920 users online (180 members and 740 guests)  


The Killing Season - Websleuths

Websleuths News


Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 22
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    State called Jason Forgey.

    JB: complains about something

    HHJP: there is no argument. State proves by testimony or they don't.

    (Casey looks uncomfortable because of this witness imo)

    LDB: how employeed

    specialized control K-9 unit

    LDB: how long OCSO?

    ? sorry

    LDB: ?

    K 9 handler, have worked a dog since 2001

    LDB: so for the last ten years you have handled k9 for law enforcement?

    yes

    LDB: training and qualifications that you have?

    the k 9 unit prior to interviewing or actually going into the unit. cross training, I talked to them about working dogs and I transfered there in 2001.

    LDB: ?

    I received a dog in 2001 I went in as a part time handler because I was training then revceived my dog.

    LDB: you trained not independ. of dog?

    correct
    scent discrimination, man training was the first training with the OCSO

    LDB: how long

    five weeks, two in class room and weeks in field

    LDB: Garret?

    yes

    LDB: aside from the training period that was completed, follow up training?

    yes, we have a minimum of training. must have two tracks enough. a supervisor is called out quarterly.

    LDB: how long with k9 Garret?

    nine months till had to put him down

    LDB: another dog?

    yes, Ike another blood hound

    LDB: train?

    yes, the same man tracking, scent discrimination. he learns the scent of what you scent him on. he must go to that one person correctly before he goes to next stage.

    LDB: how long with k9 Ike?

    somewhere in 2004 2005 I gave to another handler

    LDB: did you have multiple dogs?

    yes

    LDB: in different things?

    another dog besides Ike?

    Witness: yes-Bones has one job and one job only. taught to detect human decom. specifically cadavers. speciality standards, profenency...I was chosen after 911 towers... EOD dog is an explosive dog and we needed more dogs at the time. I worked the two dogs.

    LDB: Ike and Bones

    correct

    LDB: training a single purpose dog for human remains is different?

    correct. an imprinting stage, sorry an introduction to make sure dog will be okay. then inprinting you take him to it over and over and train him for a final alert. Take them to it and tell them sit and reward him, after that stage you get into searching. for example if odor was in can you give command and he is to go to right can and gets toy and handler praise.

    LDB: an alert is that how you know they have detected?

    alert is when he is in odor and working odor

    LDB: the final is different? the final alert?

    if my water bottle is the source of the odor and if the dog is working from this side you would see his breathing pattern, start to brackett, he would work it to source. by training him and working so many odors you know he is in the odor but not found it but then give me final alert.

    LDB: once the dog detects the odor you can see there is a behavioral change?

    yes

    LDB: when dog gets to source you expect him to give final trained alert?

    a sit

    LDB: sit?

    yes

    LDB: what sort of aids were used for Bones during imprint?

    in imprint we used mostly rags with human decomp, in the chest cavady of a cadaver.

    LDB: that is imprint stage, then move to other training aids?

    yes

    LDB: what sort of training aids?

    "bones" human bones, placentas, chest cavidey rags...psudoscent is an odor, I brought some with me.

    LDB: drowning victim only, put into water and see if dog can detect that?

    pond, the lake, puts out the odor of drown victim. drop tablets in water let it sit and you run your dog on it

    LDB: any training aids you used with bones?

    blood also, psudo tissue, decomp on rags, grave dirt, dirt where a cadaver had been recovered from

    LDB: you made reference to not having Bones

    correct

    LDB: decision made by OCSO that a full service dog not a specialized dog?

    yes

    LDB: what happened to Bones?

    we tried to make him full service dog and he didn't make it, they decided they would like me to work a full service dog and they retired him. he went to a captain at that time and sgr Brewer got him from them.

    LDB: ?

    at the time locally sworn LE I covered multiple counties.

    LDB: how long?

    long time

    LDB: Bones was the only cadaver dog in the area for a while?

    correct

    LDB: so once you had a full service k9 was needed get a new one?

    Garus, german sheppard

    LDB: same breeding program as it relates to Bones?

    no bought Garus

    LDB: he come from Germany?

    yes, imported

    LDB: was a puppy?

    no 21 months his birthday was October 20 and he will be nine this October

    LDB: ?

    basic control k9 work. teach obedience. scent discrimination. tracking. 400 hour school.

