10-18-2015, 03:28 AM #1
WI - Carmella Ball and similar murders in Beloit, 2005-08
I'm only starting a thread for Carmella Ball because I'm not 100% sure there isn't or hasn't been a thread for any of these ladies. I've looked and looked so I don't think so.
I hope somebody is interested in this. I was bored and found all this tonight. I think this is worth looking into.
Here is something interesting I didn't know before. Three women, three years in a row were all murdered in their homes. They were all stabbed to death. All murders are still unsolved.
Carmella Ball was found murdered in her home on September 20, 2005 in Beloit, WI
Aida Storhe was found murdered in her home March 4, 2006 in Beloit, WI
Angelia Warf was found murdered I'm her home June 6, 2007 in Beloit, WI
All three murders where so close to each other its scary. I could probably walk to each house in an hours time.
All three victims where found at around 4:30 am or so.
I don't know if it means anything but all three women lived with men. Two of them living with several men.
"The body of Carmella Ball, 42, was found in the 900 block of Oak Street in the early morning hours Sept. 20 by a man who also lived there."
"Police say Stoehr lived with her boyfriend and a male sub–renter."
"Angelia M. Warf, 37, was found in her apartment at 906 Harrison Ave. by her roommate around 4:45 a.m. Neighbors say Warf was living in the house with two other men. She took the middle floor, while one man lived in the basement and another in the top floor."
Then if I wanna get all crazy I could add in Brittany Zimmerman. Who was found stabbed to death in her home in 2008. She to lived with a male also. Her case might be a little different but worth checking out IMO. She only lived about an hour north of Beloit in Madison WI.
"On April 2, 2008, 21-year-old Brittany Zimmermann was found dead in her Madison apartment. She was discovered by her fiance"
Police say the murders in Beloit are not linked. I dont know why they say that. They must have DNA or something cause I couldn't find a reason they wouldn't be linked.
I'm curious if there is an unsolved stabbing somewhere close by from 2009.
10-18-2015, 04:06 PM #2
Carmella Ball , 42, Sept 20, 2005
A little more about Carmella Ball -
Police: Murder victim died of stab wounds
Posted: Thursday, October 20, 2005 12:00 am
By Jen Scherer Daily News staff writer
Beloit police announced that a Beloit woman who was found murdered on the city's west side died as a result of multiple stab wounds.
He declined to specify the number or location of the stab wounds and would not say if the murder weapon had been recovered.
Ball was found in her residence in the 900 block of Oak Street on Sept. 20 by the man who owned the house. Tyler said that man was not staying at the residence at the time of the murder, however, and he is not considered a suspect at this time.
He explained that Ball did not have regular employment, for example, which makes it more difficult to track her regular movements and routine.
As a result of the interviews and phone records, investigators have a more narrow time frame for when the homicide occurred, but Tyler declined to say what that is. Police have said the death occurred overnight between the 19th and 20th of September; Ball's body was found in the early morning hours on the 20th.
The article also says there was no sign of forced entry. Killer might have had a key, or was allowed into the house by the victim.
The house was in general disarray, but probably not as a result of the crime. In other words, no sign of a struggle or disturbance beforehand.
Capt. Tyler declined to comment on where the body was found in the house, and whether or not she was clothed.
He said a good deal of evidence had been collected, but indicated that there might have been an effort to clean up the scene.
I wonder why the guy wasn't staying there at the time.
Crime Stoppers information: Anyone with information about this crime is urged to call the Greater Beloit Area Crime Stoppers at 608-362-7463. All callers may remain anonymous and callers may be eligible for a cash reward of up to $1,000 if the information leads to an arrest.
Last edited by bessie; 10-18-2015 at 09:25 PM.
10-18-2015, 04:48 PM #3
Aida Stoehr, 52, March 2006
I couldn't find much more information about Aida Stoehr, except for a few interesting comments from neighbors.
DEATH OF BELOIT WOMAN CALLED MURDER
State Journal staff Mar 8, 2006
A Beloit woman was found dead early Sunday in a house she shared with her boyfriend and a renter, and police are treating her death as a murder case.
According to the Beloit Police Department, Aida Stoehr, 52, was found dead by police in a house at 1033 Central Ave. at 12:24 a.m.
Police are not releasing details about the cause of death, only that they did not find a murder weapon while searching the house. No arrests have been made, and no suspects have been named.
Neighbors remember murder victim
Posted: Thursday, March 9, 2006 12:00 am
By Jen Scherer, Daily News staff writer
Neighbors of a woman murdered in her Beloit home remember her as a nice person who walked her dog regularly and enjoyed gardening.
One Hispanic woman... said she was awakened by Stoehr's husband late Saturday/early Sunday morning. The man, who police call a live-in boyfriend, came knocking on her door looking for a phone to call police.
