DNA Solves Cold Cases/Parabon Nanolabs & GED/Match.

Cold Case Arrest 25 Years Later: Riverside County Serial Rapist

After extradition from Arizona, Darin Edward Cooke, 50, has been charged by the Riverside County DA's office with 16 felony counts.

Cold Case Arrest 25 Years Later: Riverside County Serial Rapist

"A serial rapist who terrorized his female victims and eluded capture for nearly 25 years in Riverside County has been arrested in Arizona after DNA helped crack the case...

A resident of Chino Valley, Arizona, Cooke was arrested May 26 in nearby Prescott. He had been living in Arizona for several years, the DA's office said.

Cooke is accused of committing the crimes between 1996 and 1998 in Riverside, and in Corona during 2007, and it wasn't until years later that the case began really coming together with the help of DNA.

With help from the FBI Los Angeles Forensic Genetic Genealogy Team, Cooke became a suspect. A surveillance of his Arizona home got underway — investigators collected trash bags from the residence, which were then examined for DNA.

A match was made.

Some of the victims resided in the same Riverside apartment complex — now known as Corona Pointe — where Cooke once lived, according to the DA's office.

The arrest was a combined effort involving the Corona and Riverside police departments, the Yavapai County (Arizona) Sheriff's Office, and the FBI Phoenix Violent Crimes Task Force which is made up of the Phoenix, Peoria, and Scottsdale police departments; the Maricopa County Sheriff's Office; the Maricopa County District Attorney's Office; and the FBI."



Who knows how many more victims there are out there. Every time I see news like this I look up the rape kit backlog in the reported state. Neighboring Orange County, CA just approved a contract to have a private lab test the majority of their untested rape kits. Unfortunately no one knows how many untested rape kits there really are in all of California.

From Feb 2020:

O.C. moves to clear backlog of unprocessed rape kits

"The Orange County Board of Supervisors this week took a step toward processing the county’s substantial backlog of rape kits when it approved a $612,000 contract with a third-party forensics tester.

Virginia-based Bode Technology will test 1,500 of the county’s 1,700 untested rape kits. The O.C. Crime Lab will test the remaining kits.

The county’s rape kit backlog has been accumulating for decades, a problem plaguing the entire state. No reliable estimate exists for the number of backlogged rape kits in California."
 
Another high-profile Doe case has been solved!
Precious Jane Doe, a.k.a. Snohomish Jane Doe, has been identified as Elizabeth ("Lisa") Ann Roberts.

Teen girl, 'Precious Jane Doe,' ID'd 43 years after her murder in Snohomish Co.

bbm
.
Successful identification of Lisa was established using SNP DNA and Investigative Genetic Genealogy. The DNA used for the identification was obtained from Lisa’s hair using a new scientific technique developed by Dr. Ed Green, a scientist of ancient DNA and paleogenomics. This new technique, previously thought to be impossible, enables DNA-based forensics from rootless hair and other difficult sources.

Through Investigative Genetic Genealogy in the hands of Dr. Barbara Rae-Venter and her Firebird Forensic Group and using public genetic genealogy websites, they were able to build a family tree to identify the biological parents. Further investigation found a biological half-brother, whose DNA was used to verify he matched to Lisa’s maternal DNA profile. Adoption records were then obtained from the Oregon Health Authority. Based on all this new information, Snohomish County Chief Medical Examiner, Dr. Matt Lacy established the positive identification of Elizabeth Ann Roberts. “We are grateful to Dr. Barbara Rae-Venter and her Firebird Forensics Group for the effort and hundreds of hours that they donated solving this case for us. Lisa would not be identified today if not for the work they did,” said Dr. Lacy.


Sources:

DNA used to identify 1977 Everett murder victim

Cold case closed: Everett murder victim ‘Jane Doe’ identified 43 years later

Detectives identify victim of 1977 murder in Everett

Solved: For 43 years, she was ‘Precious’ Jane Doe | HeraldNet.com


Lisa's WS thread:
Identified! - WA - Snohomish Co., WhtFem 516UFWA, 15-22, hitchhiker, 5'10" tall, Aug'77 Lisa Roberts
 
1982 murder of 8-year-old Kelly Ann Prosser solved

WS thread:
OH - OH - Kelly Prosser, 8, Columbus, 20 Sept 1982



Nearly 40-year-old cold case solved through DNA, genealogy & Columbus police work

"Her murder went unsolved for nearly 40 years, until now. 8-year-old Kelly Ann Prosser was kidnapped as she walked home from school in September 1982.

