Well, why wouldn't they have simply said so in a report, clearing up the whole matter?
Who is they?
Well, why wouldn't they have simply said so in a report, clearing up the whole matter?
But, the door was locked, so whoever killed MK had the key. If it was them, they would just have entered. There is no need to peer through windows or kick doors down.
The fact that they could not get in means that they did not lock the door. RG did.
I think it's ridiculous to assume the officer placed the lamp there. It's clear to me the lamp was there when the door was opened. It's behind the door, turned over and the cord went under the door.
That was written by a known IIP poster and is no better than an opinion post on TJMK.
Amber, allow me to follow on what you wrote in the previous tread:
Does it mean you think it's possible the bathmat print is not a result of stepping in blood and there never was a trail of bloody footsteps leading to it from Meredith's room?
I'm not sure I understand how would the barefoot bathmat print be made. How do you envision it?
Obviously we can't know with 100% certainty. One explanation you proposed is that the luminol prints are residual, made during clean up, and not a result of stepping in blood. Interesting that the clean up was made barefoot.
I'm trying to understand. I'm trying to visualize the scenario constructed from your point of view. I believe it can be done by connecting the known points of evidence and filling the unknowns with some common sense.
I agree. Either it happened, or she lied about it happening for some reason (as you state, to appear panicked about MK).
See my post above where I quote from her book , verbatim, p 69.
The first responders. Don't they report what actions they took? Don't they have flashlights?Who is they?
I agree. Either it happened, or she lied about it happening for some reason (as you state, to appear panicked about MK).
See my post above where I quote from her book , verbatim, p 69.
All you need to do is say Rudy did it. If someone asks questions regarding the how pertaining to specific points of how he did it, the supporters of her innocence can just fall back on well, he did it. We don't know how he did it, but he did.
The first responders. Don't they report what actions they took? Don't they have flashlights?
Either it didn't happen and she is just making it all up to appear panicked, or it did happen (the terrace-stunt and the kicking the door) and she is just substituting Meredith for the lamp.
Nope. Well, I suppose we can all envision our own scenarios.I haven't seen any reports. Have you?
I can easily envision, given the crowd and disorganization at the scene, that someone moved the lamp and didn't communicate it to the investigators.
Nope. Well, I suppose we can all envision our own scenarios.
I disagree. I personally don't think there is anything in the 'Guede only' scenario that cannot be explained. Could you give some examples?
There is no doubt that the Guede-as-lone-wolf scenario is a compelling one, especially after Hendry made it "come alive" with his analysis.I disagree. I personally don't think there is anything in the 'Guede only' scenario that cannot be explained. Could you give some examples?
I haven't seen any reports. Have you?
I can easily envision, given the crowd and disorganization at the scene, that someone moved the lamp and didn't communicate it to the investigators.
The first responders. Don't they report what actions they took? Don't they have flashlights?
Not much sunlight in November and it was a cloudy day, judging by the photos.Wasn't it daytime when the discovered the body? No need for lamp in the daytime.
Yes, good point. Especially if they saw that it was raising all kinds of questions.You would think if the first responders had moved the lamp, then GM wouldn't need to wonder how it got there.
What reason would they have for not saying they had placed it there?
When it was brought up as questionable why it was there, why would one not say "well I put that there" or was someone already in the mind set of framing Amanda?
SMK I'm not meaning these questions necessarily towards you, more just voicing my questions.
I would think police and responders always have flashlights because they never know what they may have to probe and look at. (even the postal police looking for cellphones in the grass).Not much sunlight in November and it was a cloudy day, judging by the photos.
Not much sunlight in November and it was a cloudy day, judging by the photos.