"We gave him the telephone so he could call,” the woman's daughter translated. "He said that someone did something to his wife.”
"She was scared because he had blood on his face,” the daughter translated. She added that Stoehr's husband was working Saturday night and had just arrived home.
Stoehr's next door neighbor, RC, ...said Stoehr didn't really come outside a lot, but he did see her regularly walking a small dog.
"Her husband is the one I saw more,” RC said, adding that he hasn't seen the man for several days.
RC said he was friendly with the people next door when they first moved in a couple years ago, both being Hispanic, but grew distant with them after he started noticing a lot of cars coming and going from the house.
He said he didn't know what they were doing, but didn't feel it was probably good. Since this happened, Casique said the traffic has stopped altogether.
[Police]have said only that there were no signs of forced entry to the home, and that no murder weapon has been found. Deputy Police Chief Norm Jacobs also said there were apparent injuries to Stoehr's body.
Stoehr lives in the house with her boyfriend and a sub-renter.
The article says Aida was originally from Puerto Rico, enjoyed spending time with her family and grandchildren, and was a member of the Foursquare Gospel Church. Her supervisor at Swiss Colony described her as a friendly, cooperative employee who loved her job in the shipping department, and was always willing to help in other areas if needed.
Then there's this:
Police say they were called to the house last September for a stabbing. Stoehr's next door neighbor JH was home when officers came by. She says, "Not so long ago, Aida's son I guess stabbed her husband or boyfriend and well that was exciting so the police came for that."
Hoople says she saw lots of people in and out of Stoehr's home and police say they're looking at all angles, including if the murder was drug-related.
Last edited by bessie; 10-18-2015 at 09:26 PM.
10-18-2015, 05:01 PM #4
Angelia Warf, 37, June 2007
Beloit woman found slain
By Rasmieyh Abdelnabi
Daily News staff writer | Posted: Monday, June 18, 2007 12:00 am
Angelia M. Warf, 37, was found in her apartment at 906 Harrison Ave. by her roommate around 4:45 a.m. Neighbors say Warf was living in the house with two other men. She took the middle floor, while one man lived in the basement and another in the top floor.
Beloit Police Deputy Chief Norm Jacobs said detectives have interviewed a number of people, including Warf's roommates. Investigators also spoke to Warf's husband, who was not in the area at the time of the homicide.
They have not found a weapon.
Officers did not find signs of forced entry into Warf's home, which is a major indicator that it was not a random act of violence...
However, the police call log indicates that officers initially responded to a stabbing at Warf's residence.
She was quiet,” said neighbor SE of Warf. I don't think she'd hurt a flea.”
Warf was in the process of getting a divorce after an 18-year marriage, she said, adding Warf left behind a teenage daughter...
Erickson last saw Warf around midnight Saturday. She came to Erickson's house around 10 p.m. Friday and said she was too scared to go home.
Friends say Warf worked at a concession stand at Blackhawk Farms Raceway. She spent time with her boyfriend, chatted with her neighbors and walked to the pharmacy down the street for soda and cigarettes.
So, again, no sign of forced entry, and no weapon found at the scene. Why was she afraid to go home Friday night?
10-18-2015, 08:13 PM #5
It sticks out to me also she was scared to go home. It could be any thing.
Was she scared of someone who had threaten her? Did she know somebody was watching her or following her home?
Or when she got home she felt something was off and was scared to go in. Something like an unlocked door when she swore she had locked it.
10-18-2015, 09:04 PM #6
Bus tickets from Beloit to Madison are like $16 round trip. I know they found DNA on Brittany Zimmerman. And that DNA matched DNA from a break in not far. I wonder if they ever ran that DNA against any DNA found at these murders. If any was found.
10-18-2015, 09:20 PM #7
Here's the link to Brittany's thread.
10-18-2015, 10:05 PM #8
What's interesting about these three murders is the ages of the victims, for one thing, 37-52. There's no mention of sexual assault, though that's a possibility. In at least two cases, there was no sign of forced entry, and no weapon found at the scene.
All were found by either a boyfriend or roommate, yet none of those individuals were arrested. Normally, when the perpetrator is a domestic partner, it becomes obvious pretty soon, and either there's an arrest, or a suspect is named. That doesn't seem to have happened in any of these cases. At least as late as 2012, all three remained unsolved.
ETA: By the way, when I was researching these cases, I came across two other murders from the Beloit area. They are thought to be connected.
WI - Crystal Lynn Soulier, 18, Beloit/Rock County, October 1996
WI - Terryl J Stanford, 29, Beloit/Rock County, 24 August 1994
10-18-2015, 10:48 PM #9
It stood out to me also that these where women who were middled aged. And from what I understand they all had pretty quiet lives. Nothing that stood out to me. They were not prostitutes or did anything to put their self's out there. They were all in the safety of their own homes.