    LDB: once that is complete is Garus certified to do police work?

    yes, evaluated by two outside evaluators. Obedience, voice, criminal apprehention...then certified

    LDB: you work with him,

    you are the only person that works with your dog, when he is tested you are tested.

    LDB: after fulfilling the certification is there further training?

    go back to school and he does 160 hours for his cadaver dog work

    LDB: what do?

    same things, introduce them to odor, imprint them, teach him responses. his final alert was different than bones, he lays down at source

    LDB: what sort of items did you utilize to imprint Garus on human remains?

    the same, rags soaked in chest cavady placenta...

    LDB: Garus?

    grave dirt, human bones, adopicer, blood placenta, burnt bones, psudo scent.

    LDB: drown victim?

    yes, but not in normal training.

    LDB: proof them off of other odors from what they are trained to do?

    you want to think of scenerios they find in life. make sure they are not affected by that. Garus in his whole career never received a bone so as not to teach him to chew on bones. we train him around ham, dumpsters, gas you use in your car. distractors with cheese burgers, decomposing animals, chained him around animal remains, near a horse...purposely train that way.

    LDB: horses, does that include Garus wouldn't alter to dog urine or feces as well?

    correct, we have multiple dogs we also have dogs that urinate on poles and they are not going to alert on that at all.

    LDB: expose them to, Garus in particular, different invironments? Landfill, parking lots?

    Yes, tried to expose him to everything. I went to the fire training pile and mock a recovery...drainage pipes...in cars, fields every scenerio I could think of at the time.

    LDB: when you are training Garus you know where the scent is hidden?

    correct

    LDB: after initial training, does he go to specialty schools?

    yes

    LDB: is this a place where both you and the dog have no idea where the smell is set up?

    correct, unknown finds

    LDB: unknown to you.

    yes, always unknown to the dog but in this case unknown to me.

    LDB: heard of any bias by a handler?

    yes, false altert

    LDB: what was done with Garus to avoid that?

    you will only find false alert with new handlers, our department goes to great lenghths to avoid that. stages where you introduce him imprint him and then search him. I let the lead slack, he stops and I walk...I keep on walking to make sure you do not que your dogs.

    LDB: Garus have evaluation by outside source?

    yes, initially

    LDB: certified to do all kinds of work, including cadaver work?

    yes

    LDB: basic cadaver school hosted by an enitity separate from OCSO?

    yes, Andy Redman and his company, a school, I applied for it and went

    LDB: Redman is identified as a expert in training?

    yes, a week long seminar
    John 14:6

  2. #2
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Orange County
    Posts
    1,437

    Jason Forgey testimony (OCSO dog handler of Gerus and Bones)

    State calls Jason Forgey as the next witness.

    Direct examination of Officer Jason Forgey by LDB:

    (He is in OCSO uniform)

    He is employed with OCSO assigned to specialized patrol, K-9 unit. Been with OCSO since 1994, 17 years.

    He currently handles a full service dog and has worked a dog since 2001.

    Training that initially qualified him - he cross trained with the K-9 unit prior to interviewing or going into the unit. Cross training meant he watch dogs, caught dogs, talked to them about working dogs and then transferred there.

    He received a dog in 2001 when he went in as a part time blood hound handler. A few months later he became a full time handler.

    His training initially was scent determination/man handling with his blood hound. Lasted 5 weeks, 3 in class, 2 in field, then proficiency test. This was K-9 Garret. He then did follow-up training consisting of meeting the monthly minimum of 2 training tracks a month and a supervisor would observe once a quarter. He worked with this dog for 10 or 11 months until the dog had to be put down.

    He then received Ike, another blood hound. He trained Ike the same way - scent discrimination/man tracking and man trailing. He worked with Ike until he gave him to another handler in 2004 or 5.

    At some point he had multiple dogs he was training.

    In 2002 he received a german shepherd from a breading program named Bones, a single purpose cadaver dog, meaning this is his only job. He is taught to detect human decomp. 160 hours of specialty training and then the dog is certified in proficiency of working and can be deployed in field. These dogs were after 9/11 and the dogs had been converted over from bomb dogs.

