1437 users online (268 members and 1169 guests)  


Websleuths News


Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 ... LastLast
Results 1 to 15 of 52
  1. #1
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    155

    Magnotta diagnosed with paranoid schizophrenia, 2005 doctor’s letter reveals


  2. #2
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Small town at a pristine lake in Ontario
    Posts
    3,087

    Lightbulb

    Oh good - we now have a thread just for LM's diagnosis. How cool is that?

    Seeking justice for Audrey Gleave
    -------------------------------------------
    *ALL POSTS ARE MY OWN OPINIONS UNLESS I GIVE A LINK OR REFER TO OTHERS*
    -------------------------------------------
    “The inspiration you seek is already inside you. Be silent and listen." ~ Rumi

  3. #3
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    155
    Here is a good piece with Charles Adler and Ross McLean, talking about a possible NCR case for Magnotta.

    http://link.brightcove.com/services/...=2277993947001


    They bring up the good point that in order to get an NCR ruling, per Section 16 of the Canadian Criminal Code - it has to be proven that the person;

    1. suffering from a mental disorder; and,
    2. unable to appreciate the "nature and quality" of the act, or
    3. did not know it was "wrong"

    2 and 3 will be a hard sell for Luka's defence. Did he know it was "wrong" when he fled the country and went on the run for over a week before getting caught?

    Did he know it was "wrong" when the Berlin police found him the cafe and he declared "You got me" ?

    It's really going to be a long shot, I think.

    It's my understanding of Schizophrenics when they are in a 'psychotic break' are really not very cognizant of their actions and surroundings, nor highly functioning enough to sequence the thoughts and planning involved in something like fleeing the country and international travel.

    Vincent Li, when apprehended, was so out of it he didn't even know his name. He could barely string a coherent sentence together. Yet, Luka manged to get himself through airport security, donning a wig no less, on an international flight without anyone raising an eyebrow for suspicious or unusual behaviour.

    I realize there's varying degrees of psychosis, and what Li experienced was a "first break" which is generally the most severe. The homicide rates among Schizophrenics are often broken down to whether or not it was a first break, and if there was concurrent drug or alcohol abuse as those factors skews the data substantially.

    It will be interesting. A lot of eyes will be on this trial.

  4. #4
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Small town at a pristine lake in Ontario
    Posts
    3,087

    Lightbulb

    Quoted from ChelleBelle:

    suffering from a mental disorder; and,
    unable to appreciate the "nature and quality" of the act, or
    did not know it was "wrong"


    Well, #1 has been pretty much made obvious by the Rouge Valley Hospital and various psychiatrists.

    #2. (I don't mean to be fighting here; just playing devil's advocate!!) - I'm worried sick that someone will come along (a psychiatrist) and tell us that LM was so far into mental illness that he couldn't POSSIBLY have understood the harm of his actions. (Please pray that I'm wrong!!)

    #3. Again, devil's advocate here - perhaps another set of psychiatrists will come along and testify that LM has no knowledge of good vs. evil.



    Bottom Line = I'm getting worried sick about finding justice for Jun Lin. And some closure for his dear family!!
    Seeking justice for Audrey Gleave
    -------------------------------------------
    *ALL POSTS ARE MY OWN OPINIONS UNLESS I GIVE A LINK OR REFER TO OTHERS*
    -------------------------------------------
    “The inspiration you seek is already inside you. Be silent and listen." ~ Rumi

  5. #5
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    19,156
    Well, I wasn't exactly shocked by the info r.e. schizophrenia. I think we all expected he had some kind of mental illness. I think it explains SOME of his behaviour i.e. showing up to that lawyer and claiming he was being abused, etc. However, I don't think it explains the actual deviant behaviour at all. I also don't think that it will affect a jury's decision about whether he was in control of his own behaviour or not. JMO

  6. #6
    Join Date
    Aug 2011
    Location
    Chicago, IL USA
    Posts
    2,070
    Quote Originally Posted by matou View Post
    Well, I wasn't exactly shocked by the info r.e. schizophrenia. I think we all expected he had some kind of mental illness. I think it explains SOME of his behaviour i.e. showing up to that lawyer and claiming he was being abused, etc. However, I don't think it explains the actual deviant behaviour at all. I also don't think that it will affect a jury's decision about whether he was in control of his own behaviour or not. JMO
    matou as one of the original post-murder Magnotta sleuths, like myself, do you find Magnotta potentially capable of faking schizophrenia?

