We need a new topic anyway. So does anyone have any thoughts on why John did not mention the window being open when he went down stairs that morning until much later in the investigation. It would seem that it would be to his benefit to mention this and I read in one of the stickers on this site regarding facts of the case that Blue Crab had sealed it for someone in proving that John was involved because he did not mention the window being open when he went down there and I am not following exactly why that proves his involvement. Can any one help?