This is crazy. If we assume that this Anthony_Shots creep was initially discovered via one of the girls social medias, and we have a search warrant served out of Peru Indiana (within weeks of the murder), How could this not be connected?
We do not have the details of how they came about this Anthony_Shots warrant served out of Peru. Something tells me it isn't just a coincidence, otherwise how did they happen upon the profile in the first place? Then they serve the warrant and find multiple instances of catfishing and illicit photos, and they do not make an arrest as a result of the warrant for three plus years?
I would assume if they did serve the warrant based on something they found on the one of the girls phones and they would have had evidence of the chats between the two based on the phone dumps they did on the person connected to the "Anthony_Shots" account. But taking a look at the legal documents pertaining to the Peru warrant, the information gathered was just phone dumps (some information had been deleted) and not records directly from Instagram or Snapchat. So did they have evidence on the girls phones but could not corroborate it via the phone dumps?
Or is this guy not involved with the murder at all but did catfish one of the girls? Its possible. It's crazy.