ZFG Civil Case: Casey's Deposition #2

[Salem]

Please continue here.

Thread 1

Thread 1

Salem

[Schu7]

I have a sick feeling ZG will not be collecting any money here. Because Casey will have a built up mental insanity situation by then. Her therapy sessions could make this possible. Casey being mentally not responsible for her actions at the time. Because of Caylee's death. With a couple sick therapists backing that view up. Then the deposition may never happen. As in just not worth it from Murray's point of view. In this crazy court case, this may well happen. And these therapy BS sessions may only be a deflection against all civil suits. Oh how I hope I am wrong here, but........

[ZsaZsa]

Originally Posted by Schu7

I have a sick feeling ZG will not be collecting any money here. Because Casey will have a built up mental insanity situation by then. Her therapy sessions could make this possible. Casey being mentally not responsible for her actions at the time. Because of Caylee's death. With a couple sick therapists backing that view up. Then the deposition may never happen. As in just not worth it from Murray's point of view. In this crazy court case, this may well happen. And these therapy BS sessions may only be a deflection against all civil suits. Oh how I hope I am wrong here, but........

I don't know if she will ever collect, but I think the case will go her way.
JM is like a terrier after a rabbit. He is not letting her get away with it..

IIRC they already proved she was not insane either at the time Caylee died, up to and including the trial. She knew right from wrong, so she must pay..

[suepitzl]

IMO, all KC's attorneys have to say is that ZFG was made up, game over. MOO. It is a "ruined reputation" lawsuit for 15,000. I am sure there are many people with that name and they are not filing lawsuits. If someone said I left my child with Mark Jones, or Mary Jones, Hypothetically,what evidence is there that one didleave a child a with Mark Jones or Mary Jones? The case has no merit, there is no evidence linking KC to a ZFG, only KC's statement which KC admitted was a lie. ZFG never lived at Sawgrass apartments.

Let me put this another way as so many seem to think this lawsuit will go somewhere:

My name is Mary Jones, some nutcase says that I was a caretaker for a person later found dead. The nutcase has no info on how to contact me, no correspondance whatsoever. No link back to me.

How in the world could/would a court find that the nutcase meant me?

It is all speculation on M&M's view, IMO.

I do believe it will go nowhere. Think about it........if someone threw your name out there, and it is a common name, would you be out there claiming your reputation was ruined?
ZFG (especially in the latin community) is a very common name. How do M&M prove she meant this ZFG? Frivolous. MOO

[MissJames]

Originally Posted by suepitzl

IMO, all KC's attorneys have to say is that ZFG was made up, game over. MOO. It is a "ruined reputation" lawsuit for 15,000. I am sure there are many people with that name and they are not filing lawsuits. If someone said I left my child with Mark Jones, or Mary Jones, Hypothetically,what evidence is there that one didleave a child a with Mark Jones or Mary Jones? The case has no merit, there is no evidence linking KC to a ZFG, only KC's statement which KC admitted was a lie. ZFG never lived at Sawgrass apartments.

Let me put this another way as so many seem to think this lawsuit will go somewhere:

My name is Mary Jones, some nutcase says that I was a caretaker for a person later found dead. The nutcase has no info on how to contact me, no correspondance whatsoever. No link back to me.

How in the world could/would a court find that the nutcase meant me?

It is all speculation on M&M's view, IMO.

I do believe it will go nowhere. Think about it........if someone threw your name out there, and it is a common name, would you be out there claiming your reputation was ruined?
ZFG (especially in the latin community) is a very common name. How do M&M prove she meant this ZFG? Frivolous. MOO

I actually do have a very common name. It pops up all over the place.
But there is not usually a connection beyond having the same name.

The Sawgrass connection and the time frame will be strong evidence,but who knows if it will be enough. For some it is and for others ,not so much.
I think she deserves her day in court and let Morgan lay out what he's got. Then we'll know if it's frivolous. MOO

[Schu7]

Respectfully here to you all. But I feel that ZG should be suing Cindy. It was Casey who in jail told the police that the woman in the picture they showed her WAS NOT ZG. But that night, Cindy went on national TV and stated that this ZG in question was the right one! And that statement was made after Casey informed Cindy the police had showed her a picture of the wrong ZG. Now it gets tricky. Cindy said she was speaking as Casey's representative on TV.

