Search results

Agree, and that’s what has long (since I learned of this case) see it as a straight-up assassination, business-like as if for hire. But other people see indications of it being personal. I don’t think until tonight I’ve seriously considered a jealousy vendetta, or even that the killer had...

For anyone who knows the lay of the land more, any thoughts on why the killer chose The Goddard School for a waiting spot? I realize this has likely been discussed but probably not for a while anyway.

Many are related —via alcohol. I work at a University and it just happened again last month. They don’t always drown in the river. Sometimes their alcohol overdose results in their death by other means. This theory sucked us all I for a while but I’ve let go of it, at least for the most part...

Mille Lacs is a huuuge lake — I’ll give you that. When you drive by it you don’t see land — you just see water forever. I’m sure it hides many bodies. Edited to add: But it takes over an hour each way by roadway. I think you are doing as how the crow flies. Map from St. John’s to the town of Onamia.

I think you are going to drive yourself nuts with this theory and so just have to say nope, nope, nope. Save yourself! When, like the “smiley face killer” theory, people want it to fit some widely ranging serial killer of college boys and drowning in water, just no. They can’t all be connected...

Deleted —wrong thread

I wish more people would weigh in again too, or that we could have had your participation earlier on when there was more overall participation. I will also try to go offline for a bit —I have a non-sleuth writing project I’ve been at a standstill on and need to get back to it. Some of these sad...

Yep, it’s a good theory. I think some of the bloggers have taken a lot of liberties with stating their theories as facts, so I don’t want to rely on them too much. But all of this has long been discussed. Btw, can you verify that BW was the last or one of the last people to run the incinerator...

Good idea — and good for you for being able to shift to a new theory. Not easy, but critical and I can see the professionalism you bring to this. Plus, your OD theory work is there, it doesn’t disappear and you can go back to it. Im curious about your interest in the tunnels and Im interested...

Or of course I should say, until remains are found in the water

Being 2 months out from the breakup, at that age is high time for looking for someone new, imo, and midnight is an odd time if you might both really like each other but it’s not an odd time for a purely sexual hookup for some young people. But I don’t think that’s what happened either. It’s...

Sorry, now I remember that you did say all of that about the dumpster before. So much to keep track of. The extra detail to your thoughts on it helps though. Also your thoughts about the interviews. True, Katie is natural in speaking and so is everyone else except for Nick. But that doesn’t make...

I have read all these threads about Josh but it’s been a while. I think I’ll go back to the beginning. But two questions for you or anyone: Why do you think someone hiding something bigger than just trying to hide some bad college behavior would agree to be interviewed for a major Netflix show...

After watching again, my thoughts aren’t really unchanged from the past few weeks having read your theory. My thoughts did change from the times(years)I followed since the beginning to the times I’ve read your theory, but mainly in the order of whatI suspect happened. When I was following...

Yep, your theory has definitely risen into a top possibility for me, above the monks and above any online dating hookup. I can never rule out the water. You saw the documentary. You know it’s a big body of water. The snapping turtle statement to a parent seems terribly cruel, but it’s possible...

I’m guessing that if you don’t get a lot of responses to this post right away it’s because people are digesting it and maybe rewatching the documentary. Similar ideas have been out there, but didn’t reflect my thoughts on what happened. Thanks for the thorough explanation of your work, with...

The sleuthers, or anyone, who submit tips typically do not hear back though. LE can’t tell them what came of any follow-up to protect the investigation. Yes, we are all tired of hearing that but at times we also see why it’s often for the best. Frustrating for those who submit tips, I’m sure...

Take a few days off WS to focus on the fall to-do lists and look what happens. I caught up last night but woke up this morning thinking surely I imagined this. It’s not that the defense story isn’t realistic. We have those faux Nordic people in my state too. The leaders have violent criminal...

Oh I see where my first response went, @Trino and I’m sorry. I thought I’d lost it but I backspaced it straight into your post that so was trying to respond to. So sorry! Looks like I’m putting words in your mouth and don’t know how to change it. It only shows in your quoted post above my last one.

Uggh just typed a big long response then lost it. The point was there’s not likely a crime, so an author would have to find another angle to be able to write and sell a book. There could be many interesting things about him, but not to a crime writer. If Bryce does turn out to be a crime...