I found Crystal's and the other girl last night. I was gonna post it when I found more time. Thanks for starting a thread.
At first with Crystal and the other girl (can't remember her name) I was thinking trucker. But as I read more I'm not so sure. I'm thinking a pervert who got off on dumping them by the naughty but nice store who lives around the area.
Its believed Crystal may have made it to Madison. Madison is so close. Then again she was taking the bus possibly and could of met someone that way. I never realized till I moved to this area people treat the bus system like the atl. And the busses are cheap and connect Chicago, Rockford, Beloit, Janesville, Madison, and Milwaukee. When I think bus I think greyhound not this.
And in regards to Zimmerman her thread is closed. But I will always be confused on who's DNA that belongs too....wth! I don't understand that. Are they saying four men broke in and nobody snitched him out? For some reason I find that so hard to believe. Where did they find the DNA. Was it somewhere a cleaning man, bartender, bouncer, customer could of left it? Or was it a homeless man who happen upon an all ready broke into bar amd got him self a drink. So weird.
10-19-2015, 12:29 AM #10
"Beloit police say 37-year-old Angelia Warf was found dead Saturday morning at her home in the 900 block of Harrison Avenue. The house is near Beloit College, but residents say it's a pretty quiet neighborhood except for the occasional student party. "
10-19-2015, 07:29 AM #11
Not sure why/how Brittany's thread was locked, but it's open now.
I don't want to get off topic here, but I do believe a trucker was responsible for the murders of Crystal and Tyrell. One was a prostitute from Chicago with no family or friends in Beloit, so no reason to be there. She was dumped near the bookstore -- an area known to be frequented by truckers -- but killed elsewhere. Typical trucker killer MO.
Crystal didn't want to wait for her bus. Her family thought it possible that she would have accepted a ride from a stranger. IMO, she might have decided to hitchhike.
Last edited by bessie; 10-19-2015 at 07:43 AM.
10-21-2015, 12:25 PM #12
10-21-2015, 03:05 PM #13
You'd think that LE would offer up a deal that if one of them gave up who the 4th person was they wouldn't charge them for past crimes. I wonder if any of these other three guys where at Brittany's house or outside waiting well she was murdered.
Anyways, I really don't want to get this thread off topic. I am so interested in Carmella's murder and how the other two murders are possibly connected. At this point I have no reason to believe they are not. I can't believe after all the digging I've done on Brittany none of the murders in Beloit ever came up for me. Idk how I missed it.
Not saying Brittany's murder is connected as there does seem to be some big difference. But it really stands out to me that Brittany was murdered in 08 and in the same way as the others. Her murder got everyone talking and all eyes where on her murder then there is no more murders. They just stop. At least not murders that fit this mo.
Also I've been thinking a lot about these Beloit murders. I need to link what els I've found which isn't much. But if they are all three connected how did the perp know these ladies would be home alone considering they seemed to all have a live in male roommate or boyfriend? How did the perp get in the house? I guess a simple knock on the door could do it. But Warf told her neighbor she was scared to go home. I'm not convinced she would have open the door to anyone she didn't know if she was scared in the first place. I think what bothers me the most is how solvable these murders seem.
Location on all three murders and Brittany stand out to me.
10-21-2015, 03:17 PM #14
"The homicide took place at a residence at 906 Harrison Ave. during the early morning hours of June 16. Neighbors say Angelia Warf was found by one of her roommates, wrapped in cloth."
"However, a search warrant of the house revealed that investigators confiscated an orange tank top with hair fibers, a beer can, towel, sweatshirt, a Chips Ahoy package, a bloody sock, red shirt, sheets from Warf's bed, clothes from a washing machine, blood samples, marijuana pipe, cigarettes, clothes and lint from a dryer and a cell phone."
Not sure if it means anything but she was wrapped in cloth. Itd be nice to know more about if the other two were wrapped in cloth as well.
Last edited by giagreen; 10-21-2015 at 03:32 PM.
10-21-2015, 04:11 PM #15
Here's another one that could possibly be connected. Its still unsolved. Same mo and no forced entry. Virginia is a little younger then the other victims. Location isnt the same. But still worth looking into IMO. Posting it here so I can come back to it later when I've got more time.
Virginia Bothum Hendrickson, 23, found dead June 5, 1988, near Janesville
"Her throat was slashed. Her skull was fractured. She was stabbed or slashed 35 to 40 times."
"Investigators found no sign of forced entry, and nothing appeared to be stolen."
By OriginalJerseyGirl in forum Serial KillersReplies: 41Last Post: 11-15-2011, 01:16 PM
By Filly in forum Recently Sentenced and BeyondReplies: 25Last Post: 06-17-2008, 11:27 AM