The bottom line is that Cindy is the one who sent the dogs after ZG after Casey had cleared her. So why is Cindy not being sued here???

[LambChop]

Originally Posted by Schu7

Respectfully here to you all. But I feel that ZG should be suing Cindy. It was Casey who in jail told the police that the woman in the picture they showed her WAS NOT ZG. But that night, Cindy went on national TV and stated that this ZG in question was the right one! And that statement was made after Casey informed Cindy the police had showed her a picture of the wrong ZG. Now it gets tricky. Cindy said she was speaking as Casey's representative on TV.

The bottom line is that Cindy is the one who sent the dogs after ZG after Casey had cleared her. So why is Cindy not being sued here???

As John Morgan stated in his press conference it was CA who was acting as an agent for KC when CA went before the media and stated KC did not see any photographs of the woman from Kissimmee. CA got her information from KC so KC is ultimately responsible. If there were a real ZFG then ZG may not have a chance at her suit. But there was none. She was made up in KC's head and when the opportunity to clear ZG came before the public KC did not do so leaving the public to speculate this could be the person. Since there was no such person it appears from the jailhouse video KC's intention was to have everyone focus on the "woman from Kissimmee" as KC calls her out. This isn't a case of mistaken identity. KC intentionally tried to blame someone else, someone she knew was at Sawgrass at the time.

Imagine if ZG actually did lease an apartment at Sawgrass and moved into the apartment above 210 which was the apartment ZG was shown. That is just way too close to KC's story to suit my comfort zone. If I were ZG I would feel KC was targeting me in some way. KC did not just pick the time, date and place out of the air. Somehow she knew ZG was looking at this apartment. It's easier to believe KC knew than to think KC was able to get the time, place and approximate date ZG showed up at the apartment coincidentally. jmo

[fundiva]

Crazy isn't a defense in a civil case; only criminal.

[strawberry]

http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news...ony-civil-case

Woman writes angry letter to judge in Casey Anthony civil case

http://www.cfnews13.com/static/artic...unyon-0804.pdf

[mombomb]

Originally Posted by strawberry

http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news...ony-civil-case

Woman writes angry letter to judge in Casey Anthony civil case

http://www.cfnews13.com/static/artic...unyon-0804.pdf

Good for her for making her feelings known!

[cyberborg]

Originally Posted by strawberry

http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news...ony-civil-case

Woman writes angry letter to judge in Casey Anthony civil case

http://www.cfnews13.com/static/artic...unyon-0804.pdf

This is testimony to that this is not just some young Facebook e-lynch mob ... the sense of injustice covers a full spectrum of the population and isn't even limited to the U.S. While she crosses the line in her letter she does make a good point ... how these errors, mistakes and, events all seem to enable FCA further such that she is never held accountable or responsible for much of anything and ... justice is denied for Caylee.

It shouts loud that something needs to be done, the justice system needs updating, there needs to be rules on Defense practices since this trial pushed the envelope to the extreme and beyond in terms of deceit.

Caylee's Law is a good start but there needs to be more because FCA has become a catalyst.

[Searchfortruth]

Originally Posted by Schu7

Respectfully here to you all. But I feel that ZG should be suing Cindy. It was Casey who in jail told the police that the woman in the picture they showed her WAS NOT ZG. But that night, Cindy went on national TV and stated that this ZG in question was the right one! And that statement was made after Casey informed Cindy the police had showed her a picture of the wrong ZG. Now it gets tricky. Cindy said she was speaking as Casey's representative on TV.

The bottom line is that Cindy is the one who sent the dogs after ZG after Casey had cleared her. So why is Cindy not being sued here???

Also Casey, in the written depo, answered the question, "Is the person in the attached picture, the Zenaida Gonzalez you claim had Caylee the last time you saw her", with the fifth amendment. She had the opportunity to clear Zenaida's name then (January 2009), she did not.