Her body was discovered two days later in a Plain City cornfield. Police say she had been sexually assaulted and beaten.

A breakthrough came in March when police tracked down her killer through DNA and genealogy.

Cold case homicide detectives devoted thousands of hours to solving the case they say with Kelly Ann's mother right there every step of the way.

"Kelly's mom has stayed a very close part of this investigation. The entire time, every detective who's worked on this case received cards, letters and notes from her that always contained pictures of Kelly," said Sgt. Terry McConnell with the CPD Cold Case Unit.

The letters motivated detectives to never give up on the case.

"There's a lot of law enforcement officers current and past that never forgot about this case," said Columbus Police Deputy Chief Tim Becker.

Columbus police praised genetic genealogists for the work they did in linking Harold Warren Jarrell to the brutal 1982 killing.

Jarrell has since died.

Police say he came to Columbus by way of West Virginia and worked at a local radio station as well as some odd jobs.

Police say he had been released from prison from a child abduction conviction just months before Kelly Ann's disappearance.

She had been walking home from Indianola elementary school when she was kidnapped.

Her body was found two days later.

Columbus police say a family tree was built through a partnership with Advanced DNA that led them to a name they could use to go back through the case file. Detectives found several of Jarrell's living relatives and got DNA that confirmed a link.

"The best part of all of it, once we learned that information being able to go and speak with Kelly's mother and her sister and let them at least know what had happened. It was unfortunate we were unable to bring him to justice but giving them that answer," said Sgt. McConnell.

It brought closure to one of CPD's most intense investigations.

"Without the work of the genealogist, Mr. Jarrell may not have been linked to this case," said Columbus Police Deputy Chief Greg Bodker.

Prosser's family released a statement thanking the detectives for never giving up. They say this does not bring closure, but they've arrived at one long-awaited moment of knowing who murdered Kelly Ann."
 
Just posting for info, a long detailed article from the BBC about the truly tortuous (in every sense) twists and turns of the brutal murder of Angie Dodge in Idaho Falls in 1996 ID - Angie Dodge, 18, brutally murdered at home, Idaho Falls, 13 June 1996 *Arrest in 2019*

It goes into detail about the wrongful conviction (terrifying), the tireless work of Angie's mother to find the truth and the difficulties that CeCe Moore came across in tracing the murderer owing to a complicated family history. It brought home to me ( ex library assistant ) the importance of traditional resources and record-keeping in this work as the breakthrough came from a small library in Missouri.

Also another example of where, frustratingly, the real killer featured in the early days of the investigation but the police chose to pursue and basically "fit up" someone else. Well worth reading.
 
This is a strange one, in 1999 a police detective and his wife ambushed and killed a store owner and tied up the store owner's wife, stealing $30,000. Unsolved until now.
_______________

After an investigation spanning more than two decades, Jacksonville police have announced the arrest of a retired Jacksonville detective and his then-wife in the murder of a business owner.

Saad Kawaf was stabbed to death in his garage at his Deerwood home in 1999. Undersheriff Pat Ivey said two DNA profiles were developed in 2003. In May, through genetic testing, police were able to get two profiles.

Based on those profiles, Ivey said, William Robert Baer Jr., 64, who is a retired JSO officer, was arrested in Jacksonville on Wednesday. Ivey said Melissa Schafer, 50, who was Baer’s then-wife, was arrested in Jefferson City, Missouri.

[...]

Baer was with the Sheriff’s Office for 27 years, joining in 1975 and retiring in 2002. At the time of the murder, Baer was actively investigating Kawaf for an unspecified crime, according to police.

Baer had been an intelligence division detective at the time of the attack, and Ivey said Baer met the victim, a convenience store owner, through work.

Retired Jacksonville detective, ex-wife arrested in 1999 cold case murder
 
Baer was with the Sheriff’s Office for 27 years, joining in 1975 and retiring in 2002. At the time of the murder, Baer was actively investigating Kawaf for an unspecified crime, according to police.

Baer had been an intelligence division detective at the time of the attack, and Ivey said Baer met the victim, a convenience store owner, through work.

