I have two plausible theories on this:
Peep grabs Jayme and holds gun to her head to ensure she shuts up. He knows cops coming. So what does he do? He drags her outside under the front porch he knows it’s dark. Cops prob can’t see under the porch without specifically shining light there. But cops aren’t thinking anyone will be hiding there as they see the front door and dead man first so they focus on that. Cops enter residence and he flees with her before more cops arrive. We assume in a car. But what about if they ran? We have no idea what mode of transport they used to get away.
Theory two:
They exit and hide in the woods for some time then proceed out of area when possible. Maybe a back door exit? Into the woods? Into a car parked back there?
While your theory’s are good, and possible, there’s one big loose end.
The dog was Jaymes and if I know dogs and I do, it would be going crazy and following her scent. Especially since a dog has the ability to sense the “fight or flee” hormones adrenaline we emit when upset. I’m wondering if the dog was isolated and perhaps LE didn’t listen to it when they arrived.
I understand the dog would be upset regardless, but it’s still possible since Jayme and the dog were so close that the dog would have pursued her first.
And the other odd thing is the rumor or fact that the father was able to answer the door.
I know adrenaline can cause a last minute show of strength, but is it likely?
LE seems to believe Jayme was alive and was abducted from the House. Did the father tell them that as a dying utterance? Do not know for certain.
Is that the reason the police log was changed from a suicide call to a double homicide a time later? Don’t know
Usually if LE and EMTs arrive and find someone alive skills and medical tech can save lives.
When did EMTs arrive and was Mr. Closs dead at that time, did he die enroute
or at the hospital?
Was he the source of info that Jayme was alive when she was taken?
Where was the dog found?
What did the 911 operator hear on the recorded open call from the mother’s cell phone?
Did Jayme have a boyfriend?
There have been several references to a caregiver and the dog being a service animal. 13-15 is the age I began to trust a child to spend time alone at home.
Was Jayme home alone after school?
Did her parents arrive minutes later with a stranger having entered moments before?
Was one parent home with Jayme and the other areived home a few minutes earlier.
Jayme recently turned 13. That tween stage when daughters sometimes go a bit sideways due to adolescence, horror mones ( my name in dubious honor to my own daughter) and just simply transitioning into lovely young woman. Was Jayme at this stage?
Did Jayme have a developmental issue? An issue if any kind?
Where had the Closs family visited in the days prior to this incident? Is there any cctv coverage to see if anyone was following them or simply watching the Closs family?
Barron is another small town similar to Brooklyn Iowa where Mollie Tibbetts lived.
Are there cameras at the Closs’ place of employment that might shed light on working relationships or any workplace issues?
I would assume one if the very first interviews to occur would have been friends, acquaintances, teachers, and coaches-workers co workers and local registered sex offenders of each family member.
Is it pertinent that Jayme is a beautiful young lady with unique features such as green eyes and strawberry blonde hair?
Were school or dance pictures recently taken and if so the photographer questioned. This would be a very good method to find and target young women with unusual attributes such as strawberry blonde hair and green eyes.
In addition I would assume the people in the police log would also have been questioned. (who were asked to move on after LE observed them repeatedly driving in front of the residence when first responders arrived in response to the 911 call)
I would assume that presently, every cctv, camera and dash cam would have been turned over to identify activity if anyone.
If the casino is close, there may be a goldmine of info in their security system. Especially if the perpetrator needed a place to stay prior to the murders.
Have the cell towers been able to produce every phone in range during the few hours leading up to this incident?