UT UT- STILL MISSING 5 -Year-Old Elizabeth Shelley , Logan, 25 May 2019 (UNCLE ARRESTED)

New Posts

Status
Not open for further replies.
otto said:
If I had to guess, I do not think he took his niece anywhere on his skateboard. I think he walked somewhere with her, and she will be at that location. He then rode his skateboard to his sister's house, and went somewhere else where he was arrested.

Why would he want to get rid of, or hide, the skateboard? Where was he hiding her clothing from the night she disappeared if he was on a skateboard? Was her clothing tucked in a pocket?
Click to expand...

The skateboard was at the sister's house the last time the sister saw Alex and Elizabeth at the sister's house.

When the sister woke up the skateboard remained but Alex and Elizabeth were gone.

Alex did not return to the sister's house. He was found the next town over, several miles away.
 
Search done until morning. They must have a confession or really strong evidence.
Another monster. Please just don't let me start hearing stories that this could have been prevented, that warning signs were there. Please dont let that be the case.
 
MsFacetious said:
The skateboard was at the sister's house the last time the sister saw Alex and Elizabeth at the sister's house.

When the sister woke up the skateboard remained but Alex and Elizabeth were gone.

Alex did not return to the sister's house. He was found the next town over, several miles away.
Click to expand...

Finally, I get it - slow thinker. Thank you

She, her daughter, her brother and his skateboard were at her house at 2AM on Saturday. She woke up at 10AM Saturday, the skateboard was there, but her daughter and brother were missing.

I'm curious what made her call the police instead of assuming they were at the park for the day. I suppose she tried to reach him and then called police.

Do you know the name of the town where he was arrested?
 
otto said:
Finally, I get it - slow thinker. Thank you

She, her daughter, her brother and his skateboard were at her house at 2AM on Saturday. She woke up at 10AM Saturday, the skateboard was there, but her daughter and brother were missing.

I'm curious what made her call the police instead of assuming they were at the park for the day. I suppose she tried to reach him and then called police.

Do you know the name of the town where he was arrested?
Click to expand...
He was arrested in Hyrum.
I'm guessing he never took his niece for days out, so she knew something was wrong straight away.
 
Looking more closely, have the house and yard been carefully searched, other areas within a short walking distance? He didn't have a car and he seems to be responsible.

upload_2019-5-25_22-38-4.png

First time murderers sometimes leave the body in the opposite direction of home. In this case, there were 8 hours for the suspect to make decisions (sometime after 2AM until 10AM). I'm curious whether a murderer on foot would also first go in one direction to hide the body, and then in the other direction to avoid detection.
 
Last edited:
kiaatcher said:
He was arrested in Hyrum.
I'm guessing he never took his niece for days out, so she knew something was wrong straight away.
Click to expand...

Right. And most people would leave a note saying we are down the street at the park. Be back for lunch.

They wouldn't just quietly leave, taking a young child, and not tell where they were going, or ask the parent.
 
otto said:
Looking more closely, have the house and yard been carefully searched, other areas within a short walking distance? He didn't have a car and he seems to be responsible.

View attachment 186079
Click to expand...

MsFacetious posted an answer:
'
Kyle Harvey‏Verified account @KyleHarveyOnTV 1m1 minute ago
.@FBI has joined search effort for missing 5yo in Logan. Search/rescue crews done until morning, but work continues searching inside the girl’s home. Her uncle will be jailed on an unrelated probation violation, but police believe he knows what happened to Elizabeth. #Utah




So they have been searching inside her home, so we can assume they are looking in the front and back yards, and the immediate neighbourhood as well. Especially since they have been using dogs.
 
otto said:
Finally, I get it - slow thinker. Thank you

She, her daughter, her brother and his skateboard were at her house at 2AM on Saturday. She woke up at 10AM Saturday, the skateboard was there, but her daughter and brother were missing.

I'm curious what made her call the police instead of assuming they were at the park for the day. I suppose she tried to reach him and then called police.

Do you know the name of the town where he was arrested?
Click to expand...
Well, if he was on probation that would indicate he's been in trouble before. Maybe that's what made her suspect him. The fact that he violated it may mean double trouble. Imo
 
Last edited:
otto said:
Looking more closely, have the house and yard been carefully searched, other areas within a short walking distance? He didn't have a car and he seems to be responsible.

View attachment 186079

First time murderers sometimes leave the body in the opposite direction of home. In this case, there were 8 hours for the suspect to make decisions (sometime after 2AM until 10AM). I'm curious whether a murderer on foot would also first go in one direction to hide the body, and then in the other direction to avoid detection.
Click to expand...

Nice to see you here Otto, the scanner thread may help, start with post 139.

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/threads/breaking-news-current-scanner-alerts-8.400672/page-7
 
otto said:
Finally, I get it - slow thinker. Thank you

She, her daughter, her brother and his skateboard were at her house at 2AM on Saturday. She woke up at 10AM Saturday, the skateboard was there, but her daughter and brother were missing.

I'm curious what made her call the police instead of assuming they were at the park for the day. I suppose she tried to reach him and then called police.

Do you know the name of the town where he was arrested?
Click to expand...
Bolding mine

It's possible the uncle had given out many warning signs before that he was a creep.
He also has a criminal record.
 
MsBetsy said:
Well, if he was on probation that would indicate he's been in trouble before. Maybe that's what made her suspect him. Imo
Click to expand...
I also think it's possible he wasn't a "child person" in the first place. He was ~16 y/o when Elizabeth was born. IMO most teenage boys could care less about being around babies vs. a teenage girl.
We also don't know what history the family knows. It's possible he's had questionable thoughts or comments about children in the past, just never acted on them until now. All MOO
 
kiaatcher said:
I also think it's possible he wasn't a "child person" in the first place. He was ~16 y/o when Elizabeth was born. IMO most teenage boys could care less about being around babies vs. a teenage girl.
We also don't know what history the family knows. It's possible he's had questionable thoughts or comments about children in the past, just never acted on them until now. All MOO
Click to expand...
Yes, whatever the case, it does not look good.
I hope she is found soon and that she is ok.
 
He wasn’t seen for a total of 13 hours. If something happened near bed time, I would assume she’s close, but with all that time possibly very well hidden? I wonder if any shovels or tools were taken in the middle of the night? How deep in soil can cadaver dogs detect?
 
In moo, I have a feeling that people won’t wait for police to find her. Most of Utah is pretty tight knit. I just hope that if people continue to search they don’t contaminate evidence that can prosecute this guy. That would be bad for all involved.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

DNASolves

Who is Escambia County John Doe (1989)?

Members online

... and 201 more.
Total: 4,467 (members: 202, guests: 4,265)

Online statistics

Members online
202
Guests online
4,265
Total visitors
4,467
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
591,752
Messages
17,958,426
Members
228,603
Latest member
megalow
Back
Top