Recent content by intothenight

If the theory that the perp(s) were known to Suzie and/or Sherrill, I think it’s likely there would have been some altercation outside the house first. All it takes is the threat of violence to the other to make both women compliant. One of them may have screamed out for Stacy, still inside the...

I think Nigel's account of how Suzie "normally" parked her car has caused a little confusion since she brought it up on the Crime Watch Daily episode. It isn't anywhere to be seen here, but I don't know if it's public knowledge when she got her license or the car, but you can see the Sherrill's...

The more recent media coverage of this case (CWD, People Magazine) was really poorly done. I wish we could get a comprehensive documentary that ties together everything that is known so far and doesn't just cling to the usual narratives they use when covering this case. These women and their...

Makes me wonder if Garrison's connection to this case isn't the initial removal from Sherrill's home, but at a second crime scene.

I think Garrison knows something about what went down, whether it's through firsthand knowledge or not. Seems like whatever he provided wasn't enough of a smoking gun to directly link him, though. To clarify, the search that resulted in the gag order was of the Robb property/farmland, right? I...

I didn't know that about these photos. It makes me wonder how much had been removed for processing when they were taken, especially bearing in mind that the 48 hours episode was being filmed while the cars were still parked out on the driveway.

Going through the images in the other thread, I noticed Sherrill's bed seems to be missing a pillow here. Did she move to Suzie's room due to the fumes?

It's why I tend to believe the way the house was found was pretty much how it looked when they were removed from it. Given the timeframe provided from when the girls left the graduation parties and when the sun rose that morning, I think it would have been incredibly risky to spend additional...

I think that’s why I’m glad Sherrill’s sister has been interviewed more recently. The way the media portrayed Suzie and Sherrill was likely another factor in preventing this case from moving forward, and it’s almost as if we’re meant to believe they were somehow to blame for what happened to them.

I think the families have done all they can, really. Solving this case comes down to a confession, there’s nothing else concrete to go on. If it was the work of a lone perpetrator, he might even be dead by now. Of course, recovering bodies would bring some closure for their loved ones.. but even...

I've always been curious to what degree people think the house was staged - because aside from the lack of DNA recovered, there's really not much that was (seemingly) done to cover up the abduction. My point being that staging of a crime scene is usually done in a way that's beneficial to the...

So Sherrill knew of Carnahan? The idea of them dating never really made sense. Carnahan was born '58/59, Sherrill in '44 - doesn't make it impossible, but quite unlikely.

Now based off of your opinion, how long do you think it’s likely Sherrill and/or Suzie had held that information?

The last confirmed activity of Sherrill was the phone call with a friend late on the 6th, right? I thought about these calls that came into the house the following day - and whether they had received similar ones prior to the abduction, particularly that night. I tend to lean towards the belief...

They only showed this one unfortunately.