AM
Right, but what about the guy with the baton? Are they the same person?
The video from cnn on day two mentions the man had a sheath on his leg but LE said they didn't know what was in it. At that time they were talking about getting a sketch of the person but since that time he has been identified. So, either she was abducted or had an injury on the mountain. Since they are still on the mountain they must have some reason to believe she is there. They have a lot of man power up there.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 10:49 AM
I don't know..I haven't found confirmation of that one way or the other. I know it's being stated he (GMH) did have a sheath attached to his leg. But it could have held a flashlight, mace, a knife, a baton, who knows?
I find it weird that another poster stated they were ASB/ASP (I can't recall, but a three letter combo like that) which is only police issue I think they stated.
That was me: http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?p=1889247#post1889247
Even though it is a police-issue device, I think civilians can acquire one. I could be wrong.
So (correct me if I'm wrong) GMH was the man seen with the leg sheath and the same man seen by the ex-cop who got a strange feeling about him.
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 10:59 AM
I was thinking the same jinxie about the ex-cop....very odd if he was suspicious he didn't check into it further - being an ex-cop and all....do they know exactly who he is?? i wonder if they have spoken w/him??
and the baton thing - you can prolly find one of those online now a days....
all just very weird - something has got to give....soon
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 11:00 AM
Just thinking--I think a taser can be held in a holster.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 11:02 AM
Why hasn't LE released a description of what Meredith was wearing? You'd think that would be an important piece of information.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 11:04 AM
Or anyone know?
If you're fired/retire/whatever - do you keep your "goodies" I've read some do, some don't, but don't know the circumstances nor what is allowed not allowed.
With that in mind - would it be out of the ordinary for this person to have access still (being an ex) to any of the following. (Not what you can grab on the net, but formal police issue stuff.
A taser, if so, how are tasers normally held? Anyone know? I think C mentioned in a holster they could be..if so what size/kind? Could this be a "region terminiology thing" Ie Are they called sheaths to the south but are the same thing we would call a holster/holder/side carrier in the north? (I think of sheath, I'm thinking of a covering for a sword Big sword..Like samarai style loL)
Mace?
Do you keep your baton/wand thingee?
Gloves/coats/hats etc?
Badge?
Thanks!
SuziQ
01-04-2008, 11:10 AM
I think the ex-LE officer is highly suspicious. But why turn the items in instead of taking them with him or throwing them away?
There should be another presser in a little over an hour. I have to leave the house for the day. Can someone paraphraise? TIA.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 11:14 AM
covering tracks before all hell broke loose?
By doing it this way - he is part of the investigation from the inside. He's a witness, he's going to be wanted, would be interesting to know if he is part of the search/rescue efforts. if it was spur of the moment, maybe he's not sure he left something "behind" this gives a reason why his presence may be on certain items etc.
**DISCLAIMER**
Again, I'm not saying the person did anything or had any involvement, this is a purely "run with me" scenario.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 11:16 AM
I think the ex-LE officer is highly suspicious. But why turn the items in instead of taking them with him or throwing them away?
There should be another presser in a little over an hour. I have to leave the house for the day. Can someone paraphraise? TIA.
Actually, the spokesperson stated that the next presser would be at 11:30 EST, so in about 15 minutes. I'll tune in.
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 11:39 AM
what site is it on?
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 11:41 AM
No new information
Search area: 401 square miles
Not using civilian volunteers for searching as of now; only LE teams.
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 11:43 AM
what site is it on?
http://www.cnn.com/video/live/live.html?stream=stream1
But it's over now.
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 11:44 AM
thanks for the update.....
misterallgood
01-04-2008, 11:46 AM
The problem with suspecting the ex-officer is that at least 5 people saw Meredith talking to someone fitting Gary M. Hilton's description, including that ex-cop. That's a preponderance of reasons to want to talk to Hilton first.
About the possible connection to the Bryants. It may be nothing, but here's a link to a map (http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&hl=en&geocode=&time=&date=&ttype=&saddr=Brevard,+NC&daddr=Ducktown,+TN+to:Blairsville,+GA&mra=pi&mrcr=1&sll=35.12288,-83.560175&sspn=0.981703,1.867676&ie=UTF8&z=9&om=1) connecting Brevard, where they disappeared, to Ducktown, TN, where the ATM video of the yellow-jacketed person withdrawing money from the Bryants' account was made, with an added jog down to Blairsville, GA, where Meredith has gone missing. You'll note that everything is right there together. Like I said, probably nothing, but I was bothered by it.
