1015 users online (239 members and 776 guests)  


Websleuths News


Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 21
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    37,778

    Question about SARS

    Question for professional searchers, if anyone sees this.

    After watching 48 Hours on Amber's case last week, I noted that Amber's mom hired her own search team of dogs, and that the dogs picked up Amber's scent after 6 months, and led the handlers all the way to the Indian land, within a half mile of where she was found 6 months later. (this was several miles from where she was taken, 15 miles I think they said.)

    I always thought that Kyron could not be traced at all because he was taken into a car right in the Skyline lot, yet these dogs led the way onto a freeway, off an exit and more.

    Have you heard of this before and wonder why they don't try it with Kyron?
    Just my opinion, of course.

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Posts
    671
    Quote Originally Posted by cluciano63 View Post
    Question for professional searchers, if anyone sees this.

    After watching 48 Hours on Amber's case last week, I noted that Amber's mom hired her own search team of dogs, and that the dogs picked up Amber's scent after 6 months, and led the handlers all the way to the Indian land, within a half mile of where she was found 6 months later. (this was several miles from where she was taken, 15 miles I think they said.)

    I always thought that Kyron could not be traced at all because he was taken into a car right in the Skyline lot, yet these dogs led the way onto a freeway, off an exit and more.

    Have you heard of this before and wonder why they don't try it with Kyron?
    I'm not a SARS expert, but I did exchange PM's with Sarx at the time the dogs were being discussed on the forum. He seemed to feel that locating a scent after six months was HIGHLY unlikely.

    Actually this was a coincidence of sorts IMO. I live in the area and the "wonder dogs" did not even take the same route as JG. The dogs indicated that Amber was at the library in Pala (reservation). The handlers even insisted that the member of the tribe "knew" something, but seemed unwilling to share IIRC.

    The grandmother hired the dogs, against the wishes of Mo and Kerry, IIRC, also. I'll try to add a link or two. There was also a long discussion about the dogs on the Chelsea and Amber threads.

    The route Gardner says he drove to Pala seems to discredit the results of two search dogs last summer. The dogs had been hired by McGonigle’s mother, Sheila Welch, and their handlers at the time said the dogs had somehow tracked Amber’s scent, six months after she had disappeared, from in front of the high school, up Interstate 15, and then east to Pala. In fact, if what Gardner says is true, he got to Pala from the opposite direction. Many in law enforcement had scoffed at the idea the dogs could have tracked Amber that far, that long after she had disappeared.
    http://www.signonsandiego.com/news/2...ite-abduction/
    BBM

    I tried to do a search for "Sarx" and Amber Dubois, but wasn't able to come up with anything right away...
    "Outside of a dog, a book is man's best friend. Inside of a dog, it's too dark to read."
    Groucho Marx

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Dana Point,CA
    Posts
    52,752
    Last edited by OkieGranny; 02-22-2016 at 04:47 PM. Reason: broken link

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    5,159
    Quote Originally Posted by cluciano63 View Post
    Question for professional searchers, if anyone sees this.

    After watching 48 Hours on Amber's case last week, I noted that Amber's mom hired her own search team of dogs, and that the dogs picked up Amber's scent after 6 months, and led the handlers all the way to the Indian land, within a half mile of where she was found 6 months later. (this was several miles from where she was taken, 15 miles I think they said.)

    I always thought that Kyron could not be traced at all because he was taken into a car right in the Skyline lot, yet these dogs led the way onto a freeway, off an exit and more.

    Have you heard of this before and wonder why they don't try it with Kyron?
    I am not an expert but I spotted a few inconsistencies just based on the show.

    For one thing, towards the end of the show, when Amber's mother had a chance to question John Gardner, she found out that Gardner abducted Amber from a side street, one that Amber did not normally use in going to school. That's how Gardner was able to abduct her without witnesses; the eyewitness reports placing Amber near the school driveway were mistaken.

    The dogs appeared to follow Amber's usual route to school. Ooops! That says to me that the dogs were following cues from the handlers rather than following scent.

    Both various LE agencies and the military have done a lot of testing to see if dogs can follow humans in cars. The results I am familiar with go back to the 90s, so I'm not exactly up to date. At that time, though, the verdict was mixed. Dogs can sometimes follow scent from a human in a car but it is heavily dependent on variables. Older cars are more likely to be followed, probably because they are not as airtight as newer models (more dents and bangs, door gaskets worn out or torn, etc).

    The vehicle they showed, implying it was either Gardner's or one similar, was quite new and looked to be in very good condition. I wouldn't expect it to leak a lot of air. Gardner's testimony was that he rolled the window down initially, which suggests electric windows. Considering the risk of the victim screaming, I doubt he left the windows down while transporting her.

    It was fairly clear that Amber was not located near her home because that entire area was searched thoroughly. The logical places would be outside that initial radius and the reservation, with its abundance of land, small roads and pull offs, would be a good guess.

