Search results

I am way late to this story but was curious why tracking dogs weren't used -- he was quickly known to be missing, the neighbor knew where he went into the woods, there were plenty of items with his scent. Or, maybe dogs were used but not successful? I think he could easily have lost his clothes...

I think taking the father into the woods could simply be a strategy to unnerve the couple, and possibly "shake something loose."

Woman’s body found; authorities continue investigation into death

Kidnapped Chattanooga toddler found safe; grandmother's boyfriend charged A view of the grandmother's FB page show a group of text messages that explores the baby's mother's jealousy of the suspect. In spite of him watching the child often, she chose to say he had kidnapped her. At this...

Yes, I am so glad she has the rest of her life to do that. So relieved.

Still following just this case. Horrible feeling when it goes to the second page.

If anyone is wondering why I'm going down this particular road, it is because it would give a slightly different motive for the murder. Perhaps CL had convinced her they would be married as a way to become intimate with her, convincing her it was "ok" because they would be together forever and...

I was thinking she might be planning to make a hasty exit, as in disappearing while JC was working, and be unable to make a plan that would include taking a horse with her. In this scenario, Erin thinks she and CL will go off into the sunset together, while maybe he never had any intention of that.

PhantomThought gave me a random thought. Regarding Erin claiming that she could no longer take the horse because of immunization problems, that could have been another fib - It could possibly indicate that she planned to take off with CL when he finished his service and would not be able to take...

Lots of good points today. I was considering that if CL thought the first baby was his, that he might have caused her to lose it. He could also have caused her to lose the baby if it wasn't his, if they were together at that time. I know most of us think the affair began because JC wasn't nice...

Given the timeline, is it factually possible that the affair began while Erin was pregnant the first time? Second, is it factually possible based on what we know that the first baby could have been CLs?

I don't know if it has been proven, but if it was discussed at the neighborhood gathering the night before, some neighbors might be able to testify that he heard.

Moonbeams, I am following it to conduct psychological profiles. I want to expand the field of profiling from "use it to identify the killer" to use it to explore not only "who did it" but "how did things get here" and "what part did various parties play and why."

Do you welcome volunteer searchers or are they a hindrance?

Would setting him up to spend life in prison qualify as "taking it out" on him?

I just considered the irony (if true) that Erin began an affair because a guy was so understanding and sympathetic of her losing a baby, only to have him murder the next baby -- and her. I like Dark Horse's thinking -- it is time to think out of the box when so many pieces don't fit. We are...

I think that's true. I recall a report that she told him on Father's day, but I don't recall if it was MSM.

I still doubt that child support was an issue. I think Erin always had a back-up plan to stay with JC and raise the baby as his if things didn't work out with CL. There would have been no other reason for her to tell JC about the pregnancy so early on. If she really thought she was going to be...

I don't know how he really thought he would ever get away with this.

Bernina, I had the same thought about a .22. CL obviously knew a lot about weapons and why he would have planned to use a .22 is beyond me.