CA - Orson & Orrin West (3&4), MEDIA, MAPS & TIMELINE - NO DISCUSSION

MAR 2, updated MAR 3, 2022
Orrin and Orson West case: How we broke the story (kget.com)
A few weeks ago 17 News received a tip: A couple vans had pulled up outside a home on Aspen Avenue in California City and disgorged a group of people escorted by deputies.

[...]

The tipster provided video of a group of people in casual dress examining a yard, deputies and other, unidentified men in suits visible.

[...]

After viewing the video, our best guess was the casually dressed group was the Kern County grand jury. We surmised they had been assigned the task of reviewing evidence for possible charges in the West investigation.

[...]

After receiving the tip, I spent every morning and most afternoons at the courthouse, specifically Department 1, where we believed it most likely information about the case would be heard. Maybe I’d show up and find Trezell West sitting among the defendants or District Attorney Cynthia Zimmer in the audience holding a stack of documents.

[...]

Also, dozens of times a day, I plugged the names of Trezell and Jacqueline West into the sheriff’s online inmate search and Kern County Superior Court’s defendant search. Days and then weeks passed without a hit.

I did, however, notice something interesting on repeated visits to the sixth floor of the courthouse, which is where the grand jury meets. On one occasion I saw a man who was clearly an investigator walk into a room, and on another I saw one of the county’s top prosecutors, Eric Smith, who handles the DA’s highest profile cases.

[...]

On Tuesday afternoon I went back to Department 1. The grand jury was waiting outside the courtroom. They were let in shortly before 1:30 p.m. I was told to wait outside.

[...]

About the same time Tuesday, KGET and Telemundo Valle Central reporters tracked the Wests to the tiny post office in the community of Edison, southeast of Bakersfield.

In the nearby convenience store, Trezell West gave a false name to reporters Christian Galeno and Jose Gaspar . . . but said he knew the West family.

A moment later, a clerk confirmed he had just checked the man’s ID — it was Trezell West.

A customer overheard the conversation and, when West drove away in an RV, the customer followed him and snapped a cellphone picture.

The customer posted the RV photo on a local Facebook page, where it received dozens of comments and shares before it was removed.

Back at the office, I repeatedly looked up the adoptive parents’ names. Shortly before 5 p.m., the Superior Court website showed Trezell West had been charged with two counts of second-degree murder, two counts of willful cruelty to a child and a charge of falsely reporting an emergency. Jacqueline West was not listed.

[...]
 
Apologies for this question if already answered. Does anyone know the adoption laws in the jurisdiction the boys where adopted in?
 
MAR 3, 2022
Father of West boys speaks, for first time since arrest of Trezell and Jacqueline West | KBAK (bakersfieldnow.com)
CP, the biological Father of four-year-old Orrin, birth name Cincere and three-year-old Orson, birth name Classic, reacting to the boys' adoptive parents Trezell and Jacqueline West being arrested and indicted this week.

[...]

Pettus is suing Kern County for Child Protective Services wrongfully removing the boys out of his home and putting them into the home of Trezell and Jacquline.

When Cincere, Orrin was three months old he fractured his femur. His parents took him to the hospital. The authorities were notified. They found no sign of abuse. Castillo says after Classic, Orson was born CPS removed both boys from their parents, 11 days after Classic was born.

"It just doesn't make sense, why the two boys were taken away and then still two of their children, their siblings were still left in the household," Castillo, said. "Either a house is unsafe or it's not. Either parents are unfit or their not. You don't just take two away. It doesn't make any sense."

The attorney for the biological father of the boys tells me Orrin and Orson were originally given to a foster family that the biological parents and boys liked. He says the boys were happy and healthy.

Then he says Child Protective Services moved them to Trazell and Jacqueline West.

[...]

Castillo says immediately after the boys were given to Trezell and Jacqueline it was obvious to their biological family that they were losing weight, they looked unkept, not happy and unclean.
 
MAR 3, 2022
Orrin and Orson West adoptive parents' indictment details (kget.com)
Along with charges of murder and child cruelty filed against the adoptive parents of Orrin and Orson West are a number of circumstances in aggravation, among them that they induced a minor to assist in committing a crime.

Which juvenile, if more than one was involved and exactly what they did is not contained in the indictment, which simply lays out the charges and circumstances in aggravation against Trezell and Jacqueline West. ...

[...]

Other circumstances in aggravation listed in the indictment are as follows: the victims were particularly vulnerable due to their age; the Wests occupied a position of leadership or dominance over other participants in the commission of the crime; they threatened witnesses, unlawfully prevented witnesses from testifying or otherwise interfered with the judicial process; they took advantage of a position of trust or confidence; they committed a crime that involved great violence showing a high degree of cruelty, viciousness or callousness; and the manner in which the crime was carried out indicates planning, sophistication or professionalism.

