I am also curious about the "learning disabilities" that poster fran spoke of. Is this confirmed? Was there a central location that the girls could have attended for any type of schooling, therapy, etc...?
I am not familiar with the area/counties.
Last edited by Boyz_Mum; 03-08-2009 at 03:10 AM. Reason: addition
Perhaps a boarding school for troubled girls?
From 1971-1973, three young girls aged 10 and 11 were abducted, raped and strangled in Rochester, New York. The case got it's name because all three girls had the same first and last initial, and they were found in towns starting with that initial.
Carmen Colon age 10 was sent on an errand to pick up a prescription not two blocks from her house on 11/16/1971 at 4:15 PM. She never returned home. At about 5:15 PM that same day motorists reported seeing a nearly nude young girl, looking "terrified" running from a car that was backing up towards her on the West Expressway in Riga, New York. No one stopped to help her. Several witnesses reported seeing this but still didn't stop to help. Her body was found less than a mile away on 11/18/1971. She had only a sweater on, her skull had been fractured she had been raped , beaten and strangled. Police had the FBI make a profile of her killer, and they felt that she knew him. They believed that her Uncle, Miguel Colon was responsible. He committed suicide in 1991 and was later exonerated through DNA evidence. Carmen was found in Churchville, New York.
Wanda Walkowicz, 11, also went on an errand and never returned on 04/02/1973. A Sate Trooper on patrol discovered her little body at a rest stop at State Route 104 in Webster, New York. On 04/03/1973. She too had been raped , beaten and strangled to death.
Michelle Maenza was the third, and last child to be murdered. She went missing on 11/26/1973. Her body was found on 11/28/1973 in Macedon, New York. She, too was only 11 years old, beaten, raped and strangled.
All three of these girls were Roman Catholic, came from poor areas of Rochester and all three did poorly in school, both academicaly and socialy. The notorious "Hillside Strangler", Kenneth Bianci was suspected at first because he lived in Rochester during that time, and he had a car simular to the one that was seen backing up towards Carmen Colon. He was exonerated as well through DNA evidence.
The letters "C", "M" and "W" are the 3rd, 13th and 23rd letters of the alphabet. Police also thought that the suspect might be a teacher, or counselor that had access to personal files. All three children had white cat hair on them, and might have been lured to a car using that cat as bait. Hundreds of people were questioned, to no avail. These cases are still unsolved, although an inmate in 1995 told investigators that he knew who was responsible for these heinous acts, but no other information was available to me online regarding this.
In January, 2007 a movie was being filmed in Rochester regarding this case. It was released in October, 2007, but Agatha Christie had written a book eerily simular to these cases years before they happened. So, I'm not sure what that movie actually was based on. I'm wondering too if Investigators looked at local Libraries to see who checked out that Agatha Christie book. Or if they perused local book stores. Regardless, if you have any information contact the Rochester, New York Police Department at 1-585-428-7157 that is The Major Crimes Division.
Tags: unsolved child murders, 1971-1973, rochester new york
Photo and info for Wanda Lee Walkowicz
there's also a thread here for this case.
[ame="http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75191"]Alphabet Murders, 1970s - Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community[/ame]
Welcome to the world Bridget!
Hi grace 1984,
It is an interesting case. I had the same question that julessleuther asked on the other Alphabet Murders thread: Why did the killer stop? Were they imprisoned? Were they questioned by the police and stopped?
Such a precise m.o. would seem to be a pattern that is very important to the killer, so I don't know if they would be able to stop or the switch their m.o. I wonder if they moved to a different part of the country and the pattern went unnoticed. Perhaps the killer became more mobile and went from city to city for each individual crime.
If any of the above are possibilities you would think that the coincidences would stand out, especially since I Assume the Alphabet Murders were publicized.
It was also mentioned that the killer would have had to have access to personal information on the girls. It could have been someone they knew and had contact with, or maybe someone just who knew them from afar. I wonder if the families lived in suburbia or an apartment? A killer could move around to various apartments to find a victim that matched the criteria, befriended them if only in passing and then used that to lure his victims.
I dunno, it is an interesting case, so sad that they have never found the killer so that justice could be served and the families could have closure. Its a very sad case, especially since the father of one of the little girls committed suicide and was then exonerated with DNA.
Anyway, what do you think happened?
