Possibly related cases (GB4, Manorville, Bittrolff victims, & others)

[Really?]

I wonder if Bittrolf ( sp ) visited wildwood NJ memorial weekend in 1990........Susan Negersmith had no shoes and clean feet when found.....just sayin

 

[Anonymous19]

We don’t know about all the victims if they had 1 shoe or 2. That is a very specific thing I spoke to someone who understands profiling very well and he said that if bitrolf took off 1 shoe and AC took off two then it’s not the same killer. That’s very specific. But this is interesting first time iam hearing about this girl in jersy very possible, well iam glad they have DNA from the women found in 1986 it’s very similar way she was killed hopefully they will finally catch this guy, I think they know who it is thought on the LIsk Facebook there was someone who pointed out where to find lisk and it’s basically saying he has some tie to politics

 

[maddalena1]

I wonder if Bittrolf ( sp ) visited wildwood NJ memorial weekend in 1990........Susan Negersmith had no shoes and clean feet when found.....just sayin

I think bittrolf took only one shoe. However the ac4 and gilgo 4 were found with no shoes.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

 

[Anonymous19]

I think bittrolf took only one shoe. However the ac4 and gilgo 4 were found with no shoes.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

Then Bitrolf is not involved in theses killings. But he may know who is.

 

[deedee21]

Then Bitrolf is not involved in theses killings. But he may know who is.

I disagree. Serial killers dont send out memo's.

 

[hawkshaw]

I think bittrolf took only one shoe. However the ac4 and gilgo 4 were found with no shoes.

Sent from my SAMSUNG-SM-G930A using Tapatalk

I think we should be asking is exactly how were these gals killed. Was there something shoved down their throats?

 

[deedee21]

I think we should be asking is exactly how were these gals killed. Was there something shoved down their throats?

Oh my lord! Do you know something we dont?

 

[jessr927]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

 

[madamx]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

below photos are:

Eve Wilkowitz 1980

Janice Fullman 1980

Tina Foglia 1982

Kelly Morrissey 1984

Theresa Fusco 1984

 

[madamx]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

photos below

Jacqueline Martarella 1985

Patricia Costello 1986 (no photo)

Rita Tangredi 1993

Sandra Costilla 1993

Colleen Mcnamee 1994

Fire Island Jane Doe 1996

 

[madamx]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

photos below

Peaches/Doe#3 1997

Valerie Mack 2000

Jessica Taylor 2000

Andre Sugar Bear Isaac 2004

Asian Male/Doe#8 2006

 

[madamx]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

photos below

Rashawn Bazell 2005

Cherries 2007

Maureen Brainard-Barnes 2007

Tanya Rush 2008

Melissa Barthelemy 2009

 

[madamx]

A WS friend and I decided to put together a list of missing and murdered persons we think are connected in some way. We do not believe they are all the work of one person, but wanted to start this list to keep in one place as most of them have been mentioned on the forum as being possibly connected to LISK. Please share your thoughts. I am keeping a list in MS Word that I will update.

Eve Wilkowitz
Missing March 22, 1980 from Penn Station LIRR
Found March 25, 1980, Bay Shore
Strangled, bound, raped

Janice Fullam
Missing October 30, 1980 from Smithtown

Tina Foglia
Missing February 1, 1982, from Hammerheads Club, West Islip
Found February 3, 1982, Sagtikos Parkway
Asphyxiation by smothering, butchered “cleanly” in 3 bags

Kelly Morrissey
Missing June 12, 1984, from Lynbrook
(friends with Theresa Fusco, often hung out at Hot Skates)

Theresa Fusco
Missing November 10, 1984, from Lynbrook
Found December 5, 1984, wooded area between Park Place and Rocklyn Avenue, Lynbrook
(friends with Kelly Morrissey, worked at Hot Skates)
Ligature strangulation, nude, raped

Jacqueline Martarella
Missing March 26, 1985, Oceanside
Found April 22, 1985, Woodmere Country Club, Lawrence
Strangled, nude, raped

Patricia Costello
Found June 1, 1986, Heckscher State Park
Strangled, nude

Rita Tangredi
Murdered November 2 – 3, 1993
Found November 3, 1993, East Patchogue
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Sandra Costilla
Murdered November 18 – 20, 1993
Found November 20, 1993, 50 Fish Cove Road, North Sea
Beaten and strangled, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff suspected

Colleen McNamee
Missing January 5, 1994, Islandia
Found January 30, 1994, North Shirley
Beaten, strangled, nude, missing left shoe
John Bittrolff convicted

Fire Island Jane Doe/Jane Doe #7
Estimated date of death 1996
Found: Legs, April 20, 1996, Blue Point Beach, Fire Island
Skull, April 12, 2011, Ocean Parkway


Peaches/Jane Doe #3 & toddler
Estimated date of death 1997
Found: Peaches’ torso, June 8, 1997, Hempstead Lake State Park
Additional remains, April 11, 2011, Zach’s Bay, Jones Beach State Park
Toddler, April 4, 2011, east of Cedar Beach

Valerie Mack (aka Melissa Taylor)
Missing spring – summer 2000, Port Republic, NJ
Estimated date of death September 2000
Found: Torso,
November 9, 2000, Manorville
Head, hands, right foot, April 4, 2011, Manorville

Andre “Sugar Bear” Isaac
Missing shortly before Thanksgiving 2003
Found: Head, January 25, 2003, Forge River, Moriches
Partial torso, December 17, 2002, Far Rockaway
Partial remains, April 10, 2004, Moriches
Bullet to the temple

Jessica Taylor
Missing July 18 – 21, 2003, NYC
Found: Body (missing head and hands), July 26, 2003, Manorville
Skull, hands, forearm, March 29, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Asian Male/John Doe #8
Estimated date of death prior to 2006
Found April 4, 2011, Ocean Parkway