    Purpose of single purpose dog - training - introduction of dog to odor, imprinting stage then you train him for what you want him to do in his final alert - such as sitting.

    The alert is the dog's indication that he has found the scent he has been trained on - any body change that the handler recognizes. The final trained alert is different - it's when he is worked to source - using water bottle as source - you would see the dog's behavior change as he approached the odor, but hasn't gotten to the source. When he reaches the source, the dog gives the final trained alert - such as sitting.

    He trained Bones to proceed in this fashion. His final trained alert was a sit. Aids to train him in imprinting were mostly the rags with human decomp on them. They soak rags in the chest cavity of cadavers. Bones then went to training aids such as actually human bones, placentas, chest cavity rags, pseudo scent of drown victims - a man made odor in tablet form to see if the dog can detect the scent in a body of water. He also used blood and grave dirt as a training aid.

    He does not have Bones anymore. The Sheriff decided that a full service dog was needed as opposed to a single purpose dog. They tried to convert Bones, but he couldn't do it. They then retired Bones and he went to a captain at OCSO and then to Osceola County Sheriff's Office as a single purpose dog. At the time this witness covered multiple counties as the only sworn officer with his single purpose cadaver dog.

    Once he received a full service dog (while still working blood hound), he received Garris, a german shepherd. They bought him from a vendor in Germany. He was a little over a year. He will be 9 in October. He was sent to a program - 400 hour school - basic patrol K-9 work. Garris was then FDLE certified to do case work - evaluated by 2 outside evaluators in obedience, hand and voice, criminal patrols, building and outside areas. Dog and officer are tested as a team.

    Garris received additional training consisting of 160 hours ini cadaver dog work. Introduction, imprinting and then he was taught to lay down at a source instead of a sit like Bones. The same training aids were used in imprint and final source training, in addition to body parts such as a leg and foot.

    During process they are taught to proof off of other distracting odors - Garris never had a bone at all - no raw hide bone - didn't want him to learn to chew on bones. They trained them around ham bones, dumpsters, gas, cheeseburgers, pizza, decomposing animals, other animal scent, horse training rings, dog urine or feces. Garris was also exposed to different environments, construction area, drainage pipes, in cars, under cars, in fields, every scenario he could think of. When he is training Garris, he knows where the scent is hidden.

    Garris received training in specialty schools in which he and the dog both do not know where the training aid is. The testing by OCSO are unknown finds also. This is done to evaluate the officer and the dog as a team.

    Regarding cuing or bias on the handler, this could create a false alert. OCOS goes to great lengths to avoid this. They are trained to avoid this from the beginning. He lets the lead slack in his hand. If the dog stops, he would keep moving behind the dog to make sure to not cue the dog. This is usually only a problem for inexperienced handlers.

    Garris underwent an evaluation outside the agency after being certified. He went to a basic cadaver school in Sarasota organized by one of the search and rescue groups. Andy Redman and company hosted a seminar/school. He is recognized a leader in the field of cadaver dogs.

    Lunch recess until 1:30. Judge hopes they enjoy their lunch today.

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    Casey Anthony is speaking to Dorothy Clay Sims. Casey is smirking, holding back a smile. Casey Anthony is now speaking to Jose Baez while covering her mouth with a fist. Jose flips through red folders as she speaks, making no attempt to turn his head her way. Casey got red files from Jose, Jose turned her way and took back several of the folders while leaving some that Casey began to flip though.
    John 14:6

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    HHJP: Let's return the jury.

    Sargent Forgy Witness

    All rise for the jury.

    HHJP: was your outing for lunch okay? alright.

    LDB: states "nr" for identification.

    HHJP: all right.

    LDB "nr" do you recognize the documents contained therein?

    (looking at documents) yes

    LDB: what?

    Gerus's training logs, along with my training experience.

    LDB: enter into evidence

    HHJP: what says the defense?

    JB: objection, hearsay

    HHJP: Let me see them. (HHJP is given documents by LDB )

    JB: (is not near mic)

    HHJP: can you ask a few questions for the record?

    LDB: yes, did you see the first set, let me get those back to you...

    Thank you

    LDB: what are they?

    certification for me and Gerus, certification training course

    LDB: that is the one you already explained and a certificate was awarded?

    yes

    LDB: next?

