What Previously Sealed Evidence could we ask to have unsealed now, under FL's Sunshin

New Posts

Steft50 said:
Wouldn't anything to do with Casey and her attorney be considered privileged? I don't think we would have the right to see anything between the two of them. I could be wrong though.


I would also think similar would apply to any mental evaluations she had done, both the ones earlier in the case and the one during the trial. Her right to medical/mental privacy is greater than our right to know. Again, could be wrong.
Click to expand...

If I remember correctly the meetings between attorney/client in jail are video recorded but not audio recorded. I know he was warned by guards to not touch her on a few different occasions and I know he also filed a motion to not have videos of the two recorded. I could have sworn there was something brought up in court about how one of the videos looked bad for him.. but again, with so much information in the past 3 years I could be confroozzled..
 
Steft50 said:
Wouldn't anything to do with Casey and her attorney be considered privileged? I don't think we would have the right to see anything between the two of them. I could be wrong though.


I would also think similar would apply to any mental evaluations she had done, both the ones earlier in the case and the one during the trial. Her right to medical/mental privacy is greater than our right to know. Again, could be wrong.
Click to expand...

Since there is no sound we would not be privy to their conversation.
And, we did see them together when he escorted her from jail, and Jose already told us what she supposedly said to him during that walk, so if he argues attorney/client, he's kind of selective...I dunno.

I don't think this was sealed, but I would like to hear the second LE interview with Cindy, the one where she scored Casey in all things from honesty to responsible, etc...
 
I've been sitting here for days simmering now. I have thought of a million things that could and should be done. One thing I can't dismiss yet is Wendy Murphy's article re: chloroform and child *advertiser censored*. Also she states that there are sealed documents that would shock all of us.
I did dismiss her coming forward and saying KC woud be aquitted, but I went back and read her article and am trying to establish if this is a valid allegation.
Can anyone help out with this as it would be what NG calls a real BOMBSHELL !! Last but not least we all need to put out petitions to ABC news, Amazon and other media outlets that are willing to pay her or JB for anything and protest anything and everything.
Lastly I'm so angry (If you can't tell) We need to put pressure on the SA to go after CA for perjury.
Idea, responses welcomed :banghead:
 
DesSands said:
I've been sitting here for days simmering now. I have thought of a million things that could and should be done. One thing I can't dismiss yet is Wendy Murphy's article re: chloroform and child *advertiser censored*. Also she states that there are sealed documents that would shock all of us.
I did dismiss her coming forward and saying KC woud be aquitted, but I went back and read her article and am trying to establish if this is a valid allegation.
Can anyone help out with this as it would be what NG calls a real BOMBSHELL !! Last but not least we all need to put out petitions to ABC news, Amazon and other media outlets that are willing to pay her or JB for anything and protest anything and everything.
Lastly I'm so angry (If you can't tell) We need to put pressure on the SA to go after CA for perjury.
Idea, responses welcomed :banghead:
Click to expand...

do you have a link to Wendy Murphy's article?
 
windy91195 said:
do you have a link to Wendy Murphy's article?
Click to expand...

I'm so computer challenged I don't have a clue how to put a link up. But I googled Patriot Ledger and saw her article there. As I said at first I angrily dismissed her claims re: KC being aquitted, befoe she was, so angered me. But then my sister and me were talking and I decided to see what WM had to say. Go and read it and see what you think. I didn't know there were or are sealed docs re: this case and child *advertiser censored*. :waitasec:
 
concarino said:
What about the depositions prosecution took of the psychiatrists that were sealed.
Click to expand...

I would LOVE to see those. Do you have dates and names and were the drs. hired by the SA or defense? I don't know if those depos would be protected somehow by doctor/patient privilege or some other exclusion, but once you have the info, we can ask our resident attorneys. If the depos are accessible, let's add them to our list of items we want to request.
 
Steft50 said:
Wouldn't anything to do with Casey and her attorney be considered privileged? I don't think we would have the right to see anything between the two of them. I could be wrong though.


I would also think similar would apply to any mental evaluations she had done, both the ones earlier in the case and the one during the trial. Her right to medical/mental privacy is greater than our right to know. Again, could be wrong.
Click to expand...

I don't know if any jailhouse video could be sheltered under attorney-client privilege, but we can add that to our Want List and see what happens when the formal request is filed.

I have the same thought you do about the mental evaluations, and we'll ask our resident attorneys once someone finds out whether the drs. were hired by the SA or defense--in case that makes a difference in the answer. To be honest, I'm half hoping the depos can't be made available. It gives me the willies to think that we, the public, may be loosing one of our only privacy protections. OTH...if someone claims in a lawsuit for damages that their mental or physical health has been adversely affected, the opposing side would have every right to see the records for proof of the claim.

I dunno...my brain goes numb when I try to focus on explanations that contain "but if, unless, except for," which is why I could never be a lawyer. :(
 
I have been so anxious to read the text messages between KC and Tony that were going on all night from the 15th until the early morning hours of the 16th.. If they were released and I missed them, someone please point me in the right direction.

The talked about Home Depot video.. wth is that about and the video of when she heard about the remains being found.. reading about it just isn't the same as seeing it!
 
Friday said:
I don't know if any jailhouse video could be sheltered under attorney-client privilege, but we can add that to our Want List and see what happens when the formal request is filed.

I have the same thought you do about the mental evaluations, and we'll ask our resident attorneys once someone finds out whether the drs. were hired by the SA or defense--in case that makes a difference in the answer. To be honest, I'm half hoping the depos can't be made available. It gives me the willies to think that we, the public, may be loosing one of our only privacy protections. OTH...if someone claims in a lawsuit for damages that their mental or physical health has been adversely affected, the opposing side would have every right to see the records for proof of the claim.

