Matthew Macerato, 18, and 22-year-old new mother Jessica Watson were shot dead, execution-style, in the basement of the Casual Male Big & Tall store along Kirkwood Highway in Wilmington, Delaware on Dec. 26, 2004.

The clothing store workers were closing the shop up for the night when a robber came in, took some cash and shot them dead. Castro said his brother, who was the store’s manager, stepped out just before the robbery took place.

“My brother said ‘I’ll be right back.’ And when he came back all there was is yellow tape,” he recalled. “A lot of people changed after that day.”