Cindy does deserve 15 years in prison.
well all i have to say then all the other high profile people such as celebs presidents ect should do jail time right along with her .. so her geting away with perjury is nothing new .. other ppl get away with it . it should apply to EVERYONE who lies on the stand but it doesnt.. im not saying cindy should get away with lying no . but i just dont think its fair if she is made an example because that is what the public wants .. and yet others that are famous dont see the inside of a cell and not only that her lying on the stand sealed caseys fate even worse .. so mabey we should be thankful she did ? if she had nothing to hide why did cindy feel the need to do that ect.. JMO
kikas halloween album
I think GA knew from the get go but I am not convinced CA believed it at first. I also don't think it has been proven that she gave the wrong brush - I tend to think that sounds too much like a rumor in the media than fact.
I believe GA was always truthful with the police - maybe not the media but certainly the police.
I think it depends on the verdict whether they touch her or not. But I think you're probably right that they'll leave well enough alone - her answers were so all over the place it might actually be hard to prove she KNOWINGLY lied...there's a lot of "perhaps" and "maybes" in her testimony that might get her off the hook.
Richard Hornsby breaks it down why Cindy should not be prosecuted for perjury!
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0pRxHamdQM"]YouTube - ‪Casey Anthony: Day 33, Are Cindy Anthony's Pants on FIre?‬‏[/ame]
"It's time to tell the story of a little girl named Caylee" Linda Drane Burdick
The future has many names: for the fearful it's the unknown, for the reckless it's the adventure, for the pessimists it's the unattainable. For the brave, it is opportunity.
I'm confused on a point as i have missed some testimony. It appears from yesterday there was no phone call to George regarding the pool ladder. So the pool ladder was all a lie? Was that story not told by Cindy very early in?
If a Tomato is a Fruit how come you never find one in a Fruit Salad
I would love to for LDB to have called up CA last and asked her two questions:
Ms. Anthony, do you love your daughter? Would you do anything to save her life?
I'm sure JB would object and HHJP would sustain but it would still hammer home why CA lied---which I'm sure the jury already realized.
I would not want the SA to prosecute CA for perjury. I think the rule of not forcing spouses to testify against each other should apply to parents and children too. Especially when there is a possible DP verdict.
Unless I post a link to a fact, everything I post is my opinion only. Thanks!
As for GA always being truthful with the police, I will refer to his LE interviews, where he talks about Cindy calling him about the pool ladder and gate, his chasing Casey, as well as his mention of JBP scenario.
Justice for CAYLEE
I tried posting a topic for this but it wouldn't let me! I totally think she should be and I hope JA and LDB go forward with it! There are legit work records proving she lied (as opposed to GA whose lying can only be proven by someone else's word). They should also prosecute her for tampering with evidence!
Cindy hates to be embarrassed and to be called a liar, and more than likely for the rest of her life, she will be known as a liar. After Casey's conviction, I do believe that the punishment of loosing her grand daughter, her daughter and any reputation she may have had is enough punishment.
Justice For Caylee Marie
From what I've researched, the state of FL doesn't have to be in any rush to decide on perjury for CA.
IMO - there should be no rush to do this as if there is a later reason to have to retry this case (i.e. appeals, etc.). The state will need CA to testify. Why would she in a later case if they were already prosecuting her for perjury and conversely, she is impeached before she ever takes the stand if she has a perjury conviction. Sure they could call her to the stand, and then she immediately pleads the 5th. Not a position the state prosecutors want to be in IMO.
On the other hand, I'm sure she has been advised about her perjury situation (whether Lippman will public admit it to the world or not, he knows what was proven in court yesterday). I'm sure Cindy has also seen all the debate on the news about her perjury. She has seen first hand it's not quite that easy to lie and just go on about her business as she tried to do in this case. She was most likely mortified yesterday during all that testimony - which in itself is a sentence of punishment (public humiliation) since she is so obsessed with keeping their family secrets so hidden.
I'm certain that if this case has to be retried for any reason, LDB and JA will waste no time reminding her that there is no statute of limitations on what she has already done in open court.
Perjury: Capital Offense Cases
There is no statute of limitations for prosecuting a person for perjury in a capital offense (i.e., death penalty) case in Florida (FSA Section 775.15). The same rule applies to felony homicide cases and cases carrying a potential life sentence.
Read more: Florida Perjury Statute of Limitations | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/facts_7592826_fl...#ixzz1QxXI1vuh
Unless I've provided a link, everything I say is IMO
I'ld be fine with 30 days in the slammer, 5 years probation, 500 hours of community service in a childrens cancer hospital (so she can watch how normal parents, grandparents, & siblings grieve) & a court ordered mental evaluation.
Another benefit of this would be that it would keep her busy & give her husband, who I believe to be a profoundly changed man, time to get the heck out of Dodge & start a life away from her.
I lean (pretty far) toward prosecution, I understand the meds, desperately trying to protect you child etc... HOWEVER she didn't forget something, misspeak or anything even remotely similar! She LIED! Invented new senarios, changed her testimony. She can't even stick to her own lies! She should be punished, even if it is merely "for show".
That all being said, tigers don't change their stripes, she surely is not going to rehabilitate herself at this season of her life. imoo
On that note, Baez should maybe try playing lawer on TV, it seems that is as deep as his understanding of the law runs...
"The truth does not change according to our ability to stomach it." — Flannery O'Connor
Not only should she be charged with perjury, she should be charged with hindering LE when she gave over the wrong brush... WHO does that? Seriously?