    David Wade, actual certification. He was evaluating the dog and passed the certification memo

    LDB: OCSO?

    yes

    LDB: monitoring Gerus, your record?

    yes

    LDB: next document?

    for the original outside course I went to which was put on by k9 search and assoc.

    LDB: business record your responsibility?

    yes( I am )

    LDB: knowledge if those documents were made at the time of certification?

    yes, I made copies for myself and the defense from my records. The next one is the same certificate in a different format. 2005

    LDB: okay

    next is advanced cadaver school by same organization in sarasota hosted by Andy (rippman?)

    LDB: you person responsible for business record?

    yes

    LDB: exact duplicate?

    yes

    LDB: next?

    k9 team certification 12 31 2008 for Gerus. Gives his ID number...part of certification

    LDB: is that part of the business record you maintain for the OCSO?

    yes

    LDB: next?

    examination and evaluation for Gerus, same number ID

    LDB: next?

    this is a single form for 2010, I believe, sorry wrong it is 2006 also.

    LDB: is that the multi page form?

    yes

    LDB: are you the person responsible for the records for OCSO for Gerus?

    yes I am, this is another form for myself and Gerus, a certification from november 2007 same ID number for K9, multiple page form. Those are all pages continuous to december 2007.

    LDB: what are those?

    copy of training logs I complete when I do a training senerio, july 2005 which go thru sept 6th 2008. They are all his training logs. Cadaver only.

    LDB: you are the one who makes the entry on the log?

    I am

    LDB: at the time of the training?

    yes

    LDB: you are the one responsible for maintaining the business record for OCSO?

    I am

    LDB: ?

    HHJP: you may
    John 14:6

  5. #5
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    JB: the records, you are in charge of keeping them?

    yes

    JB: so you can show in court the dog has been trained?

    yes

    JB: so you can show judge and jury the dog is trained?

    yes

    JB: certificates are concerned it is the same?

    correct

    JB: as far as training logs go, this deals with when you trained the dog?

    yes sir I was with the dog

    JB: this has nothing to do with performance?

    ?

    JB: field performance, not training.

    LDB: objection

    sustained

    JB: nothing further

    HHJP: any objections to the proffered subjects?

    JB: cites case law

    HHJP: ? vs State april 21st 2011 the supreme court found that (numbers) I will admit them into evidence.
    John 14:6

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    LDB: may I publish documents from the exhibit into evidence?

    HHJP: you may

    LDB: andy redman?

    november 1st 2005

    LDB: if I may(not near mic) even though you were under going training with outside group you were responsible for info?

    yes

    LDB: tell us what this info is that you put on log and reason for

    who dog is who handler is the date the time and what we did that day. We trained all day because it was a seminar, sarasoda florida, search area, if target was found or not.

    LDB: as far as the requirements of this school, these are the different environments the dog was exposed to in training?

    a pipe a drain pipe a culvert, a field, a trailer like a portable and gravel mounds of gravel where a dumptruck had dumped gravel.

    LDB: cadaver material was ultimately found?

    yes

    LDB: you made indication as to whether he missed?

    yes, but he located all targets

    LDB: you have number of searches and have total false alters to date, what is it?

    that is what the box is for

    LDB: next collum you have total misses is that a situation where the target, (my fault she says, thank you) okay this first box is the different search areas, this box is training locations and then circle target found in this instance Gerus found all targets?

    correct

    LDB: here is where there would be a false alert?

    correct

    LDB: whether there was something a miss?

    correct

    LDB: then the number of finds?

    yes

    LDB: this day there were eight targets and eight finds?

    yes

    LDB: what info is put on bottom?

    weather, day the condition hot or cold, raining, humid, fog. Wind direction, speed, then comment section

    LDB: your comments to the different targets used in training?

    yes

    LDB: all records are done like this?

    yes

    LDB: may I approach witness with "ns"..."ny" "oa" "ob"..."oh"...

    Approaches witness
    John 14:6

  7. #7
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    LDB: do you recognize?

    yes, me and Gerus training at the seminars in 05 and 06

    LDB: do those photos fairly and accurately depict that training?

    yes

    LDB: enter into evidence?