A hearing on a gag order and to seal documents related to the case is scheduled next week.
 
Updated: Mar 7, 2022 / 05:37 PM PST
Defense counsel for Trezell and Jacqueline West to hold news conference (kget.com)
[...]

Defense counsel for the adoptive parents of Orson and Orrin West accused District Attorney Cynthia Zimmer of misleading the public and preying on people’s emotions during her press conference last week.

“Statements that have been used by the Kern County District Attorney in her press conference tend to invoke a tidal wave of emotion toward finding guilt, whether substantiated or not, and this will taint a local jury pool and could deny our clients a chance at a fair trial,” said Timothy Hennessy, attorney for Trezell West. “It’s odd that the office held their press conference, made a series of comments which both mis-and-disinformed the public then the following day came and requested a gag order to stop the defense from having an ability to make similar comments.

“This action is disingenuous but may also cause a change of venue in the future. This is an election year and this case is serving as a compass to guide the DA to her path of reelection. However, now is the time when the misleading and theater end and the constitutional protections begin.”

The phrasing used by Zimmer — saying the grand jury was “convinced” and it “believed” — is not a legal standard used at trial, Hennessy said. He said the standard of proof at grand jury proceedings is much lower than the standard of being found guilty beyond a reasonable doubt required at trial.

[...]
 
MAR 8, 2022
Gag order issued in West case (kget.com)
A Kern County judge on Tuesday issued a gag order in the case of a couple accused of killing two of their adopted children.

The order bars attorneys and their investigators and law enforcement involved in the case of Trezell and Jacqueline West from speaking publicly about it. It also applies to witnesses and court personnel with access to reports filed in the case.

Additionally, Judge Chad A. Louie ordered all search warrants and grand jury transcripts sealed.

Prosecutor Eric Smith had requested the gag order and defense lawyers Timothy Hennessy and Alekxia Torres Stallings joined in the motion.

[...]
 
MAR 8, 2022
Gag order set for remainder of trial for West Boys case (turnto23.com)
[...]

Meanwhile, given Tuesday’s hearing was a motion, Jacqueline and Trezell West were not physically in court. The attorneys representing them were and agreed to the gag order and are asking to extend the order to others.

Prosecutor Eric Smith originally did not list witnesses in the motion, but after it was brought up to the judge, the West's attorneys submitted to include witnesses.

“I don’t have any issue with that, the issue would be contacting all of the witnesses in an appropriate fashion and let them know there is a gag order,” said Smith.

The prosecutor will have until March 15 to let witnesses know of the gag order.

[...]

Judge grants gag order in case against adoptive parents of Cal City boys | Breaking | bakersfield.com
Torres Stallings also requested the gag order be imposed on all witnesses.

Smith did not object to the defense’s request, but he asked the court to have until Tuesday to contact every witness and inform them of the gag order.
 
MAR 2, 2022
Neighbors react to West Boys parents murder charges (turnto23.com)
[...]

Thompson’s dad and stepmom live directly behind the adoptive parents’ old residence in California City, where they were first reported missing. They say cracks are wide enough to see inside their backyard from the pool, but Thompson said her parents never saw the boys or any children at all.

“Even my parents say, within [those] six months they were supposed to be renting that house, they never once saw anybody. And their kitchen door faces the back of the house, and they’re there several times a day, and they never saw anything. No lights on at night, or anything.”

But neighbor, JQ saw something during his daytime walk weeks before the boys were reported missing.

“I remember seeing a van. I believe they had a white van. They had backed it up against the door, completely! Like they were trying to seal the scene, so that nobody could see who was going out or going in.”

JQ said he's seen kids at or by the house before but never the missing West boys. ...

[...]
 
MAR 16, 2022
Motion granted in Trezell, Jacqueline West case (kget.com)
A defense motion was granted Wednesday ordering prosecutors to turn over information gathered in the case against accused child killers Trezell and Jacqueline West but redact material that would violate medical privacy laws.

Prosecutor Bryant Estep acknowledged defense lawyers Timothy Hennessy and Alekxia Torres Stallings were entitled to the discovery and said it will be provided.

Estep said a “voluminous amount of material” has been gathered which the District Attorney’s office is uploading to a digital format. He estimated it’s equivalent to 200 to 300 gigabytes of data.

A new motions date in the case was set for Tuesday. Judge Chad A. Louie said the defendants must appear. Defense counsel appeared on their behalf for Wednesday’s hearing.

