Canada - Bruce McArthur- Pleads Guilty - murders of 8 men, Toronto, 2010-2017 #2

I was told that the warrants on police is for information obtained from other investigatons — like the cannibal ring. Not sure why they need a warrant and can’t just access the info between departments. Maybe it just makes it easier to obtain.
 
I was told that the warrants on police is for information obtained from other investigatons — like the cannibal ring. Not sure why they need a warrant and can’t just access the info between departments. Maybe it just makes it easier to obtain.

It’s possible that they’re going the warrant route because of the official complaint by the lead investigator on BM’s case.

JMO, because I have no idea of what the procedures for such a complaint would be.
 
I was told that the warrants on police is for information obtained from other investigatons — like the cannibal ring. Not sure why they need a warrant and can’t just access the info between departments. Maybe it just makes it easier to obtain.
Yes, I read this somewhere...Police services are a very big bureaucracy, so just like for any other organization, they issue a warrant in order to make retrieving files a matter of urgency vs something that goes to the bottom of the inbox.
 
Unsealed warrants show trail police followed to Bruce McArthur's arrest | CBC News
"From Project Houston to Bruce McArthur's arrest: a timeline of what we know so far
Unsealed warrant information sheds light on investigations into missing men that led to alleged serial killer"


"Nearly five months after alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur's arrest, unsealed warrant information has revealed new details about police investigations into missing men from Toronto's Gay Village.
CBC Toronto and other media outlets are in court fighting to unseal more than 88 judicial orders obtained by investigators in Project Houston and Project Prism."

"The timeline below includes the information that has been unsealed from the investigations, along with most of CBC Toronto's reporting so far."

 
WHY IS GOLDEN STATE KILLER SUSPECT JOSEPH DEANGELO IN A CAGE IN COURT APPEARANCES? HOW COULD IT AFFECT HIS TRIAL?

"He stood in a cage with metal bars. A sign on it warned others in the courtroom not to talk to the man inside.

Joseph DeAngelo, the 72-year-old Golden State Killer suspect, peered through the bars while locked up inside a Sacramento courtroom last month. It was the second time since his arrest in April that the accused serial killer appeared in court in a cage, resembling Hannibal Lecter in "The Silence of the Lambs."

It's a stunning image that, some experts say, could subliminally sway the entire case.

“We just saw something that we've only seen in the movies, which is why it's so tough to wrap one's head around it,” Lance Reenstierna, co-host of two popular true crime podcasts (Missing Maura Murray and Crawlspace), told Oxygen.com. “What is inevitable and unfortunate is that the cage elevates him to a legend status as a serial killer.”..."

Why Is Golden State Killer Suspect Joseph DeAngelo In A Cage In Court Appearances? How Could It Affect His Trial?
---

FOX40 was live.
May 29 at 9:04am ·
LIVE: East Area Rapist suspect Joseph DeAngelo appears in court.

(video link )

https://pbs.twimg.com/media/DeYQwpCWkAAGE7z.jpg
---

Are the unknown victims of alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur hidden among these 22 cold cases?
The Post combed through 186 Toronto cold cases and countless newspaper reports between 1975 and 1997, searching for a pattern (with clip)


"...Police are cracking open the files on decades-old cases again, looking for any connection to McArthur. At an April press conference, Det-Sgt. Hank Idsinga said that police were digging into 15 cold cases between 1975 and 1997.

When pressed for more details about the cold cases at an April 11 press conference, Idsinga was asked if all the victims were gay men. Idsinga said he didn’t want to be specific about the lifestyles of the cold case victims and said police were aware of a CBC broadcast that focused on seven cases from the 1970s. “We’re aware of those and we’re looking at those. And the majority of them are of gay men.”

That number has since grown to include more than 20 cold cases, the National Post has learned, over an expanded timeline that Idsinga would not clarify....

These are the 22 cold cases (in chronological order):..."

Are the unknown victims of alleged serial killer Bruce McArthur hidden among these 22 cold cases?
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Case of accused serial killer Bruce McArthur put over to July 23
"TORONTO -- The prosecution says it has now turned over all its evidence to the defence of a Toronto man accused of being a serial killer.

They say lawyers for Bruce McArthur can now begin compiling their list of witnesses.

McArthur appeared by video link from a Toronto jail today, and his case was put over to July 23."
 