    I ask this not to trivialize those who have been diagnosed with it and work hard to manage their condition, but I ask this with knowledge of Magnotta's online world. Considering the countless hours Magnotta devoted to creating, managing and adding personification to each of his characters and developing a structure where each character helped to create the illusion of Magnotta being a wealthy, world traveler who was either famous or infamous (depending on the audience).

    With the loss of those characters in conjunction with the loss of internet access upon his arrest; is it not likely that Magnotta simply transfers the details of his characters to exist only in his mind in order to convincingly utilize his characters to convincingly demonstrate to a psychiatrist evaluating him that he is likely suffering from schizophrenia when in reality he's simply doing what he does best: lie convincingly to advance his personal goals.

  7. #7
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    19,156
    Why would he fake it though? To get away with hurting and killing animals? To get famous for killing Lin Jun? I don't think getting meds would be a factor either. I'm trying to remember something about him going to the hospital and him being held there. I think it was something he wrote about in one of his blogs and I can't remember under which name he was posting as. I think a family member was involved in his hospitalization, his mother? Did she abandon him at the hospital or something? Maybe I'm remembering another case LOL.

    I wonder what Baudi Moovan would think about him faking it? She was after him for a long time and has a better sense of things, I would think. If anything, I wonder if he was misdiagnosed. To me, he is sociopathic. JMO

  8. #8
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    Ontario, Canada
    Posts
    155
    Quote Originally Posted by No_Stone_Unturned View Post
    Quoted from ChelleBelle:

    #3. Again, devil's advocate here - perhaps another set of psychiatrists will come along and testify that LM has no knowledge of good vs. evil.
    Good points, but the fact he tried to dispose of the body then fled the country won't bode well for him. If he didn't understand what he did was wrong, why would he run away?

  9. #9
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Posts
    147
    Richard Kachkar knowingly murdered Toronto police officer Ryan Russell, attempted to flee the scene , admitted later to doing it but claimed he didn't know what he was doing. Had a history of mental illness, Had 3 psychiatrists testify on his behalf, and was found NCR. The selling point is you come in and out of these episodes at times. So... (devil's advocate) you wake up in the morning to a bloodbath in your apartment, of course you're going to clean it up (or half-ass clean it up in this case). Yet you have no memory of the murder, the mailing of parcels , so let's hop a flight to Euro for vacation to clear the mind. Maybe they don't come out of the episode until they're on the way to the airport to buy the ticket. (on a side note, I'm eagerly anxious to know when that 2-way flight to Paris was BOOKED) .

    Just throwin' it out there ... this is what goes on now in the courts. Right, Wrong or somewhere inbetween ... it's an endless debate.

    Quote Originally Posted by ChelleBelle View Post
    Good points, but the fact he tried to dispose of the body then fled the country won't bode well for him. If he didn't understand what he did was wrong, why would he run away?

  10. #10
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    U.S.
    Posts
    389
    It is likely that he has multiple diagnosis, which will come out later in court. I hate to say it, but there's a very good chance that he will receive sympathy and leniency because of his history. This is a clear cut case of someone who has been mentally unstable for many years, all the warning signs were there and essentially ignored, and what could have been (and was) predicted by many unfolded just as anyone would have guessed. I think his lawyers will paint a picture of this poor, unfortunate, mentally ill kid who had no emotional support, who when left to his own devices made a series of increasingly bad choices and decisions, and this is where it lead - his family, doctors, LE, and society are all to blame for essentially sitting back and watching it happen. Frankly, I see no other angle of defence.