Wow. Glad they finally caught him and his ex-wife!
Given that Baer is reported to have been an "intelligence division detective" and that he met Kawaf, the victim, through work, wonder if Kawaf was an informant. Hope local media investigates this further, this guy's whole career should be under review.
 
This is a strange one, in 1999 a police detective and his wife ambushed and killed a store owner and tied up the store owner's wife, stealing $30,000. Unsolved until now.
_______________

After an investigation spanning more than two decades, Jacksonville police have announced the arrest of a retired Jacksonville detective and his then-wife in the murder of a business owner.

Saad Kawaf was stabbed to death in his garage at his Deerwood home in 1999. Undersheriff Pat Ivey said two DNA profiles were developed in 2003. In May, through genetic testing, police were able to get two profiles.

Based on those profiles, Ivey said, William Robert Baer Jr., 64, who is a retired JSO officer, was arrested in Jacksonville on Wednesday. Ivey said Melissa Schafer, 50, who was Baer’s then-wife, was arrested in Jefferson City, Missouri.

[...]

Baer was with the Sheriff’s Office for 27 years, joining in 1975 and retiring in 2002. At the time of the murder, Baer was actively investigating Kawaf for an unspecified crime, according to police.

Baer had been an intelligence division detective at the time of the attack, and Ivey said Baer met the victim, a convenience store owner, through work.

Retired Jacksonville detective, ex-wife arrested in 1999 cold case murder
My youngests father in law is a Jax chaplain. This is scary.
 
Wow. Glad they finally caught him and his ex-wife!
Given that Baer is reported to have been an "intelligence division detective" and that he met Kawaf, the victim, through work, wonder if Kawaf was an informant. Hope local media investigates this further, this guy's whole career should be under review.
BBM. Seems like local media are looking into this. Baer testified against another JSO officer in a very similar murder. I've started a thread:

FL - Saad Kawaf, 39, Deerwood, Jacksonville, May 1999 *DNA Arrest in 2020*
 
This one seems solvable:
_____

KANSAS CITY, MO (KCTV) -- Fawn Cox was raped and murdered in 1989. She was just 16 years old.

No advanced testing or genetic tracing for suspects has taken place on the DNA left behind. Investigators say KCPD doesn’t have the right equipment or funding for DNA testing.

The family has offered to pay for the testing by raising community funds- a move that other families have done across the nation-- but that’s not allowed by KCPD. So, the money which could pay for the test just sits.

The department maintains that there needs to be an overall program to fund all genetic genealogy testing and not just fund one case for answers.

“It’s so hard. I understand the family, you know, ‘I want to get this moving.’ But from a police department perspective, we treat every case the same,” said Chief Rick Smith.

[...]

“We need to see this solved. And money is their excuse? I don’t understand it. It’s just sitting there. And now there this all this advancement in technology. Why have they not taken care of that?” Felisa Cox said.

Recently, an outside non-profit group tried to step in and help with testing. But the department turned down that offer too.

“It is frustrating. I’m not bashing law enforcement either. I work in law enforcement and have been for 21 years, I get both sides. But this is such a solvable case! I cannot understand what the holdup is.” Della Williams said.

Kansas City family questions lack of advanced DNA testing in cold case

Fawn's thread:
MO - MO - Fawn Cox, 16, Kansas City, 26 July 1989
 
State College police have arrested a Port Matilda man they say is responsible for the serial rapes of four Penn State students between 2010 and 2017.

Jeffrey P. Fields, 36, was taken into custody Tuesday on 16 felony charges, including multiple counts of rape and sexual assault. He was arraigned by District Judge Don Hahn, who denied bail.

...

In 2018, DNA samples were sent to private labs for genetic genealogy screening, with the profile being loaded into genealogical databases.

Through forensic genetic genealogical work, police developed the suspect’s family tree which “was identified as having a high likelihood of including” Fields, according to the affidavit.

State College, PA - Port Matilda Man Arrested for Alleged Serial Rapes of Four Penn State Students -
 
The oldest Jane Doe homicide case in Orange County has been solved! Huntington Beach Jane Doe'68 has been identified through genealogy as Anita Louise Piteau.

