Transgender considerations in UID remains and missing/murder investigations

carbuff

Well-Known Member
Joined
Oct 30, 2009
Messages
29,441
Reaction score
69,123
Website
www.colealicem.com
I'm sorry if this is too blunt, but I can't think of any good ways to paraphrase it.

Clearly if the body of a transgendered person is found, the DNA tests will identify the person's sex at birth. But if the person had undergone sex reassignment surgery and treatment, would that leave any traces that could be detected after skeletonization?

Related: if a transgendered person is missing, do they get listed under their sex at birth, or the sex they lived as?

Pointers to detailed discussion would be most welcome.
 
I very rarely discuss this with strangers since people can be intrusive and I'm an introvert, but my partner is transgendered (MTF, or male to female).

When a person transitions AND takes hormones (estrogen for MTF, testosterone for FTM) on a regular basis, there are changes to their muscular structure. I have heard that there can also be changes to skeletal structure, but am having a hard time finding a good link to back this up. The International Olympic Committee only permits trans athletes to compete if their hormones are within the average range associated with people who are born female (see The Transgender Athlete).

The earlier in life someone begins taking hormones, the more his/her body will look like the sex to which he/she is transitioning. Now that people are more aware of trans issues, some adolescents who are trans are being allowed to take hormones that suppress secondary sexual characteristics. This is so they can decide when they're an adult whether or not they wish to fully transition.

I don't know much about osteology, but some people who are MTF have facial feminization procedures done such as brow ridge reduction and cheekbone enhancement. I would certainly expect these to show up on a skeleton.

Carbuff, your latter question is very important. Each state has its own laws regarding changing birth gender on official documents. You do have to go to court to get a name change. My partner is fortunate enough to have been born in California and has an official (re-issued) birth certificate listing the name she uses now and listing her gender as female. By contrast, if we were in Texas, they would still consider her male because that state uses your chromosomal makeup to dictate whether you're male or female.

My partner's path follows the ideal in many respects--she had enough family support and financial resources to go through full surgery, changing her name, etc. Many trans people don't have this--they might not have had surgery, are taking black-market hormones (very dangerous), or their families don't accept them for who they are.
 
I very rarely discuss this with strangers since people can be intrusive and I'm an introvert, but my partner is transgendered (MTF, or male to female).

When a person transitions AND takes hormones (estrogen for MTF, testosterone for FTM) on a regular basis, there are changes to their muscular structure. I have heard that there can also be changes to skeletal structure, but am having a hard time finding a good link to back this up. The International Olympic Committee only permits trans athletes to compete if their hormones are within the average range associated with people who are born female (see The Transgender Athlete).

The earlier in life someone begins taking hormones, the more his/her body will look like the sex to which he/she is transitioning. Now that people are more aware of trans issues, some adolescents who are trans are being allowed to take hormones that suppress secondary sexual characteristics. This is so they can decide when they're an adult whether or not they wish to fully transition.

I don't know much about osteology, but some people who are MTF have facial feminization procedures done such as brow ridge reduction and cheekbone enhancement. I would certainly expect these to show up on a skeleton.

Carbuff, your latter question is very important. Each state has its own laws regarding changing birth gender on official documents. You do have to go to court to get a name change. My partner is fortunate enough to have been born in California and has an official (re-issued) birth certificate listing the name she uses now and listing her gender as female. By contrast, if we were in Texas, they would still consider her male because that state uses your chromosomal makeup to dictate whether you're male or female.

My partner's path follows the ideal in many respects--she had enough family support and financial resources to go through full surgery, changing her name, etc. Many trans people don't have this--they might not have had surgery, are taking black-market hormones (very dangerous), or their families don't accept them for who they are.


I've wondered this myself. Is it possible for your partner to see if her physician can give us an answer?
 
Just found a case in Canada- links are not working. Not sure if any of you have seen this case on WS. I don't have time to search.

cold cases scroll to The Man in the Red High Heels: Unidentified skeletal remains.


