CAN someone please explain what Jury of the Defendants peers really means?

Bathbuddys

Verified Family Member Thomas Schramm
Joined
Aug 23, 2008
Messages
789
Reaction score
0
Website
www.bathbuddys.com
Hi,
I have been watching Jury selection for 10 days now and am confused on why the courts and law says that we have the right to a jury of our peers?

I am confused as Casey was born to two caucasian parents and her hispanic attorney is asking for minorities?, single men, women with no children, etc etc.
Does anyone else feel confused on the meaning of a jury of one's peers?
 
Hi,
I have been watching Jury selection for 10 days now and am confused on why the courts and law says that we have the right to a jury of our peers?

I am confused as Casey was born to two caucasian parents and her hispanic attorney is asking for minorities?, single men, women with no children, etc etc.
Does anyone else feel confused on the meaning of a jury of one's peers?


maybe this should be asked in the questions for lawyers thread?
 
According to:

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/jury+of+one%27s+peers
it means:

jury of one's peers n. a guaranteed right of criminal defendants, in which "peer" means an "equal." This has been interpreted by courts to mean that the available jurors include a broad spectrum of the population, particularly of race, national origin and gender. Jury selection may include no process which excludes those of a particular race or intentionally narrows the spectrum of possible jurors. It does not mean that women are to be tried by women, Asians by Asians, or African Americans by African Americans.
 
Will leave this thread open for now, but am taking the original post over to the Verified Lawyer's thread. Think it is a great and relevant question, but I think our VLs will have an answer for us in short order.
 
I think Marina answered that question very well, so I don't think I can add more to that question... but I don't think the DT are at all interested in a jury of ICA's peers because-- lets face it: ICA's peers are level headed, successful, well educated people. They want the exact opposite. Single men that have never had children. I hate to agree with the FB p juror re: how the defense wants him because he's single, AA, no children & and he's a man.
 
I think Marina answered that question very well, so I don't think I can add more to that question... but I don't think the DT are at all interested in a jury of ICA's peers because-- lets face it: ICA's peers are level headed, successful, well educated people. They want the exact opposite. Single men that have never had children. I hate to agree with the FB p juror re: how the defense wants him because he's single, AA, no children & and he's a man.
That man was everything the defense wanted all rolled up into one and he knew it.
 
According to:

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/jury+of+one%27s+peers
it means:

jury of one's peers n. a guaranteed right of criminal defendants, in which "peer" means an "equal." This has been interpreted by courts to mean that the available jurors include a broad spectrum of the population, particularly of race, national origin and gender. Jury selection may include no process which excludes those of a particular race or intentionally narrows the spectrum of possible jurors. It does not mean that women are to be tried by women, Asians by Asians, or African Americans by African Americans.[/B]


Yet this is precisely what some attorneys in some cases-cough cough OJ-seek.
 
If I remember from my HS government class it was to keep the upper class from ruling over the lower class and giving the government too much control over the little guy. In a way like the balance of power we see in our 3 part government (President, Judicial, Congress) Our founding Fathers hoped to avoid some of what they had just lived during the Colonial/Revolutionary days.

In having a trial by jury, it keeps the government from having too much control.

Most of the time it works...some times it back fires but that will happen in any institution where humans are involved.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
196
Guests online
3,957
Total visitors
4,153

Forum statistics

Threads
591,819
Messages
17,959,585
Members
228,620
Latest member
ohbeehaave
Back
Top