  11. #11
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Location
    Small town at a pristine lake in Ontario
    Posts
    3,087

    Lightbulb

    It's the NCR result of the Kachkar case in Toronto which has me leary about LM's case.

    Kachkar deliberately stole the snow plow and went on to kill a police officer. He must have known what he was doing when he stole the snow plow! And yet - NCR!!

    Seeking justice for Audrey Gleave
    -------------------------------------------
    *ALL POSTS ARE MY OWN OPINIONS UNLESS I GIVE A LINK OR REFER TO OTHERS*
    -------------------------------------------
    “The inspiration you seek is already inside you. Be silent and listen." ~ Rumi

  12. #12
    Join Date
    Jun 2012
    Location
    Austria
    Posts
    231
    Quote Originally Posted by matou View Post
    Why would he fake it though? To get away with hurting and killing animals? To get famous for killing Lin Jun? I don't think getting meds would be a factor either. I'm trying to remember something about him going to the hospital and him being held there. I think it was something he wrote about in one of his blogs and I can't remember under which name he was posting as. I think a family member was involved in his hospitalization, his mother? Did she abandon him at the hospital or something? Maybe I'm remembering another case LOL.
    You remember correctly, I also had to think about this post immediately. He made the original post on wordpress (username: lotusbomb) but it got deleted by now. However, I found a blog in which LM's post has been copied and pasted:

    http://ubermagik.blogspot.co.at/2012...-magnotta.html

    Last edited by italianWSfan; 04-06-2013 at 07:12 AM.

  13. #13
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    19,156
    Quote Originally Posted by No_Stone_Unturned View Post
    It's the NCR result of the Kachkar case in Toronto which has me leary about LM's case.

    Kachkar deliberately stole the snow plow and went on to kill a police officer. He must have known what he was doing when he stole the snow plow! And yet - NCR!!

    Yes, he did it deliberately but he did it with bare feet in the winter time! He was really out of it at the time and it was done spontaneously, IMO. I don't see this as the same with LM. There was real planning in what he did. JMO

  14. #14
    Join Date
    May 2009
    Location
    Toronto
    Posts
    19,156
    Quote Originally Posted by italianWSfan View Post
    You remember correctly, I also had to think about this post immediately. He made the original post on wordpress (username: lotusbomb) but it got deleted by now. However, I found a blog in which LM's post has been copied and pasted:

    http://ubermagik.blogspot.co.at/2012...-magnotta.html

    OMG! Thank you! LOL, I follow so many cases that I worry that I get the details mixed up. I'll be reading this later! xo

  15. #15
    Join Date
    Jan 2013
    Location
    South Florida
    Posts
    892
    I'm really surprised that Magnotta wasn't diagnosed with narcissistic (or antisocial) personality disorder at any point. He has a giant and unwarranted sense of self-importance, is obsessed with fame, is obsessed with his looks, has no empathy, exaggerates his achievements, cannot handle rejection, is arrogant, requires a lot of praise, feels entitled to things, is very self-centered, believes he's special, thinks he's superior and special... I'm no doctor but those are big red flags.

    The homicide rates among Schizophrenics are often broken down to whether or not it was a first break, and if there was concurrent drug or alcohol abuse as those factors skews the data substantially.
    It also depends on whether the schizophrenic is being treated for his disorder. It's been shown that schizophrenics (or anyone with a serious mental illness, for that matter) are no more dangerous than the general population so long as they're in treatment and not using drugs/alcohol. Going by statistics, you're several times more likely to be struck by lightning than be killed by a schizophrenic stranger.

Page 1 of 4 1 2 3 ... LastLast


Similar Threads

  1. Replies: 16
    Last Post: 06-08-2016, 10:59 PM
  2. Replies: 8
    Last Post: 09-26-2013, 10:04 AM
  3. Replies: 7
    Last Post: 03-24-2010, 08:03 PM
  4. OH - Cup Of Coffee Reveals Attacker's Identity, Springdale, 2005
    By mysteriew in forum Crimes in the News
    Replies: 1
    Last Post: 10-04-2005, 07:19 AM

Tags for this Thread