Family of alleged McArthur victim wants public inquiry
The family of a man allegedly murdered by accused serial killer Bruce McArthur is calling for a public inquiry into the police investigation of several men who went missing from Toronto's gay village.
Selim Esen's brother issued the demand after a brief court hearing for McArthur on Friday, where his case was put over until July 23 as prosecutors said they had handed over all their evidence to the defence.
 
Lengthy article.
How alleged Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur went unnoticed
June 23 2018
"From Santa to serial killer

While investigators are still developing a profile of the alleged serial killer, they are certain of one thing. The jolly-looking McArthur, who is divorced and has two grown children, did not have the menacing countenance of a serial murderer.

In fact, he was so convincingly harmless looking that he was able to play Santa in at least one suburban shopping mall. His age, as well as his unthreatening appearance – round features and a broad, cheery smile – made him seem approachable to children shopping with their parents, as well as to gay men seeking a dark sexual encounter with someone they could trust.

After divorcing his wife, McArthur, who had been active on his church board in Oshawa, east of Toronto, became a regular in the city’s gay village. He trolled hook-up sites like Manjam and Recon, where the “silver fox” made his taste for submissive men clear – especially those who wanted to test the limits of their curiosity for dangerous sex."
"Just as gay men from North Bay and Moose Jaw flocked to Toronto in the 1970s to live free and open lives, a new generation of gay men from south Asia and the Middle East have been drawn to Canada in the last 20 years for the same reasons. The new arrivals may revel in Canada’s acceptance, but they are still vulnerable – still suspicious of authority, reluctant to attract attention, perhaps too eager to fit in. And perhaps too trusting of a gentle-looking older man who appears harmless.

Predators thrive on marginalized groups, says University of Toronto associate professor of sociology Jooyoung Lee, an expert in violent crime and serial homicide. Gay men – particularly gay refugees or other relatively new Canadians – fit into a population that includes prostitutes, aboriginal women and immigrants.

And then there is what Lee refers to as “missing white woman syndrome”: the idea that police, media and the public are less inclined to pay attention to crimes that are perpetrated on marginalized communities."
 
Excellent article ^

--
It was a holiday tradition each Halloween during the 1960s and 70s for Toronto residents to taunt gay men, especially drag queens, as they entered bars on Yonge Street like the St Charles Tavern and the Parkside. They pelted eggs, which turned into rocks, which turned into beatings on darkened side streets.

Police mostly looked the other way, recalls the Rev Brent Hawkes, a longtime leader of the city’s gay rights movement who was once himself restrained on a sidewalk by two officers as a third punched him. “Stories of men being arrested and taken to Cherry Beach for a beating were common,” he says. Officers would lurk beside the urinals in bars, waiting for men to engage in a sexual act. Entrapment was widespread at department stores, universities and hotels such as Hudson’s Bay, the Royal York and the University of Toronto.

“Sex had to be quick and anonymous,” says Hooper. “There was no courtship that led to sex. If you were married and lived in the suburbs – and you were gay – you had to hook up on your lunch break.”

The constant harassment by police reach the boiling point in 1981, when 200 police officers descended on four gay bathhouses. They marched through the corridors, swinging crowbars and sledgehammers, breaking down doors and corralling groups of men into showers and lounge areas. One officer reportedly commented that he wished the showers were hooked up to gas, Hooper said. Men were arrested and charged according to the city’s antiquated bawdy house laws.

A few of the officers were apologetic, but another boisterous contingent “seemed to enjoy it – like jocks in a frat house”, says Hooper.

By morning, 250 men had been charged. The humiliation caused some to contemplate suicide. Others were fired from their jobs after police officers called their employers. Many lost the support of family and friends.

The raids were a tipping point for Toronto’s gay community. Like the Stonewall riots in New York, the bathhouse raids ignited a fury that led to the city’s modern gay pride movement.
--​
 
Judge named to lead review of Toronto police handling of missing person cases - CityNews Toronto

The Toronto Police Services Board says it has retained an Ontario Appeal Court judge to lead an external review into how the police force handles cases of missing persons.

The board says in a statement that Justice Gloria Epstein will be retiring Sept. 1 and will then “be devoting herself thereafter to the review.”

The announcement comes about three months after Mayor John Tory moved a motion to go ahead with the review, saying there were “troubling questions” in light of the killings for which landscaper Bruce McArthur has been charged.