I've updated my blog entry (http://www.truecrimeweblog.com/2008/01/mysteriously-missing-from-blood.html) with some of this info, as well as info provided by a good friend of Meredith's who is participating in the civilian search.
Steve/Mr. A
misterallgood
01-04-2008, 12:08 PM
The following is the text of an update I just appended to my blog entry about this case. It suddenly got even closer to home than just happening in North GA.
I am the tenor section leader and soloist for a large Presbyterian Church choir in Roswell, GA. We have a pretty efficient system of spreading info among choir members via e-mail. Ten minutes ago I received an e-mail from Beth, the main distributor of those messages. It was titled, "Urgent prayer request..." The following is the message text, with some names redacted for privacy reasons:[Redacted] just called from the mountains of North Georgia where they are in their second day of joining in the search of close family friend Meredith Hope Emerson hiker who has been missing since New Years Day. [Meredith] is a special friend of their son...
[Redacted] asked for prayers for Meredith's safety and that searchers will find her quickly. She said there is concern that there might be foul play involved but nothing to prove that...
The person who called from the mountains is a soprano in the choir, her husband a bass. Their son who is friends with Meredith often comes during the Christmas season to add a strong, youthful tenor sound to my section.
They've got my prayers, that's for sure.
The couple making the prayer request and their sons are some of the nicest, most amiable folks in my church choir. They are involved and sincere members of the church. Their sons come during the holidays to beef up our tenor section, and they do it well.
I had the weird feeling I recognized Meredith Emerson. Now I'm wondering if I've seen her at church at some point.
Steve/Mr. A
dimples37398
01-04-2008, 12:10 PM
I don't know for sure, but have a feeling since looking around online.....that GMH might have been incarcerated for a long period of time either in Georgia or some other state.
I looked on Veromi, intellius, peoplesearch, and all of these have him listed with no age, no relatives, no previous locations lived.
His being unnaccounted for as far as people finders, jail records, anything else really, he was either incarcerated somewhere else, lived by himself somewhere else and maybe had no utilities in his name,
or maybe he was just a drifter that hiked places and had no so called "home".
I really would like to know here else he has lived in the past 10 years.
btw......I found a GMH "same name exactly" in Colorado being investigated for strangulation on a college girl, but the guy I found .....the age difference is too far off. Pretty weird coincidence still though.
Kel
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 12:29 PM
GBI enters search and possible link to 2 missing NC hikers. All professionals searching during the night and today. Volunteers ask to distribute flyers.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
SewingDeb
01-04-2008, 12:38 PM
They have confirmed that they are looking into a link between this case and the case of two missing hikers in NC (John and Irene Bryant...Irene found beaten to death and John missing). Someone wearing a yellow jacket was seen near them and this guy was wearing a yellow jacket when he was seen with Meredith.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:01 PM
I really believe that this yellow jacket bit is the wrong stance to take on these cases. One was a windbreaker style one and the description isn't the same as the one Hilton was wearing. To connect the cases through the jacket, will only take away from other potential circumstances and bias the mind towards connecting them. The more i think about it, i think it may have been a heavy yellow jacket with inforced black elbow patches and stripes, or a throw over rain slicker type thing. It's not the same style as seen in the Bryants' atm video still case.
I want to know more about this ex cop witness who sees Meredith and Hilton talking on the trail and is so uneasy about it. He obviously sticks around somewhere there long enough to find the items near her car and turn them in, not caring about destroying potential evidence. Maybe he waited until Hilton left and did something to Meredith, as he knew Hilton would be suspected and was openly seen talking to Meredith.
I think we need to be focusing on this ex cop as much as we are focusing on Hilton.
Dimples brings up a good point as to where was Hilton the past ten years? Incarcerated? Yet if he is a drifter, a transient then he's not going to have the money to leave records like the rest of us do.
The activities of this ex cop are suspicious and why hasn't his name been identified so we can run a background check on him too? He destroyed evidence at a scene he thought was suspicious to begin with. Obviously his police training didn't pay off one bit. I wonder if he's the one who got the Astro van's plate # as well.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:15 PM
I agree that people need to speak w/ GMH as soon as possible, however, I don't think that just because 5 people seen him w/ her that makes it a stronger scenario than the ex officer. Actually I think the opposite. I cannot see bringing that much attention to ones self but then who the heck knows what people think anymore lol.:doh:
On the other hand, I know if *I* were to do something I would not want to be connected to the person in anyone's mind, vision, or recollection. On that tangent though, does anyone recall the cop in the area at that time?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:19 PM
From SewingDeb's link above
Another hiker told officials he saw a man with a similar baton clipped to his belt hiking on the same trail that Emerson took.