[...]
 
MAR 22, 2022
Trezell, Jacqueline West served with criminal protective orders (kget.com)
The California City couple charged with killing Orrin and Orson West were served criminal protective orders Tuesday in connection with their other children.

[...]

While not stated in court, filing such a motion suggests at least one of the children may have witnessed a crime and be called to testify. Along with charges of murder and child cruelty brought against the Wests is an allegation that they induced a minor to assist in committing a crime.

[...]

During the morning session Alekxia Torres Stallings, defense lawyer for Jacqueline West, told the court the Wests last year were allowed twice-weekly visits after their remaining children were taken into protective custody.

[...]

The Wests are supervised during the visits.

“Under no circumstances are they allowed to be alone with their children,” Torres Stallings said.

She said now that the Wests are in custody they would likely be limited to monthly visits which could be done in-person or virtually — and the Wests were willing to take the latter option.

Prosecutors have said Orrin, 4, and Orson, 3, were killed three months before the Wests reported them missing. Their bodies have not been found.

[...]
 
MAR 22, 2022
Judge hears motion to bar Cal City toddlers’ adoptive parents from visiting their other kids | News | bakersfield.com
[...]

It is unclear if Judge Chad A. Louie granted the prosecutors’ motion, or adjudicated any other matter regarding the filing, because the public was barred from the afternoon hearing where it was scheduled to be heard. When the public was allowed into the courtroom, Torres Stallings and Tim Hennessy, representing Jacqueline and Trezell West, respectively, said they “received the criminal protective order,” but there was no explanation as to what that meant or what was decided.

At the hearing earlier in the day, Torres Stallings said their clients visited their children twice a week for the past 10 months. These meetings were monitored. The Wests also underwent strict drug and alcohol testing while attending parenting classes, she said.

After the Wests were in custody, the visitation schedule was modified to one visit per month either in person or virtually, she added. Torres Stallings said she believes the parents will visit the children virtually, thereby removing a need for the criminal protective order.

[...]
 
MAR 23, 2022
Judge grants motion to prohibit Cal City brothers' adoptive parents from visiting their other children | News | bakersfield.com
[...]

“The motion of (the district attorney) for issuance of a criminal protective order was granted,” Kristin Davis, spokeswoman for Kern County Superior Court, said to The Californian on Wednesday.

Davis declined to speak on the motion’s specific details because of the gag order. Judge Chad A. Louie precluded the public from attending a Tuesday afternoon hearing where the motion was discussed.

[...]
 
APR 23, 2022
Orrin and Orson West's biological mother, grandmother seek $40 million from county
Sixteen months have passed since toddlers Orrin and Orson West were first reported missing. Last month, adoptive parents Trazell and Jacqueline West were arrested on murder charges. Now, the boys' biological mother and maternal grandmother are demanding $40 million in damages from the county.

They sent a claim to the Board of Supervisors, and it is expected to be reviewed at their next meeting on Tuesday during their closed session.

[...]

The murder trial is scheduled to begin on May 23.
 
JUN 2, 2022
[...]

Originally set to start in May, the trial was moved back to July 25. Further postponements are possible.

Lawsuits filed

The biological parents of Orrin and Orson have taken legal action against the county, saying negligence by the Department of Human Services contributed to the boys’ deaths.

Ryan Dean, the boys’ mother, filed a claim — the precursor to a lawsuit — seeking $40 million. It alleges the department unlawfully took the children and put them in harm’s way.

“Respondent and its employees acted affirmatively and used their authority in a way that created a danger to the children or that rendered the children more vulnerable to danger than had the state not acted at all,” according to the claim filed by San Francisco-based McCoy Law Firm.

Human Services ignored reports of suspected abuse by the Wests, according to the claim, resulting in their deaths.

Orrin was taken from Dean on Nov. 13, 2016, after she returned home from work and found the then-3-month-old “crying uncontrollably,” the claim says.

The boy’s biological father, Charles Pettus had been home with the child.

Dean took Orrin to Memorial Hospital, where it was discovered his legs were broken. Suspecting abuse, Human Services took the child, the claim says.

In June 2017, Dean gave birth to Orson. He was released into her care, according to the claim, but days later was taken from her.

Charles-Pettus2.jpg
Charles Pettus, 17 News file image.

[...]

Pettus has also filed suit and has a hearing scheduled for August.

In the meantime, the question remains: Where are the boys?
 

Staff online

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
197
Guests online
3,330
Total visitors
3,527

Forum statistics

Threads
592,308
Messages
17,967,112
Members
228,739
Latest member
eagerhuntress
Back
Top