Maps and Timelines - *NO DISCUSSION*

Sillybilly

Administrator
Staff member
Administrator
Joined
May 9, 2009
Messages
38,650
Reaction score
114,690
Please post any maps or timelines here.

This is a NO DISCUSSION thread.

:wave:
 
Draft Timeline. I’ll tidy it up/revise & update as necessary.

All this information comes from MSM. There are a few other bits I haven’t included because not yet confirmed by LE or in MSM.

- BM graduated high school 1970 in Fenelon falls
- BM Gets married and has 2 children at some point after that and family moved to/lived in/around Oshawa
- Divorced sometime between 1998 - 2001(?)
- He and wife declared bankruptcy 1999, don’t know if it was before, during or after divorce
- 2001 Arrested for assaulting someone in Toronto
- Convicted of above assault April 2003, 2 yr suspended sentence, plus 3 years probation. Restraining order to stay out of the village AND away from an address that could be linked to Majeed
- Dated Skanda in, or from, 1999, who disappeared Labour Day September 2010 last seen in the Village
- Faizi disappears December 29th 2010 last seen in the Village
- Majeed Kayhan reported missing 14 October 2012, no exact last seen, or where info
- Saroush Mahmudi reported missing August 2015, Scarborough
- Dean Lisowick, never reported missing, death estimated between May 2016 - July 2017
- Salem Esen disappears around April 14th 2017
- Andrew Kinsman disappears 26 June 2017
- At some point Andrew & BM were in a relationship
- BM was in a longish (?) term relationship, or an “on/off” relationship with an unidentified man (by MSM/LE) up until his arrest or until shortly before it (?)
- Police start following/investigating BM September 2017
- Police get a hold of BM’s van October 2017 in Courtice
- Arrested 17th January 2018, unidentified man found restrained in BM’s apartment and released unharmed
- Charged with murdering Andrew and Selim 18th January 2018
- Charged with murdering Majeed, Saroush, Dean 29th January 2018
- As yet unidentified human remains of (at least?) three bodies found between 18th January - 29th January 2018.
- Investigation ongoing, not limited to Toronto and not limited to the gay community.
 
https://www.ctvnews.ca/canada/timel...-toronto-police-serial-killer-probe-1.3780133
Jan 29 2018
Timeline of key disappearances in Toronto police 'serial killer' probe
https://www.thestar.com/opinion/sta...s-of-deaths-of-andrew-kinsman-selim-esen.html
Jan 19 2018

attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • map.jpg
    map.jpg
    100 KB · Views: 239
Source: National Post, published Jan. 29, 2018

http://nationalpost.com/news/toronto/what-we-know-about-bruce-mcarthurs-alleged-victims

TIMELINE OF KEY EVENTS IN THE BRUCE MCARTHUR CASE:

October 2012 — Majeed Kayhan, 58, of Toronto, is reported missing.

November 2012
— Police launch Project Houston to investigate the disappearance of three men from Toronto’s gay village, including Kayhan.

April 2014 — Police close Project Houston, saying none of their findings would classify anyone as a suspect of a criminal offence.

August 2015 — Soroush Mahmudi, 50, of Toronto, is reported missing.

May 2016-July 2017 — Police believe Dean Lisowick, 47, of no fixed address, was killed by McArthur during this timespan.

April 14, 2017 — Selim Esen, 44, is reported missing from the area of Toronto’s Yonge and Bloor streets.

June 26, 2017 — Andrew Kinsman, 49, is reported missing from the area of Parliament and Winchester streets.

August 2017 — Police launch Project Prism to investigate the disappearances of Esen and Kinsman.

September 2017 — Project Prism officers identify Bruce McArthur “as someone to be included or excluded as being involved in the disappearance of Andrew Kinsman.”

Dec. 8, 2017 — Police Chief Mark Saunders says the force will review its practices in missing persons investigations. He denies that there is evidence suggesting a serial killer is walking the streets of Toronto.

Jan. 17, 2018 — Police uncover evidence suggesting McArthur was responsible for both Kinsman and Esen’s deaths, along with the deaths of other unidentified people.