This is where I'm getting confused :waitasec: - they talked about GMH being seen w/ Meredith, then a paragraph or so later they put in this statement (above)
Are we looking for TWO individuals then? Mr. Hilton for questioning what he may know about her, where she went, if she mentioned anything out of the ordinary.
As well as this individual w/ the baton? IF so, does anyone have a description? And if they do, does it match up w/ any other witnesses that have come forward?
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:25 PM
I agree that people need to speak w/ GMH as soon as possible, however, I don't think that just because 5 people seen him w/ her that makes it a stronger scenario than the ex officer. Actually I think the opposite. I cannot see bringing that much attention to ones self but then who the heck knows what people think anymore lol.:doh:
On the other hand, I know if *I* were to do something I would not want to be connected to the person in anyone's mind, vision, or recollection. On that tangent though, does anyone recall the cop in the area at that time?
Jada, i agree with you on this, GMH was not trying to hide himself at all, he was hanging around the park area, out in the open, with a red dog and yellow noticeable jacket and hiker attire.
Maybe the cop figured he would look less obvious turning in and damaging the evidence. He has an uneasy feeling and doesn't follow his gut about it, yet he is also hanging around long enough to find the items near Meredith's car.
We don't know how long he was around the scene, he could have seen her arrive, on the trail, and then he has such an uneasy feeling, doesn't even bother to investigate it, which is the first thing a good cop would do, he would insert himself into the situation nonchalantly just to make sure that "uneasy feeling" he had was just an uneasy feeling, you would think? Then despite feeling so uneasy about GMH and Meredith, he gets his hands all over potential evidence.
If i had an "uneasy feeling" about something, i would go check it out, most hikers are friendly and great each other in passing. It wouldn't be hard for this ex cop to have made some small talk, if anything, just to reassure himself that the scenario was okay. I guess he didn't care enough to do that, yet he turned in the items near the car when he is the one who said he noticed GMH had a baton and a baton is one of those items turned it. Hmm not to mention it was an ASP law enforcement type baton. It makes ya think.. why didn't this ex cop put two and two together?? Wasn't his "uneasy feeling" also do to seeing GMH with a police baton?
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 01:26 PM
From SewingDeb's link above
Another hiker told officials he saw a man with a similar baton clipped to his belt hiking on the same trail that Emerson took.
This is where I'm getting confused :waitasec: - they talked about GMH being seen w/ Meredith, then a paragraph or so later they put in this statement (above)
Are we looking for TWO individuals then? Mr. Hilton for questioning what he may know about her, where she went, if she mentioned anything out of the ordinary.
As well as this individual w/ the baton? IF so, does anyone have a description? And if they do, does it match up w/ any other witnesses that have come forward?
Thank you--I asked that same question above and didn't really get an answer.
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 01:27 PM
The problem with suspecting the ex-officer is that at least 5 people saw Meredith talking to someone fitting Gary M. Hilton's description, including that ex-cop. That's a preponderance of reasons to want to talk to Hilton first.
About the possible connection to the Bryants. It may be nothing, but here's a link to a map (http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&hl=en&geocode=&time=&date=&ttype=&saddr=Brevard,+NC&daddr=Ducktown,+TN+to:Blairsville,+GA&mra=pi&mrcr=1&sll=35.12288,-83.560175&sspn=0.981703,1.867676&ie=UTF8&z=9&om=1) connecting Brevard, where they disappeared, to Ducktown, TN, where the ATM video of the yellow-jacketed person withdrawing money from the Bryants' account was made, with an added jog down to Blairsville, GA, where Meredith has gone missing. You'll note that everything is right there together. Like I said, probably nothing, but I was bothered by it.
I've updated my blog entry (http://www.truecrimeweblog.com/2008/01/mysteriously-missing-from-blood.html) with some of this info, as well as info provided by a good friend of Meredith's who is participating in the civilian search.
Steve/Mr. A
Apparently GBI is drawing a correlation as well.
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:30 PM
I think LE should still compile a composite sketch from witnesses anyway. Then it could be compared to GMH. If there are any discrepancies, it would help things. GMH made have changed in appearance since that license picture. Also there is no trail on him the past 10 years, is he even alive? Would someone steal his identity if they are similiar in appearance?
