Australia Australia - William Tyrrell Disappeared While Playing in Yard - Kendall (NSW) - #74

Status
Not open for further replies.


I know this has been discussed before and I know there are inconsistencies (could have been any number of missing children)which aren't able to be explained BUT :-

RD
- Thought he left the Tennis Club at 10.15 just after policewoman WH received a call about a missing child. (10.15 would have tied in to the original FFC timeline of when W could have gone missing)

BUT the CCTV times had issues and the corrected time RD left the Tennis Club was corrected to 9.43

And the reason RD said he left was due to the phone call WH received? Seems a weird reason to leave considering WH wasn't even playing tennis.
(I know it could have been coincidence or he was planning to do something totally unrelated)

Maybe RD didn't want to reveal a conversation that he overheard the details due to its sensitive matter?? MOOO


Just running with that idea - if RD have heard more than he wants to reveal about that phone call because interestingly 9.43 could have been when W went missing.

Only If the photos at 9.37 are in question!! MOO

Some relevant points that Detectives would need to clear up:-
Extracted from this post:
"And the reason RD said he left was due to the phone call WH received? Seems a weird reason to leave considering WH wasn't even playing tennis. (I know it could have been coincidence or he was planning to do something totally unrelated)

Maybe RD didn't want to reveal a conversation that he overheard the details due to its sensitive matter?? MOOO

Just running with that idea - if RD have heard more than he wants to reveal about that phone call because interestingly 9.43 could have been when W went missing.

Only If the photos at 9.37 are in question!! MOO"

If Wendy Hudson has told the Inquest (Behind closed doors) that she had initially learned about William's disappearance during that phone call at the Tennis Club, that would create an additional timeline for events (Such as the FM drive and possibly the photo times).

JMO
 
The same airport from where FM reportedly picked up her sister. They may have flown to savetime.
Which airport did she pick up her sister from? I would say her sister lived interstate? Either way there is no report of a second drive to the airport or that their friends flew in. If it wasnt mentioned in the inquest then it didn’t happen.
 
Which airport did she pick up her sister from? I would say her sister lived interstate? Either way there is no report of a second drive to the airport or that their friends flew in. If it wasnt mentioned in the inquest then it didn’t happen.
LolaAngela, do you know when FM picked up her sister from the airport?

Edited to add:

William Tyrrell's foster-mother feared her daughter would be abduction target
"I was driving to Port Macquarie Airport to collect a family member, and had this flash of [realisation that] there were two cars," she said, adding she had forgotten about them in the panic of William's disappearance.

"I just went, 'There were two cars there.' My heart just sank because I thought those two cars were there for both of them," she said.

"I got back to the house, I went straight down to the command post and I told the guy on duty. He gave me his phone and said search for the cars," she said.
 
Last edited:
Some relevant points that Detectives would need to clear up:-
Extracted from this post:
"And the reason RD said he left was due to the phone call WH received? Seems a weird reason to leave considering WH wasn't even playing tennis. (I know it could have been coincidence or he was planning to do something totally unrelated)

Maybe RD didn't want to reveal a conversation that he overheard the details due to its sensitive matter?? MOOO

Just running with that idea - if RD have heard more than he wants to reveal about that phone call because interestingly 9.43 could have been when W went missing.

Only If the photos at 9.37 are in question!! MOO"

If Wendy Hudson has told the Inquest (Behind closed doors) that she had initially learned about William's disappearance during that phone call at the Tennis Club, that would create an additional timeline for events (Such as the FM drive and possibly the photo times).

JMO
Her evidence doesn’t include this earlier call as per Dr Sleuth’s account from the inquest

Post in thread 'Australia - William Tyrrell, 3, Kendall, NSW, 12 Sep 2014 - #68'
Australia - Australia - William Tyrrell, 3, Kendall, NSW, 12 Sep 2014 - #68
 
Her evidence doesn’t include this earlier call as per Dr Sleuth’s account from the inquest

Post in thread 'Australia - William Tyrrell, 3, Kendall, NSW, 12 Sep 2014 - #68'
Australia - Australia - William Tyrrell, 3, Kendall, NSW, 12 Sep 2014 - #68
I wonder if witnesses from the Inquest were recalled...as per this link:https://www.news.com.au/national/ns...s/news-story/40851ecde70b526cada45e5ae979bebf
“Detectives investigating the disappearance of William Tyrrell are conducting more interviews after a subdued end to their renewed search for the missing boy’s remains.”

