butwhatif?
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 24, 2008
- Messages
- 3,598
- Reaction score
- 40
I havent seen alot of discussion about the players who are refusing to hand over cell records. Mods feel free to merge if there is already a thread relating to this topic.
My intent is not to throw anyone under the bus, but to discuss the idea of the right to privacy vs justice for Caylee.
Firstly nobody would want to have their cell records released for the world to see the most personal details of your life. But these are not ordinary circumstances.
IMO, providing cell records will serve two purposes. 1: tracking Kc's movements, and any contact she had with them in order to bolster the case against her. 2. proving that you have nothing to hide regardless of its its involvment or knowledge of the crime, or even making money off of Caylees death.
Some of these are people who claim to have loved Caylee, so why would they value their privacy more than helping to get justice for her?
What are the motives for holding them back?
In RM's case it seems $$$$$$ was the motivater for deleting emails from his PC. And in one of his interviews they say something along the lines of "Now ,you gave us permission to download your cell phone data, but that didnt work out too well, did it?" So its possible he also deleted everything on his cell. But why?
JG's cell records that have been released only show calls and no text content.
His dad repeatedly mentioned in his interview with LE the financial strain he was under because of the case.
So the motivater for refusing to hand them over could be that they, and all the others who are not willing to hand them over, dont want the public to know that they have gained financially by selling pics or their stories to media.
If thats the case, do you think that the public has a right to know who made money from caylees death, and who could have leaked info before the docs were released?
If they sold their story, then just 'fess up!! At least it will prove that they are completely forthcoming and holding nothing back.
Also, if they are keen to hide these details, does it make you wonder what else they could be hiding?
What is the A's PI hiding? Why not jump at the oportunity to prove to the world you are not lying about anything?
And RK, the hero.....why not live up to that title?
If I were a player in the case, and my records were requested, even if they were humiliating for me, I would hand them over because justice for a murdered child outweighs my possible embarrasment.
Who cares about raunchy texts, or people reading your text arguments? Isnt justice for caylee more important?
The 'I dont want all my friends and relatives brought into this' excuse doesnt fly, since we all know the numbers are redacted.And even if they werent, again, isnt justice for caylee more important?
Am really interested to hear other peoples perspective on this.
My intent is not to throw anyone under the bus, but to discuss the idea of the right to privacy vs justice for Caylee.
Firstly nobody would want to have their cell records released for the world to see the most personal details of your life. But these are not ordinary circumstances.
IMO, providing cell records will serve two purposes. 1: tracking Kc's movements, and any contact she had with them in order to bolster the case against her. 2. proving that you have nothing to hide regardless of its its involvment or knowledge of the crime, or even making money off of Caylees death.
Some of these are people who claim to have loved Caylee, so why would they value their privacy more than helping to get justice for her?
What are the motives for holding them back?
In RM's case it seems $$$$$$ was the motivater for deleting emails from his PC. And in one of his interviews they say something along the lines of "Now ,you gave us permission to download your cell phone data, but that didnt work out too well, did it?" So its possible he also deleted everything on his cell. But why?
JG's cell records that have been released only show calls and no text content.
His dad repeatedly mentioned in his interview with LE the financial strain he was under because of the case.
So the motivater for refusing to hand them over could be that they, and all the others who are not willing to hand them over, dont want the public to know that they have gained financially by selling pics or their stories to media.
If thats the case, do you think that the public has a right to know who made money from caylees death, and who could have leaked info before the docs were released?
If they sold their story, then just 'fess up!! At least it will prove that they are completely forthcoming and holding nothing back.
Also, if they are keen to hide these details, does it make you wonder what else they could be hiding?
What is the A's PI hiding? Why not jump at the oportunity to prove to the world you are not lying about anything?
And RK, the hero.....why not live up to that title?
If I were a player in the case, and my records were requested, even if they were humiliating for me, I would hand them over because justice for a murdered child outweighs my possible embarrasment.
Who cares about raunchy texts, or people reading your text arguments? Isnt justice for caylee more important?
The 'I dont want all my friends and relatives brought into this' excuse doesnt fly, since we all know the numbers are redacted.And even if they werent, again, isnt justice for caylee more important?
Am really interested to hear other peoples perspective on this.