Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
4h
It’s 7:30 and I’m outside the courthouse for day 4 of US v Elizabeth Holmes. The line outside isn’t so bad this morning - mostly tv press and random spectators. A lady behind me says she had work off today so decided to come watch. The case is “big for Silicon Valley,” she says.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
2h
Erika Cheung is back on the stand to wrap up her cross-examination and any rebuttal qs, before Gangakhedkar is expected to testify. Holmes' counsel begins by asking her about Theranos' lab database and software.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
2h
Holmes' counsel says he's concerned the gov't will mention Gangakhedkar's immunity deal to wrongfully suggest she and others at Theranos committed crimes. A prosecutor says he won't make that suggestion, and the judge notes that immunity deals aren't uncommon in criminal trials.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
2h
Holmes' counsel Lance Wade asks Cheung if she can recall how many patient tests were conducted monthly on the Edison when it was launched in Walgreens in late 2013. She repeatedly replies she doesn't know. "I understand, it’s a specific question from a long time ago," he says.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
2h
Wade points to a standard-operating-procedure "corrective" policy document that Theranos had explaining what to do in the case tests had errors. "I have never seen this document," Cheung says.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
2h
Wade brings up the David Boies letter Cheung received in July 2015. She says she began talking with then-WSJ reporter John Carreyrou about Theranos in May 2015, and after she received two calls from Theranos' HR head, which she didn't return, before she got the letter from Boies.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Wade shows Cheung emails b/w Tyler Shultz and Holmes. Shultz asked Holmes to meet in person and Holmes replied that she was tied up, but she asked Shultz to email her to be sure everything 'gets addressed.' That prompted Shultz's long email. (Feds left the exchange out on direct)
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Wade points to a patent authored by Theranos engineers on "Devices methods and systems for reducing sample volume." He asks Cheung about the patent claims, but she says it was after her time at Theranos and she doesn't know specifics about patents. Wade moves on.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Wade wraps Cheung's cross-examination showing her some more Theranos policy documents, which she says she's never seen. John Bostic is now up for the gov't on redirect.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Bostic asks Cheung how many tests out of the hundreds of tests offered by Theranos could be done on the Edison w/ blood from a fingerstick prick. She replies only 4-9 tests could be done on the Edison.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Cheung says she started having concerns about Theranos' blood tests after a month working there and there were problems with machine performance. "We had people sleeping in their car because it was taking too long... we had to perform these samples over and over and over."
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Cheung on Theranos' policies and the Edison blood test devices: "Just because they’re less expensive doesn’t mean you should give people false information about their health status... It shouldn’t be the case [that] because you pay less, you get a less quality result."
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Cheung's examination wraps w/ her saying she didn't answer the calls from Theranos' HR head Mona Ramamurthy b/c "when I heard Mona’s voice and heard how scared she was" Cheung said she remembered how scared she felt while working at Theranos.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Cheung: "I just felt I didn’t have to. It wasn’t my responsibility to pick up the phone and talk to these people -- that it was my responsibility not to speak to them." With that, Cheung's examination is over w/o re-cross. Ex-Theranos team manager Surekha Gangakhedkar is up next.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
1h
Gangakhedkar begins by recalling that she started working at Theranos in 2005 and was eventually promoted to assay systems team manager. She eventually resigned in Aug 2013, over her concerns with the Edison devices. "I was not aligned with some of those decisions," she says.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
50m
Gangakhedkar says GSK evaluated certain Theranos tests in 2008, but she would not have said GSK "comprehensively validated the technology," b/c "this was just a single study." We're taking a break, and will be back in ~45.
Dorothy Atkins@doratki·
11m
Courtroom trial break banter among certain counsel/court staff is about how grateful everybody is that this isn't a patent case. (for real)