MT MT - Jeannette 'Charlie' Atwater, 34, Billings, 16 Jan 2000

  • Thread starter Deleted member 165632
  • Start date
D

Deleted member 165632

Guest
Jeannette "Charlie" Atwater was killed on January 16, 2000 in Billings, Montana. She was a 34 year-old divorced mother of 3 children.

Case Summary from the Yellowstone County Sheriff's Office Cold Case Unit profile:

"Shortly after 3:30am on the morning of January 16, 2000, firefighters were called to the scene of a car fire near a pull-off area on Bench Blvd. in Billings Heights. When firefighters opened the trunk of the burning car they discovered a body, later identified as Jeannette Atwater. The previous evening, this attractive young Billings woman, and the mother of three small children had attended an office party with several co-workers from the NAPA store where she worked. The major clue in this case is video from the Cenex Convenience Store located near the crime scene. The store's video monitoring system recorded a male, approximately 5'8" in height, wearing dark coat and pants. The suspect got into an older model compact car... possibly brown in color with an orange stripe on the side. Drawings of the suspect and vehicle were made and circulated. To-date, no arrests have been made."
Source: http://yellowstonecoldcase.com/Atwater.html

Photo of Atwater, source: YCSO
attachment.php

Atwater often went by her nickname, "Charlie".


Events of that night:


Atwater attended an office party, after that she went to a bar & met up with former colleagues. She then left that bar and joined some of her current co-workers (from the office party) at the Player's Club bar which was then located on 231 Main Street in Billings. The bar is no longer there, has been replaced by a Country Inn.

Just before 2 a.m. the bar announced closing time. Police have found no witnesses nor any conclusive security footage from the bar showing how Atwater left. According to the co-workers, she did not leave with the group. By 2:15 a.m. the bar's parking lot was empty. "Bar employees monitored the parking lot... and no one recalls any kind of disturbance or problem."
Source: http://billingsgazette.com/news/loc...cle_d6d7c4b2-f2b6-11de-9f4f-001cc4c03286.html

There is a period of time in which no one knows what happened to Atwater. How she left the bar, as well as her whereabouts between the last time she was seen and when her car was found engulfed in flames remains unknown.

The Unidentified Man:
Security footage from the Cenex Station time stamped 3:09 a.m. showed an unidentified man. According to the store clerk, the man bought $1's worth of gas (paid in coins) and took a packet of matches with him. Both a gas container AND similar matches as the ones given out by Cenex were found near Atwater's burning car.
Sources: http://billingsgazette.com/news/loc...cle_d6d7c4b2-f2b6-11de-9f4f-001cc4c03286.html
http://doenetwork.org/cases/1665ummt.html

Below are security camera images from the Cenex store of the unidentified man plus a composite of the vehicle he may have been driving:

attachment.php


attachment.php


The store clerk could not give a good description of the man, but said he smelled strongly of aftershave or cologne. He has been described as either 5'8" or 5'10" white man with brown hair wearing pants and jacket warm-up or jogging suit. He also had slight acne scaring on his face. The clerk described the vehicle that he was driving as, "possibly an 80's vintage model... a small, brown hatchback with an orange stripe."
Source: http://doenetwork.org/cases/1665ummt.html

At 3:30 a.m. a couple driving on Bench Boulevard saw the car in flames in the pull-off graveled area & called police/fire dept.

From the Dec 27, 2009 Billings Gazette article:
Police have not disclosed whether Atwater was sexually assaulted nor what toxicology says about her blood-alcohol level. They also have not discussed "how or where they believe Atwater was placed in the trunk."
Police did say say that she "died of smoke inhalation, so she was most likely alive when she was put in the trunk. An autopsy showed no other obvious signs of fatal injury, such as bullet wounds or head trauma... she did not appear to have been gagged or bound."
Source: http://billingsgazette.com/news/loc...cle_d6d7c4b2-f2b6-11de-9f4f-001cc4c03286.html

There is a possibility that this may have been a random crime b/c police have described finding no motives or reasons why Atwater may have been targeted. She was described as well-liked, with no addictions & no financial problems.
Source: http://billingsgazette.com/news/loc...cle_d6d7c4b2-f2b6-11de-9f4f-001cc4c03286.html

There was a monster truck show and a semi-professional basketball game in Billings that night, police have wondered if the unidentified man was passing through & attended one of those events.
Source: http://doenetwork.org/cases/1665ummt.html

The 3 locations (Player's Club bar, Cenex station & where her car was found) were all close to MetraPark, a multi-purpose arena.

