This guy was clearly mentally ill. He reached out to the FBI because of his paranoia, said Miami capital-litigation lawyer Terry Lenamon, who is not involved in the case. There will be a lot of mitigation to work with.
Kaiser, the former federal prosecutor who was involved as a defense attorney in the 2007 Joe Cool case, agreed with him.
Its a tough death case. Once you start peeling back the onion, you never know what youre going to find.
Allan Kaiser, Miami defense attorney and former federal prosecutor
Its a tough death case, Kaiser said, citing Santiagos mental health problems, his approaching the FBI and his recovering the firearm from police. Once you start peeling back the onion, you never know what youre going to find.
Miami defense attorney Bruce Fleisher, who has been involved in more than 80 capital and homicide cases, said no one should jump to conclusions about Santiagos state of mind based soley on his cold, calculating demeanor shown on an airport surveillance video of the shooting.
Fleisher said Santiagos defense team including the federal public defenders office assigned to represent him this week will have to conduct a complete historical, medical and psychiatric evaluation to assess his profile and gauge what made him snap.
I dont think anyone can offer their opinion until they do their due dilligence, Fleisher said. Its the ultimate due dilligence to investigate every aspect of your clients life. ... Does he have a viable insanity defense?