[mombomb]

I'm assuming that the 8/2 letter was the older woman writing to the judge. Do we know what the three subsequent letters are which are listed in the Clerk's records?

OTHER EVENTS AND HEARINGS
08/09/2011 Letter
08/09/2011 Letter
08/05/2011 Letter
08/04/2011 Notice of Cancellation
Notice of Cancellation
08/02/2011 Letter

http://myclerk.myorangeclerk.com/Cas...CaseID=1450829

[WolfmarsGirl]

Originally Posted by suepitzl

IMO, all KC's attorneys have to say is that ZFG was made up, game over. MOO. It is a "ruined reputation" lawsuit for 15,000. I am sure there are many people with that name and they are not filing lawsuits. If someone said I left my child with Mark Jones, or Mary Jones, Hypothetically,what evidence is there that one didleave a child a with Mark Jones or Mary Jones? The case has no merit, there is no evidence linking KC to a ZFG, only KC's statement which KC admitted was a lie. ZFG never lived at Sawgrass apartments.

Let me put this another way as so many seem to think this lawsuit will go somewhere:

My name is Mary Jones, some nutcase says that I was a caretaker for a person later found dead. The nutcase has no info on how to contact me, no correspondance whatsoever. No link back to me.

How in the world could/would a court find that the nutcase meant me?

It is all speculation on M&M's view, IMO.

I do believe it will go nowhere. Think about it........if someone threw your name out there, and it is a common name, would you be out there claiming your reputation was ruined?
ZFG (especially in the latin community) is a very common name. How do M&M prove she meant this ZFG? Frivolous. MOO

Well, because you were shopping for an apartment in the exact location where the fake 'Mary Jones' resided. In fact, if you looked at her exact apartment as part of your tour, had license plates from the same state, and were at her imaginary residence exactly one day after the dead person was, well, ummm, made to be dead, then I think they can zero in on you and only you.

See how it worked for the real ZG??

[Horace Finklestein]

Originally Posted by suepitzl

IMO, all KC's attorneys have to say is that ZFG was made up, game over. MOO. It is a "ruined reputation" lawsuit for 15,000. I am sure there are many people with that name and they are not filing lawsuits. If someone said I left my child with Mark Jones, or Mary Jones, Hypothetically,what evidence is there that one didleave a child a with Mark Jones or Mary Jones? The case has no merit, there is no evidence linking KC to a ZFG, only KC's statement which KC admitted was a lie. ZFG never lived at Sawgrass apartments.

Let me put this another way as so many seem to think this lawsuit will go somewhere:

My name is Mary Jones, some nutcase says that I was a caretaker for a person later found dead. The nutcase has no info on how to contact me, no correspondance whatsoever. No link back to me.

How in the world could/would a court find that the nutcase meant me?

It is all speculation on M&M's view, IMO.

I do believe it will go nowhere. Think about it........if someone threw your name out there, and it is a common name, would you be out there claiming your reputation was ruined?
ZFG (especially in the latin community) is a very common name. How do M&M prove she meant this ZFG? Frivolous. MOO

Not at all frivolous. If you throw a rock into a crowd of people and injure a person, it doesn't matter who you meant to injure, or if you meant to injure anyone at all - you did something illegal and harmed someone, so you pay. imo

[lauriej]

Originally Posted by suepitzl

-----snipped-----

It is all speculation on M&M's view, IMO.

I do believe it will go nowhere. Think about it........if someone threw your name out there, and it is a common name, would you be out there claiming your reputation was ruined?

ZFG (especially in the latin community) is a very common name. How do M&M prove she meant this ZFG? Frivolous. MOO

..the point of the civil suit by this particular Zenaida Gonzales isn't that kc identified HER -----only that kc came up with the name Zenaida Fernandez Gonzales, a woman who lived at Sawgrass apartments.

..it doesn't matter where kc got the name/description from.

..what matters is----LE went to Sawgrass and found out that ---A--- Zenaida Gonzales had looked at an apt. there.

..they went to HER door , took HER down for questioning, HER apt. manager asked HER to leave, due to the negative publicity, HER boss at the housekeeping job asked HER to leave , due to the negative publicity.