Please read this article which is very detailed on the case:
http://billingsgazette.com/news/loc...cle_d6d7c4b2-f2b6-11de-9f4f-001cc4c03286.html

There's also a 24-minute youtube video on the case made with YCSO Cold Case Unit with interviews with investigators:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Djld6-N16nw&feature=youtu.be
 

Attachments

  • Jeannette+Charlie+Atwater+unsolved+billings+montana+cold+case.gif
    Jeannette+Charlie+Atwater+unsolved+billings+montana+cold+case.gif
    51.5 KB · Views: 78
  • Jeannette Charlie Atwater Unidentified man photo.jpg
    Jeannette Charlie Atwater Unidentified man photo.jpg
    33.1 KB · Views: 81
  • Jeannette+Charlie+Atwater+unsolved+billings+montana+cold+case+Suspect+car.jpg
    Jeannette+Charlie+Atwater+unsolved+billings+montana+cold+case+Suspect+car.jpg
    38.8 KB · Views: 77
Wow. I have to read the articles but a couple of things popped into my head right away.

He probably wasn't at the party with her. His clothes are pretty casual, almost like something you'd travel in for comfort so it would make sense that the unidentified man was just passing through.

Whose car was Jeannette found in? Hers? It wasn't this man's since he was seen leaving in a different car.

I think it would be a fantastically unfortunate coincidence if this man isn't her killer considering his purchases.

Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk
 
Wow. I have to read the articles but a couple of things popped into my head right away.

He probably wasn't at the party with her. His clothes are pretty casual, almost like something you'd travel in for comfort so it would make sense that the unidentified man was just passing through.

Whose car was Jeannette found in? Hers? It wasn't this man's since he was seen leaving in a different car.

I think it would be a fantastically unfortunate coincidence if this man isn't her killer considering his purchases.

Sent from my KFTHWI using Tapatalk


Jeannette was found in her own car.


I also think that there's a lot of info on the crime that police haven't disclosed. The Doe Network says, "Other evidence found at the scene indicates this man may have some knowledge of the crime." But this has never been publicly released.
source: http://doenetwork.org/cases/1665ummt.html

Such a sad & terrible case.
 
Bumping for Jeannette "Charlie" Atwater

Will be the 17th year anniversary soon of her unsolved death. Still no answers.
 
bumping for Jeannette Atwater
17th year anniversary coming up
 
I'd never heard of her until I was browsing Montana UIDs on Doe Network and the profile for her killer popped up. Surprised that he had a Doe page.
 
Bumping for Jeannette Atwater. Her case is still unsolved 18 years later.
 
Good for you with your suspect I have a strong one in this case as well.

I have also submitted my tip to LE some time ago and also reported my suspect had too much after shave on before the nasty piece of work set the mother of three on fire while she was still alive.
 
I have also submitted my tip to LE some time ago and also reported my suspect had too much after shave on before the nasty piece of work set the mother of three on fire while she was still alive.

Sorry if this offends people but I believe the man in the CCTV is also the actual Golden State Killer.
 
Sorry if this offends people but I believe the man in the CCTV is also the actual Golden State Killer.

Like I say Websleuths is a good site but I will face Paul Holes and Anne-Marie Schubert in a court of law anytime to tell what I see as the truth. In fact I will even pay for my own flight and accommodation and all living expenses even though I have never been to the US and you see to see the truth I will not want a penny back.
 
Last edited:
I would never criticize someone for their opinion and instincts. So, jaejae, you have every right to what you believe. I could be totally wrong as well, but I have a feeling that the guy I suspect just might be the right guy. He is a dead-ringer for the suspect, even down to the details. Now we have to wait and see, though.
 
I would never criticize someone for their opinion and instincts. So, jaejae, you have every right to what you believe. I could be totally wrong as well, but I have a feeling that the guy I suspect just might be the right guy. He is a dead-ringer for the suspect, even down to the details. Now we have to wait and see, though.

Thanks same sentiments to you regarding your suspect. I hope you are right. A horrible crime where the killer valued the victims life as a dollar in loose change.
 
Hey just wanted to know if you found out or heard anything new k we on jeannette Atwater case I'm her oldest son a. I think I know who did it
I'm so sorry for the loss of your mother. This case has always driven me crazy. After all this time, it's frustrating that LE has not made more information public. This one has to be solvable.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
249
Guests online
3,977
Total visitors
4,226

Forum statistics

Threads
591,713
Messages
17,957,843
Members
228,593
Latest member
NickyBones
Back
Top