    HHJP: yes, entered into evidence.

    (court reporter giving long lost of evidence entered by letter and given a number)

    LDB: May I publish these?

    HHJP: You may

    LDB: you indicated the photos incompassed Gerus's training at two different schools?

    yes

    LDB: 2005 in Sarasota more?

    yes 2005 and 2006

    LDB: what is difference?

    basic cadaver and advanced cadaver

    LDB: what difference?

    more of the distracting a more profecent and advanced school, you will see in pics what they had to go thru to pick up the right stuff, the distracters.

    LDB: which school? (is showing pic of Gerus at training)

    2006

    LDB: (is having slight technical difficulties: there is glare) IMHO: she is very professional.
    John 14:6

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    LDB: it is the light from the ceiling causing a reflection.
    John 14:6

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    LDB: what are we looking at?

    interrior search a haunted house

    LDB: you can touch the screen

    it is in front of him, it is where his head is turned in this direction of a pile of clothes

    LDB: any indicators during this session this dog is alterting?

    his ears are sticking out, he is proud a head snap working into odor, we were walking down the hall way I thought he was going to go into the room but did not gave a head snap and then gave final alert.

    LDB: state's 146 in evidence, what are we looking at here?

    the bone room within the haunted house, for obvious reasons. Two real bones in room, rest all fake, he had to find them.

    LDB: Gerus had to find?

    the two real human bones amongst the fake distractors

    LDB: 147 into evidence. what's happening here?

    05 or 06, the horse training field. the training aid is under this box. in the center of this so as to have all the animal distractors. tail is up, fuzzy again and nose is down.

    LDB: 148 into evidence. what is happening here?

    final trained alert.

    LDB: 149? different than 148?

    Gerus, yes would like to give the final trained alert and then turn and make eye contact with me, he always has. he looks to me for acknowledge ment.

    LDB: ? into evidence. 151 in evidence let me show you.

    a car search a training of car search at advanced school. sweep them low and sweep them high. it is why I let the lead loose so you do not pull dog you leave slack.

    LDB: 152 in evidence, what are we seeing here?

    same, another car search training, his tail he is in odor I am going to spin him because I thought he passed the door too fast and he continued to search it was on the rear bumper.

    LDB: 153 what shows?

    training aid, a femur

    LDB: aid as well?

    upper jaw bone

    LDB: 155?

    horse training field it shows we are finding the search, directing

    LDB: 156?

    this was the pipe, the culvert I was explaing it training aid was at the center and he had to work to get it

    LDB: 157

    block searches, his head and tail. fixing to dump his head into the odor. he has shifted forward because he is still moving forward. I give his leash slack.

    LDB: ?

    more blocks, some empty training the wind was hitting us in the nose that day. straight past everything right to it.

    LDB: 160, he gets reward if successful?

    yes, handler praise and a ball.
    John 14:6

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Orange County
    Posts
    1,437
    Jury back in courtroom after lunch recess

    Continued Direct Examination of Jason Forgey by LDB:

    Jurors had an outing for lunch.

    LDB showing witness State's N.R. composite exhibit. He recognized them as K-9 Garris's certification, training logs and his K-9 experience.

    JB objected to them being entered into evidence as hearsay and improper (something)

    HHBP asked LDB to ask a few more questions.

    JF said the first item certification for him and dog for basic training in human remains training course. Next - copy of memo by Sgt David Wade sent to chain of command as to actual certification - 7/29/05. Next - original outside course in Sarasota, basic cadaver course school dated 11/05. Next - continuation of same certificate. Next - Advanced Cadaver Search School completed in 11/06 in Sarasota, copy of certificate. Net - Canine Team Certification dated 12/08 for K-9 Garris, part of FDLE certification. Next - part of examination and evaluation form for 11/06 for K-9 Garris for FDLE certification. Next is another evaluation form - multi-page form. Next - another FDLE certification form for him and dog 11/07, multi-page form.

    Next set of documents - copy of training logs he completes when he does a training scenario starting 1/11/05 through 9/06/08.

    VOIR DIRE OF WITNESS BY JB:

    He is in charge of keeping these records so that he can show the court that the dog has been trained. The training logs deal with the times he was with the dog training, not the field performance.