To amateur and professional cold case investigators: Your assistance is urgently needed to help identify this long neglected victim!

The victim’s remains were discovered on July 16, 1980, on the Eleventh Concession near Steeles Avenue in Markham, Ontario and he is believed to have died approximately 3 years earlier. In 1983, three years after the body was found, for some unknown reason, the body and the clothing found with it were buried at Mount Pleasant Cemetery essentially causing all physical evidence to disappear.

In 2007, the remains were exhumed, believing a possible connection with the murders of Richard Hovey and Eric Jones who were identified through massive media coverage of facial reconstructions. (Please see links below).

The skull of The Man in the Red High Heels had been virtually reassembled from fragmented remains and recreated in 3d on a rapid prototype printer at John Abbott College, QC. The facial reconstructions were completed within 3 weeks and delivered to York Regional Police Cold Case Unit in July 2009. The facial reconstruction of The Man in the Red High Heels has been exposed once on the national news in Dec 2009 at approximately 8:10 am. (News coverage is to the best of the artist’s information).

To date, the facial images and clothing sketches have never been posted on the unidentified bodies site belonging to the Ontario provincial authorities. While there may have been more local media releases in the Toronto area, it is the artist’s opinion that news coverage of any cold case file must be extensive and repeated in order that just one person out there with the knowlege of the deceased can recognize the images and the story.

The 2d reconstruction has never been seen as a 3d photo was incorrectly posted instead on the police website.

The full body clothing sketch is the artist’s initial impression received from a meager available description. Although the shoes were described as pink and red, the pink portion could never be pin-pointed. Specific details of the shirt and jeans are only an impression as no examples were offered at the time of the drawings.

To Recap: The Man in the Red High Heels has not been seen by family or friends since approximately 1977. His remains were discovered in July 1980 one mile north of Steeles Avenue in a bushy area on the east side of 11th Concession in Markham Ontario. He is said to have been a white male between the ages of 25 to 40 years with a slim build weighing approximately 99-121 lbs. and was about 5ft 4 in. to 5ft 7 in. tall. He had medium to dark brown straight hair, 4 inches long. He had fillings in his teeth and a number of his teeth had been missing for some time before he died. His eye colour is unknown. He was wearing a lady’s red shirt, women’s “Brittania” jeans (sized 30 inch waist and a 29 inch inseam), white frilled socks and red and pink high heeled shoes.

Articles found in the same area include a compact containing a mirror and face powder and 2 green, plastic garbage bags with additonal articles.

Please help this victim go home. Talk about the case and spread the news across the borders, as he may not be from Ontario, Canada. If you recognize the face or the story and can offer any leads to detectives, please contact Det. David MacDonald, Homicide Unit, York Regional Police at 1-866-876-5423, (905) 830-0303 ext 7871.
 

Attachments

  • man_in_red_high_heels_3d-41_co8s_71fc.jpg
    man_in_red_high_heels_3d-41_co8s_71fc.jpg
    12.9 KB · Views: 104
  • man_in_the_red_high_heels_clothing_description1_megu.jpg
    man_in_the_red_high_heels_clothing_description1_megu.jpg
    17.5 KB · Views: 120
  • man_in_the_red_high_heels_3d-31.jpg
    man_in_the_red_high_heels_3d-31.jpg
    12.3 KB · Views: 93
I think how the missing person is reported would depend on the family and friends and how they felt about their loved one being trans. I have seen one missing person report which stated that the man preferred to dress in women's clothing. If the family did not approve they might not be willing to share this information though...

I don't know anything about the forensic side of things but unless the person had surgery which changed the bones then I don't know how anyone would know if they'd had gender reassignment surgery. I suppose hormones changing muscle tone could affect the bones though. Interesting topic!
 
Here's the missing case I was remembering:
http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/l/lawson_harold.html

It was bugging me that I couldn't remember his name! Harold went missing in 1983 so he's not the man in the red high heels although that case is intriguing to me! He is described as a cross-dresser, not transgendered but it sounds like he was almost always seen in women's clothes. It's hard to know how he viewed himself. It would be harder to identify skeletal remains as Harold since the picture posted is of him dressed as a woman. You might not think of him as readily when reading about male remains.
 