There is so much of what seems contradicting information. One of the witnesses, the ex cop, who is he?? Why does it seem his name hasn't been reported anywhere?
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 01:31 PM
If I'm recalling correctly, the yellow jacket that the Bryant perp was wearing in the ATM video was one that belonged to the Bryants themselves, which would explain why there was duct tape on it. John Bryant had been wearing it and he had been restrained with duct tape. The perp put on the jacket to withdraw money, perhaps to hide any identifying clothing he may have had on.
Of course, the duct tape comment above is just my conjecture.
ChevyTX
01-04-2008, 01:32 PM
IMO i dont believe that the yellow jacket should be ruled out as being the same one because who is to say that it isnt the same jacket. Yes a person would have to be thinking crazy to were the same jacket but if he in fact did abduct her than wouldnt that be thinking crazy also?
jennyjwv
01-04-2008, 01:33 PM
yeah i'm still weirded out by the ex-cop...doesn't add up....and is the sheath they are talking about covered or open to where you could see what was in there - i mean from what i'm thinking it to be is like a gun holder type thingy for a knife or some other weapon - anyone has a better description? i mean i'm thinking it would be hard to see exactly what was in it unless you got a good closeup look.....
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:35 PM
Jada, i agree with you on this, GMH was not trying to hide himself at all, he was hanging around the park area, out in the open, with a red dog and yellow noticeable jacket and hiker attire.
Maybe the cop figured he would look less obvious turning in and damaging the evidence. He has an uneasy feeling and doesn't follow his gut about it, yet he is also hanging around long enough to find the items near Meredith's car.
We don't know how long he was around the scene, he could have seen her arrive, on the trail, and then he has such an uneasy feeling, doesn't even bother to investigate it, which is the first thing a good cop would do, he would insert himself into the situation nonchalantly just to make sure that "uneasy feeling" he had was just an uneasy feeling, you would think? Then despite feeling so uneasy about GMH and Meredith, he gets his hands all over potential evidence.
If i had an "uneasy feeling" about something, i would go check it out, most hikers are friendly and great each other in passing. It wouldn't be hard for this ex cop to have made some small talk, if anything, just to reassure himself that the scenario was okay. I guess he didn't care enough to do that, yet he turned in the items near the car when he is the one who said he noticed GMH had a baton and a baton is one of those items turned it. Hmm not to mention it was an ASP law enforcement type baton. It makes ya think.. why didn't this ex cop put two and two together?? Wasn't his "uneasy feeling" also do to seeing GMH with a police baton?
I agree meo - I'm going to take it a step further. He sees GMH talking to her (which he's admitted obviously) but now...On the surface of stating that uneasy feeling, he sure has taken down alot of details about them but did nothing to act upon it, even as you stated, after he found the items? no notification to LE? eh? What better way to set up a fall guy.
guess my imagination is going overtime. There is something here, I just cannot put my finger on. I'm nobody on the great big scheme of things, but I do try to listen to my "gut instinct" There's too many pieces of the puzzle missing,
When they state she was prepared to go up for a day hike..what does that mean exactly? When you prepare for a dayhike (Exp. Hiker) do you also bring provisions in case you are stranded overnight? Is it possible as another poster brought up, that w/ Ella off leash, she may have seen something went after it, and in the pursuit after her, she slipped/fell/stumbled and has an injury that makes it improbable to walk out. (Doesn't even to be anything serious, sprained ankle etc) I would think that if that were the case she would have been discovered by now though or they would have come across Ella/Tracks/Etc something.
I know all reports say she is very well trained, I don't doubt that, but even the best trained pups/dogs can have their moments! :D
Cwiz,
I'm trying to find the answer. So many conflicting reports. and nothing 100% confirmed grr!
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 01:42 PM
Not to turn this thread into a rehashing of the Bryant case (although the two could be related), it appears that the motive for the Bryant kidnapping/murder was money, although pure homicidal mania is as good a motive as any for some criminals. If Meredith's disappearance is criminal in nature and the two cases are related, what then would be the motive for the crime? As far as we know, no one has tried to access her money.
Bascially, what I'm saying is that criminals tend to follow patterns and one of these patterns is motive. Some criminals like to sexually assault people for the thrill and power, some criminals are after money. The motives in these two cases appear (on the surface) to be dissimilar. Money in the case of the Bryants (even though the perp only got $300). ??? in the case of Meredith (perhaps sexual assault, ransom?). It's almost too early even to be speaking of motive in Meredith's case since we're not positive there has been foul play.