Rashawn Brazell
Missing February 14, 2005, Bushwick, Brooklyn
Found February 18, 2005, Nostrand Avenue/Fulton Street subway station, Brooklyn (head never recovered)
Arm and leg found in recycling plant in Greenpoint
Kwahuru Govan convicted

Cherries
Estimated date of death February – March 2007
Found: Torso, March 3, 2007, Harbor Island Park, Mamaroneck
Leg, March 21 – 22, 2007, Cold Spring Harbor
Leg, March 21 – 22, Cove Neck

Maureen Brainerd-Barnes
Missing July 9, 2007, NYC
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Tanya Rush
Missing June 23, 2008, Brownsville, Brooklyn
Found June 27 or 28, 2008, Bellmore

Melissa Barthelemy
Missing July 12, 2009, Unionport, the Bronx
Found December 10, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Shannan Gilbert
Missing May 1, 2010, Oak Beach
Found December 13, 2011, Oak Beach

Megan Waterman
Missing June 6, 2010, Hauppauge
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Amber Lynn Costello
Missing September 2, 2010, North Babylon
Found December 13, 2010, Gilgo Beach

Lattingtown Jane Doe
Estimated date of death prior to October 2012
Found January 21, 2013

Natasha Jugo
Missing March 16, 2003, Queens Village
Found June 24, 2013, Gilgo Beach

Photos Below

Shannan Gilbert 2010

Megan Waterman 2101

Amber Lynn Costello 2010

Lattington Jane Doe 2013

Natasha Jugo 2013

 

[marble]

Long time no post, but here's an interesting story. 42 year old man in Elizabeth NJ arrested as a serial predator of escorts, arranging for them to travel in to nyc from other places in the US and Canada, bringing them to nj, and then instead of reimbursing and paying them raping/assaulting (including choking) them. His name sounds familiar in relation to I think Shannan Gilbert when I was researching her connections, but it's an extremely common name so I could be mistaken about this being the same person. Regardless I hope they are carefully checking him against the list of victims: FBI Seeks Help Finding More Victims Of Jersey Pimp Who Beat, Raped Escorts

 

[marble]

FBI Bulletin states Jose Torres has travelled extensively throughout the country and victimized escorts for over 10 years: Seeking Victims in the Jose Ovidio Torres Investigation — FBI
More - he was known as "Joey the Player": Jose Torres aka ‘Joey the Player’: 5 Fast Facts | Heavy.com
edited to add: sex worker alert page listing phone numbers and aliases used: Joey The PLayer of NJ - Beware/ Be Aware!!!

 

[marble]

One more link about this guy- he ticks a lot of boxes. White collar job, ability to travel, and he repeatedly called and stalked women who posted legitimate job-seeking requests/resumes online in addition to assaulting escorts 848-667-1692 / 8486671692

 

[marble]

Sorry about the million posts about this guy, but the Feds DEFINITELY need to be checking his alibis for gilgo . This press release from 2015 when he was hired by his current firm says he previously worked at Centri Consulting in NYC. RRBB Accountants and Advisors Hires Jose Torres I'll give you one guess where that office is- yup 530 7th avenue. One long block from Port Authority, three short blocks from Times Square, 7 short blocks from Penn Station.

 

[coldcaser]

FBI Bulletin states Jose Torres has travelled extensively throughout the country and victimized escorts for over 10 years: Seeking Victims in the Jose Ovidio Torres Investigation — FBI
More - he was known as "Joey the Player": Jose Torres aka ‘Joey the Player’: 5 Fast Facts | Heavy.com
edited to add: sex worker alert page listing phone numbers and aliases used: Joey The PLayer of NJ - Beware/ Be Aware!!!

Oh my God, I can't believe they caught him. I've known of this guy and sex workers have been warning each other about him for a long time. He was like totally untraceable (til now of course) and always used trap phones. I can't believe I'm reading this right now, wow!

When I read girls warning each other about him, I thought to myself, "imagine if he was LISK." He does check off a lot of boxes. Promising large amounts of money really stands out to me on top of everything else. He's been victimizing people for a long time and if cops cared they'd have saved many from a lifetime of horrific trauma. However he lured women to NJ. I don't think he ever did to LI. But I know he "imported" girls from LI. I absolutely think he should be looked into for the AC4 though.

 

[coldcaser]

Now for what I actually came to this thread to ask: the AC4 were all found face down. It's never been stated what position the GB4 were found in, right?

 

[coldcaser]

Has anyone considered the Dutchess County Jane Doe could be an early victim? Almost too early for me to think so, but the dismemberment is reminiscent of Valerie Mack and Jessica Taylor.

NamUs UP 8374
The National Missing and Unidentified Persons System (NamUs)

W/F, 20-30 Y.O.
Brown hair
Head not recovered
One or more limbs not recovered

On March 20th, 1980, a nude white female aged approximately 20-30 years old was found in a travel trunk at the Hudson View Apartments in Fishkill NY. It was left there between noon and 10pm on that date. She is described as 5'4" and 5'6" on NamUs. Her shoe size was usually small at 4.5 to 5. Her bra size was 34C. She had been dismembered and was missing her hands and head.

The trunk she was found in is described on NamUs as such: "Green with black trim and blue lining. 21"wide, 37"long, and 14"deep with brass fittings. various stickers on the outside indicate the trunk travelled from NYC to France in 1958 and returned to NYC in 1960. Original ownership has been verified as June Leaf."

I'm not suggesting this is a LISK case as I don't know enough about it, but I thought it was worth bringing to everyone's attention because of the dismemberment and physical characteristics.

Here is her websleuths thread.