    Objection by LDB - Sustained

    No further questions by LDB.

    JB objects to proffered exhibits and feels they are inadmissible. HHBP cited 4/21/11 Supreme Court decision and admitted into evidence as Exhibit 144.

    Exhibit 144 published to the Jury.

    First training by Andy Redman group in 11/05. During this time, he continued to maintain a training log for the dog. The logs identify the dog, handler and what they did that day, where they trained and then the quantities, search area, target locations and whether the target was found. If he had missed the target, it would have been listed under missed. He found all the targets.

    Total False Alerts To Date and Total Misses and number of finds - boxes on the form. On this date there were 8 targets and 8 finds.

    The bottom half of form contains weather info/condition, wind direction, speed and temperature. Then his comments regarding the different targets.

    This is the same format utilized in all of the training records.

    LDB shows witness multiple State's exhibits (photos)

    He has reviewed the photos as showing him and the dog training in Sarasota in 2005 and 2006. They show some of the things that were required during the training.

    LDB submits documents in to evidence as Exhibit 145-160 with no objection from JB

    Photos published to the Jury.

    Photos from two different schools.

    There was training in Sarasota in 11/05 and 11/06. One was basic and the other advanced cadaver dog course. The second one involves more distracting and more proficiency.

    Exhibit 145 was from the 2006 course

    (JB finding something amusing)

    Lights in courtroom dimmed because they were causing a glare on the photos when put on the telestrator.

    #145 was an interior search of a haunted house. There was blood in the back on cloth in the corner. His hair is sticking up, he is head snapping, looking into the odor. Photo taken right before the final trained alert.
    #146 was the bone room in the haunted house. There were two real bones and Garris had to find them mixed in with fake bones - one on the wall and one in the pile.
    #147 (2005) in the middle of a horse training field. The training aid is under the box - there were several boxes. It shows an off lead search.
    #148 audio lost
    #149 - shows Garris making eye contact with him which is what he always does after his final trained alert.
    #150 ?
    #151 shows a vehicle search. He has a slack lead.
    #152 another vehicle search showing hair on tail changing. Odor was actually under the rear bumper.
    #153 Shows the femur as a training aid
    #154 is an upper jaw bone training aid
    #155 is the horse training field. He is refining the search by directing.
    #156 shows the culvert. Training aid was at the center.
    #157 - block searches, shows dog's tail and head. Odor is in concrete box, ready to give final trained alert.
    #158 shows him working odor in a set of blocks.
    #160 shows Garris getting a reward - a ball. Handler praise and ball is his reward.

    (ICA and DS whisperig)

    He had a few misses and one false alert during this training. They did 15 searches. He missed 2 small pieces of napkin that had a couple of drops of blood in the hallway. There were 15 items and he missed 2. The false alert - 2006 no false alert, 2005 one false alert on the 9th and 3 on the 8th. On the 8th they had 31 searches and he was tired

    JB objected and moved to strike - overruled.

    31 searches is the most the dog has done in one day and the dog was tired and bored. That was why he gave false alerts. On the 9th he did 12 searches with one false alert. His log doesn't indicate why.

    He would never have a dog do 31 searches in one day in the real world. They would normally find one item.

    Garris continues maintenance training - minimum 2 specialty trainings a month and then quarterly they are evaluated by either a supervisor or trainer.

    Between 7/05 and 6/10 he had 21 quarterly evaluations by supervisor or training. He had no problems with misses or false alerts during this time.

    Casey looking bored.

    Garris has been trained on residual odor (where a body has been removed). First time in 9/9/05 - body had been located next to a retention pond. He ran it before they moved the deceased. He then went back 10 days later and worked it from 2 different directions to see how the dog reacted. They actually found 2 bones that had been missed.

    The next time was 4/4/06 where a transient had been located deceased - approx 2 days - 20-25 yards off the roadway in the woods. There was food around her. He ran it as a training aid. No problems with missing or false alert.

    The third time was 7/22/07 - body had been removed from the side of the roadway 10 hours earlier in Osceola County. No issues with misses or false alerts.

    Since 2001 he has had 200 real world cadaver calls and 498 training situations.

    Garris is a full service dog. He undergoes other training. The dog works as many hours as he does - 80 hours every 2 weeks.