Just thinking here: how odd is it that someone would go after hikers for money? I mean, of all the places to find a person with large amounts of money on them, is a hiking trail really on your top ten?
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:43 PM
I agree meo - I'm going to take it a step further. He sees GMH talking to her (which he's admitted obviously) but now...On the surface of stating that uneasy feeling, he sure has taken down alot of details about them eh? What better way to set up a fall guy.
guess my imagination is going overtime. There is something here, I just cannot put my finger on. I'm nobody on the great big scheme of things, but I do try to listen to my "gut instinct" There's too many pieces of the puzzle missing,
When they state she was prepared to go up for a day hike..what does that mean exactly? When you prepare for a dayhike (Exp. Hiker) do you also bring provisions in case you are stranded overnight? Is it possible as another poster brought up, that w/ Ella off leash, she may have seen something went after it, and in the pursuit after her, she slipped/fell/stumbled and has an injury that makes it improbable to walk out. (Doesn't even to be anything serious, sprained ankle etc) I would think that if that were the case she would have been discovered by now though or they would have come across Ella/Tracks/Etc something.
I know all reports say she is very well trained, I don't doubt that, but even the best trained pups/dogs can have their moments! :D
Cwiz,
I'm trying to find the answer. So many conflicting reports. and nothing 100% confirmed grr!
I'm thinking the "fall guy" type thing, also..
For a day hike, my guess is that she'd have to have brought a backpack herself to hold stuff for a "day hike", she'd bring food for herself and Ella, a lot of times hikers bring a mixture of nuts, dried fruits, some sweets (i forget the name, like a trail mix type thing that would boost energy) water bottles, either a fold up bowl, or some type of bowl for Ella, tissues or napkins, extra clothes layers, and possibly a med kit. Also anything else that one would take with them, her cell phone, maybe a camera (if she was a regular hiker of this trail, she probably wouldn't have brought a camera, yet you never know).
From the description of GMH's backpack it sounds like it was the large hiker type, in which he may have had extra items in case he was stuck in bad weather. If he was weathered looking, he has been out in the elements a lot so may have been used to such scenarios as getting stuck while hiking and had a large backpack just in case.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 01:45 PM
Not to turn this thread into a rehashing of the Bryant case (although the two could be related), it appears that the motive for the Bryant kidnapping/murder was money, although pure homicidal mania is as good a motive as any for some criminals. If Meredith's disappearance is criminal in nature and the two cases are related, what then would be the motive for the crime? As far as we know, no one has tried to access her money.
Bascially, what I'm saying is that criminals tend to follow patterns and one of these patterns is motive. Some criminals like to sexually assault people for the thrill and power, some criminals are after money. The motives in these two cases appear (on the surface) to be dissimilar. Money in the case of the Bryants (even though the perp only got $300). ??? in the case of Meredith (perhaps sexual assault, ransom?). It's almost too early even to be speaking of motive in Meredith's case since we're not positive there has been foul play.
Amen to that, cwiz!! Does anyone know if Meredith had her wallet on her, or was it in her vehicle?
In any case, activity of her cards would have been checked by now i would hope. I hate to say this, i think in Meredith's case the motive wasn't money. I think it's sexual in nature, she was an attractive young woman. I don't think the cases are related, aside from the fact that the unidentified suspect wants people to think they are to throw them off.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 01:51 PM
Amen to that, cwiz!! Does anyone know if Meredith had her wallet on her, or was it in her vehicle?
In any case, activity of her cards would have been checked by now i would hope. I hate to say this, i think in Meredith's case the motive wasn't money. I think it's sexual in nature, she was an attractive young woman. I don't think the cases are related, aside from the fact that the unidentified suspect wants people to think they are to throw them off.
I don't know how much is fact, I know Steve had mentioned that He had knowledge that the interview on Nancy grace left some stuff out and iirc some details were a bit skewed. So with that said.
It was stated on there that her phone and id haven't been found in her car/house etc. So it's being assumed I guess she has them on her. Her phone is going into voicemail, but it was stated by someone on the show that could be because, she is out of reach of signal (mountaintop/range thing), the phone is dead (battery), or worse case, it's been turned off/dumped by someone.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 02:00 PM
The perp in the Bryants' case almost immediately used their atm card, in desperation for money. Whoever has Meredith and her cards, if the motive were for money, would know that time is essential in using the cards, before a hold is put on them, and this case has made so much news, national coverage, that at this point it would be worthless and stupid for anyone to use her cards, as they would immediately be suspect. In the Bryants' case the card was used pretty much right away. We don't have that in this one. Any type of credit card, atm card theft would have to be done immediately before the card has a hold put on it or attention is aroused as to the person whose card it really is. I think the yellow jacket bit is a coincidence that is handy in distracting LE from the real culprit. It is possible it's the same suspect with different motives on each case, yet i see it as highly unlikely.