Jan. 18, 2018 — McArthur is arrested and charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of Esen and Kinsman. Police say McArthur is believed to be responsible for other deaths.

Jan. 19, 2018 — McArthur has his first court appearance.

Jan. 29, 2018 — McArthur is charged with first-degree murder in the deaths of Mahmudi, Kayhan and Lisowick. Police call McArthur an alleged serial killer and say more victims may be identified.
 
https://www.thestar.com/news/crime/...d-support-as-a-shocked-community-grieves.html
Bruce McArthur: What we know and don't know (Updated: Feb. 1, 2018)
- Bruce McArthur, a 66-year-old landscaper, was charged with murder on Jan. 18 in the deaths of Selim Esen and Andrew Kinsman, who went missing from Toronto's Gay Village in 2017 under mysterious circumstances. -- McArthur was charged with three more counts of murder on Jan. 29 in relation to the deaths of Majeed Kayhan, Soroush Mahmudi and Dean Lisowick. -- Police have also confirmed that human remains were found in planters at a Leaside home where McArthur worked as a landscaper. -- Investigators have confirmed McArthur had a sexual relationship with Kinsman. It’s not known what kind of relationship McArthur had with other alleged victims. -- McArthur lived in the Thorncliffe Park area and was known in the Church and Wellesley area. -- Police have searched multiple properties connected to McArthur in Toronto and one in Madoc. They have now expanded their search into the Peel and Durham regions. -- Police "believe there are more victims." -- Project Prism — the police investigation into the Kinsman and Esen disappearances — was launched in July 2017. -- Project Houston is the police investigation launched in 2012 into the disappearance of three men who frequented the Gay Village around that time: Skandaraj Navaratnam, 40, Abdulbasir Faizi, 42, and Kayhan, 58. According to Xtra, McArthur once dated Navaratnam. -- McArthur was convicted of assault with a weapon and assault causing bodily harm for attacking a man with a pipe in 2001. As a result, McArthur was barred from an area of downtown that included the Gay Village and his conditional sentence prohibited him from spending time with “male prostitutes.” -- It’s not known what role his previous conviction may have played in helping investigators narrowing in on McArthur.
 
This is what I have. It's likely similar, but thought I'd post it anyway:

Timeline

1951-Born in October
1965- Attended high-school in Fenelon Falls, Ontario
1970- Graduated high-school
1986- Bought home in Oshawa, Married, Kids
1997- Remortgaged home
1999- Bankruptcy
1999- “dating” Navaratanam
2000- Oshawa home sold
2001- Landscaping business
------- Moved to Toronto
2001- Divorce
2001- October 31, charged with 1 count of Assault causing bodily harm, 1 count of Assault with a weapon, and 1 count of carrying a concealed weapon in relation to assaulting a male prostitute with a metal pipe
2003- April 13, convicted on 1 count of Assault causing bodily harm, and 1 count of Assault with a weapon, conditional sentence of 2 years, and probation for 3 years, conditions included: being barred from an area of the city which included the Gay Village, prohibited from spending time with male prostitutes, staying at least 10 meters away from 484 Church St. or any address known to be the home or workplace of the victim, ordered to go to counseling including anger management, prohibited from having any firearms, crossbows, ammunition or explosives for 10 years, prohibited to possess amyl nitrates (poppers), and was to have a sample of DNA taken and added to a database indefinitely
2008- Sentence complete
2008- “break up” Navaratanam
2010- September, Navaratanam reported missing
2010- December, Faizi reported missing
2012- October, Kayhan reported missing
2012- November, Project Houston developed
2014- April, Project Houston ends
2014- Suspended sentence granted
2014- “dating” boyfriend
2015- Mall Santa Claus
2015- August, Mahmudi reported missing, Scarborough
2016- Lisowick, never reported missing, death estimated between May 2016-July 2017
2017- “break up” boyfriend
2017- April, Esen reported missing
2017- June, Kinsman reported missing
2017- August, Project Prism developed
2017- September, BM sells his car to scrap yard
2017- October, TPS seize BM’s car from scrap yard, blood evidence obtained
2017- December, TPS hold news conference, updating the public on 3 different investigations, and suggest that there is no serial killer, and no suspect in Project Houston and Project Prism
2018- January, TPS asks for the computer of Faizi from family
2018- January, BM arrested and charged with 2 counts of first degree murder for Esen and Kinsman
2018- January, evidence suggests there are at least 4 victims total, 2 that haven’t been identified
2018- January, BM charged with 3 additional counts of first degree murder for Kayhan, Mahmudi, and Lisowick
2018- January, unidentified human remains discovered of 3+ victims
2018- January, 30+ properties being searched
 