BBM Why CCTV at local club could prove crucial in William Tyrrell case
“Child advocate Allanna Smith told Daily Mail Australia that the timeline of William's last morning needed re-investigation.
'I am not here to accuse anybody,' she said, 'I am here going over the things I think have not been and should be looked at'.
She said the William Tyrrell inquest 'needed to recall' witnesses, including the policewoman Mr Donoghue spoke to that morning.
Mr Donoghue was interviewed three times by police, but never called on to give evidence before NSW State Coroner Harriet Grahame.”
 
I wonder if witnesses from the Inquest were recalled...as per this link:https://www.news.com.au/national/ns...s/news-story/40851ecde70b526cada45e5ae979bebf
“Detectives investigating the disappearance of William Tyrrell are conducting more interviews after a subdued end to their renewed search for the missing boy’s remains.”

BBM Why CCTV at local club could prove crucial in William Tyrrell case
“Child advocate Allanna Smith told Daily Mail Australia that the timeline of William's last morning needed re-investigation.
'I am not here to accuse anybody,' she said, 'I am here going over the things I think have not been and should be looked at'.
She said the William Tyrrell inquest 'needed to recall' witnesses, including the policewoman Mr Donoghue spoke to that morning.
Mr Donoghue was interviewed three times by police, but never called on to give evidence before NSW State Coroner Harriet Grahame.”
We need to work with the evidence given at the inquest though. If that is what Wendy said then that is what happened. We could speculate all day about who may have been recalled and what they may have said. I’m not sure what is the relevance of a member of the public’s comment?
 
We need to work with the evidence given at the inquest though. If that is what Wendy said then that is what happened. We could speculate all day about who may have been recalled and what they may have said. I’m not sure what is the relevance of a member of the public’s comment?

Of course, Wendy Hudson's phone records need to be checked, it's a no-brainer. It would either rule in or out Mr. Donoghue's evidence, the case is blown wide open if phone records supported what he says is true. If there was any resistance to confirming who she was talking to that would raise a red flag.

Ms. Hudson was a central figure in that first week, she assisted with the search, and was also present when William's sister was first interviewed. I do find that strange why she would be present in that interview.

If I recall she went with the carers to the beach midweek and also saw them off when they finally left to return to Sydney.

A map of homes around Benaroon Drive - Copy.jpg
 
Of course, Wendy Hudson's phone records need to be checked, it's a no-brainer. It would either rule in or out Mr. Donoghue's evidence, the case is blown wide open if phone records supported what he says is true. If there was any resistance to confirming who she was talking to that would raise a red flag.

Ms. Hudson was a central figure in that first week, she assisted with the search, and was also present when William's sister was first interviewed. I do find that strange why she would be present in that interview.

If I recall she went with the carers to the beach midweek and also saw them off when they finally left to return to Sydney.

View attachment 410199
I have no doubt police checked Wendy’s phone records and likely the CCTV from the tennis club. That would be why her evidence is accepted as fact and Mr.Donoghue wasn’t even asked to attend the inquest.
 
I have no doubt police checked Wendy’s phone records and likely the CCTV from the tennis club. That would be why her evidence is accepted as fact and Mr.Donoghue wasn’t even asked to attend the inquest.

You could very well be correct, that her records were checked etc.

However, you could view it this way too; Mr. Donoghue's not being asked to give evidence at the inquest because it potentially goes against the abduction narrative. Recall the bold statement by Craddock "proof of life " , when then discover the discrepancy with the timestamps later during the inquest.

<modsnip> There is so much to lose in this case for FACs - police handling. Thus I'm that doubting Thomas when it comes to why some evidence/testimony wasn't presented at the inquest etc.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Not only is Wendy Hudson a cop but a youth liaison officer. It's most likely she would've worked closely with the department - child agencies on occasions when dealing with youth matters.