I dunno...my brain goes numb when I try to focus on explanations that contain "but if, unless, except for," which is why I could never be a lawyer. :(
Click to expand...

BBM

IF I remember correctly, the defense had at least one mental eval done but once the prosecution found out about it they petitioned to have the states own evaluation done and the defense withdrew the motion to put the eval in the trial. Or something like that. The release dates for several of these motions are about April 8th and April 12 of this year. I view documents from one of the Orlando tv station websites but I'm not sure I'm allowed to post that. http://www.cfnews13.com/article/news/2011/march/219927/
So if I'm not its cfnews13 under the dates listed above. As usual I could be wrong and as usual if it's an opinion it's my opinion. :crazy:
 
Friday said:
I don't know if any jailhouse video could be sheltered under attorney-client privilege, but we can add that to our Want List and see what happens when the formal request is filed.

I have the same thought you do about the mental evaluations, and we'll ask our resident attorneys once someone finds out whether the drs. were hired by the SA or defense--in case that makes a difference in the answer. To be honest, I'm half hoping the depos can't be made available. It gives me the willies to think that we, the public, may be loosing one of our only privacy protections. OTH...if someone claims in a lawsuit for damages that their mental or physical health has been adversely affected, the opposing side would have every right to see the records for proof of the claim.

I dunno...my brain goes numb when I try to focus on explanations that contain "but if, unless, except for," which is why I could never be a lawyer. :(
Click to expand...

I feel the same as you about the mental evals. They may be off limits, but maybe we could get the transcript of the sidebar that was held in chambers that prompted those last three evals being done. I've always wondered why at the 13th hour they wanted evals done.
 
DesSands said:
I've been sitting here for days simmering now. I have thought of a million things that could and should be done. One thing I can't dismiss yet is Wendy Murphy's article re: chloroform and child *advertiser censored*. Also she states that there are sealed documents that would shock all of us.
I did dismiss her coming forward and saying KC woud be aquitted, but I went back and read her article and am trying to establish if this is a valid allegation.
Can anyone help out with this as it would be what NG calls a real BOMBSHELL !! Last but not least we all need to put out petitions to ABC news, Amazon and other media outlets that are willing to pay her or JB for anything and protest anything and everything.
Lastly I'm so angry (If you can't tell) We need to put pressure on the SA to go after CA for perjury.
Idea, responses welcomed :banghead:
Click to expand...

I'm still angry too, and agree 100% that CA should be arrested for all her lies on sworn depositions that were designed to mislead and obstruct justice, plus her perjured testimony during the trial, plus the wrong toothbrush, plus everything else she's done for 3 years to make sure ICA would go free.

As far as I'm concerned, Jose Baez isn't the one who accomplished ICA's acquittal, the credit for that belongs to Cindy Anthony. Furthermore, I will never be able to forget her ultra-pious reply each time the clerk swore her in. In stead of merely answering "yes" CA said, "So help me God, yes." And then she got on the stand and lied, and lied, and lied, and lied. I can't explain why, but that dramatically religious, totally deceitful performance as she raised her right hand and swore an oath makes me crazy when I think about it.

I am not the sort of outwardly religious person who quotes the bible to help make a point, and I don't refer to "the Lord" or "Satan" in regular conversation, either. But when the jury's verdict was read, I realized that Cindy, George, and Lee had managed to spit in the face of LE for 3 years without punishment, and now they'd just managed to accomplish the seemingly impossible--They'd outwitted and thwarted the justice system enough to enable JB to get Casey off, scot free.

I stared at the television set in furious disbelief, watching the Anthonys duck out of court while Casey celebrated getting away with murder, and all I could think was, "I can't believe it! How could this have happened? How could this have happened?"

A long-forgotten, old-fashioned, and seemingly nonsensical religious belief of my great-grandmother's occurred to me for the first time in decades, and I wondered if maybe she'd been right after all. I gave that possibility a little thought and then rejected it because I prefer not to believe such things. Nevertheless, her words still run through my mind fairly often these days, like when Casey's dazzling financial future is discussed or when I realize how much she's going to love her celebrity status.... "The devil takes care of his own."
 
Maia said:
I feel the same as you about the mental evals. They may be off limits, but maybe we could get the transcript of the sidebar that was held in chambers that prompted those last three evals being done. I've always wondered why at the 13th hour they wanted evals done.
Click to expand...

I'd like to see that sidebar transcript, too.
 
IIRC wasn't there also another jailhouse visit we never got to see?
 
IfIMay said:
The photos that LE said George wouldn't like that would paint his daughter in a not so nice way...
Click to expand...


Yup, we still don't know the extent of what was included in these pics.
There was some sleuthing going on after that interview video was released, and some people did supposedly find some on the net.

LE was warning George that if they (LE) had/found them, that someone else had surely had them, and they could surface.

Wonder if those pics are tied in, in any way with what Wendy Murphy is referring to, or what she is referring to are other pics.


:dunno:
 
Sidebar transcripts, vids, pictures, all the things that were withheld that could be deemed "predjudicial" toward ICA. Unseal all sealed documents that the state of Florida had which would show the real ICA.
 
I can't sleep and have the trial running through my mind as usual when I suddenly remembered KC's diary. I can't remember if it was ruled inadmissable or what....I REALLY would like to know if we have seen everything in that diary. I may be way off on this one ....just a thought.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

DNASolves

Who is Escambia County John Doe (1989)?

Staff online

Members online

... and 201 more.
Total: 3,813 (members: 202, guests: 3,611)

Online statistics

Members online
202
Guests online
3,611
Total visitors
3,813
Totals may include hidden visitors.

Forum statistics

Threads
591,825
Messages
17,959,626
Members
228,621
Latest member
MaryEllen77
Back
Top