    He is typically called to a scene by a detective. Sometimes cold case files, or it could be a fresh case. There have been a few calls he has heard dispatched that he thought he could help with, or he has checked the screen and seen something where he felt he could help. The typical end result is that there is no alert.

    In 2005 Garris had no real world cadaver searches.

    In 2006 there were 6 calls. Garris alerted once - they found a deceased person. No false alerts.

    In 2007 Garris had 9 real world cadaver searches, no alerts.

    In 2008 71 real world cadaver searches with 3 alerts - 3/24/08 the first one was a find of a lower jaw bone.

    Skipping over this case.

    In 2008, after July he had several call outs as it related to the disappearance of Caylee. That is why he went from 9 searches to 71. He was following a number of tips on this case.

    He documented two of these cases that appeared to be a small shallow grave. Garris did not alert to either location. They were still dug by forensics and both were animals.

    In 2009 Garris had 12 cadaver searches with 1 alert - a find of a drowning victim still under water. He fell out of a canoe and had not surfaced.

    In 2010 Garris had 11 searches and no alerts.

    Garris is currently retired. His last day of work was in 11/10 and he went down in a call.

    The first search in 2006 was documented on video. A male called in and said he heard there was a deceased female and that she had been discarded in a wooded area near a pond. 5 detectives searched on foot, the helicopter came and searched two more times. He was told there was a large alligator in the pond. It was dark. This search was captured on video by the helicopter which stayed around because of the alligator.

    LDB wants to introduce the video
    JB objects due to no prior disclosure

    SIDEBAR #5


  11. #11
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    LDB: during any of those schools Gerus have misses?

    yes

    LDB: false alerts?

    yes misses

    LDB: reasons?

    on the one day we had done 15 searches and worked all day. the haunted house he missed two pieces of napkin that had blood but he got 15 and missed two.

    LDB: hit on anything that was not there?

    correct, refer back to logs, I don't believe there was....06 no false alerts in 05 one false alerts on the 9th and three on the 8th.

    LDB: why?

    31 searches that day. he was tired

    objection
    overruled

    31 that day. the most he did in one day. he was tired. I indicate that in my log I typed it in the bottom. He was bored and tired.

    LDB: next day you indicated...

    on the 9th? it was 11 9, soil adopocier and muscle he just false alerted that day

    LDB: do those training situations like real life? 31 searches in a day?

    no, if you find one item you usually stop

    LDB: Gerus have any maintainance training?

    quarterly, a certified trainer

    LDB: how many times between ? july 2010 under go evaluation by certified trainer?

    (is looking) 21 times he was evaluated

    LDB: you kept training records?

    yes

    LDB: any misses or false alerts?

    no

    LDB: any sit where you knew the body was there then removed, residual odor?

    yes

    LDB: specific? where and when

    yes, the first time was 9 5 05 a body was near a retention pond in the high grass. the gentleman had been deceased for 7 days. I ran a training. I went back ten days. that was the first one and we found two bones they missed.

    LDB: second time?

    a transient, deceased two days just off the road way into the woods. food around it was a white female. ran as a training aid. It was okay. I ran that one.

    LDB: any false alerts?

    no, then the next one was a body that was removed from the roadway, ten hours.

    LDB: ten after the body had been removed?

    yes

    LDB: any issues with Gerus missing that area or false alert the area?

    no

    LDB: since 2001 when you started this work how many cadaver calls?

    real world calls: over 200 in training almost 500

    LDB: in addition to the cadaver work Gerus is full service and under goes training

    yes

    LDB: when you work he works?

    yes. 80 hours every two weeks

    LDB: how called?

    a detective will call. cold case file. or a fresh case a dect calls and I get out there. I have heard a few calls dispached I could help with, or check the screen they had heard that someone has been killed and I go out and help.

    LDB: are these calls...there is no alert?

    that is correct it is typical

    LDB: in 2005 did Gerus have any real world?

    no not in 2005

    LDB: 2006?

    six calls

    LDB: of six did Gerus alert?

    one

    LDB: result?

    a find, we found a deceased person. I don't know the end result of that, have case document.

