We all know what the worst case scenario is regarding what a guilty BL knows and why he refuses to talk to the police. What is the best case scenario in terms of why he will not? If he truly does not know what has happened GP, what possible scenario could have happened that he could tell his lawyer, and the lawyer tells him not to say a word? For some reason, it is precarious and unfavorable to him to simply say when he last had contact with GP, and how they left thing. Assuming he did not harm her, is there a solid reason an attorney would not have him give that info to police or parents or to slip out through third parties? Also, in FL, what does an attorney have to report to police? If BL told attorney , he harmed her, then would attorney have to report this? Or if he know she went off a cliff? Of course, attorneys tell their clients up front specifically what they have to report