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 03:10 PM
From the new article, police on placing as much emphasis on finding Hilton as they are on Emerson. A check of his address where he registered his vehicle did not locate Hilton.
http://www.ajc.com/gwinnett/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/03/missing0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 03:11 PM
Has E.Search been talked about coming in to help with the search at all? I know that their are experienced searchers looking, but aren't these people kind of the "top dogs" for searching in this type of terrain (as far as gear, skills etc go?)
Edited to add. I went to their website, didn't see anything mentioned about her, so I sent off an email to see if they are contemplating going over there. I'll post back if I should get a response. Not sure if the request has to come from family/friends/LE, and I'm sure they are bogged w/ emails/calls etc. We'll see what happens, I figured it couldn't hurt!
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 03:20 PM
Has E.Search been talked about coming in to help with the search at all? I know that their are experienced searchers looking, but aren't these people kind of the "top dogs" for searching in this type of terrain (as far as gear, skills etc go?)
Normally I would agree with you about TexasEquuiSearch but in this case the search is being fueled by metro Atlanta, LE, firemen, paramedics, SAR teams and using high tech equipment that typically other search teams would have to borrow from them. In addition to GBI and the Georgia State Police. There is a lot of skilled manpower right now. So I guess I am saying if this was in a rural area with no proximity to Atlanta then they would have been called right away.
Even still TES is a volunteer organization that would have to recruit locally to fill the search teams. Time is of the essence right now due to the cold weather and rugged conditions.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 03:25 PM
Even with Ella being so well trained and not to hurt people, the close bond exists so much between dog and owner, and dogs are usually very intuitive, mine is a big mush, until yet will grow if someone we don't know approaches me. She's also growled when my friend's alcoholic boyfriend came into the house to get her out (she was inside talking and petting Cinnamon) so she is a good judge of character.
I think Ella will help them find Meredith. If Meredith is hurt somewhere, i doubt Ella would leave her side.
I think Meredith may not be on the mountain, that she may have been kidnapping coming back from the trail. Items found near her car.. i really wish that we knew if it was a collar or a leash that was found. I'm certain Meredith would never take the collar off of Ella, especially in an open area like that. If Meredith was removed from the scene via car, where is Ella? Maybe she is working on her own search to get to Meredith. If the collar was removed by someone other than Meredith, they would expect Ella to run off and without a collar she would be harder to identify (thankfully she is microchipped).
If for instance, Meredith is still on the mountain and underneath a make shift shelter of sorts, would she still show up on the infrared from the helicopter search?
Then the ground search with the dogs didn't pick up anything either..
cwiz24
01-04-2008, 03:28 PM
Even with Ella being so well trained and not to hurt people, the close bond exists so much between dog and owner, and dogs are usually very intuitive, mine is a big mush, until yet will grow if someone we don't know approaches me. She's also growled when my friend's alcoholic boyfriend came into the house to get her out (she was inside talking and petting Cinnamon) so she is a good judge of character.
I think Ella will help them find Meredith. If Meredith is hurt somewhere, i doubt Ella would leave her side.
I think Meredith may not be on the mountain, that she may have been kidnapping coming back from the trail. Items found near her car.. i really wish that we knew if it was a collar or a leash that was found. I'm certain Meredith would never take the collar off of Ella, especially in an open area like that. If Meredith was removed from the scene via car, where is Ella? Maybe she is working on her own search to get to Meredith. If the collar was removed by someone other than Meredith, they would expect Ella to run off and without a collar she would be harder to identify (thankfully she is microchipped).
If for instance, Meredith is still on the mountain and underneath a make shift shelter of sorts, would she still show up on the infrared from the helicopter search?
Then the ground search with the dogs didn't pick up anything either..
Unfortunately, someone that would harm a person would probably have no problem harming a dog. If Meredith is no longer with us and it is due to foul play, I hardly think the perp would have left the dog alive.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 03:29 PM
Normally I would agree with you about TexasEquuiSearch but in this case the search is being fueled by metro Atlanta, LE, firemen, paramedics, SAR teams and using high tech equipment that typically other search teams would have to borrow from them. In addition to GBI and the Georgia State Police. There is a lot of skilled manpower right now. So I guess I am saying if this was in a rural area with no proximity to Atlanta then they would have been called right away.
