Search results

It's not necessarily that he wants it excluded. He wants the Alibi Response to follow Idaho Code so that it cannot be tailored to the evidence. JMO

Snipped by me--agree with this--I'm Catholic and my dad's whole family is Catholic in NE PA about an hour west of where BK grew up and have attended mass in that area many times--this is interesting but I've never experienced it. I think a lot of people enjoy astronomy and also some of us may...

To be clear, the first alibi response was filed July 24th in response to the state's demand for one: https://s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/isc.coi/CR29-22-2805/072423+Notice+of+Defendants+Response+to+States+Alibi+Demand.pdf There weren't even the vaguest details about where he was, just that they...

Agree they should be considered together, but also recognized for what they are. On the 24th of July the defense filed their Notice of Defendant's Response to State's Alibi Demand, which had been filed by the state in May. They did not really provide an alibi so on the 27th of July the...

Your entire post referred to and quoted from the alibi response filed 17 April 2024. You quoted nothing from the Objection to the Motion to Compel. So I was looking at the document you referred to and quoted from and responding to the comments you made about that document. You said, "It...

My points addressed to Balthazar were all specifically addressed to the alibi response, which is what he was quoting from. The passage above is from last year when the defense filed an Objection to the State's Motion to Compel "Motive of Defense of Alibi". That was not the alibi response--they...

Snipped by me--okay, a couple of points. I don't see anywhere in the alibi response that the defense tries to claim BK left his Pullman apartment before midnight. They say that he was out driving around in the early morning hours of November 13th--that's Sunday, after midnight. Also, they...

Agree--all the other evidence just supports the main contention that HE left the sheath there with his dna on it THAT night.

I think it doesn't really matter where it was pinging prior to 2:42am. The primary point is that the pings of the phone are matching up with the video of the white Elantra they believe to be his. He might have been driving around prior to midnight, turned his phone off or not, but his phone...

So in your opinion, the defense expert is going to testify that BK never turned his phone off that night? And this expert will testify that he left his apartment before midnight? This might be a hard sell for the defense, though, as you say, we don't know what meta data they have. According...

The PCA says that the phone connected to a tower that provides service to Moscow on the 14th, but they don't believe the phone was in Moscow on that date--so maybe there's some confusion with the dates?

In your opinion, how do you think they will attempt to show that he wasn't in Moscow if his phone was turned off between 2:50am and 4:50am and it can't place him elsewhere? How will they introduce that if he chooses not to testify? If he had anything solid, like video evidence, electronic...

I think it probably is a coincidence because the plates were expiring. If he planned it that way, it backfired. He would have been better off having the front plate if it couldn't be read on the camera footage. The lack of the front plate would convince me more than any headlight expert the...

Snipped by me--when the video captured around 3:30am on Indian Hills Dr shows a white vehicle matching his, without a front license plate, it's going to be an almost impossible sell to the jury that the other cars captured in the natural progression of travel and the appropriate times are not...

In the new filing, the defense says: Bryan Kohberger's mobile device did not travel east on the Moscow-Pullman Highway in the early morning hours of November 13th, and thus could not be the vehicle captured on video along the Moscow-Pullman Highway near Floyd's Cannabis shop. The problem with...

https://patch.com/virginia/across-va/6-year-olds-gun-jammed-after-shooting-va-teacher-report-finds?utm_source=share-link&utm_medium=web&utm_campaign=share It could have been so much worse. From the article: The gun a 6-year-old boy used to shoot his teacher last year jammed after firing the...

I'm guessing if the IGG produced the lead before the other evidence the defense will want to fix it by throwing out the DNA evidence on the sheath if they can find some way to challenge the IGG. I'm not arguing the merits or likelihood of that, just offering it as explanation when people are...

I don't think we know when the results of the IGG came in--do you have a link that says they decided on BK before the results of the IGG? Because, if that's true, the IGG really doesn't matter--the defense can't use it to try to get the DNA thrown out and neither defense nor prosecution will...

23andMe is similar to Ancestry in that law enforcement can't access the databases without a court order.

Yes, they obtained his DNA from the sheath. But they had no matching DNA in any databases where DNA has been legally obtained to be matched, like CODIS or GEDMatch, etc. Before IGG that would be the end of the line. They would have to wait until BK's DNA was loaded to where they could legally...