CA - Lily Burk, 17, Los Angeles, 24 July 2009

Lily Burk and the Liberal Love Affair with Criminals
August 19, 2009
Senator Bob Dutton
<snipped>
Everyone knows that liberals have a soft spot for criminals. But few seem to realize that what was once a relatively harmless crush is now blossoming into a full-blown love affair.

A recent court order from a panel of unelected liberal judges requires California to release nearly 43,000 of approximately 160,000 prison inmates within the next two years. These judges, all appointed by Jimmy Carter in the 1970s, are clearly out of touch with reality. Yet, rather than protest their decision, California´s leftist Legislature seems ready and willing to go along with the idea.

In fact, on Thursday Democrat members of both the Senate and Assembly, with the apparent support of Governor Schwarzenegger, are planning to ram through a plan that will allow for the early release of 27,000.

The recent murder of 17-year-old high school senior Lily Burk provides a sobering warning to those who advocate the early release of prisoners. Burk´s body was discovered July 25&#8212;with throat slashed and head beaten&#8212;in the passenger seat of her Volvo in downtown Los Angeles. Police have arrested Charles Samuel, a 50-year old whom the system had determined was a "low-risk" parolee. It´s now abundantly clear that Samuel was anything but "low-risk."

Should thousands more "low-risk" parolees like Charles Samuel be released to roam California´s communities as envisioned by the court order or the current legislative proposal, it is inevitable that many more Lily Burks will soon be found dead on our streets. Releasing hardened criminals to make prison more roomy and comfortable for the remaining criminals is both foolish and short-sighted.

If California´s liberals do not come to their senses soon, it may be too late. You or someone you love could become the next Lily Burk.


Article:
http://www.californiachronicle.com/articles/view/115081
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
8/20/2009 - Senator Dutton Outraged by Legislation Releasing Felons Early
<snipped>
Ironically, on the same day there was world-wide outrage over Scotland&#8217;s decision to grant an early release of the man convicted for his role in the 1988 bombing of Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie that killed 270 passengers, the Democrat controlled Senate approved a measure that will allow early release of up to 27,000 dangerous felons into neighborhoods throughout California.

The bill passed the Senate on a 21-19 vote with Sen. Bob Dutton (R-Rancho Cucamonga) voting no.

&#8220;It was interesting to see how quickly world leaders, including the Obama administration, reacted to what Scotland called the compassionate release of a mass murderer,&#8221; Senator Dutton said. &#8220;But what was approved today will allow felons just as dangerous to be released from prison early.

&#8220;California is now a more dangerous place in which to live as the result of this disturbing measure passed by the Democrat controlled legislature today,&#8221; Senator Dutton continued.

Senator Dutton recently highlighted the case of Lily Burk, a 17-year-old high school senior who was recently murdered in Los Angeles by Charles Samuel, a San Bernardino County native who the judicial system determined was a &#8220;low-risk&#8221; parolee. (Read Senator Dutton&#8217;s Op-ed here). With the passage of the legislation today, Senator Dutton is concerned that more of these so-called &#8220;low-risk&#8221; parolees will be released early, putting the public&#8217;s safety at risk.

&#8220;There is no such thing as a &#8216;low-risk&#8217; parolee,&#8221; Senator Dutton said. &#8220;Today our neighborhoods are more dangerous. People&#8217;s lives and property are at risk.&#8221;


Article:
http://www.inlandempire.us/rss/article.php?client=redfusion&id=20090820195211

:angel:
 
Suspect in Lily Burk killing escaped possible 3rd strike in '06 attack
Charles Samuel slipped into the home of his ex-wife's boyfriend and punched him, court records show. Prosecutors, unaware of one of his two previous strikes, didn't seek a long prison term.
November 28, 2009 | 12:55 p.m.
<snipped>
Three years before he was charged with kidnapping and murdering 17-year-old Lily Burk, Charles Samuel slipped through an unlocked side door of a Van Nuys home.

The man living inside, James Alger, was dating Samuel's ex-wife, according court records newly obtained by The Times. As he spotted Samuel in his home, Alger confronted the intruder, asking why he had entered the house.

Samuel punched Alger two or three times in the face, leaving the victim bruised before Samuel snatched a cordless phone and keys and fled, according to a probation report released to The Times in response to an order from a court of appeals.

The Times argued in court papers that state law requires that a defendant's old probation reports -- normally public for 60 days after a defendant is sentenced -- be made public again when the offender is charged with a new crime.

The Times asked the California Court of Appeal to review the decision. An appeals court panel ordered the judge to release the report or explain her refusal to do so. Schnegg released the report Tuesday.

*Much more at link!