I have no idea if this is any help at all, but:

- If the person has not undergone surgery and has not taken any hormones, and if there was nothing in the remains to indicate that this is a trans person, they would probably be listed as the gender they were assigned at birth.

- As to hormones, I believe it depends on the type of hormones and how long. If someone starts hormones when they're very young (say, puberty-ish) it's very likely that there will be at least some changes in their skeleton. However, in the case of older people, I'm pretty sure that changes are minor if there are any because after your skeleton has stopped growing it has already assumed a more definitive shape. According to the NHS (#1 link) hormones cannot change the shape of your skeleton, so if you're not exceptionally young, you won't get wider shoulders, wider hips, changes in height. According to Wikipedia, so take it with a grain of salt, while the size of bones cannot change, enough time can make testosterone change bone shape. If it's true then people with apparently contradictory features in their bones could have been FtM trans people. I don't know if the reverse is also true of MtF people.

NHS - scroll down to "Monitoring" - http://www.nhs.uk/Conditions/Gender-dysphoria/Pages/Treatment.aspx

Wikipedia - http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hormone_replacement_therapy_(female-to-male)

I found this link which discusses the skeletal changes in a MtF girl who starts hormones around the time of puberty - http://www.gendercentre.org.au/82article6.htm

If you google a combination of transgender, hormones, and skeleton, you'll also finds LOTS of FAQs on trans and health sites that say basically the same thing, starting hormones as an adult won't have much of an influence on your skeleton, at least not in huge amounts and quickly.

- I don't know if this is possible, but hormones can lead to changes in muscle and fat tissues. I don't know if it could leave a mark if a person who wasn't very fat or very muscly gained fat/muscle tissue. I've heard that rapid weight losses and gains can leave a mark on the skeleton but I don't know if hormones would make it sudden enough, plus I don't know if this is true of muscles.

- As to surgery, I don't know if it would leave a mark. It seems like most of it is related to soft tissue and not bones. I can try to find some more information about this. So far the only thing I know is that there is facial surgery, for MtF people at least, that changes facial bone structure so I assume that at least would leave a mark. However, something to keep in mind about surgery is that different parts of the world can have different standard procedures and it might depend on the person's background. For example, it's not free or cheap everywhere so in some parts of the world a trans person may not have had it.

- By the way, in the case of FtM people, I know that binders that are not of good quality or are ill-fitting can be dangerous. I don't know if that would leave marks on bones, in some cases I think it could be possible.

- The gender that a person would be reported as would depend on people. If their family/friends are not ok with them being trans or don't know they might report them as the gender they were assigned at birth, or perhaps less likely, might use their correct gender but not mention that the person they're looking for is trans so no connection gets made between them and the remains. It also depends on the local police. If the family thinks they won't get help if they're looking for a trans person or if the police officers in the case are fans of misgendering or being dismissive (or plain ignorant). We're not even talking about the media which always seems to love using the wrong pronouns.:furious:
 
Just found a case in Canada- links are not working. Not sure if any of you have seen this case on WS. I don't have time to search.

cold cases scroll to The Man in the Red High Heels: Unidentified skeletal remains.


To amateur and professional cold case investigators: Your assistance is urgently needed to help identify this long neglected victim!

The victim’s remains were discovered on July 16, 1980, on the Eleventh Concession near Steeles Avenue in Markham, Ontario and he is believed to have died approximately 3 years earlier. In 1983, three years after the body was found, for some unknown reason, the body and the clothing found with it were buried at Mount Pleasant Cemetery essentially causing all physical evidence to disappear.

In 2007, the remains were exhumed, believing a possible connection with the murders of Richard Hovey and Eric Jones who were identified through massive media coverage of facial reconstructions. (Please see links below).

