Can someone please list the defence’s witnesses who also testified in trial number one? I am going to read the transcript of their evidence from the first trial to help spot any inconsistencies in this new trial. Thanks, all.
If you are looking for inconsistencies (but include prosecution witnesses ) then have a look at the Proffer discussion of Rivera with Det Isom and I think the note taker is FBI agent Sanford (Ytube) .
Concentrate on the area from about 1:05:00 in Then get a copy of the trial transcripts or listen to Sgt . Corbitt on the digital forensics for the 17th (not much there , no numbers called no data on who called whom and for how long ... yet for the 18th there is a plethora of that data).
Another document to compare is the Warrant and probable cause document for K Magbanua. A link to one copy of that has already been posted here.
This document is a bit of a dog's breakfast in terms of time line structure and you will find two separate sections which mention events of the 17th with SG/Rivera. The data of Sgt. Corbitt is more detailed than what you will find in the Warrant.
Rivera says that Wendi saw them (SG and LR) when they has a stake out at the Markel house and consequently made a phone call . Yet the state has never offered a list of calls that WJA made from the vicinity of the Markel Residence on the 17th July 14. Given here phone was taken for forensics on camera in the famous interview with Det Isom, getting this sort of information should be a dozy . It was only 24 hrs old at that point.
This misalignment exists because -
a/ Rivera was confused or lying . Or
b/ Wendi tried to make a call but did not get through or
c/ Because the state has the record but would not release it at the first trial because they wanted to keep WJA sweet because she was an Indemnified witness. or
.. AN Other explanation (Wendi had a second unknown cell phone, for example).
The attachment is fascinating I found from the trial. Rivera has said that Sigfreido Garcia called KM after they saw WJA near Markel's residence.
The first call of the day is FROM KM to SG. It's 28 seconds long at 1:51 pm (see graphics snip attached ) . According to Corbitt , SG is in a position consistent with a cell tower near Markel's residence at 14:30. Where is he at 13:51 hours on 17th July 14 when KM calls him ? ...possibly in the same place.
LE must know what tower near SG that KM call at 13:51 was routed through. It seems that the Court is not being told the full story just snippets for events on 17th July . It also seems Rivera was lying in the Proffer when he said Garcia called KM. It happened the other way around.
The question is did someone from Tallahassee call CJA or KM to force this call to happen ?
Text version of the SG-KM call list - taken from ST exhibit 181 part only . First trial of K Magbanua Oct 2019
7/17 - no KM to SG calls before 1:51 pm that day.
7/17/14 1 :51 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls 28 seconds
7/17/14 1 :52 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls
7/17/14 6:25 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls
7/17/14 6:28 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls
7/17/14 6:33 PM Magbanua, Katherine texts
7/17/14 7:14 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls
7/17/14 7:15 PM Magbanua, Katherine calls
7/17/14 8:04 PM Garcia, Sigfredo calls