Article:
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-samuel29-2011nov11,0,329917.story
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Interactive timeline
The trail and trials of Charles Samuel
<snipped>
Charles Samuel's criminal record dates back more than 30 years to a misdemeanor conviction when he was 19. This interactive timeline traces his history using court, jail and prison records, as well as other law enforcement sources. Samuel, 50, has been charged with killing Lily Burk, a 17-year old Los Angeles high school student who went missing July 24 while running an errand for her mother. Click icons on timeline for more information.

Article:
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-charlessamuel-timeline,0,7810737.htmlstory

:angel:
 
A 17-year-old girl killed last July, allegedly by a transient parolee, had bite marks to her face and ear and had injuries all over her body showing she violently struggled with her attacker, a coroner&#8217;s official testified this morning.

[Updated at 3 p.m.: Samuel was ordered to stand trial this afternoon for the murder of Burk and other felony counts, including kidnapping, robbery and carjacking.
More at link


http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...f-violent-struggle-coroner-official-says.html
 
Lily Burk's Alleged Killer Charged with New Felony Counts at Preliminary Hearing
Fri., Jan. 22 2010 @ 5:10PM
<snipped>
A parolee who is accused of kidnapping and killing a 17-year-old Los Feliz teen was charged today with two new felony counts at a preliminary hearing in downtown Los Angeles.

Los Angeles County prosecutors charged 50-year-old Charlie Samuel with one felony count each of carjacking and kidnapping for carjacking, as well as a new special circumstance allegation that he killed Lily Belle Burk, the daughter of attorney Deboraz Drooz and former LA Weekly music editor Greg Burk, during the commission of a carjacking.

It is still unclear whether prosecutors will seek the death penalty.

A superior court judge is expected to rule on Monday whether there is enough evidence for Samuel to stand trial for the brutal slaying.


Article:
http://blogs.laweekly.com/ladaily/crime/lily-burks-alleged-killer-char/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Preliminary hearing opens in teen's death
Charles Samuel, 50, is accused of abducting and killing Lily Burk, 17, in downtown L.A.
January 22, 2010 | 9:37 p.m.
<snipped>
In broad daylight, a large, bald man in a patterned shirt walks into an ATM kiosk in downtown Los Angeles with one arm tightly wrapped around a petite, teenage girl, barefoot and in a sundress. When they emerge about two minutes later, the man appears to be grabbing her right arm and left wrist.

Prosecutors presented the surveillance footage Friday as a key piece of their murder case against Charles Samuel, the 50-year-old man they allege kidnapped 17-year-old Lily Burk in July and killed her after repeatedly trying to get her to withdraw money from the ATM.

The testimony at Friday's hearing revealed a series of moments that could have changed the course of the day's events.

*Minutes before Samuel allegedly kidnapped Burk, an assistant at Southwestern Law School offered to help Burk carry a box of exams out to her car, the assistant testified. The girl said she could manage, he testified, and walked out on her own. Burk's mother, an attorney, taught at the school

*A security director at the law school testified that he had noticed Samuel peering over a gate, then slipping onto the school's grounds. But when he saw the man leave the school's premises after getting a light, possibly for a cigarette, he stopped watching the man, thinking he was no longer of concern.

*The surveillance images from the downtown bank showed other ATM users and pedestrians walking past Samuel and Burk, but paying little attention to the pair.

One of his lawyers, Albert DeBlanc Jr., questioned the identification of Samuel from the grainy surveillance images and pressed the lead investigator on whether anyone could have tampered with the car between the late afternoon when Burk died and the next morning, when her body was found.


Murder suspect Charles Samuel is flanked by defense attorneys Ben Pesta II, left, and Albert DeBlanc Jr. at Clara Shortridge Foltz Criminal Justice Center in Los Angeles. January 22, 2010
51802651.jpg


Article:
http://www.latimes.com/news/local/la-me-lily-burk23-2010jan23,0,4260975.story
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
UPDATED: Lily Burk autopsy shows evidence of a violent struggle, coroner's official says
January 25, 2010 | 1:13 pm
<snipped>
A 17-year-old girl killed last July, allegedly by a transient parolee, had bite marks to her face and ear and had injuries all over her body showing she violently struggled with her attacker, a coroner&#8217;s official testified this morning.

[Updated at 3 p.m.:
Samuel was ordered to stand trial this afternoon for the murder of Burk and other felony counts, including kidnapping, robbery and carjacking.

Judge David S. Wesley found there was &#8220;sufficient cause&#8221; to believe Samuel is guilty of the crimes, and ordered him to return to court in February for arraignment. The judge denied a motion by Samuel&#8217;s attorney to dismiss the case.]