Seems like they even know who killed her as well:
The woman was identified as Anita Louise Piteau, whose family tree runs through Augusta and Lewiston, Maine. Police on Wednesday, July 22 said they believe she was killed by a man named Johnny Chrisco, who died at age 71 in 2015. Very little is known about him, said Huntington Beach Police Department public information officer Angela Bennett.

Additional sources:

Huntington Beach police identify oldest Jane Doe in Orange County

Huntington Beach police identify oldest Jane Doe in Orange County – Daily Breeze

Huntington Beach police identify oldest Jane Doe in Orange County – Orange County Register


Anita's WS thread:
Identified! - CA - Huntington Beach, WhtFem 457UFCA, 25-30, in field, Mar'68 - Anita Louise Piteau
 
Last edited:
NORTHFIELD, Vt. — Detectives with the Vermont State Police are hoping an emerging investigative technique involving DNA will help shed light on the unsolved 1982 killing of an infant in Northfield.

Baby Boy Doe was found dead April 1, 1982, on the side of Mill Hill Road in Northfield, wrapped in a brown bath towel inside a sealed plastic garbage bag. Evidence indicated the boy had been carried full term and born healthy only hours earlier, likely nearby. His death is attributed to exposure to the elements. The identity of his parents remains unknown.

[...]

“Baby Boy Doe left us with an important clue about what might have happened to him: his DNA,” said Capt. Scott Dunlap, who oversees the Cold Case Unit as commander of the Major Crime Unit. “In the nearly 40 years since his death, technology has caught up with the evidence, allowing us to move forward in a way that was never possible before.”

The Vermont State Police has partnered with Parabon Nanolabs, based in Reston, Virginia, to conduct the genetic genealogy testing — a procedure that comes with a roughly $5,000 price tag. Parabon has launched a “Justice Drive” to raise money to cover their costs.

VSP focuses on new DNA technology in unsolved 1982 homicide of infant

WS thread:
VT - VT - Baby Boy, Northfield, 1 April 1982
 
Cece Moore posted about an announcement today

CeCe Moore - Genetic Genealogist

WHAT: News conference to announce a break in a 1993 Homicide Cold Case
WHEN: July 29, 2020 at 11 a.m.
WHERE: Snohomish County Courthouse, Kinard Room, 4th Floor, 3000 Rockefeller Ave, Everett, WA (USA). A livestream will be available at www.facebook.com/SnoCoSheriff
Thanks for the heads up. This is the only cold case I've found so far for 1993 in Snohomish Co.:

Melissa Ann Lee spoke with her mother on the phone the night she disappeared.

She was at home. Three hours later, when her mom returned from work, the 15-year-old girl was gone.

The front door was open. There were signs of a struggle inside the Bothell house.

The next day a couple spotted Melissa’s body in a brushy ravine under the Edgewater Creek Bridge near Mukilteo.

She was strangled to death.

The killer has never been arrested.


‘93 slaying hangs over mother’s life | HeraldNet.com
 
Thanks for the heads up. This is the only cold case I've found so far for 1993 in Snohomish Co.:

Melissa Ann Lee spoke with her mother on the phone the night she disappeared.

She was at home. Three hours later, when her mom returned from work, the 15-year-old girl was gone.

The front door was open. There were signs of a struggle inside the Bothell house.

The next day a couple spotted Melissa’s body in a brushy ravine under the Edgewater Creek Bridge near Mukilteo.

She was strangled to death.

The killer has never been arrested.


‘93 slaying hangs over mother’s life | HeraldNet.com

Maybe this is the one!
 