HER kids names, HER car etc. were in the police report and released.

..this didn't happen to any other Zenaida Gonzales-----just HER.

..it didn't matter that she didn't fit the description or have the full name that lies-about-everything-kc had said.

..HER life /HER kids lives were impacted------b/c of kc's lies about the fictitious sitter @ Sawgrass apartments that she happened to share the name of.

..that's the premise of their civil suit.
..and i think it has merit.

[Leila]

Originally Posted by Schu7

Respectfully here to you all. But I feel that ZG should be suing Cindy. It was Casey who in jail told the police that the woman in the picture they showed her WAS NOT ZG. But that night, Cindy went on national TV and stated that this ZG in question was the right one! And that statement was made after Casey informed Cindy the police had showed her a picture of the wrong ZG. Now it gets tricky. Cindy said she was speaking as Casey's representative on TV.

The bottom line is that Cindy is the one who sent the dogs after ZG after Casey had cleared her. So why is Cindy not being sued here???

I've always thought that Cindy was just as liable as Casey in regards to ZG. Cindy did indeed go on television and make the point that the woman was the right one.

I think ZG's lawsuit should include Cindy, not only because of that one statement on television, but she also continuously promoted the story that ZFG kidnapped Caylee long after Casey had been arrested and was sitting in jail not talking. Cindy kept throwing in details, saying that she had phone numbers for ZFG and had given them to LE. She said that Zanny had a puppy and that Caylee had talked about playing with Zanny's puppy.

The bottom line is that Cindy kept the "Zanny the nanny kidnapped Caylee" story in the headlines for many months after Casey went to jail.

[pinkfly]

Originally Posted by Leila

I've always thought that Cindy was just as liable as Casey in regards to ZG. Cindy did indeed go on television and make the point that the woman was the right one.

I think ZG's lawsuit should include Cindy, not only because of that one statement on television, but she also continuously promoted the story that ZFG kidnapped Caylee long after Casey had been arrested and was sitting in jail not talking. Cindy kept throwing in details, saying that she had phone numbers for ZFG and had given them to LE. She said that Zanny had a puppy and that Caylee had talked about playing with Zanny's puppy.

The bottom line is that Cindy kept the "Zanny the nanny kidnapped Caylee" story in the headlines for many months after Casey went to jail.

I agree with you very much

[Horace Finklestein]

Originally Posted by strawberry

http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news...ony-civil-case

Woman writes angry letter to judge in Casey Anthony civil case

http://www.cfnews13.com/static/artic...unyon-0804.pdf

Whoa - a lowly citizen asking for explanations?? Surely this will not fly.

[legalmania]

I'm sure that this has been posted but with a new thread I thought I would repost the complaint.

http://media.myfoxorlando.com/photog...001_Page_1.htm


Here is Florida cases and what elements are required by the plaintiff to prove defamation by a preponderance of the evidence.

http://www.citmedialaw.org/legal-gui...defamation-law

[Schu7]

Originally Posted by Leila

I've always thought that Cindy was just as liable as Casey in regards to ZG. Cindy did indeed go on television and make the point that the woman was the right one.

I think ZG's lawsuit should include Cindy, not only because of that one statement on television, but she also continuously promoted the story that ZFG kidnapped Caylee long after Casey had been arrested and was sitting in jail not talking. Cindy kept throwing in details, saying that she had phone numbers for ZFG and had given them to LE. She said that Zanny had a puppy and that Caylee had talked about playing with Zanny's puppy.

The bottom line is that Cindy kept the "Zanny the nanny kidnapped Caylee" story in the headlines for many months after Casey went to jail.

Well I detest Cindy ever so much. That is my right. Nobody can force me to like or dislike someone. That is called freedom of thought. An item we never want to lose!

But I also hate the media sensationalism in reporting these days. And the media has made huge money off Cindy being so hate able! Heck, the 4 Anthony's have made the media an extra 10's of millions or so in higher ratings, sold tabloids etc.... Nancy Grace alone has seen her ratings from 3 years ago, go from a nightly take of around 600,00 viewers, to 1,400,000 viewers! So do we hate the media with such a passion? No. Probably because we the public feed that media frenzy. And rarely do humans lay the blame at their own feet. Which is in a way the same thing as Cindy does. And Cindy has run that family. Make no mistake about that!

