Search results

Notes: Helpful observations, and information with some official verification that may help toward resolution Verified: Answered using official verification (may include supplemental evidence) Value of point/question (by consensus): A-C, with A being most important; D = unsleuthable 91. Is it...

Notes: Helpful observations, and information with some official verification that may help toward resolution Verified: Answered using official verification (may include supplemental evidence) Value of point/question (by consensus): A-C, with A being most important; D = unsleuthable 1. Name...

Does anyone know...if Dale were arrested for Michelle's murder, what would happen with the twins--who would they go to? Would both sets of grandparents battle for custody, and would DS Sr.'s drug charge likely prevent him from winning custody? (Opinions are fine, but I was hoping someone who...

Well, we have a difference of opinion on that issue, you and I. This just further illustrates my main point in that post you referenced that those of us who may agree that Dale is the likely perp may also disagree on other elements of this case. :)

Thanks CarolAnn! :) I will post an updated list when another thread is started.

This is my feeling, too: the Hummer may not have been in the Oak Ridge area at all. Michelle's cell phone was not necessarily with the Hummer. LE may very well have Oak Ridge video footage of a vehicle associated with the perp in this case. They're not going to release that evidence to the...

I just want to mention that although there are a great many people who post on here who feel that Dale is the likely perp, our views on Dale's personality, motives, "dating" history, and so on ad nauseam are most certainly not monolithic. I myself, for example, feel that the repeated suggestion...

Wow, I totally don't remember seeing that at all. I would love if someone could find that. SleuthDecay, you've been digging up some good tidbits the past several days.

Just some IMO thoughts: If Michelle didn't want to be bothered with giving her brother a ride, why would she even text him back at all? Why not just ignore the brother's text like his mom and his other sister did? I think that by 4:30, if the day had unfolded as Michelle planned, she already...

Thanks to the conversations over the past several days, I've been able to fill in bits and pieces on the question list. Not that it's the final word on anything, but it could help you find some bit of info. I even forget about checking it myself though. :doh: (Current question list is in this...

I believe that there's no confirmation that the Hummer was seen then, only that the cell pinged then. Some may have speculated that the Hummer and cell were in the same place, perhaps. jmo

Sounds like she was found pretty quickly, at least. Did he (or they) take her car too?

Are you mixing me up with someone else? I do think it's very likely that Dale is responsible for Michelle's disappearance, but my musing speculations about what could have happened when Michelle arrived at Dale's have nothing to do with evidence of his guilt or innocence.

Well ain't that a kick in the head! :)

Only speculating about a possibility, if one or both of his parents were there. I had that train of thought, since Thor mentioned the parents being at the condo too in one of his posts.

Respectfully snipped to address one point. Actually, do we know for sure his parents weren't there? Do we know for sure that a friend of his wasn't there? I don't think we know either way.

Hmmmmm. If Dale's parents were at the condo when Michelle arrived (perhaps having watched the PC episode with him?) that would be very convenient. He wouldn't have to call for assistance. And there would be someone to distract and look after the twins for a while...

BBM Thor, here's where I believe the 42 minutes in question come into play. At the beginning, when Michelle was first missing, Dale told Michelle's family (and perhaps LE, since he was "cooperating" with them at the beginning) that Michelle had brought the twins to the condo at 4 PM, had...

I talked about this in an earlier thread, but can't resist repeating it here: Check out a true crime book called Finding Amy. Actually, I don't recommend it, because I feel it isn't that good, but just for the sake of an anecdotal story about polygraphs, the beginning of this book is quite...

I was attempting to say (perhaps not well :) ) that circumstantial evidence is as valid and useful for a conviction as any other sort of evidence. I wasn't trying to say what is or isn't physical evidence. Dale's fingerprints on Michelle's cell phone (and this is entirely hypothetical, so I...