IN IN - Timothy Willoughby, 24, Mary Ann Higginbotham (fd dec'd), 22, Clayton, June 1978

Tricia · Jan 17, 2012

Dear Everyone,

The Higginbotham thread has been pulled from Websleuths for over a year.

It got totally out of control. To the point that it was causing problems on and off the forum.

I have been asked to put it back.

Rather than try and figure out who said what about whom and what is true and what is not I decided we should try and start over.

Please read over our rules if you are not sure what you can or cannot post. Here they are

The Rules - Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community

Here is the first post from Celine in April 17, 2009 that started our discussion about Mary Ann.

Mary Ann Higgbotham was my friend in high school. She went missing in 1978 and her body was found in a welded shut barrel in 1979 in a creek. Mary's boyfriend Tim also was missing. For 4 years, it was suspected that he killed Mary (Tim has never been found dead or alive) until an informant with burden heart called Indiana State Police Detective York saying they could not live with the secret any longer. This lead to an arrest of 2 men but there was not enough evidence to satisfy the prosecutor to bring them to trial. Charges were dropped.

This is where it gets complicated. A fellow classmate told me details about the case that were never published in any of the newspaper reports. She said she knew this from an other girl we went to school with that was talking to a newspaper reporter. She told me this sometime around 1982-84 and again in 2000.

I found the class mate that was supposed to have this information. She did not know the detail that other person said they got from her talking to the reporter.

I believe that the first classmate is the burdened informant.

I don't know if this classmate called the ISP anonymously or not.
Does anyone have a suggestions of what I should do?

Still_Seek_Answers · Jan 17, 2012

I think you should tell the authorities what you suspect. Sometimes police officers can get information from those who are hesitant. Even if the third party decides to remain quiet......your mind is cleared because you have done all you can. Most important is that you know you are not helping anyone withhold information from the police that could help solve this murder. Honestly, I think you already know the answer, you know in your heart what is the right thing to do....follow that and you won't go wrong. Naturally, this is JMO.....

Cilene · Jan 18, 2012

I want to thank Tricia for opening this thread back up. I regret that some information and suggestions have been lost from the original thread that was started in 2009. My original question "Was my friend the confidential informant?" took me on a journey of discovery through court documents, newspaper articles and also meeting with people that have ties to this case.

I did find out for sure that my high school friend was not the confidential informant that called Indiana State Police in 1982.

I will be going back through my notes and posting what has been saved from the original thread, newspaper articles and court documents.

Cilene · Jan 18, 2012

The Banner Knightstown Indiana 1983
Column published August 6, 2008

This week in 1983
Acting on a tip received from a caller in Connersville, Knightstown Police Department members arrested an Indiana man sought since may in connection with a double-murder that occurred in 1979. Law enforcement officers arrested James. L. Kellams, 37, as he drove on U.S. Hwy. 40 just east of Knightstown. Kellams had been charged with murder in the deaths of Mary Ann Higginbotham and Timothy Willoughby, of Clayton, IN. Assisting in the arrest was KPD Marshal Robert Bitler and deputies Danny Baker and Tom Nelson.

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 26, 2012

Sidney · Jan 28, 2012

Thank god there are no statute of limitations for murder.

Sidney · Feb 2, 2012

Happy Birthday Tim, We really thought by now, your remains would be found, its been 34 years and we still have no Justice. Gone but not forgotten, we will never give up, love you always.

Sidney · Feb 15, 2012

:banghead::waitasec::waitasec:

Sidney said:

State Police Sgt.Frank Love, God rest his sole worked so hard to get indictments against these two men, ( James Kellams and Ronald Tomasik) Frank Love had a reliable informant that was very close to the situation, that could have only known the killers. The men asked for a speedy trial so the prosecutor needed more time , so it was handed off to the ISP and through the years different Detectives from the cold case units worked on it here and there, its been 34 years and there is still these two men(murderers) just living there lives like nothing ever happened, they murder two people , stuff them in barrels and just go on with life, like its nothing.

Sidney · Feb 16, 2012

Sidney said:

I hope people wont judge Tim ( Willoughby) by his involvement in this Auto Theft Ring, he was pretty young I believe 17 when he got involved with these people that he thought to be his friends. There is no excuse for doing illegal things , but Tim and Mary didn't deserve to pay with there lives for it.

lease:

Sidney · Feb 16, 2012

Sidney said:

Never in a millon years did we think these two men Ronald Tomasik and James Kellams would NEVER go to trial for there crimes, but 34 years later they are still free as birds. Sometimes it makes you want to give up on the Justice System, why did it fail so badly.:waitasec:

Sidney · Mar 2, 2012

This case is now on the :

Unsolved Cold Case Homicides

Indiana State Police

District Investigative Commander

8620 E. 21st Street

Indianapolis, Indiana 46219

Anyone with information on this case please contact the ISP at:

1-317-899-8577 or 1-800-582-8440

Cilene · Jul 24, 2013

Investigators report that the body is likely a male from the clothing, has been in tank for over 5 years.

http://www.wishtv.com/dpp/news/local/west_central/police-investigate-bones-found-in-brownsburg

Cilene · Jan 2, 2014

No they did not have children together.

Lori J. · Jan 3, 2014

I have a neice who is 8. She is the spitting image of Mary Ann. Beautiful child. She even has a long neck like Mary Ann. I wonder if she was tall, because my niece is. I have always wondered what transpired with this case. I am friends with a lot of people from Plainfield Highschool. I wished the person who came forward would have done it sooner because evidence goes south when time goes by.

Coffee56 · Nov 20, 2019

Demographics
Missing Age24 Years
Current Age65 Years
First NameTimothy
Middle NameLee
Last NameWilloughby
Nickname/Alias--

SexMale
Height5' 10" - 6' 0" (70 - 72 Inches)
Weight160 - 170 lbs
Race / EthnicityWhite / Caucasian

Circumstances
Date of Last ContactJune 6, 1978
NamUs Case CreatedOctober 13, 2014
Last Known Location Map
LocationMooresville, Indiana
CountyMorgan County

Circumstances of DisappearanceTimothy Willoughby and Mary Ann Higginbotham were last seen on 06/06/1978.
Physical Description
Hair ColorBrown
Head Hair Description--
Body Hair Description--
Facial Hair Description--
Left Eye ColorGreen
Right Eye ColorGreen
Eye Description--
Distinctive Physical Features
Item
Description
Tattoo
on the shoulder, in small letters, the name ann

R/O

The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)

IN IN - Timothy Willoughby, 24, Mary Ann Higginbotham (fd dec'd), 22, Clayton, June 1978

Manager Websleuths.com

Hope is our strength......love is our determinatio

Active Member

Active Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

Active Member

Active Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

DNASolves

Online statistics

Forum statistics