While the review won’t look at the investigation into McArthur, who has been charged with eight counts of first-degree murder, it will examine how missing persons cases connected to the investigation were handled.

The review also follows the death in November 2017 of 22-year-old Tess Richey, whose body was found by her mother in an outdoor stairwell.

[...]
 
How alleged Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur went unnoticed

"A friendly gardener and mall Santa, McArthur may also have been the worst ever serial killer of gay men. As Toronto police reopen 25 cold cases dating back to 1975, they are facing tough questions about decades of hostility to the gay community

When the biggest forensic investigation in Toronto history began, it was still possible to be blind to the full extent of the horror...."

How alleged Toronto serial killer Bruce McArthur went unnoticed
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Bruce McArthur showed ‘minimal’ potential for violence, 2003 report concluded | The Star
“There is no trace of psychosis, no trace of hallucinations or delusions, no trace of mood disorder and no trace of any personality disorder or anti-social behaviour,” Dionne wrote. “As a matter of fact, Mr. McArthur is well oriented in space, time and toward people.”

The report paints the picture of a man who tried to be well-liked and obey others, but might possess “underlying resentments.” He was passive, indecisive, tended to procrastinate and could easily be upset by changes to his daily routine, Dionne wrote. He also lacked insight into himself."

"Palladino’s pre-sentence report chronicles McArthur’s childhood and how he struggled with his homosexuality until his forties. Born in Lindsay, Ont. in 1951, McArthur was very close to his mother, but felt he could never please his father, who was tough on him, the report says.

“Looking back, the subject questions whether this was due to his father sensing his homosexuality or lack of masculinity,” the report states.

His parents were both very religious, but practised different faiths, which led to a lot of arguments, Palladino wrote. McArthur would often side with his mother, which resulted in “verbal abuse” from his father."
 
Analysis from McArthur assault trial in 2003 shows ‘absolutely no signs of psychopathy’

"...According to the court documents, the psychiatric report concluded that McArthur’s personality profiles were “within normal range.”...

The analysis, conducted by Dr. Marie-France Dionne, further concluded that McArthur’s “risk for violence is very minimal.”...

Here are the full court documents:...

Analysis from McArthur assault trial in 2003 shows ‘absolutely no signs of psychopathy’

Judge's decision to release McArthur documents

Judge's Decision to release McArthur documents

2003 McArthur psychological report

2003 McArthur Psychological Report

2003 McArthur pre-sentence report

Analysis from McArthur assault trial in 2003 shows ‘absolutely no signs of psychopathy’
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
 
Each of BM's parents were apparently very religious but had differing views that caused arguments, BM took his mother's side and also regularly attended church.
BM's alleged victims seem to be from different religious backgrounds, did any share the same religion as either one of his parents, or BM?
Did BM remain heavily involved with the church out of " devotion" or to " hide in plain sight"?
Would a mental health pro. be swayed by such a person's religious " devotion" especially if it is a shared one?
imo speculation.
Bruce McArthur showed ‘minimal’ potential for violence, 2003 report concluded | The Star
"His parents were both very religious, but practised different faiths, which led to a lot of arguments, Palladino wrote. McArthur would often side with his mother, which resulted in “verbal abuse” from his father."
"He became very active in his church, and told Palladino he later realized his hectic schedule was “likely to avoid dealing with his feelings of guilt for being gay.”
 
Police are back searching at Mallory Gardens property today.

They have the large Command Centre vehicle as well as others and are working with the Forensics Dept. Further excavation is needed according to the article on their website.

Nothing was found on the other 100 properties searched.

Now, they are saying that there will be an update in a few weeks after the excavation is completed.

Tent is up again, area is roped off with police tape.

Stay tuned.
 
Last edited:
Det. Sgt. Hank Idsinga, the lead investigator in the case, had said earlier this year that the search for further remains at the Mallory Crescent location will continue once the weather warmed up and that cadaver dogs will be deployed for the ground investigation.

Police said they will conduct further excavation of the area and an update on the search will be provided once the operation is complete.

Toronto police continue search at Mallory Crescent property linked to Bruce McArthur - Toronto | Globalnews.ca
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
60
Guests online
3,072
Total visitors
3,132

Forum statistics

Threads
592,184
Messages
17,964,813
Members
228,714
Latest member
hannahdunnam
Back
Top