If someone accurately guessed that a victim was from the tristate area state of Connecticut, which is only an hour drive away from Gilgo, that is not specific at all. What would have been strange is if someone accurately predicted the identify of the victims. Just guessing a state is not specific AT ALL. However, royceking later wrote that he/she wasn't specific in everything he/she originally stated. I was only concerned with one piece of what could have been a lot of information in the comment.