Possible Victim: Fire Island Jane Doe, UP9098, found Davis Park Apr 1996 & Ocean Parkway Apr 2011 - Karen Vergata

JJBONES · Dec 21, 2016

Are there pictures of the ankle scars? I had ankle surgery for a torn tendon and a fasciotomy recently. Would be interesting to compare to my scare.

Mountain_Kat · Dec 21, 2016

Holly Gothlightly said:
A jogger ... yes, of course. There has been so many sad stories of women attacked while jogging recently. If this victim is one of the LISK women though, she would most likely be a sex worker. I feel like a jogger who went missing would be reported missing and she would be identified before now.

I wasn't necessarily saying that she was abducted while jogging...just that she may have been a jogger at some point in her history. Also...it's possible that this girl was reported missing and we simply haven't been able to connect her to Fire Island Jane yet.

Mountain_Kat · Dec 21, 2016

Holly Gothlightly said:
This age progression of missing girl Patricia Taylor looks a bit like Jane Doe's sketch.

Fire Island Jane's legs were found in 1996, so not Patricia.

Mountain_Kat · Dec 21, 2016

I still say Fire Island Jane looks a lot like Dawn Holt, although how she would have ended up in NY is anyone's guess.

http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/h/holt_dawn.html

watergirl62 · Dec 21, 2016

Holts last seen date doesn't work. She caught my eye too.

karmaskiss01 · Dec 21, 2016

Mountain_Kat said:
I still say Fire Island Jane looks a lot like Dawn Holt, although how she would have ended up in NY is anyone's guess.

http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/h/holt_dawn.html

You're right she looks a lot like the sketch. It looks like she went missing 5 days after the legs were found. I wonder how accurate her last seen date is? For a second I thought you got it.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

Holly Gothlightly · Dec 21, 2016

She most certainly does. I wish there was more information on any scarring on her legs.

Holly Gothlightly · Dec 21, 2016

Were we ever told foot size?

Mountain_Kat · Dec 21, 2016

watergirl62 said:
Holts last seen date doesn't work. She caught my eye too.

It's a difference of 5 days. Close enough for error, imo.

watergirl62 · Dec 22, 2016

Mountain_Kat said:
It's a difference of 5 days. Close enough for error, imo.

Yeah maybe, since she was travelling and her family didn't know she was back in Maryland.

I don't see a list of exclusions on Namus. Maybe there are none. Sad.

Sent from my LG-H740 using Tapatalk

BigCityAccountant · Dec 22, 2016

Wondering if the postmortem could be wrong??

Judie Kay Lowery Munguia went missing in May 28, 1981 from Odessa, TX and to me she looks alot like Fire Island Jane Doe.

She fits the profile... 5.3" 150 lbs.

She has a scar on her left leg between the knee and ankle.

http://www.charleyproject.org/cases/m/munguia_judie.html

There is another woman from TX that went missing in 1981 who bares a resemblance to Jane Doe #6. I will post her in that thread.

Super Sleuth · Dec 24, 2016

Could Dawn Almo be Fire Island Doe?

Super Sleuth · Dec 24, 2016

Or what about Mary Kopacz?

Cici_Cyclone · Dec 24, 2016

You folks are amazing for finding all these potential matches. Are any of you working through Namus directly on these suggestions already? Or are you feeding them through to somewhere else? Just curious after listening to the life episode last week and finding out how much hard work it is for people outside of and inside Namus to generate matches.

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

scotiansleuth · Dec 24, 2016

How about Robin Ann Vaudreuil?
Missing since April 1995 from Worcester, MA, contacted mother said she was headed to Oswego. (Oswego , NY ?). I think it's something about the eyes and mouth.

http://www.doenetwork.org/cases/3079dfma.html

Super Sleuth · Dec 24, 2016

scotiansleuth said:
How about Robin Ann Vaudreuil?
Missing since April 1995 from Worcester, MA, contacted mother said she was headed to Oswego. (Oswego , NY ?). I think it's something about the eyes and mouth.

http://www.doenetwork.org/cases/3079dfma.html

That's actually a really good find scotiansleuth!! I think you may have hit it on the money with that one.

Super Sleuth · Dec 24, 2016

There's also a Oswego Place in West Babylon, NY, and that's not far from Gilgo Beach or Fire Island at all.

scotiansleuth · Dec 25, 2016

Thanks Super Sleuth, I have contacted NamUs with the information, see where it goes. I will post any updates.

scotiansleuth · Dec 25, 2016

Also supplied potential match to DOE network.

scotiansleuth · Dec 25, 2016

Hello Stephen,

Thank you for the suggested match. I don't show any comparison of these having been done so I will have our panel look at it. If is proven to be a positive match, I will contact you further.

Best Regards,
Mary Bell
Tips & Potential Match Coordinator
Doe Network "International Center For Unidentified And Missing Persons”

Possible Victim: Fire Island Jane Doe, UP9098, found Davis Park Apr 1996 & Ocean Parkway Apr 2011 - Karen Vergata

Active Member

Heca Firimar !

Heca Firimar !

Heca Firimar !

.

Active Member

Member

Member

Heca Firimar !

.

Well-Known Member

Attachments

Armchair Detective

Attachments

Armchair Detective

Attachments

Member

New Member

Attachments

Armchair Detective

Attachments

Armchair Detective

New Member

New Member

New Member

DNASolves

Online statistics

Forum statistics