investikater
Well-Known Member
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2021
- Messages
- 931
- Reaction score
- 4,150
Oh boy. I so hope that everyone knows what they are doing
The conflicting diagnosis is also concerning
Schizoaffective disorder VS psychotic episode during major depression
That's a relief, thank you for your expert input.That isn't really all that concerning.
Schizoaffective disorder means the psychotic symptoms are present even without depression. Depression with psychosis just means the psychotic symptoms are present when the person is depressed. Treatment for both is exactly the same so the diagnosis doesn't matter much as long as it's one of the two. We'll see what happens in this case, but if this is the legitimate diagnosis, particularly the Schizoaffective dx, then this treatment plan could work very well and actually is a novel way of reducing the burden on prisons. The whole point of prison is to protect the public from dangerous criminals. General criminality is not usually treatable outpatient. Schizoaffective disorder is. Someone with schizoaffective disorder behind bars is likely to get sub-par treatment, will likely be introduced to other harmful behaviors and substances while incarcerated, and will be taking up a cell that could be used by a hardened criminal we have to release early to prevent overcrowding. Meanwhile, if the schizoaffective patient can get suitable outpatient care (and this treatment plan sounds suitable, particulary the drug levels twice a week), then I think it's reasonable.
That's a relief, thank you for your expert input.
Are you able to explain why they disagreed on the diagnosis?
Also does Schizoaffective disorder have a young onset like schizophrenia?
Because if so I don't understand how he was high functioning enough to get through medical school?
Wow that's amazing. Thanks very much again for your insight.The two diagnoses are difficult to distinguish without knowing the patient for some time or relying on a reliable historian, such as former treaters they may have seen or medical records.
In schizoaffective disorder, the psychosis is the predominant feature. These patients can be psychotic without depression. However, anytime they're depressed, they're also psychotic. The depression is never present by itself. There are different types of schizoaffective disorders. The one he likely has (if this is the correct diagnosis) is schizoaffective disorder, depressed type.
In major depression with psychosis or psychotic depression (the latter is an outdated term), the patient can be depressed without being psychotic. But they will never be psychotic without depression playing a role.
These two illnesses represent the relationship between psychosis and mood. In one, it's the psychosis driving the pathologic mood (psychosis --> depression). In the other, it's the mood triggering psychosis (depression --> psychotic).
If they haven't known the patient long enough, then it becomes impossible to tell if the patient has ever had psychosis without depression or ever had depression without psychosis. Since the patient is likely ill when you meet them, the patient probably can't tell you (plus, they likely lack the insight to tell you). But without a reliable family member, former treater or medical records, you have no way of knowing if it's the psychosis or the depression that's the prominent "always-there" symptom without knowing the patient for some time.
Yes, schizoaffective disorder typically has a younger onset, but generally isn't as severe as schizophrenia can be. Don't fool yourself, there are people with schizophrenia who are extremely high functioning. These people DO become doctors, CEOs, top government officials, Nobel Prize winners (like John Nash), celebrities, legislators, teachers, lawyers, and everything in between. As a society, we're programmed to see people with schizophrenia as those who are homeless, addicted to drugs or alcohol and needing group homes to survive. In fact, there are many out there who either have a milder course of the illness or take their medications and are compliant with treatment and are able to do well for themselves. The thing is, those who are successful are very reluctant to say they have schizophrenia because of the stigma. Imagine a Fortune 500 company CEO saying it. It wouldn't happen because people would lose trust in his or her ability to run the company even if he or she has already done so successfully for years. So they keep quiet. But I promise you they exist. It's a shame that all we hear about are the ones who don't do well.
The conflicting diagnosis is also concerning
Schizoaffective disorder VS psychotic episode during major depression
Very hard to distinguish. I'm surprised they didn't add Bipolar II. What's weird about this particular psychotic episode, if such it was, is that the man was apparently able to converse well enough that his wife thought he was relatively normal/okay to drive with. He drove quite a way successfully in this state.
Oh my. How did anyone survive that crash? Extraordinary.There is a two minute video of passengers rescued after Tesla plunges off the cliff. It's worth the watch, imo.
Rescue workers, emergency services (Im leaving so many out), but you know who you are do such amazing work- risking their lives to save others.
A hearing regarding the mental health diversion is scheduled for July 1.
California doctor who intentionally drove Tesla off cliff will not face trial
Dharmesh Patel was charged with attempted murder after he was accused of driving his Tesla off a cliff with his wife and children inside last year.www.usatoday.com
Bipolar II doesn't usually include psychotic episodes and we haven't heard of hypomania here as far as I know.
I have a feeling he will bend (break) a few of these rules. No way is he going to stay away from his wife and kids for two years. They will be at his parents’ house.Dharmesh Arvind Patel, who was charged with three counts of attempted murder, will not be allowed to practice medicine, smoke marijuana, drink alcohol or see his wife and children during the program, according to county prosecutors.
San Mateo County Superior Court Judge Susan M. Jakubowski ordered the treatment over objections from prosecutors.
A doctor who drove his family off a cliff will receive mental health care
July 8, 2024