    LDB: one alert and one find

    yes

    LDB: no false?

    none

    LDB: ?

    no alerts

    LDB: no alert means no false alert

    right

    LDB:

    the first one was 3 24 2008, that was a find.

    LDB: what did Gerus find?

    a mandable, lower jaw bone with teeth attached.

    LDB: the events in this case in 2008 after july 15th 2008 did you have several call outs for Caylee Anthony

    absolutely, we had hundreds of tips on this particular case, that is why we went from such a little number of searches to a large number.

    LDB: did you see anything that suggested disturbed earth?

    yes, documented two of these cases, a recent shallow grave. indent in the dirt, the grass is not the same. small shallow grave. did Gerus alert to these location?

    no

    LDB: ?

    both were animals

    LDB: in 2009 did Gerus have any cadaver searches

    yes 12 in 2009 a find, a drown victim still underwater, fell out of a canoe and had not surfaced.

    LDB: 2010?

    11 searches and no finds.

    LDB: Gerus is retired?

    yes

    LDB: last day of work?

    sept. 2010 he went down on a call

    LDB: you have video tape?

    the first one the female in 5 29 2006

    LDB: alert?

    call in deceased female, had been shot and discarded. the deputies went out and walked the woods and searched the pond and could not find anything. They called helicopter and searched the area again. I helped, the helicopter saw I arrived and said they were leaving but there was a aligator, I asked them to stay while I searched.

    LDB: evening dark?

    yes, dark

    LDB: helicopter caught it because of aligator in the area?

    yes

    LDB: you have had a chance to review this video?

    yes

    LDB: fair and accurate representation?

    yes

    HHJP: any objections?

    JB: we object.
    John 14:6

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Orange County
    Posts
    1,437
    Objection overruled and video admitted as Exhibit #???

    Recess until 2:55.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    Feb 2009
    Location
    South
    Posts
    3,835
    HHJP: overruled. The video is 20 minutes and we will recess until five minutes to three. We will be in recess. Okay thank you.
    John 14:6

  14. #14
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Orange County
    Posts
    1,437
    Jury not present.

    LDB wants to start the video at the 15 minute mark because that is when Officer Forgey comes into the picture.

    JB says this is not in accordance with Harris. He feels they are addressing a matter of law with the Jury. Feels they are holding a motion to suppress hearing in front of the jury. The jury is hearing things that are completely irrelevant. If it proceeds, the matter will be made worse - matter of law as opposed to matter of fact.

    HHBP 12 individuals will be asked to evaluate the believability of this testimony. They will have to decide if this or any other K-9 is reliable. The training and certification and experience all go to factors that will enable the triers of fact will reject or accept this evidence.

    Previous ruling will stand.

    Jury coming back.

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Sep 2008
    Location
    Orange County
    Posts
    1,437
    Continued Direct Examination of Jason Forgey by LDB.

    Video published to the Jury. Officer Forgey says he does not come into view until 15:45 on the video taken by the helicopter with infrared lighting. At the time they are performing, he did not know where the body was.

    LDB wants to start at 15:45. JB renews all previous objections.

    Video is started.

    (There is no audio and it is hard for me to see. Can't report much to you all - sorry.)

    Now I can see the body in the water. The water is light and the ground is dark.

    (ICA is watching the monitor on and off.)

    We can now see the dog and he is close to the body.

    End of tape.

Page 1 of 2 1 2 LastLast


Similar Threads

  1. Alina Burroughs testimony (CSI with OCSO)
    By Patience in forum Witness Testimonies and Closing Arguments
    Replies: 7
    Last Post: 06-14-2011, 02:04 PM
  2. Support Thread: Gerus and Bones (K9's)
    By strawberry in forum Caylee Anthony 2 years old
    Replies: 149
    Last Post: 06-08-2011, 01:59 PM
  3. Kristen Brewer testimony (OCSD cadaver dog handler)
    By wenwe4 in forum Witness Testimonies and Closing Arguments
    Replies: 9
    Last Post: 06-08-2011, 10:01 AM
  4. 2011.03.24 - Deputy Jason Forgey Testimony At Casey Anthony Hearing
    By Kimster in forum Caylee Anthony 2 years old
    Replies: 13
    Last Post: 03-26-2011, 09:37 PM