Though another psychic we spoke did not hesitate.
"I can usually feel if they've passed on. She doesn't feel passed on. Not at all, she doesn't."
She's one of several psychics we contacted.
While she never worked on this case with the family, she's the only psychic, other than DuBois who'd go on record with her thoughts.
"I still think there's a potential of her returning in three, could be three or five years, something like that," Aitreyia says. "But like I said, I keep seeing her playing, keep seeing her happy."
Without revealing any of that information to Aitreyia, she said whoever abducted Isabel didn't intend to keep her this long.
Though plans changed after seeing all the attention the case received nationally, even into Mexico.
"That person has not returned her because I think they're more afraid of persecution and things like that," Aitreyia says.
Over the last 25 years Aitreyia has helped find missing people from Arizona to Florida.
Again, she believes Isabel is still alive, probably somewhere south of the border.