Casey Anthony attorney: Judge Perry has 'clear bias'

Reality Orlando · Mar 24, 2011

"Because there are factual inaccuracies in the court's order which were relied upon in reaching its conclusion, the undersigned respectfully asks that the court grant an additional hearing in order to rule on the actual facts in evidence," defense attorney Cheney Mason wrote in one part of the motion.

In another part of the nine-page motion, involving whether Casey Anthony was in custody when she gave early statements to investigators, Mason wrote, "the court did not look at the evidence from the hearing objectively and instead displays a clear bias in explaining law enforcement conduct"

http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/local/caylee-anthony/os-casey-anthony-hearing-thursday-20110324,0,2758083.story?page=1

Uh, oh....how will HHJP handle this one?

beach · Mar 24, 2011

More hyperbole. lol Too bad they used their big strike on Judge Strickland.

They wanted a new judge and they got him! :woot:

sumbunny · Mar 24, 2011

Reality Orlando said:
"Because there are factual inaccuracies in the court's order which were relied upon in reaching its conclusion, the undersigned respectfully asks that the court grant an additional hearing in order to rule on the actual facts in evidence," defense attorney Cheney Mason wrote in one part of the motion.

In another part of the nine-page motion, involving whether Casey Anthony was in custody when she gave early statements to investigators, Mason wrote, "the court did not look at the evidence from the hearing objectively and instead displays a clear bias in explaining law enforcement conduct"

http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/local/caylee-anthony/os-casey-anthony-hearing-thursday-20110324,0,2758083.story?page=1

Uh, oh....how will HHJP handle this one?

O.M.G ~jaw drop~
They want a second bite at the apple?

HHJP won't be impressed with this latest motion. Do you think he'll flat out deny them another hearing or humor them?

Unbelievable

Wagara · Mar 24, 2011

I don't blame CM...I wouldn't be in court today either if I was him!!!

Didn't AZLawyer say this couldn't be contested until after the trial?

angeldust · Mar 24, 2011

I imagine JP is getting a little fed up. I think he has on many occasions held the DT hand and guided them forward. If there has been any "bias" in this case it has been in favour of the defense. imo

the cheek of them....

believe09 · Mar 24, 2011

FWIW, I doubt he takes this stuff personally. You have to have a pretty big personality to be a judge....sure some are better than others.

If CM really wants to capture the attention of Perry with his extensive knowledge of the law, he should pare his motions down some rather than taking the everything but the kitchen sink approach...JMVHO.

As for Perry, well I dont see him rising to this kind of bait.

coopzoo · Mar 24, 2011

Don't like the judge, JB and CM? Congratulations... you made your bed...

:angel:

MOO

bananarama · Mar 24, 2011

Here is a link for this motion:

http://www.wesh.com/pdf/27311555/detail.html

Very accusatory. I can't wait to hear JBP's response to this!

Melanie · Mar 24, 2011

I don't know - how many judges does JB want to go through? Enough to get him a not-guilty verdict? Fortunately, the US Judicial System doesn't work that way. You can't just pick and choose and move on when you don't get a response in your favour.

Counsel needs to move on and get this case rolling (we're talking a 2008 crime here). Enough cushion has been provided thus far -- far more than many other defendents that I've read about.

Justice for Caylee is all I want.

Mel

TotallyObsessed · Mar 24, 2011

I am now going to read the motion. Without having done so and without know what the defense has asked for (i.e., recusement of the judge) let me just say that ultimately, recusal is up to the judge. It is almost never done except where there are obvious financial conflicts. IMHO Judge Perry has no intention of leaving this case at this point. He has done nothing wrong.

ETA: Just finished reading....they are not asking for recusal. Smart ones, those guys.
All I can say is I hope JBP has a big 'ole "DENIED" stamp.

cloud9 · Mar 24, 2011

INSANITY!!!!!!!!!!!!!!:banghead:

ZsaZsa · Mar 24, 2011

bananarama said:
Here is a link for this motion:

http://www.wesh.com/pdf/27311555/detail.html

Very accusatory. I can't wait to hear JBP's response to this!

At the first hearing he pretty much opened by saying if the decisions went against ICA then they would be back to try again....

Just Jayla · Mar 24, 2011

Would he prefer HHJP be a liberal judge, making up law from the bench as he goes? Cause that is a two way street, double edged sword...A liberal judge can certainly make things up for the prosecution to utilize as well...

strawberry · Mar 24, 2011

CM warned this wouldn't be the end of it if motions were denied.

RR0004 · Mar 24, 2011

Reality Orlando said:
"Because there are factual inaccuracies in the court's order which were relied upon in reaching its conclusion, the undersigned respectfully asks that the court grant an additional hearing in order to rule on the actual facts in evidence," defense attorney Cheney Mason wrote in one part of the motion.

In another part of the nine-page motion, involving whether Casey Anthony was in custody when she gave early statements to investigators, Mason wrote, "the court did not look at the evidence from the hearing objectively and instead displays a clear bias in explaining law enforcement conduct"

http://www.orlandosentinel.com/news/local/caylee-anthony/os-casey-anthony-hearing-thursday-20110324,0,2758083.story?page=1

Uh, oh....how will HHJP handle this one?

Wow...them fighting words!

nursebeeme · Mar 24, 2011

will the defense do this with every ruling they don't like/doesn't fit with their overall plan and strategy?

Kimster · Mar 24, 2011

All these motions are making me seasick. :sick:

strach304 · Mar 24, 2011

CM needs to check himself. He was the one stating inaccuracies at that hearing. Many as a matter of fact. In his motion everything he has listed is according to Casey, CA or GA. Is that the bias he means? JP didn't believe their version of events? CM states ICA was never 10 feet away from an Officer. That is BS. Even Cindy said she was in her room for about an hour before Yuri got there.

strach304 · Mar 24, 2011

I don't think it helped any with all the facts CM misstated. I'm JP now who am I gonna believe?

JustJax · Mar 24, 2011

This isn't Walmart here...you can't keep going back for an exchange because you don't like the fit.

Casey Anthony attorney: Judge Perry has 'clear bias'

Verified Aquaculturalist

Verified Expert

New Member

Wishin' and hopin’ and thinkin’ and prayin’...

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Whoever is trying to bring you down is already bel

Seeking Justice for the little ones without a voic

Inactive

New Member

New Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

New Member

Registered User

Former Member

New Member

New Member

New Member

DNASolves

Online statistics

Forum statistics