The email was to Hollie, who claims not long after the couple married four years ago, Jerry became very controlling. She says he'd read Susan's texts and listen in to her phone calls.
"She would have to talk to me on speakerphone when he was around because I guess he wanted to listen in to the conversation," said Hollie.
In January 2016, Susan forwarded Hollie emails that had been written by Jerry Osborne.
"The first email she sent me was the screen shot of the emails back and forth between him and other men; and the second email she sent me the same day was the profile page back from 2011 from the escort page," said Hollie Hatfield.
Hollie says her jaw dropped.
"Hi there guys! My name is Jay..."
But there it was in print. Jerry Osborne's ad on a website called Boyscort.com.
"And I'm looking for older generous gentlemen to spend some quality time with. .... Your satisfaction is guaranteed everytime. Your sexy boy toy is waiting!"
Hollie says Susan was certain her husband Jerry was the one pictured in the ad.
"She says she was able to identify him from the tattoos," Hollie tells Crime Watch Daily.
But Jerry's ink isn't the only thing that blew his cover.
"The phone number that was in that profile page was a phone number I think he used to have," said Holllie.
Hollie isn't the only person Susan told about Jerry's alleged prostituting past.
"She called me and she was very, very upset, very sick, she said 'Mom, I need to explain something to you and tell you what I found,'" said Susan's mother Linda Anklam.
Linda says her daughter wanted advice about what she should do.
"So I had asked her, you know, 'You need to talk to him and find out why,' because I thought this only happened in the past, but I think that she believed that this was happening all along," said Linda.
Linda says she never talked about it with her daughter again. But Susan did continue to confide in Hollie.
So Susan finds out that at some point her husband was a male prostitute, and currently he's cheating on her with other men. Does she confront him?
"She did later down the road at one point start mentioning to him something she found out, because he asked her why she wouldn't sleep in the bed with him," said Hollie.
But she says Susan didn't tell Jerry everything.