    Dogs are really, really good at reading their handler's body language and going what the handler wants, rather than where the evidence (scent) leads them.

    There is an awful lot of handler error that goes on with handlers of scent dogs.

    That particular case makes me think that it was similar to cases "solved" by psychics; they got a few results that were kinda close to what really happened, so the handlers decided they were accurate.

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    1,769
    I really wish something would bring Kyron home.
    Search dogs.
    Psychics.
    Guilty conscience.
    God.
    Luck.
    Good Sleuthing.
    An angel.
    Anything. Just...anything.
    "Keep your friends close, your enemies closer, and the cookies at the other end of the table." - Kingkeld.

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Jul 2004
    Location
    Dana Point,CA
    Posts
    52,752
    [ame="http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?t=97380"]Dogs - Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community[/ame]

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Mar 2009
    Posts
    43,418
    We need to stay on topic here and how this relates to Kyron please.

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Dec 2003
    Posts
    14,189
    Kyron may have left the school in a vehicle, but what if he was taken back to the home or near the home. I think the ravines all around the home and surrounding properties should be thoroughly searched with people, dogs, whatever it takes to search every bit.

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2010
    Posts
    37,778
    If this thread was not appropriate, I apologize and please delete it.
    Just my opinion, of course.

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jul 2010
    Posts
    1,769
    I didn't find it inappropriate.
    Perhaps my answer was, Idk.
    I really wish they would have search dogs search VERY close to the school, and VERY close to the house.
    I don't know if it's too late now, but he really needs to be found.
    "Keep your friends close, your enemies closer, and the cookies at the other end of the table." - Kingkeld.


  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Posts
    5,159
    Quote Originally Posted by mmmagique View Post
    I didn't find it inappropriate.
    Perhaps my answer was, Idk.
    I really wish they would have search dogs search VERY close to the school, and VERY close to the house.
    I don't know if it's too late now, but he really needs to be found.
    As I recall from the early media coverage (first two weeks), they did have search dogs covering the area around the school very intensively.

    Other media reports have referred to multiple searches, with dogs, around the Sheltered Nook home.

    My guess is that Kyron is probably not within one mile of either the school or his home but probably not more than ten miles from either. This is strictly a guess, though.

    As I recall, someone mentioned a large park or wilderness area about five miles away. That's one place I'd be really curious about.

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    6,304
    Just found this and thought I might be able to "help". Well, maybe not help but I can answer the question at hand.
    There is nobody I know that would put their name on a 6 month old trail. I would not trust anyone if they said they would. True, dogs were brought in by the Grandmother in Amber's case, they were dogs for hire as nobody else would have done it. I am sure that there are handlers out there that could be paid to do a search for Kyron (trailing), but in my professional opinion this is bordering on criminal. At the bare minimum it is seriously taking advantage of people and their money.
    Yes, dogs can be affected by their handlers, they can be pulled on and off of a trail either by accident or on purpose.
    Dogs, just like everything else have their limits and a six month old trail is way past their limit! Hope that helps.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Jun 2010
    Location
    Portland
    Posts
    986
    Thanks for answering SARX. I can't remember what your area of expertise is but do you know if divers can search all year round in cold (but not frozen) water? Is there a limit to how low the temps can go?

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Mar 2010
    Posts
    6,304
    I am not a SAR diver, but do have a close friend who is and have worked with them several times. They are really only limited by the gear they have. Searches take place in frozen waters where they have to break through the ice to get in regularly. So, yes, they can work in cold waters, how long they stay down will be affected though.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Dec 2009
    Posts
    7,762
    Quote Originally Posted by sarx View Post
    Just found this and thought I might be able to "help". Well, maybe not help but I can answer the question at hand.
    There is nobody I know that would put their name on a 6 month old trail. I would not trust anyone if they said they would. True, dogs were brought in by the Grandmother in Amber's case, they were dogs for hire as nobody else would have done it. I am sure that there are handlers out there that could be paid to do a search for Kyron (trailing), but in my professional opinion this is bordering on criminal. At the bare minimum it is seriously taking advantage of people and their money.
    Yes, dogs can be affected by their handlers, they can be pulled on and off of a trail either by accident or on purpose.
    Dogs, just like everything else have their limits and a six month old trail is way past their limit! Hope that helps.
    Want to stay on topic (Kyron) but also want to answer this question re: SAR dogs from a professional standpoint. I am on the other side of the country, but I too do not know any professional dog handler that would put their name on a 6 month trail.

    It doesn't hold in court, even if the MP is found, because defense attorneys rip the stats on these trails to shreds. So it ends up being a worthless claim (whether true or not) to the justice system.
    (I am verified SAR, fwiw.)

    HTH.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast


Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 8
    Last Post: 09-26-2013, 10:04 AM
  2. Copyright question/ Online photo question
    By laini in forum Forum Finesse
    Replies: 6
    Last Post: 07-08-2008, 10:54 AM