Hudson was well known to the foster grandparents, that is a fact.

If it's important enough to have her in on the job on her days off searching and taking carers to the beach and providing them escort ..then it would be feasible enough to imagine her number was a number that may very well have been called ...that fateful day.
 
Not only is Wendy Hudson a cop but a youth liaison officer. It's most likely she would've worked closely with the department - child agencies on occasions when dealing with youth matters.

Hudson was well known to the foster grandparents, that is a fact.

If it's important enough to have her in on the job on her days off searching and taking carers to the beach and providing them escort ..then it would be feasible enough to imagine her number was a number that may very well have been called ...that fateful day.
Well known? Do you have a link for this? I believe it was assumed they knew of each other since it was a small town nothing more
 
Well known? Do you have a link for this? I believe it was assumed they knew of each other since it was a small town nothing more
With regard to how FGM knew Wendy Hudson:

Caroline Overington's book, Chapter 2:
Senior Constable Wendy Hudson was at home in Kendall at 12.20 p.m. when her sister-in-law, Allison Kennedy, called to tell her that a three-year-old was missing from Benaroon Drive.

She asked her sons, Jayden, 19, and Blake, 16, if they would come with her, and they immediately agreed. They jumped in the car and she drove around to William’s foster nana’s house. They knew each other reasonably well, since both were active in the Kendall community. They had, at times, been members of the same committees. She asked her what had happened. William’s foster nana told her they had been outside on the deck, having a cup of tea.
 
With regard to how FGM knew Wendy Hudson:

Caroline Overington's book, Chapter 2:
Senior Constable Wendy Hudson was at home in Kendall at 12.20 p.m. when her sister-in-law, Allison Kennedy, called to tell her that a three-year-old was missing from Benaroon Drive.

She asked her sons, Jayden, 19, and Blake, 16, if they would come with her, and they immediately agreed. They jumped in the car and she drove around to William’s foster nana’s house. They knew each other reasonably well, since both were active in the Kendall community. They had, at times, been members of the same committees. She asked her what had happened. William’s foster nana told her they had been outside on the deck, having a cup of tea.
Thanks for that, so they knew each from being active in the community. No different to most small towns.
 
Last edited:
Well known? Do you have a link for this? I believe it was assumed they knew of each other since it was a small town nothing more

Don't we think it would be convenient to know your local cop in a small community? The FGM was heavily involved with the local Kendall community for many years before she took a step back. Even lobbying for grants for projects to assist the community.

Imagine a scenario where an incident occurs at your house, you're in a state of panic, what should I/we do? Perhaps I call my local cop to seek advice on what they recommend. That is the context I suggest could've played out on the morning of September 12th. There's no disputing, that Ms. Hudson leaves the courts not long after Mr. Donoghue, but what causes her to do so? It might not have anything to do with William, it could've been with another youth matter, unrelated, that prompted someone to call her.

I'm not suggesting for a minute that Ms. Hudson has done anything wrong. However, if something has happened where an incident needed to be covered up it puts her in a compromising position if she has taken a call that morning, off duty, from the FGM.

That is a scenario that should be (needs to be) checked. We have no idea if the investigative team has done this.
 
JMO, it might have been comforting to the Fosters that the FGM personally knew Constable Wendy Hudson who attended quite soon.
If I remember well, WH was the first person, who thought, that something wasn't right with the disappearing. I would like to know, what exactly was going on in her mind.
 
If I remember well, WH was the first person, who thought, that something wasn't right with the disappearing. I would like to know, what exactly was going on in her mind.
FromGermany1, did you mean to say WH?

Because:
When Detective Vanessa Partridge arrived at the scene that evening, she knew immediately something wasn’t right.

“I just had this feeling that things weren’t right. There’s… There’s something wrong. William’s not missing,” she told 60 Minutes.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
149
Guests online
929
Total visitors
1,078

Forum statistics

Threads
589,931
Messages
17,927,844
Members
228,004
Latest member
CarpSleuth
Back
Top