Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
It may seem strange after all this time but I still wonder why someone from the "Red Cross" was weeping into the boyfriend's voicemail on that Wednesday morning.
I found this from an article on Maura I had never seen before. If everyone else has seen it but me, then I apologize, but I have spent some time reading up on Maura and I had never come across this particular article.
http://www.wnd.com/2006/03/35310/
I don't believe anyone ever said a red cross employee was "weeping" on Billy's voicemail. Billy heard sounds that he thought sounded like whimpering in his voicemail. The call was traced to a calling card used by the Red Cross. I have had calls and voicemails from a poorly connected call that made strange sounds and I could convince myself they are just about anything. I am certain that in his emotional state he could have taken whatever sounds they were and called them whimpers. If I recall correctly, the message was analyzed and they were not able to determine the origin of the noise. What I find even more strange is that he deleted the message shortly after he discovered it in his voicemail.
I followed this case for a while, and after reading "Finding Me" by Michelle Knight, one of the girls who was held captive all those years, I can't help but wonder how many other missing people are still alive and being held captive?
I don't believe anyone ever said a red cross employee was "weeping" on Billy's voicemail. Billy heard sounds that he thought sounded like whimpering in his voicemail. The call was traced to a calling card used by the Red Cross. I have had calls and voicemails from a poorly connected call that made strange sounds and I could convince myself they are just about anything. I am certain that in his emotional state he could have taken whatever sounds they were and called them whimpers. If I recall correctly, the message was analyzed and they were not able to determine the origin of the noise. What I find even more strange is that he deleted the message shortly after he discovered it in his voicemail.
I don't think it was shortly after that he deleted it. Eventually he did because every time he went to check his voicemail he'd have to hear it before going on to the new ones. That had to be very difficult for him. But that was some time later.
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
...However, the fact the originating number was traced to the Red Cross...
:cow:
I had always understood it to be a calling card purchased by the Red Cross to donate to someone in need: homeless, lost, etc. I didn't think it was a Red Cross worker calling. Why would a Red Cross worker use a calling card? It could have been Maura making that call. She could have "picked up" the card somewhere the way she helped herself to other things.
For clarification: the call was traced to Red Cross, and Billy's mother assumed that meant the Red Cross calling card she gave Maura. In fact, it traced back to a Red Cross office and Lt. Scarinza spoke to the employee who made the call.
For clarification: the call was traced to Red Cross, and Billy's mother assumed that meant the Red Cross calling card she gave Maura. In fact, it traced back to a Red Cross office and Lt. Scarinza spoke to the employee who made the call.
It is very strange to me that Scarinza would not have made a public clarification of this fact. To many people, the "Maura weeping voice mail" was evidence that she was alive and in severe distress.
I am also not entirely buying this, sorry. So would a Red Cross employee, someone who is trained to assist people in times of serious personal emergencies, really make a phone call and not leave a clear and concise voice mail? Just some weeping sounds? Really? If I ran that office, then whatever employee did that would be fired. Hear me out for a moment. These people's jobs are to help people who are likely going through something like a sudden death in the family. Surely those people would leave a clear and professional voice mail. Let's really think about this for a moment. Billy gets leave. He is traveling and someone from the Red Cross calls him as part of a program they have to assist military families. This person leaves a cryptic, "whimpering" voice mail. Now I am going to have to assume here that this was the first and last time the Red Cross ever called Billy. I am assuming this because had the red cross called Billy later and had he spoken to them, then when they got the phone bill it would have been the same number, so it all would have been cleared up for them and that part of the story would have never even made it into media reports because it would have been a complete non-event. So, this is what we have:
1. A "red cross" employee calls Billy.
2. He or she has the job of helping people in serious family emergencies.
3. He or she most unprofessionally leaves no voice mail, but instead leaves something like a whimpering sound.
4. This employee knows that the person they were trying to reach is likely going through an emotionally devastating time.
5. The Red Cross never calls Billy back. Had they, it would have been clear what happened.
6. Maura's family and friends for weeks and months after the disappearance believe it likely it was her.
7. Sometime after 2012, Lt. Scarinza tells Renner the "true story" about this.
8. No one in the family ever once goes to the media to make this clarification.
Like so much in this case, this just stinks. It is simply one more "fact" that when really broken down, does not add up.
Even if I were to give the benefit of the doubt and say that it is entirely true, then that makes me wonder what other media reports that were mysteries at the time have subsequently been cleared up with nary a peep from the family. For all we know, they have known for years what the breakdown at work was really about, or why Maura went up there. It is so unfathomably perplexing to me that the family is adamant about not clearing things up that they know now to be wrong.
For clarification: the call was traced to Red Cross, and Billy's mother assumed that meant the Red Cross calling card she gave Maura. In fact, it traced back to a Red Cross office and Lt. Scarinza spoke to the employee who made the call.
Scoops you make a good point. You make damn fine point actually. So Sharon herself contacts the Red Cross on Tuesday and then on Wednesday Billy gets a call "traced to the Red Cross" and the family puts out there to the media that this very well could be Maura? Seriously? I mean, look, we're all people of at least average intelligence. If you call a number and that number calls you back the next day, then that is your answer. You're right that maybe some weird thing happened on the other end of the phone, like the employee had voice mail issues. The reason I thought the whole thing was fishy was because the family used this event as evidence that Maura was alive in media reports and the never once cleared it up. Sheet, they even had an explanation: Sharon had given Maura some Red Cross calling cards.
Why would they do that? Why give the public a red herring like that?
Okay, this has to be a lie from the start. Let's break this down, shall we? So as Scoops points out, Sharon called the Red Cross on Tuesday and the whimper VM came on a Wednesday. So here we are, 48 hours after the disappearance and Billy gets a whimper VM. Now are we honestly supposed to believe that call was not traced very soon after Billy got it? I get the NH LE were a bit slow here, but I do not believe call went untraced for very long. First of all, as a call to a cell phone, Sharon could have traced it almost immediately. So even if LE was not interested, then surely the Murrays and Rausches at once called the cell phone company and asked which number called, which would have been traced to the Red Cross.
So then were those media reports just some b.s. they made up? They must have put two and two together rather fast. Was this just something they put out there to keep the public interested? Well, at the very least they knew the truth many years before Renner did, and yet they never once bothered to correct it.
Me? Well, the answer seems clear to me. Whatever is going on, to them the lie about this phone call is far more beneficial than the truth. So I suppose it is not out of the question to consider what that might be. For whatever reason, the family wants it out there that Maura might very well have still been alive and in distress on Wednesday. They have known for more than ten years that the call was not from her and they never thought it prudent to clear that up. Well, I think that is odd. I am sure someone will come here and tell me I am being "judgmental" or something but that is strange to me. If my brother went missing, then I would be obsessed with making sure that only things which were factual were made public. I would never stop hoping that the facts would lead me to him. Gee, this sounds awful lot like the opposite of that; it sounds just like falsehoods leading us away from Maura.
I am still open to anything, but I the more I see things like this, the more I am convinced that the family knows where Maura is and what happened to her. They are more than welcome to publicly clear all this up at any time and prove me wrong.
SO to summarize really this whole case in a nutshell.
Either a bunch of people (interested in this case for many years) have been played -- thanks to clever spoon-fed media spin
OR
Police investigators in this case have left a whole lot to be desired in terms of their abilities to solve puzzles.
Regarding unsolved murders and missing persons cases, police in New Hampshire have historically left a whole lot to be desired. Generally, it's best not to ascribe malice where simple incompetence would suffice.