I love so much all of you here who hold fast the belief that Gabe is out there somewhere with a loving couple waiting to come home to his precious father and eager family. I really really do. Thank you so much for your beautiful hearts and tenacity. Your hope and caring shows us all the finest traits of humanity: faith, hope, and love.
I have finally allowed myself to read the recently released documents. Here is the reaction I have to what I have read of the facts in the case.
First and foremost is the reaction that SOME PEOPLE, and we know who they are, need some MAJOR psychological help, way, waaaay beyond the rote-spouting of Bible verses. What I have just read calls to mind the final scene in the movie Cape Fear, as the boat is sinking and the perp is "speaking in tongues" in an obvious mental illness frenzy while sinking into the snake and gator infested waters.
Secondly, I firmly do believe Gabe is with us securely embraced and protected in our heart of hearts forever, but no longer in a physical body on earth. I also hope I am wrong.
I believe when EJ was told that a mother can give her child up for adoption in Texas WITHOUT the father's consent if they are not married, she immediately began to plan to move there, thinking she would wait out their 6 months residency requirement. I think it is what she had in mind when she sold her stuff to raise money and kept her last months rent. I believe that is why she looked for jobs in San Antonio. I believe that is why she did NOT depend on shelters or undergrounds as TS had suggested.
I believe EJ is bipolar, borderline personality disordered, oppositionally defiant, intermittent explosive disordered, had a history of becoming unhinged during periods of chaos in her life, AND had a binge drinking problem. Each of the LE reports of her prior violence and false accusations against LM involved (according to the report) her being under the influence of alcohol. Alcohol is KNOWN to provoke heightened bipolar symptoms in addition to the general release of inhibitions which would have set loose BPD feelings of abandonment, resentment, jealousy, and rage. For EJ, the rage and resulting damage is very well documented.
I think initially she had every intention of showing Logan once and for all that she and only she had power and control of Gabriel and that the mighty state of TEXAS would allow her to do it legally and openly, leaving him without recourse. (This is what I'm thinking SHE was thinking in her own mind) In Texas, she could stick it to him with impunity.
The documents show that, once in SA, she looked for childcare and jobs, THAT soon. I do not believe she would have done this if she knew she was going to give Gabriel to someone else within a very short time frame or thought she would be leaving to move on quickly, or thought she would be 'coming into money' soon from an illegal addoption. At that time, I think she fully intended to wait out the six months. I also think 6 months gave her a safety net of 'breathing' time so that things might actually work out with Logan.
But those disturbing calls from TS resumed and she was told she HAD to return to AZ where TS and Jack **S would take control again. I am remembering the babysitter's account of EJ screaming at the "grandmother" on the phone and what was said about THAT.
I also believe EJ very quickly became overwhelmed with the solitary care of Gabriel and desperately needed help/respite. Desperately. Especially so after the chaos-inducing conversations with the Smiths resumed. My strong sense of this is based on personal experience with someone very near and dear to me; I have SEEN it up close and KNOW the danger firsthand. I changed/moved my whole life last year to care for a baby and her mother who is similarly challenged. Attending physicians insisted it was necessary for the safety of the baby and the mental health of the mother. And this mother has nowhere NEAR the documented history of violence and disturbing symptoms that EJ does.
For someone with the mental challenges of EJ, having to give up her organized (in her own mind) plan, being pushed to do first one thing and then another she didn't want to do would generate a feeling of chaos in her life, setting off a whole chain of bad reactions. Add the overwhelming and unrelenting demands of a needy baby and you have a pretty sure formula for tension and a bottleneck of emotions in turmoil. What would she likely reach for to self-medicate, quick, easy, and cheap? ... Alcohol? .....We now KNOW the past results of alcohol for EJ; they are in the police reports. It's not pretty. And her previous reponse to the criminal charges? She simply didn't understand why she didn't have the right to destroy what she considered to be her own (breakage of apartment windows?).
On reading these recently released documents, I find EJ's account of her relationship with the Smiths, her decision to leave Phoenix, her trip, and her time in San Antonio to be consistent and believable, right up until she starts talking about the couple and the park. Then I feel there starts to be signs of 'fabricating memories', with lots of shrugged off blanks when it is too much work to come up with real 'remembered' detail. There are just too many blanks there at the end. And I don't think it is Gabriel's interests that she is protecting.
Hope I am wrong. Very sadly, I really don't think so.