It reminds me of ICA and CA's relationship, they were both willing to accept each others lies without consequences, and this is what ultimately lead to this tragedy. I say, enough is enough.
azmama, BeagleMom, Boytwnmom, Chiquita71, crucibelle, DigitalDog, downport, elementary, EnquiringMind, feddup, Friday, Glassgirl, GoneWithTheWind, Granna6, HOTNTX, JustMeDeb, LaLaw2000, LancelotLink, LinasK, Nessa, noonie, Oakley, PurpleHaze, rookie, shotgun09, sincityvixen, sneezy, travel8*, Trident, twomanywords, Wendy101, zippitydoda
I really believe she should be charged with perjury and obstruction of justice. I think Gentiva lawyers have grounds to prosecute also, as she may have caused problems for them also through her lies. If nothing is done at all, it really sends the wrong message to all citizens involved in future cases.
OMG...it seems like forever ago that this started. Everything that has happened yet it's still like at the beginning. Cindy, Cindy, Cindy. Still in competition with Casey.
Been here from the very 1st post and will be here, God willing, when ICA is convicted. Cindy has lied and lied and covered up and impeded and slandered innocent people (I, personally, will never forgive her over what she did and said to Tim Miller. Vile woman!) She always got a pass because she was a "grieving grandmother" . And, with a lot of people she still gets that pass because of the grieving grandmother excuse but, also, she might lose her daughter.
In the beginning, most people were asking, why did Cindy let this go on for so long? This is after we learned that ICA and Caylee lived with the Ants. And that ICA had no job. And, why is she not trying to find out where Caylee is? What started the protests at the house, besides ICA being released, was Cindy yelling at the media and public to "get off our a**ses and find her grandaughter"!! Really, Cindy?? The answer to that is living in your house. You are lying for her. Coddling her. Covering up for her. You and George smelled human decomp in the damn car!! This went far beyond denial with Cindy. And, it continues to this day.
I suppose what I, personally, wanted to see from Cindy from the beginning to this day.....put Caylee first. Bless her heart....she was only 2. She loved you. Stop using her for your "grieving grandmother" excuse. For your media shows. For money. Stop lying for her killer.
Forgot to add.....YES!! Charge her with anything they can come up with. Without her and GA's lies, Caylee might have been found sooner. We might have found a cause of death. Caylee's little body might not have been torn apart by animals.....OMG, yes, charge her.
Last edited by Amster; 07-02-2011 at 11:19 AM. Reason: add on
azwriter, BeagleMom, Boytwnmom, Chiquita71, CountitallJoy, Cross Creek, crucibelle, drip~drop, elementary, EnquiringMind, Glassgirl, GoneWithTheWind, HOTNTX, JustMeDeb, LaLaw2000, LancelotLink, Lanie, leophoenix, LinasK, nerdy, Oakley, rookie, sincityvixen, Sistah Sleuth, sneezy, spamelope, travel8*, Trident
Yes, she should be charged with perjury.
Also, Cindy should be charged for obstruction. There wasn't just one occasion. She did it multiple times throughout the investigation.
If she isn't charged with any crimes, it leaves the door open for others to think, that they can do as she did and get away with it.
I don't think she will be charged. I think LE knew from very early on that Cindy realized that her daughter was the only one responsible and the stories began. We saw her screaming at the media that there was a pizza and garbage in the trunk in the heat, and other twisting of the facts. Cindy became hostile to questioning by the Investigators. By the time depositions were taken Cindy became evasive and tried to explain things away. In the Hearings she was hostile to the State.
Once Cindy entered into those depositions she was locked into her testimony. Now she tried to stray from that saying she remembers things better now because of the medications etc., but in reality she was trying to skirt her testimony in the deposition and help her daughter.
Cindy would have done more IMO on the stand to help her daughter if for not those depositions. She walked a fine line, was impeached, but I don't think she will be charged.
Cindy and George were used from day 1 by the defense..... He probably was way too close to Casey's parents in giving them advice about how to save her. I wouldn't be surprised at all if the Anthonys don't go after Baez with charges of misconduct after this is all over.
And then at the 11th hour Baez having given them these phones allegedly, having kept Casey from them for 2.5 years, having used them for his purposes, i.e. the Ritz to make money for the defense etc., other times when he was in their home, he then throws George and Lee under the bus after they had cooperated with him to help Casey.
Yup I see Baez not Cindy being the target after this trial. Not only will the Anthony family go after him I also think the sanctions will be strong on his failure to follow court orders. MOO
It wasn't just lying under oath on the witness stand, the Anthony Trio worked throughout the past three years to turn the finger pointing at Casey another direction.
If George did tell his girlfriend that Caylee died in an "accident" that meant he knew she was dead while he and Cindy were prompting the public to join them in a search for a live child and accepting donation. That to me, is a serious crime.
Once a verdict has been reached and Casey is being marched to a prison, officials need to get their heads together, examine the Anthony behavior and seriously consider charges. They owe it to the people of Florida who have footed the bill for this legal mess.
The Hokey Pokey Clinic - A good place to turn yourself around:
I think the DA will hold off on prosecuting Cindy Anthony during the appeals process, assuming there is one. For now, I'm rather pleased with LDB's rebuttal of Cindy's testimony that has exposed Mrs. Anthony for the blatant liar that she is.
Cindy thought that lying about the chloroform searches would benefit Casey and perhaps prevent consideration of premeditation in Caylee's death. Alas! Cindy succeeded in sealing Casey's fate. Indeed, the iorny is rich.
This is my perspective and understanding of the situation based on the current information that I know......the final answer to the equation is the only question we are all asking ...the unknown pieces to the puzzle!!!