The skull of The Man in the Red High Heels had been virtually reassembled from fragmented remains and recreated in 3d on a rapid prototype printer at John Abbott College, QC. The facial reconstructions were completed within 3 weeks and delivered to York Regional Police Cold Case Unit in July 2009. The facial reconstruction of The Man in the Red High Heels has been exposed once on the national news in Dec 2009 at approximately 8:10 am. (News coverage is to the best of the artist’s information).

To date, the facial images and clothing sketches have never been posted on the unidentified bodies site belonging to the Ontario provincial authorities. While there may have been more local media releases in the Toronto area, it is the artist’s opinion that news coverage of any cold case file must be extensive and repeated in order that just one person out there with the knowlege of the deceased can recognize the images and the story.

The 2d reconstruction has never been seen as a 3d photo was incorrectly posted instead on the police website.

The full body clothing sketch is the artist’s initial impression received from a meager available description. Although the shoes were described as pink and red, the pink portion could never be pin-pointed. Specific details of the shirt and jeans are only an impression as no examples were offered at the time of the drawings.

To Recap: The Man in the Red High Heels has not been seen by family or friends since approximately 1977. His remains were discovered in July 1980 one mile north of Steeles Avenue in a bushy area on the east side of 11th Concession in Markham Ontario. He is said to have been a white male between the ages of 25 to 40 years with a slim build weighing approximately 99-121 lbs. and was about 5ft 4 in. to 5ft 7 in. tall. He had medium to dark brown straight hair, 4 inches long. He had fillings in his teeth and a number of his teeth had been missing for some time before he died. His eye colour is unknown. He was wearing a lady’s red shirt, women’s “Brittania” jeans (sized 30 inch waist and a 29 inch inseam), white frilled socks and red and pink high heeled shoes.

Articles found in the same area include a compact containing a mirror and face powder and 2 green, plastic garbage bags with additonal articles.

Please help this victim go home. Talk about the case and spread the news across the borders, as he may not be from Ontario, Canada. If you recognize the face or the story and can offer any leads to detectives, please contact Det. David MacDonald, Homicide Unit, York Regional Police at 1-866-876-5423, (905) 830-0303 ext 7871.


Bumping this case and wondering what size the shoes were, maybe somebody remembers selling or giving the shoes to the uid.
Wondering if he/she ( sorry just not sure in this case of the correct gender term to use) came from the Queen's Park area or from Gerrard St area, perhaps as a prostitute?
He may not have been gay at all, but in need of money and fulfilling a role for someone requesting it.
speculation, imo.
 
Bumping this case and wondering what size the shoes were, maybe somebody remembers selling or giving the shoes to the uid.
Wondering if he/she ( sorry just not sure in this case of the correct gender term to use) came from the Queen's Park area or from Gerrard St area, perhaps as a prostitute?
He may not have been gay at all, but in need of money and fulfilling a role for someone requesting it.
speculation, imo.

I wonder why there was no bra or panties and if the killer took them. I wonder if he was trans but did not have breast implants yet and if he did if animals had taken them from the scene.
 
http://doenetwork.org/cases/1084umon.html

1084UMON.jpg 1084UMON11.jpg
Unidentified Male
Date of Discovery: July 16, 1980
Location of Discovery: Markham, Ontario, Canada
Estimated Date of Death: 1 to 3 years prior
State of Remains: Skeletal
Cause of Death: Unknown

Physical Description
** Listed information is approximate

Estimated Age: 20-40 years old
Race: White
Gender: Male
Height: 5'4" to 5'7"
Weight: 99-121 lbs.
Hair Color: Brown, medium to dark, straight and 4" long.
Eye Color: Unknown

Distinguishing Marks/Features: Slim build. Light-boned with poorly developed muscular markings.

Dentals: Unknown. Fillings present. Several teeth had been missing for some time before he died.
Fingerprints: Unknown
DNA: Available.
Clothing & Personal Items
Clothing: Found in the same vicinity as the remains were the following: red (and possibly pink) high heeled shoes with a decorative flap and bow (larger sized), Brittania jeans (women's size 30/29), a woman's red shirt, and white frilled socks.