Gutstadt said most of the injuries occurred while Burk was still alive. She was killed by an incision to the right side of her neck, possibly caused by a broken bottle, which would have caused her to lose consciousness within minutes, the examiner testified.

The examiner also testified that Burk had sustained abrasions and contusions to her scalp, possibly indicating that her head had been hit against the car&#8217;s dashboard or struck from above with an object.

Burk&#8217;s mother, Deborah Drooz, clutched onto a handkerchief and quietly sobbed, her body shaking, as the coroner&#8217;s official testified. The girl&#8217;s father left the courtroom before the testimony began.


Article:
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/lan...f-violent-struggle-coroner-official-says.html
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Coroner: Los Feliz Teen Lily Burk Died from Fatal Wound to Neck
Mon., Jan. 25 2010 @ 2:45PM
<snipped>
Dr. Jeffrey P. Gutstadt testified at a preliminary hearing that the Oakwood School student had injuries from head to toe, including a fatal wound to her neck. The weapon used was consistent with a broken glass bottle, he said.

"Fragments of a green broken glass bottle were observed in [Burk's] hair," according to the autopsy report.

There also appeared to be "bite marks" on her left face and neck, bruising marks to her "right leg, right knee and right forearm with her left ankle appearing to be dislocated."

"The windshield on the passenger side was shattered as if [Burk] was attempting to kick out the window in an apparent struggle," according to the autopsy report.


Article:
http://blogs.laweekly.com/ladaily/crime/coroner-los-feliz-teen-died-fr/
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Suspect ordered to stand trial in Lily Burk's slaying
Charles Samuel, 50, is accused of kidnapping and killing the teen in July 2009. A coroner's official testifies that Burk had wounds all over her body, indicating she struggled with her attacker.

January 26, 2010
<snipped>
After hearing the evidence presented by the prosecution over two days, L.A. County Superior Court Judge David S. Wesley ordered Samuel to stand trial for Burk's slaying and other felony counts, including carjacking, robbery and kidnapping. Prosecutors have not said whether they intend to seek the death penalty against Samuel.

Burk, who was 5 feet 2 and weighed 100 pounds, had blunt-force trauma injuries and hemorrhaging on her scalp, wounds consistent with bite marks on the left side of her face and her left earlobe, as well as bruises and other injuries to her back, knees, legs, forearms and the bottom of her feet, Gutstadt testified. He also said that Burk had bruising on both wrists, possibly indicating that someone was holding them in a tight grip. The injuries on her scalp could suggest that her head had been hit against the car's dashboard or struck from above with an object, he said.

According to sheriff's records, Samuel is 5 feet 9 and weighs 185 pounds.

A forensic print specialist for the Los Angeles Police Department testified later in the morning that broken shards of green-colored glass were found in the black Volvo where Burk's body was found. No fingerprints were found on the glass, she testified during cross-examination by Samuel's attorney, Albert DeBlanc Jr.

But a print found on a soda can in the Volvo matched Samuel's, a different forensic expert testified. Additionally, an L.A. County sheriff's criminalist said on the stand that a bloodstain on the shirt Samuel was wearing at the time of his arrest contained DNA that matched Burk's. The criminalist testified that the shirt also had smaller quantities of DNA, possibly what is known in forensics as "wearer's DNA," that could belong to Samuel.


Article:
http://articles.latimes.com/2010/jan/26/local/la-me-burk26-2010jan26
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
AUDIO: Alleged kidnapper and murderer of Lily Burk to stand trial
A Los Angeles Superior Court Judge has ordered Charlie Samuel to stand trial. Samuel is charged in the abduction and murder of 17-year-old Lily Burk last summer. More on the story from KPCC's Brian Watt. His arraignment is scheduled February 9th.
http://media.scpr.org/audio/features/20100125_features3053.mp3
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Accused teen killer ordered to stand trial
Monday, January 25, 2010
<snipped>
A parolee accused of kidnapping and killing a 17-year-old Los Feliz girl has been ordered to stand trial, and DNA evidence was a key factor in the judge's ruling.

The autopsy on the body of Lily Burk shows evidence of a violent struggle, according to officials from the coroner's office who testified Monday at a preliminary hearing of the teen's accused killer. The judge in the case listened to graphic details of Burk's murder, and he ordered 50-year-old Charles Samuel to stand trial.

Monday, a judge ordered a trial for Samuel after ruling there is enough evidence to support one count each of murder, kidnapping to commit robbery, carjacking, kidnapping for carjacking, second-degree robbery, attempted first-degree ATM robbery, along with the special circumstance allegations of murder during a kidnapping, robbery and carjacking.

Prosecutors are expected to decide later whether to seek the death penalty for Samuel, who they alleged has previous conviction of robbery and petty theft with a prior. The judge has ordered Samuel to return to court next month for arraignment.