So we have Cindy making money off Caylee. Lying. Obstructing the LE. Destroying Zenaida Gonzales life to a big degree, Etc... Oh yes, the Cindy-Casey show has been probably the worst mother-daughter show in recent history. Certainly the most public visible. And the whole sad mess has struck a major nerve in the publics wish to peek into the very darkest areas of human behavioral possibilities. All under the nice clean cloak of wanting to see justice done for Caylee. But how about some justice for Zenaida Gonzales? Or the ruined neighbours lives? We have had a good look into the dark morass of the Cindy - Casey life's. It is ever so ugly! Yet society is supposed to make "bad" people pay for their evil doings and ways. So why not in this case with this horrific mother - daughter tragedy? Will be ever really know what went wrong with the system here? A civil trial of Zenaida Gonzales against Casey Anthony might be very helpful in finding the truths here.IMO But a trial against Cindy Anthony would probably be even more informative.IMO

[Leah0107]

However the ZG case turns out, she was harmed as a result of FCA's lies and I hope she get's her pay day.

[OneLostGrl]

Originally Posted by Horace Finklestein

Whoa - a lowly citizen asking for explanations?? Surely this will not fly.

No kidding.. if it were Perry she were writing to the poor thing would probably be held in contempt and put in jail.

[Purple Iris]

I have to agree with those of you that Cindy should have been included in this lawsuits, all for the very reasons stated.

Plus, I have to admit, it was pretty out there seeing the ole pit-bull let loose.
Talk about showing your true colors.
I could sit through another one of those sessions just for the pure awe of it all over again!

And, Cindy is just defiant enough to once again look straight at *this* ZFG, and repeat, "This is not the ZFG that Casey talked about. I'm sorry Ma'am, you're cute, but you're no "10".

Case closed and wrapped up in Cindy's mind.

[legalmania]

Originally Posted by Leila

I've always thought that Cindy was just as liable as Casey in regards to ZG. Cindy did indeed go on television and make the point that the woman was the right one.

I think ZG's lawsuit should include Cindy, not only because of that one statement on television, but she also continuously promoted the story that ZFG kidnapped Caylee long after Casey had been arrested and was sitting in jail not talking. Cindy kept throwing in details, saying that she had phone numbers for ZFG and had given them to LE. She said that Zanny had a puppy and that Caylee had talked about playing with Zanny's puppy.

The bottom line is that Cindy kept the "Zanny the nanny kidnapped Caylee" story in the headlines for many months after Casey went to jail.

Cindy never meet ZFG nor could she point out ZG, until she saw her on t.v. There were 34 other ZG in the state of Fl alone. Casey also said that they needed to spread their search to other states. Cindy was simply repeating what Casey told her. Cindy and George were asking Casey what do you want us to say to the media, and Casey would tell them what to say. Casey even went as far as saying who ZG mother, step father and sister were. The police would not do a sketch of ZG so they would at least have something to go by. Casey talked about this baby sitter for two years before this happened. I don't think Cindy will be held responsible or they would have already done it and I believe it's to late now the statute of limitations is up.

http://names.whitepages.com/florida/zenaida/gonzalez


Here is a link that Casey was talking about a ZG for over 2 years.

http://www.unexplained-mysteries.com...owtopic=203925

Casey claims that Caylee's Babysitter, Zenaida "Zanny" Fernandez-Gonzalez, abducted Caylee. Casey said Fernandez-Gonzalez had been a caregiver for the child for over two years. However, in the nearly three years that Caylee was alive and living at Cindy Anthony's house, neither of Casey's parents nor any of her friends, boyfriends, family, or acquaintances had reportedly ever met the purported babysitter. Casey led The authorities to at least three apartments buildings where Fernandez-Gonzalez supposedly lived but nobody found anything about this woman, we have no proof that this woman really existed.