Even still TES is a volunteer organization that would have to recruit locally to fill the search teams. Time is of the essence right now due to the cold weather and rugged conditions.
CP - I wasn't sure if they did this kind of thing w/ other parties involved. I also didn't know about the part about them filling their teams locally =( . Guess I jumped the boat a little soon eh? :bang:
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 03:37 PM
Even with Ella being so well trained and not to hurt people, the close bond exists so much between dog and owner, and dogs are usually very intuitive, mine is a big mush, until yet will grow if someone we don't know approaches me. She's also growled when my friend's alcoholic boyfriend came into the house to get her out (she was inside talking and petting Cinnamon) so she is a good judge of character.
I think Ella will help them find Meredith. If Meredith is hurt somewhere, i doubt Ella would leave her side.
I think Meredith may not be on the mountain, that she may have been kidnapping coming back from the trail. Items found near her car.. i really wish that we knew if it was a collar or a leash that was found. I'm certain Meredith would never take the collar off of Ella, especially in an open area like that. If Meredith was removed from the scene via car, where is Ella? Maybe she is working on her own search to get to Meredith. If the collar was removed by someone other than Meredith, they would expect Ella to run off and without a collar she would be harder to identify (thankfully she is microchipped).
If for instance, Meredith is still on the mountain and underneath a make shift shelter of sorts, would she still show up on the infrared from the helicopter search?
Then the ground search with the dogs didn't pick up anything either..
All articles I have read today say it was a leash and water bottle found. I do know they were using a heat sensor on Wednesday night hoping to pick up info that way and they were using tracking dogs all through last night until this morning. I am beginning to think she isn't on the mountain at all. They have covered about 400 miles of area but she still could be hurt in a ravine and is being missed. Pray she is found soon.
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 03:57 PM
Bad thought - and I will remove it if it's too sensitive considering the situation - but I'm guessing the roads that run through the area are pretty rural (eg - not heavily trafficked at the same time)
Does anyone know if a search has been conducted along the main roads used to get out of the area of the park they were in? Could someone have pushed her out a door while traveling down the road somehow? Not a pleasant thought, but Im trying to be realistic and look at all views.....
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 04:42 PM
"Last Modified: 1/3/2008 9:54:53 AMAccording to her roommate, a former police officer hiking on the trail on Tuesday said he recalled seeing her and her dog and that he also noticed a man on the trail that gave him an uneasy feeling. That man was carrying a police baton.The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.All of that information is being checked into and the former officer returned to the scene Thursday morning to help pinpoint the area where he saw the suspicious man."
"Another hiker told officials he saw a man with a similar baton clipped to his belt hiking on the same trail that Emerson took."
Link to article:
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
"Before Hilton was connected to the case, several people told investigators they saw her with a gray- or silver-haired man who had a backpack and wore a yellow jacket with black elbow patches and stripes, Verdone said. Police say Hilton is about 5 foot 10 inches tall and weighs 160 pounds."
Link to article:
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
The first paragraph is about the ex cop who witnessed Meredith and GMH talking. I wish he would explain his "uneasy feeling" for us and as to why he was feeling "uneasy". Sometimes they like to return to the scene, anyway to relive it argh.. sorry i had to..
Second line is from another article and i am wondering how many witnesses saw one man with a baton or was it two different men with batons or what?
The third paragraph is the best description yet of the jacket Hilton was seen wearing. I would guess that the stripes were going vertically down the arms of the jacket, although it is just a guess. I've seen other clothing patterned that way, until we can get a solid report of what it looked like..
If we could recreate the scene, at first where on the trail did the ex cop see GMH and Meredith talking? If there was more than one point on the trail where he had seen them (which there would be if they were walking in motion) what points of the trail were they at or near? If it made him feel uneasy why didn't he observe more? How soon after that did he come down the trail to find the things near her car?
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 04:47 PM
"Last Modified: 1/3/2008 9:54:53 AMAccording to her roommate, a former police officer hiking on the trail on Tuesday said he recalled seeing her and her dog and that he also noticed a man on the trail that gave him an uneasy feeling. That man was carrying a police baton.The former officer said he continued up the hill. He said that when he came back down the hill he found some of Meredith's belongings including a leash, two water bottles and some dog treats. Also, next to those items, were a police baton and some men's sunglasses. He turned those items into a local shop owner.All of that information is being checked into and the former officer returned to the scene Thursday morning to help pinpoint the area where he saw the suspicious man."