Jewelry: Unknown

Additional Personal Items: Found in the same vicinity as the remains were the following: A compact containing face powder and mirror; two green plastic bags with additional items; and a small bag containing small animal bones.

Case History

The victim's skeletal remains were found in a bush area on the east side of the 11th Concession, 1 km north of Steeles Avenue in the York Region of Markham, Ontario.

The female clothing located and other items found led investigators to believe the man was most likely transgendered.
 
In above post, wondering about the " small bag containing small animal bones." ?!
 
Possibility?

http://www.nampn.org/cases/beauchamps_denis.html
Denis Beauchamps
beauchamps_denis.jpg
Missing Since: April 18, 1977 from Montreal, Québec
Classification: Endangered Missing
Date Of Birth: 1950
Age: 27
Height: 5'3"
Weight: 110 lbs.
Hair Color: Brown, dyed blond
Eye Color: Brown
Race: White
Gender: Transgender
AKA: Danika Valery
Case Number: 234-16-770531-026

Details of Disappearance
Denis Beauchamps was last seen on April 18, 1977 in Montreal. Mr.Beauchamps went to his sister's house after an argument with his boyfriend. He stayed there for a few days, and then left without giving any more news.
rbbm.
 
I think we're going to have to contact LE so am going to leave some links I found yesterday. I wonder if they can look at the crime scene photos to see if anything resembles breast implants, they obviously weren't looking for it when they found the skeletal remains. They probably thought he was female due to the clothing. Next question would be were any items found that a trans woman would use to conceal male reproductive organs? Were they able to run any tests that would show he was taking hormones? Not sure what the test is called but there's a case in FL (IIRC) where they know remains found were taking female hormones. I don't have time right now to grab the case info. They had recently done a sketch for her in fall of 2015

Transvestite - a person, typically a man, who derives pleasure from dressing in clothes appropriate to the opposite sex.
synonyms: drag queen, cross-dresser, female impersonator

He is mentioned in a book Unsolved: True Canadian Cold Cases By Robert J. Hoshowsky; they go into more details about LE thinking the person was hit by a car, I guess thrown 75ft into the woods. When they reopened the case they realized that the clothing never was on the remains

"We hope it looks pretty close to this and that someone comes forward," said Detective-Constable Clarke, who unveiled a drawing to the media of what police believe the victim looked in life: a slender, effeminate-looking young man with dark hair about 4 inches long, wearing red and pink, pointy toed, high heeled shoes, white frilly socks, form fitting blue Brittania jeans (women's size 30/29), and an open-collard, red, short-sleeved blouse.

"It's my belief that he was transgender, possibly in the sex trade down in the Toronto area which … was a bit of a haven, in the 70's for gays," said Clark, who also speculated that the young man may have come to Toronto years ago to live his life as part of the city's large gay, lesbian and transgendered community. "In my opinion, I think he was picked up in the city, taken to [Markham], endeavors occurred and then he was killed and left there," repeated the Detective-Constable, calling the wooded area "a dumping ground."

They are looking at James Henry Greenridge in prison in British Columbia

Video at link - Chilling portrait of transgendered victim - Chris Doucette, Sun Media - First posted: Wednesday, December 02, 2009 04:44 AM EST | Updated: Wednesday, December 02, 2009 04:47 AM EST
It was initially thought the man may have been hit by a car, wandered off the road and died in the wooded area.

But the story took an odd turn when women's clothing was found next to the remains -- a red shirt, a pair of woman's jeans, red-high-heeled shoes and white frilly socks.

"To walk off to the side of the road, take of your clothes and die, it just doesn't make sense," Clarke said.

The female clothing and other items found led investigators to believe the man was most likely transgendered.

"We don't have a cause of death," Clarke said. "But it's believed foul play was involved."

Whether the man was left there to die or his body was dumped remains a mystery.


