Search results

  1. S

    Possible Victim: Shannan Gilbert #2

    I think it was her saying to Michael Pak ‘You’ve been in on this since the start’ which implies an organised, pre-arranged plan to kill her for which she was brought to Gilgo. People seem to be overlooking that and it’s strange given that there were women deliberately brought to the same area...
  2. S

    Victim: Melissa Barthelemy #2

    I’m sure Melissa was white. “Half-breed” referred to her little sister. I remember her Mum said that Melissa desperately wanted to be black and her mixed race little sister wanted to be white. There were photos on phones back then. Often not great quality. iPhones came out in 2007.
  3. S

    Victim: Amber Lynn Costello

    IIRC he said he was out of his nut on drugs too which contributed to not looking properly.
  4. S

    UK - Logan Mwangi, 5, found dead in Wales River, Bridgend, 31 July 2021 *arrests, inc. minor* #4

    But fibromyalgia doesn’t make people lie. If someone in that situation with those issues was asked a question like ‘How many punches were there?’, the truthful answer would be ‘I know he punched him but I don’t know how many times, I have memory issues because of my medical condition so I can’t...
  5. S

    UK - Logan Mwangi, 5, found dead in Wales River, Bridgend, 31 July 2021 *arrests, inc. minor* #4

    My Dad died of MS related complications last October after suffering from it for 26 years. MS is a neurological condition that is diagnosed by an MRI scan. It’s not something that can be faked. I think, like many people, you’re mixing it up with ME which was the subject of controversy in the...
  6. S

    UK - Logan Mwangi, 5, found dead in Wales River, Bridgend, 31 July 2021 *arrests, inc. minor* #4

    At one point she was saying that Logan’s head was shaved because it made him look like his bio father Ben Mwangi which made John Cole jealous. She said Logan was the double of Ben so that made Cole jealous too. Then later on she said that Logan wanted it cut like that because John Cole’s hair...
  7. S

    Possible Victim: Shannan Gilbert #2

    That post makes a lot of sense in some ways…but it also says Hackett called Mari from Pak’s phone, wasn’t Hackett shown to have made those calls because they appeared on his own phone records in the end?
  8. S

    IDENTIFIED! Valerie Mack - Jane Doe #6/Manorville Jane Doe - remains located Nov 2000 & April 2011

    Do you remember the pics and the descriptions? I’ve added the pic where it’s most prominent. A huge deal was made of that feature. It’s not present in any of her mugshots (which were taken fairly close to her disappearance) and you’d expect a woman with such a prominent feature whose family...
  9. S

    Shannan Gilbert Found, death declared an accident. #2

    It’d still be normal to go meet them rather than letting them search for a house in an area that we know from Shannan’s call was not easy to navigate and didn’t have good signage. We do know Gus Colletti definitely called the police from multiple witnesses. It’s been widely debated too because...
  10. S

    IDENTIFIED! Valerie Mack - Jane Doe #6/Manorville Jane Doe - remains located Nov 2000 & April 2011

    One of the worst things about Valerie is that she was last seen in Spring/Summer 2000. The facial reconstruction gave her a very distinctive damaged and crooked nose which had been broken then healed. None of the photos of Valerie or descriptions of her before she went missing mention this. Her...
  11. S

    UID Victim: Toddler's Mother/Peaches/Jane Doe #4

    You know this post has really made me think. You (and I) have both assumed that this jewellery was theirs. Something worn habitually, that other people would see and link to them. So why would he leave such identifying things there, he’s a clever man (assuming it’s one killer and Baby Doe being...
  12. S

    UID Victim: Toddler's Mother/Peaches/Jane Doe #4

    Identification often doesn’t happen via one factor alone. An ancestral/location based DNA profile can dramatically reduce the pool of possible people that could be Peaches. This is particularly so for non-Europeans in America the mix of their DNA can give a great deal of clues as to who she is...
  13. S

    UID Victim: Toddler's Mother/Peaches/Jane Doe #4

    They don’t need a relative match to learn from her DNA. It can narrow down her likely area of origin/ancestral region which would greatly lessen the pool of people the police would need to look at.
  14. S

    Victim: Maureen Brainard-Barnes

    If Cann is saying she has confidence it’s encouraging. She is intelligent, she’s kept herself up to date with everything in the case and fought so hard, as has Sherre. I really feel for those two. So much tragedy in their lives but they keep on fighting. I admire their strength.
  15. S

    Victim: Maureen Brainard-Barnes

    I think that is an extremely interesting idea. We have a phrase in the UK ‘Fly tipping’. It describes people who do not want to pay the proper fees legitimate disposal of industrial/agricultural/horticultural waste. It’s an industry often associated with Gypsies (often called travellers) in this...
  16. S

    Victim: Maureen Brainard-Barnes

    The parts of Mack & Taylor found earlier were not at Gilgo/Oak Beaches or in the immediate area. The parts of them in those areas weren’t found until 2011 after the Shannan incident and discovery of the GB4. More parts of Peaches and her entire child were also found around there in 2011 as was...
  17. S

    Victim: Maureen Brainard-Barnes

    But there weren’t better hiding places. This person had been dumping bodies in this rough area probably since 1997. And although some body parts had been found, nothing overly alarming. Many of the bodies had been there years without detection. If the Shannan incident hadn’t happened, they’d...
  18. S

    Victim: Amber Lynn Costello

    I don’t think someone like LISK would have taken the risk of at least 4 times driving more than an hour from Manhattan to Gilgo Beach with a body in his car. He’s obviously not stupid and it would be too risky. NYC is busy all the time and something as mundane as his car being rear ended could...
  19. S

    Victim: Amber Lynn Costello

    My thought on that is that usually he was happy with once every few years, and there may be more bodies out there too. But Shannan’s death caused fuss and ruckus. He may well have felt he might be arrested/convicted over Shannan so wanted to get several fast fixes just in case they he lost the...
  20. S

    Victim: Maureen Brainard-Barnes

    My hunch on this (as always speculation) is this. We know from the calls to Melissa’s sister that LISK, pings and links to victims that is often in Manhattan. Maybe he works there or goes there for socialising or to pick up hookers. I see no reason why it would be unusual for a predatory...
Top