After Garth Rector was shot to death on March 21, 2008, in his rental house outside the sleepy rural Delaware County town of Cowan, investigators quickly determined his slaying was no random act.

The 48-year-old wrestling coach, who was separated from his wife, was shot five times, an indication his killer or killers felt strongly about ending his life.

And interviews quickly led investigators to believe that Rector might have been targeted by any one of several women he had been dating or their jealous boyfriends or husbands.