York Regional Police file # 1980-13437

On December 1, 2009, York Regional Police investigators had reason to be hopeful about a new investigative avenue in the case of unidentified skeletal remains found nearly 30 years earlier.

Members of the public were asked to view a new, museum-quality clay bust of the unidentified man. The man's remains were discovered by a Markham resident on the side of the Eleventh Concession, north of Steeles Avenue, on July 16, 1980.

Unfortunately, the bust failed to spark anyone's memory and the man has yet to be identified. Forensic testing found that he was a white male between 25 and 40 years old when he died. He stood at roughly 5'6", weighed between 100 and 120 pounds and had dark, medium-length brown hair.

Along with the remains, police found a variety of women's clothing items, including red high-heeled shoes, white socks, jeans and a powder compact with a mirror. Investigators believe those items were worn by the victim.


Help Solve a Cold Case - Do you have information about this unidentified victim? Do you know anything about him, or the circumstances that led to his death?

If so, please contact the York Regional Police Cold Case Unit at 1-866-876-5423 ext. 7865 or email the investigators directly. Want to remain anonymous? Call Crime Stoppers at 1-800-222-TIPS, leave a tip online at www.1800222tips.com or text a tip by sending TIPYORK and a message to CRIMES (274637).
View attachment 91575 1084umon.jpg
 

Confusing. Looking at the photo of Denis Beauchamps looks like he was living as a male so I'm not sure if he would fit. I wish they would tell us if he was born male or female. The bio says he had a boyfriend, alias is Danika Valery. I'm assuming that he was born female but identified as male. We would have to contact LE in his case too.
National Centre for Missing Persons and Unidentified Remains - Denis Beauchamps Case reference: 2014002519
Mr. Beauchamps was last seen on April 18, 1977 in Montreal. Mr.Beauchamps went to his sister's house after an argument with his boyfriend. He stayed there for a few days, and then left without giving any more news.

Aliases - VALERY, Danika
Missing since - April 18, 1977
Year of birth - 1950
Age at disappearance - 27
Gender - Transgender
Bio group - White
Eye colour - Brown
Hair - Brown, Dyed blond hair
Height - 160cm / 5 ft 3 in
Weight - 50kg / 110lb

Thanks for all that info Roselvr, you are very quick and organized!!

Adding this thread as some details may also pertain to this case..

http://www.websleuths.com/forums/sh...oronto-Ont-1967/page2&highlight=Richard+Hovey
Canada - Eric Jones, 18, & Richard Hovey, 17, Toronto, Ont, 1967

Will try to get back to the other thread, wonder if the people that were identified were gay. I assume they were killed by the same serial killer.
Yesterday while googling, I thought I found a thread for our guy but when I clicked on it it wasn't here. Not sure what search terms I used to find it lol
I want to make an album for him on an MP/UP FB page Still Seek Answers and I run so was grabbing info for it. Now I just need the time to do it lol
 
From this article UID with red shoes is identified as male..

Apr. 10, 2009
http://www.theglobeandmail.com/news...usion-to-42-year-old-mystery/article17940176/

rbbm.

3.
The skeletal remains of an unidentified third young man were found in a wooded area near Markham in 1980. The victim had been dead for up to two years, and his clothes were found nearby. Police believe the case may be connected.

4. In July of 1967, William Howell, 21, was found by a farmer nude and bleeding to death in a field near Barrie. His throat had been slit, and female undergarments were found nearby. The victim said he'd met his attacker near College and Yonge the night before, according to reports.

5. The nude body of 17-year-old Robert Mortimore was found in a field northeast of Markham Village in July of 1967. One year later, James Henry Greenridge, a 30-year-old computer operator, was sentenced to 17 years for manslaughter in connection with Mr. Mortimore's death, and for the attempted murder of Mr. Howell.
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
175
Guests online
2,137
Total visitors
2,312

Forum statistics

Threads
589,982
Messages
17,928,637
Members
228,030
Latest member
lee k
Back
Top