Shannan Gilbert Found, death declared an accident. What do you think?

[Peter Brendt]

The point i rather, is there a connection between SG and the GB4? As of yet, the only obvious connection is the vicinity and I don't trust that one because I have seen bad things happening twice and even trice in one area.

Peter

 

[BKS]

Looking back over SG's case it is clear to me that we are missing some important answers from MP.

Seaslug44 I could not agree with you more. The conversations that took place between MP and SG are extremely pertinent, and as far as I know MP has never discussed them or their contents. Starting at 2:57 AM SG spent nine minutes speaking to MP.

The topics could have been
- The number of people in JB's house and their actions and behavior
- Payment or lack of it, from JB
- SG being uncomfortable with something she heard, saw or was asked or told.
- A call for help to MP, to which he does not respond.

For somebody portraying themselves as a 'good-guy' MP has a lot of explaining to do.

MOO

MP is one of the reasons they couldn't find Shannon to help her. If he wanted to help he would have stayed.

 

[Seaslug44]

Hi Seaslug!

How reliable is this information? When I follow the link, I come to JusticeForShannanGilbert.wordpress.com and there I find some of the entries from you post. But when I follow from there the link http://www.findshannangilbert.com/inside-the-investigation-part-1/
which appears to be the source, they got the records from, I end up on some defunct site.
So now it appears as if those records come out of the blue, but at some time, this findshannangilbert-site was active. Did you copy from there (because the justice site has less records than you have in your post above?)

Peter

These are the phone records that were published in Newsday as supplied by the family. I have always expressed some concern about them because they appeared to be typed by a family member. One mistake we noticed last year was calling the CVS "Oak Beach CVS".

 

[Peter Brendt]

These are the phone records that were published in Newsday as supplied by the family. I have always expressed some concern about them because they appeared to be typed by a family member. One mistake we noticed last year was calling the CVS "Oak Beach CVS".

Oh, I remember some posts from back then, but the original article disappeared in the meantime. Thanks for clearing that up.
Did they ever figure out, which CVS it was? None in OB, I assume.
About the rest, I'm not so sure. I have seen borderline patients call people all few minutes right at the end of a high-spirit phase. But as it looks, MP called also back, so there was at least some substance in those calls.

Peter

 

[BKS]

Oh, I remember some posts from back then, but the original article disappeared in the meantime. Thanks for clearing that up.
Did they ever figure out, which CVS it was? None in OB, I assume.
About the rest, I'm not so sure. I have seen borderline patients call people all few minutes right at the end of a high-spirit phase. But as it looks, MP called also back, so there was at least some substance in those calls.

Peter

With all the arrests at the CVS Pharmacy stores recently, how do those locations correspond to the victims?

 

[dcgrumpy]

Oh, I remember some posts from back then, but the original article disappeared in the meantime. Thanks for clearing that up.
Did they ever figure out, which CVS it was? None in OB, I assume.
About the rest, I'm not so sure. I have seen borderline patients call people all few minutes right at the end of a high-spirit phase. But as it looks, MP called also back, so there was at least some substance in those calls.

Peter

It was the CVS in West Islip. It is the closest to OB, but it would never be referred to ad ON CVS.

 

[BKS]

It was the CVS in West Islip. It is the closest to OB, but it would never be referred to ad ON CVS.

Was that one of CVS stores recently in the paper with all of the drug arrests?

 

[dcgrumpy]

Was that one of CVS stores recently in the paper with all of the drug arrests?

Not that I'm aware of, but I'm not familiar with the story.

 

[BKS]

Not that I'm aware of, but I'm not familiar with the story.

Interesting that it is the CVS stores

 

[dcgrumpy]

Interesting that it is the CVS stores

Do you have a link to the story you are referring to? There are dozens of CVS stores on LI.

 

[Peter Brendt]

With all the arrests at the CVS Pharmacy stores recently, how do those locations correspond to the victims?

I don't know, that is why I asked you ...

Peter

 

[BKS]

Do you have a link to the story you are referring to? There are dozens of CVS stores on LI.

This is a link to recent arrests at the Hicksville CVS which is approx. 15 minutes from the CVS store that Shannon called the night she disappeared. There were 17 arrests.
http://www.nassaupba.org/public/resources/prescription-drug-arrests.shtml

 

[svpernin]

Here we go...

http://www.newsday.com/long-island/suffolk/shannan-gilbert-s-family-meeting-with-m-e-1.3692324?p=

Two years to the day after the disappearance of Shannan Gilbert, her family is meeting with the Suffolk County medical examiner Tuesday, a family attorney said.

The meeting is scheduled to take place in Hauppauge at 1 p.m.

 

[MrsPC]

from Newsday police & crime reporter tweets:

http://twitter.com/#!/taniaelopez/status/197366283560431617/photo/1

http://twitter.com/#!/taniaelopez/status/197367293582381057/photo/1

"they are supposed to tell us the results"

 

[svpernin]

I truly hope the Gilbert's get some REAL answers today.

 

[truthspider]

anybody want to make a prediction on what the ME will say?

I'm going with some type of injury to head and water in lungs (or strangulation).

Why? Because "She probably hit her head, fell in the water and drowned." is the excuse that GC started to propagate after being misdirected by his pal CPH. GC's original theory was that he believed she probably got killed.

 

[MrsPC]

anybody want to make a prediction on what the ME will say?

I'm going with some type of injury to head and water in lungs (or strangulation).

Why? Because "She probably hit her head, fell in the water and drowned." is the excuse that GC started to propagate after being misdirected by his pal CPH. GC's original theory was that he believed she probably got killed.

if they tell us anything at all...I think they'll say it was a homicide, but they won't release details.

 

[Seaslug44]

anybody want to make a prediction on what the ME will say?

I'm going with some type of injury to head and water in lungs (or strangulation).

Why? Because "She probably hit her head, fell in the water and drowned." is the excuse that GC started to propagate after being misdirected by his pal CPH. GC's original theory was that he believed she probably got killed.

They are going to say "no foul play could be detected from the state of the remains".

 

[MrsPC]

http://twitter.com/#!/taniaelopez/status/197395600168329216

"no word yet on the outcome" after 2 hrs

 

[truthspider]

Well ss, that would be silly because I don't think anyone needs an ME report to know there was foul play that night. Much like we don't need a polygraph test to confirm CPH is a liar, there are already plenty of testimonials published in Newsday, and other sources that confirm more conclusively than a polygraph that he is.

Yes, thank you. I will have the truth-burger, rare, with a side of reality, and a Guinness extra stout.

Can't wait to hear what comes....