Un-freaking belivable!!!!!!!!At about 5:15 PM that same day motorists reported seeing a nearly nude young girl, looking "terrified" running from a car that was backing up towards her on the West Expressway in Riga, New York. No one stopped to help her. Several witnesses reported seeing this but still didn't stop to help.
I wonder if it was just coincidence about the girls names. I've read a little on this case, mostly from Wikipedia. They were about the same age, did they have similar looks?
Everyone is entitled to his own opinion, but not his own facts.---Patrick Moynihan
Living in the
the female dective in the movie, what ever became of her?
in the movie she had a nervous breakdown i believe, and stated that she was seeing the spirit/ghosts of the young victims.
Can anyone supply any links with information on this detective, i would like to read more about her part in the investigation, and the reported sightings of the young girls ghosts visiting her from time to time.........thank you.
Me too. How terrifying.
Brand new forum dedicated to the Keddie Cabin Murders - everyone welcome at
Who killed Sarah Pryor?
My blog: http://genkidjericho.blogspot.com/
My first post here! After watching the movie, and being in home sales in the Delaware beach area, would like to know if anyone has a link to the composite sketch?
Seems to me, that if that sketch was posted in the local news in the early 70s, that the person(s) responsible probably fled the area.
Does anyone have a link, or some other means of helping with this info?
Very intriguing!!! I read through everything and did not find whether the DNA in the three cases in the 70s matched each other.
Here's another article about Joesph Naso: http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/42558019...me_and_courts/
That'd be one heck of coincidence if these killings aren't related.
Just watched the movie on Netflix...Whoever posted upthread that this was about the detective's breakdown was right...Was the "math instructor/tutor/mentor" ever looked into? TIA
Proud WS N-LIB
So glad to see you brought this up in a thread. I watched The Alphabet killer last night on Lifetime and it brought back all the old memories. Too bad it wasn't real true to fact, but it seemed funny hearing the promos and I knew it was this story when they mentioned Churchville.
I think of this from time to time as I lived on the same street yrs. before Carmen Colon was killed.
Bev mentioned that it had to be someone who knew them and IIRC I believe detectives went down those avenues. IMO there could be a connection in as much as the mothers were all on Public assistance and to me that was always a strong lead. Who better to know their names and addresses than a social worker from the County? It's another strong tie IMO. I've spent years racking my brain to think about how this could have happened and how it has gone unsolved. Technology today would be the key here and as was mentioned, there were no cell phones then, so people who saw Carmen running on I 490 could have called LE.
Two last points I want to make, there is that guy Joe Naso who lived here and was arrested in Calif. for double initial murders, but they say his DNA doesn't match. Also Kenneth Bianchi who denies any involvement? Are we supposed to believe him or did they ever go into it any further with him?
Thanks for the links to the D&C articles.
Be sure to watch for my book I'd die for you.
Some accounts from real DMV victims
Hopefully will be published
First ten to IM me will get a free copy sent to them.
This is the first I had heard of this so thank you. Will have to do more research on this
On Wednesday the 22nd, Investigation Discovery channel is having a show on these cases at 10pm.
Sorry for the lateness of these replies but I may have been in the hospital or something when they were written. They never showed up on my CP page.
There is a thread on this in the Serial Killer forum and has been discussed at length. My apologies for not catching it here.
FOLLOW ME ON TWITTER
In memory of Ron Pruitt
After watching the show I'm convinced that Carmen Colon was killed by her uncle. The second girl who had DNA on her doesn't match any suspect so far. The third victim may or may not be related to the second killing. When you remove Carmen Colon from the mix. (Her uncle failed a lie detector test, had a car similar to the one last seen chasing CC, that the car had been cleaned, a doll belonging to Carmen was found in the car,his DNA didn't match that found on the second victim and that he ran away to Puerto Rico and when he returned he failed the polygraph and then offed himself.) You're left with two. So now it's just two double initial murders. Now we're getting closer to coincidence.
Those who've been eliminated from doing all three murders.
Carmen Colon's Uncle
The new guy in California
I have to say that I'm very weirded out by how many serial killers have passed through this city.
by the sketches that were released in the News Papers Dec 1973?
He could have gone into hiding or even moved.
Has the Alphabet killer been found ?
This guy is a one man crime wave
Mods I think you need to merge this
[ame="http://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?t=75191"]CA Joseph Naso, once a suspect in NY Alphabet Murders, now on trial in California - Websleuths Crime Sleuthing Community[/ame]