The man who gave her a lift, saw her on the day before.
RSBM
I haven't been following that angle of the driver, I didn't realize this, thanks. Talk about red herrings!
November 19. After staying at a friendly hostel somewhere, and a few days trekking in solitude/snowy conditions, got a lift back to her van in Benasque by a fellow hiker
*Confusion #1: who was this person, did he mean her harm, where is he now?*
November 19-21. Hanging out in Benasque.
Uploaded the last bit about her trek to SM.
*Confusion #2: was this the trek she was on when she disappeared?*
Chia/yoga sightings.
Nov 21. Got a lift from a Spanish driver to the trailhead for Port Venasque.
*Confusion #3: She was supposed to be heading to Port de la Glere per the previous reporting!...Did she tell this man the secrets of her life?*
From there, hiked up the peak of Sauveguard and returned the way she came, back to the van in Benasque. Posted photos online.
*Confusion #4: were these the photos of the day she went missing? Why are they dated November 21, when she went missing on the 22nd?*
Talked to father, partner, and did various other things to prepare for a longer hike along that route.
Nov. 22. Set off on a 3 day trek with full backpacking gear, along a circle route that would pass into France (stay at the Refuge Venasque on her first night), continue through France to a different border crossing, and then back to her camper van in Benasque.
Took a side trip to hike again to the peak of Sauveguard. Was seen (1 hour before she reached the peak) by a hiker and his companion, probably near the pass at Port de Venasque, which is about 1 hour from the peak for a fit hiker. The witnesses continued downhill back to Benasque, as they were on a day hike. Esther intended to head downhill in the opposite direction, into France.
Sent a message to her partner when she reached the peak at 4 pm.
*Confusion #4 again: are the photos online really the photos of her at the peak at 4 pm on the 22nd, or are they photos from the previous day's hike, the 21st, that she had posted to SM and sent to her partner?
Then: No witnesses, no cellphone signals, no evidence as to what happened to her after that point.
IMO, regarding the 4 confusions:
#1: the previous hiker is IMO irrelevant, she'd met him several days earlier.
#2: the post on the 19th is IMO irrelevant, this was a completely different route from the one she was on when she disappeared.
#3: what route was she on and when did she start? IMO, the trek started Nov 22, she was to return on the 25. She was on a loop into France and back into Spain, via two different mountain passes.
#4: IMO, the photos were all taken on the 21st, a day hike to the peak where she took lots of photos. I'm not sure whether she took any photos on the 22nd. Possibly she just sent Colegate a text message, but he shared the photo from the previous day so people who might have seen her would know what she looked like.