"Another hiker told officials he saw a man with a similar baton clipped to his belt hiking on the same trail that Emerson took."
Link to article:
http://www.wsbtv.com/news/14964662/detail.html
"Before Hilton was connected to the case, several people told investigators they saw her with a gray- or silver-haired man who had a backpack and wore a yellow jacket with black elbow patches and stripes, Verdone said. Police say Hilton is about 5 foot 10 inches tall and weighs 160 pounds."
Link to article:
http://www.ajc.com/metro/content/metro/gwinnett/stories/2008/01/02/missing_0103.html?cxntlid=homepage_tab_newstab
The first paragraph is about the ex cop who witnessed Meredith and GMH talking. I wish he would explain his "uneasy feeling" for us and as to why he was feeling "uneasy". Sometimes they like to return to the scene, anyway to relive it argh.. sorry i had to..
Second line is from another article and i am wondering how many witnesses saw one man with a baton or was it two different men with batons or what?
The third paragraph is the best description yet of the jacket Hilton was seen wearing. I would guess that the stripes were going vertically down the arms of the jacket, although it is just a guess. I've seen other clothing patterned that way, until we can get a solid report of what it looked like..
If we could recreate the scene, at first where on the trail did the ex cop see GMH and Meredith talking? If there was more than one point on the trail where he had seen them (which there would be if they were walking in motion) what points of the trail were they at or near? If it made him feel uneasy why didn't he observe more? How soon after that did he come down the trail to find the things near her car?
And another thing! If after having that uneasy feeling and then coming DOWN off the mountain and discovering her things /w her no where around WTF did he NOT contact LE right then and there??!?!?!?!
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 05:01 PM
I hope it's ok to post the body of the email. Should I contact someone to put them in connection with these guys?
Lisa,
It is our protocol that we can not enter a case with out first being
contacted by law enforcment or family members. As of now, neither of
these has happened. There are alot of very qualified resources out
there,
however, if we are contacted we will do all that we can to help.
Thank You,
***** contact info edited for privacy.
I do not know if the numbers listed are out there for public viewing. If someone needs them, Pm me and I'll give them to you w/ no problems!
So I'm deciphering that they are willing to help if contacted, but they can't get involved until they are right? My asking about this is because, I know that there are lots of qualified people out there, BUT if she is on that mountain SOMEWHERE, time is running out..the more qualified people up there..IMO the better. So what's ya'lls opinion?
concernedperson
01-04-2008, 05:10 PM
I hope it's ok to post the body of the email. Should I contact someone to put them in connection with these guys?
Lisa,
It is our protocol that we can not enter a case with out first being
contacted by law enforcment or family members. As of now, neither of
these has happened. There are alot of very qualified resources out
there,
however, if we are contacted we will do all that we can to help.
Thank You,
***** contact info edited for privacy.
I do not know if the numbers listed are out there for public viewing. If someone needs them, Pm me and I'll give them to you w/ no problems!
So I'm deciphering that they are willing to help if contacted, but they can't get involved until they are right? My asking about this is because, I know that there are lots of qualified people out there, BUT if she is on that mountain SOMEWHERE, time is running out..the more qualified people up there..IMO the better. So what's ya'lls opinion?
That is correct. Only LE and family can ask for assistance. Right now it is a search and rescue mission so all the stops are gone but as time goes on and they don't find her more help may be required. Personnel from LE and other agencies are being used now but at a certain point they will have to return to their regular jobs.
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 05:10 PM
We have the ex cop "witness" who sees that GMH has a baton on his person and is talking with Meredith. He later finds a baton after feeling on easy and messes up all the evidence by moving it and getting his own prints all over it.
Why is he an ex cop??
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 05:16 PM
Check your pm's please!
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 05:18 PM
I'm going to appear really dumb on this, how do i check my pm on here? I've never used it before..
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 05:19 PM
Upper right hand corner...Under where it says "welcome" you will see the spot marked "private messages" click it and it will open up your folders ^^
MeoW333
01-04-2008, 05:27 PM
*smack self i figured it out durr.. on me =p
JinxieJada
01-04-2008, 05:42 PM
lol check it again :rolleyes:
vBulletin® v3.8.1, Copyright ©2000-2010, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.