*More At Link!

Video: Accused teen killer ordered to stand trial 2:02
http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/video?id=7239029

Article:
http://abclocal.go.com/kabc/story?section=news/local/los_angeles&id=7239033
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Autopsy Shows Lily Burk Fought for Her Life
7:27 AM PST, January 26, 2010
<snipped>
A judge on Monday ordered a trial for Charlie Samuel after ruling there is enough evidence to support charges of murder, kidnapping and robbery.

He will be arraigned Feb. 9.

Earlier, the coroner testified that the autopsy conducted on Burk showed the teenage engaged in a violent struggle with her attacker.

"The cause of death was (an) incised wound to the neck," Dr. Jeffrey P. Gutstadt.

The fatal wound was consistent with having been inflicted by a sharp object such as a broken glass bottle, Gutstadt said.

Fingerprints found in her car led police to 50-year old Charlie Samuel.


Charlie Samuel, 50, in court 1/28/09
48334074.jpg


Video: Lily Burk Remembered by Family, Friends
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-video-burk-funeral,0,3032202.tivideo

Video: Error Kept Charlie Samuel on Streets
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-video-lily-burk-death,0,1641051.tivideo

Photos: Remembering Lily Burk
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/la-me-lily-burk-pictures,0,5023600.photogallery

Video: Parolee Arrested in Death of Lily Burk Should Have Been Supervised
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-video-girl-dead-car,0,534874.tivideo

Video: Suspect In Burk Abduction Shook Supervision
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-burk-video,0,7122803.tivideo

Video: Self Defense Classes Popular After Abduction
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-video-self-defense-classes,0,3004797.tivideo

Article:
http://www.ktla.com/news/landing/ktla-lily-burk,0,1344096.story
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ ~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Judge Orders Parolee to Stand Trial in the Murder of 17-Year- Old Lily Burke
Wednesday, 27 January 2010
<snipped>
The ruling came after about 1 1/2 days of testimony, including a DNA analyst's account that a blood sample from the teen matched the genetic profile of blood taken from a short sleeved shirt allegedly discarded by the 50-year- old defendant.

Cristina Gonzalez, a senior criminalist with the Los Angeles County Sheriff's Department, told the judge that the likelihood of that DNA profile was 1 out of 165 quadrillion, noting there are only 6.5 billion people on Earth.


The shirt also contained lower DNA levels from a second contributor &#8212; with Samuel included as a possible contributor in what could be "wearer's DNA" on an item habitually worn by a person, the criminalist testified.

Allan Villacorte, a latent prints examiner for the Los Angeles Police Department, testified that he compared fingerprints taken from the defendant and a latent print recovered from a Coca-Cola can found on a floorboard in Burk's black Volvo, and determined that "they were both from the same individual."

Samuel, who is jailed without bail, is due back at the downtown LosAngeles courthouse on Feb. 9 for arraignment.


Article:
http://www.sanfernandosun.com/sanfernsun/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=4824&Itemid=2

:angel:
 
i dont get california anymore the i get my own state.
too much bowing dow to criminal rights and the theory that these 'people' can be redeeemd.
they make that ruling shortly after lily is murdered.........and a week before jaycee was found.
when does the madness stop? when do the voters elect people that are tough on crime, or when do the ones who claim they are tough on crime, actually vote like it?
 
It's time to unfold the eyes of Lady Justice
Published: March 23, 2010
Updated: March 26, 2010 1:25 p.m.
<snipped>
Is the problem in the criminal justice system, or could it be in the social structure of our society, where there are more excuses for lack of accountability? Should the goal of the criminal justice system to be the conviction of the guilty, fair trails for all, or the elimination and reduction of such brutal crimes?

On the other hand, if fair trails are the goal, and crime still dominates, then how could we maintain our confidence?

We live in a country that has shown concern for other nations' lack of fairness and harmful cultures and customs. Perhaps it is time to rethink some aspects of the infrastructure of our traditional criminal justice system.

In memoriam of Chelsea King, Amber Dubois, and Lily Burk.


Article:
http://www.ocregister.com/news/criminal-240616-justice-ribbons.html
 
Thank God Lily's sweet parents won't have to be tortured with a trial for this - while I'd love to see him fry, having to see the Burks go through years of torture via trial and appeals...well, I'm sure you get my point. Now if California will just use prison overcrowding as an excuse to put him and those like him in the general prison population (aka a real death sentence), I'll be really satisfied.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
196
Guests online
3,844
Total visitors
4,040

Forum statistics

Threads
591,764
Messages
17,958,546
Members
228,603
Latest member
megalow
Back
Top