BREAKING: Suspect Arrested in 1993 Homicide Cold Case
SNOHOMISH COUNTY, Wash. – Detectives from the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office Major Crimes Unit arrested a 62 year-old Bothell (Washington) man for the April 1993 murder of 15 year-old Melissa Lee. Alan Edward Dean was taken into custody without incident at 5 p.m., Tuesday, July 28, 2020, near his residence in Bothell. He has been booked into the Snohomish County Jail on one count of 1st degree murder and one count of 1st degree kidnapping for the 1993 kidnapping and killing of 15 year-old Melissa Lee. Detectives continue to gather and process evidence and interview witnesses related to the investigation of Lee’s murder.
Because of this arrest, detectives are asking for people to come forward with information, specifically anyone who:
• Currently knows Dean, previously knew Dean or knew of his activities in or around 1993 (he would have been 35 years-old at the time of the murder);
• Recognizes Dean from the attached photo of him around the time of the killing in 1993 and/or from the more recent photo of him;
• Dated, communicated with, or has any information regarding Dean around 1993 using a night talk line (he used a fake name of Mike or Michael);
• Has information regarding Dean having access to Ethyl Ether and Heptane chemicals around the time the crimes were committed.
Detectives confirmed Dean was living on Madison Street in Everett in 1993; his residence was approximately 3.6 miles from where Lee’s body was found. He worked dayshift at Boeing in Everett prior to the killing.
“We never gave up hope that we would find Melissa’s killer,” said Snohomish County Sheriff Adam Fortney. “The arrest yesterday shows how our detective’s determination, combined with new advancements in DNA technology, continues to get us one step closer to justice for victims and their families, even decades later. We are also extremely thankful for the support and expertise from our partners at Parabon.”
Dean was identified as a suspect through the use of genetic genealogy, which is the use of DNA testing in combination with traditional genealogical methods to establish the relationship between an individual and their ancestors.
Successful identification of Dean was established with assistance from Parabon NanoLabs (Parabon), a DNA technology company in Virginia that performed genetic genealogy analysis for the case. A digital file containing DNA genotype data derived from evidence at the crime scene was uploaded to a public genetic genealogy website, and promising matches were found for multiple of the suspect’s relatives. After Parabon’s genealogists deduced Dean’s identity, detectives subsequently acquired an abandoned DNA sample from a cigarette butt he had used. Washington State Patrol’s crime lab confirmed that it positively matched the DNA profile from the crime scene evidence.
This is the third arrest of a murder suspect in Snohomish County that involved assistance from Parabon.
If you or anyone you know has information related to this case or suspect, please call the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office tip line 425-388-3845.
###
Case background
On the evening of April 13, 1993, 15 year-old Melissa Lee was home alone at her residence on Filbert Road in Bothell. Lee was planning to have a girlfriend come stay the night at her house, however she never made it. Lee spoke with her mother on their home landline phone around 9:30 p.m. When Lee’s mother arrived home after midnight, she discovered the front door ajar and signs of a struggle inside: the living room coffee table askew, an ashtray upside down on the floor, a glass of milk spilled on the floor and 15 year-old Lee was not home. Her mother reported her missing to the Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office on April 14, 1993.
On the evening of April 14, 1993, Melissa Lee’s body was found in a ravine on the north side of the Edgewater Creek Bridge in the 3800 block of Mukilteo Boulevard located in the city of Everett. The following day, an autopsy was completed by the Snohomish County Chief Medical Examiner. The autopsy determined Lee’s death was attributed to asphyxia due to manual strangulation and was classified as a homicide. A toxicology report did not detect any drugs or alcohol in Lee’s system; however, Ethyl Ether and Heptane chemicals were detected in Lee’s system.
In 1993, detectives interviewed Alan Dean three times after finding notes in Melissa Lee’s address book with a phone number for someone named “Michael”. The male was identified as Alan E. Dean and told detectives he used the name “Mike” when he met Lee through a night talk line and dated her twice in March of 1993.
Captions for attached photos:
Melissa Lee
A resident of Bothell, Wash., she was 15 year-old at the time of her death. Her body was found in the city of Everett in Snohomish County (Washington State) in a ravine on the north side of the Edgewater Creek Bridge on 04/14/1993.
Melissa Lee Cold Case Playing Card
This is Melissa Lee’s cold case playing card. The Snohomish County Sheriff’s Office Cold Case Unit created a deck of playing cards, the first in Washington State, and distributes them to inmates, offering a reward for information leading to an arrest and conviction.
Alan Edward Dean 1993
A photo of the suspect, Alan Edward Dean, around the time of the killing in 1993. He was 35 years-old, a resident of Everett, Wash., and worked dayshift at Boeing in Everett prior to the killing.
Alan Edward Dean
A more recent photo of the suspect, 62 year-old Alan Edward Dean, now a resident of Bothell.









116116
18 comments
36 shares
Like
Comment
Share
Log In or Sign Up to View
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
101
Guests online
3,458
Total visitors
3,559

Forum statistics

Threads
591,886
Messages
17,960,322
Members
228,625
Latest member
julandken
Back
Top