Toronto police fear some-more victims in Bruce McArthur case

http://usmorning.net/news/u-s/toronto-police-fear-more-victims-in-bruce-mcarthur-case/

attachment.php

[FONT=&quot]This map shows the locations the 5 famous victims were last seen in around Toronto. Kinsman and Esen were last seen around the city’s Gay Village area.

[/FONT]
attachment.php

[FONT=&quot]This map shows where stays have been recovered, and the place of the unit where McArthur was arrested. [/FONT]
 

Attachments

  • 48BC4D8F00000578-5330289-image-a-45_1517330394784.jpg
    48BC4D8F00000578-5330289-image-a-45_1517330394784.jpg
    116.4 KB · Views: 188
  • 48BBE4F500000578-5330289-This_map_shows_where_remains_have_been_recovered_and_the_locatio-a-39_1.jpg
    48BBE4F500000578-5330289-This_map_shows_where_remains_have_been_recovered_and_the_locatio-a-39_1.jpg
    86.7 KB · Views: 189
Former classmate shocked by murder accusations facing Bruce McArthur
Feb 6, 2018

Snipped...
...McArthur spent his childhood on a farm along Palestine Road, close to where MacEachern lives and raises beef cattle with his wife, Lynda. McArthur, who also attended Fenelon Falls Secondary, left Kawartha Lakes for the GTA in 1970 at the age of 18.


https://globalnews.ca/news/4008870/...-by-murder-accusations-facing-bruce-mcarthur/
 
Bruce McArthur worked as salesman and in retail offices before move to landscaping
February 4, 2018

Snipped...
...Before starting work in landscaping, Bruce McArthur spent many years as a salesperson in Ontario, including time in Toronto in the 1970s.

...Quiet, polite, and “floppy,” is how McArthur carried himself during his days as a buyer and assistant for Eaton’s department stores in Toronto between at least 1973 and 1978, Foot said.


https://www.thestar.com/news/gta/20...etail-offices-before-move-to-landscaping.html
 
Thanks Candaceshaw - such a good timeline.
I would like to understand the exact date that BM started using the Mallory property...I see on the your timeline it is around 2010, based on the disappearance of Skandaraj and his remains being found there...

Any insight into this?
I believe the Mallory property owners have just said BM used the property for "years"
 
Hi,
This is my first post!

Andrew Kinsman was a friend of mine, and so this case is something I've been thinking about a lot, so to keep things straight in my own head and help other people, I created this spreadsheet with events and links to sources: https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Vt0-QhuCG0tZ8eH-M6-ujX-NqYmnEWkDWXfR91pGS-M/edit?usp=sharing
I've been updating it as new info is released, and I hope to continue.
Welcome to Ws candaceshaw, thanks for the timeline!
Links to all the threads where BM and his alleged victims are discussed..
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?622-Bruce-McArthur-Toronto-CANADA-2010-%96-2018
Forum: Bruce McArthur, Toronto CANADA

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/s...rged-in-murders-of-five-men-Toronto-2010-2017
Canada - Bruce McArthur charged in murders of five men, Toronto, 2010-2017

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/s...eged-serial-killer-Bruce-McArthur-1970-s-2018
Possible victims of alleged serial killer, Bruce McArthur 1970's-2018

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?342310-Andrew-Kinsman-49-Toronto-26-June-2017
Andrew Kinsman, 49, Toronto, 26 June 2017

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/s...ing-in-same-Toronto-ON-neighborhood-2010-2012
3 men missing in same Toronto ON neighborhood, 2010-2012

https://www.websleuths.com/forums/s...-no-fixed-address-not-reported-missing-ARREST
Dean-Lisowick
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?344921-Selim-Esen-44-Toronto-14-April-2017
Selim Esen
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?342575-Majeed-Hamid-Kayhan-59-Toronto-14-Oct-2012
Majeed Hamid Kayhan
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?115680-Skanda-Navaratnam-40-Toronto-5-Sept-2010
Skanda-Navaratnam
https://www.websleuths.com/forums/showthread.php?364287-Soroush-Mahmudi-50-Scarborough-Aug-15-2015
Soroush Mahmudi, 50, Scarborough, Aug 15 2015
 
I’ve been tinkering with the various timelines and have a revised/updated one.

I used Grey-St’s as a template because it was the cleanest:

:

Timeline

1951-Born in October
1965- Attended high-school in Fenelon Falls, Ontario
1970- Graduated high-school
1986- Bought home in Oshawa, Married, Kids
1997- Remortgaged home
1999- Bankruptcy
1999- “dating” Skanda Navaratanam
2000- Oshawa home sold
2001- Landscaping business
------- Moved to Toronto
2001- Divorce
2001- October 31, charged with 1 count of Assault causing bodily harm, 1 count of Assault with a weapon, and 1 count of carrying a concealed weapon in relation to assaulting a male prostitute with a metal pipe
2003- April 13, convicted on 1 count of Assault causing bodily harm, and 1 count of Assault with a weapon, conditional sentence of 2 years, and probation for 3 years, conditions included: being barred from an area of the city which included the Gay Village, prohibited from spending time with male prostitutes, staying at least 10 meters away from 484 Church St. or any address known to be the home or workplace of the victim, ordered to go to counseling including anger management, prohibited from having any firearms, crossbows, ammunition or explosives for 10 years, prohibited to possess amyl nitrates (poppers), and was to have a sample of DNA taken and added to a database indefinitely
2008- Sentence complete
2008- “break up” Skanda Navaratanam
2010- September 6, Skanda Navaratanam reported missing
2010- December 30, Abdulbasir Faizi reported missing
2012- October 14, Majeed Kayhan reported missing
2012- November, Project Houston developed
2014- April, Project Houston ends
2014- Suspended sentence granted
2014- “dating” boyfriend
2015- Mall Santa Claus
2015- August, Saroush Mahmudi reported missing, Scarborough
2016- Dean Lisowick, never reported missing, death estimated between May 2016-July 2017
2016- BM violently assaults an unidentified man in North York. No charges
2017- Spring, Peter Sgromo violently assaulted by BM, survives. Assault not reported to police
2017- “break up” boyfriend
2017- April ~14, Selim Esen reported missing
2017- June 26, Andrew Kinsman reported missing
2017- August, Project Prism developed
2017- late summer, Sean Cribbin violently assaulted by BM, survives. Assault not reported to police
2017- September, BM sells his car to scrap yard
2017- October, TPS seize BM’s car from scrap yard, blood evidence obtained
2017- December, TPS hold news conference, updating the public on 3 different investigations, and suggest that there is no serial killer, and no suspect in Project Houston and Project Prism
2018- January, TPS asks for the computer of Faizi from family
2018- January 18, BM arrested and charged with 2 counts of first degree murder for Esen and Kinsman
2018- January, evidence suggests there are at least 6 victims
2018- January 29, BM charged with 3 additional counts of first degree murder for Kayhan, Mahmudi, and Lisowick
2018- January, 30+ properties being searched
2018- February 23, 1 additional count of first degree murder for Navaratanam. The remains of Navaratanam, Mahmudi & Kinsman are identified. 3 sets of as yet unidentified remains.
2018- March 8, police announce a 7th set of remains found and release a photo of an unidentified victim
2018- March 9th: internal investigation into possible mishandling of the investigations by police announced.

- Investigation ongoing, not limited to Toronto and not limited to the gay community. Some properties/locations will be searched/searched again when the weather warms up.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
182
Guests online
1,532
Total visitors
1,714

Forum statistics

Threads
589,951
Messages
17,928,083
Members
228,013
Latest member
RayaCo
Back
Top