IN IN - Paul Raymond Harrod, adult, may have been using false identity, Hamilton County, 27 Nov 1992

StarrChance

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2008
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
3,307
LG history short version

Charges Filed Date​

Jan 15, 2022

Charges/Offenses​

Cocaine/Possession | Cocainepossession | Cocaine/ Possession | Battery/Aggravated | Battery/Aggravated | Tamper With Physical Evidence | Tamper/Phys Evidence | Cocaine/Possession | Cocaine/Possession | Burglary/Unoccupied Conveyance | Burglary Tools/Possession | Probation Violation | Grand Theft 3rd Deg/$300+/-5000 | Grand Theft 3rd Degree/Vehicle | Burglary Tools/Possession | Burglary/Unocc Convy | Grd Theft/3d/Vehicle | Grd Thft/3d/300+/-5k | Probation Violation | Probation Violation | Operating Without Valid License | Fail Register Vehicle | Assault And Battery/County Ordinance | Assault And Battery | Prostitution/County Ordinance
 

StarrChance

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 15, 2008
Messages
1,494
Reaction score
3,307
Warning very long version

Male

Physical Appearance​

Eye Color
Bro,Gnn
Hair Color
Blk,Bln,Whi
Height
NaN'NaN"
Weight
000,160,170,195 Lbs

Jan 15, 2022 - Charges Filed - Cocaine/Possession​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 15, 2022
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Cocaine/Possession
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
893.13(6)(A)
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F22000781
Arrest Date
Jan 14, 2022
Disposition
Conviction With Credit Time Served
Disposition Date
Feb 14, 2022

Jan 15, 2022 - Charges Filed - Cocainepossession​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 15, 2022
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Cocainepossession
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
89313006A1
Case Type
Felony Third Degree
Case Number
132022CF0007810001XX
Arrest Date
Jan 14, 2022
Court Name
County And Circuit
Fines
$668.00
Disposition
Conv W/Cts
Disposition Date
Feb 14, 2022

Jan 14, 2022 - Charges Filed - Cocaine/ Possession​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 14, 2022
Charge Category
Arrest
Offense Description
Cocaine/ Possession
Counts
1
Arrest Date
Jan 14, 2022

Jan 5, 2011 - Charges Filed - Battery/Aggravated​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 5, 2011
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Battery/Aggravated
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
784.045
Case Type
Second Degree Felony
Case Number
F11000265
Arrest Date
Jan 3, 2011
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence
Disposition Date
Jun 28, 2011

Jan 5, 2011 - Charges Filed - Battery/Aggravated​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 5, 2011
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Battery/Aggravated
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
132011CF0002650001XX
Arrest Date
Jan 3, 2011
Court Name
County And Circuit
Fines
$753.00
Disposition
Conv And Sent
Disposition Date
Jun 28, 2011

Dec 2, 2004 - Charges Filed - Tamper With Physical Evidence​

Charges Filed Date
Dec 2, 2004
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Tamper With Physical Evidence
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
918.13(1)(A)
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F04035805
Arrest Date
Dec 1, 2004
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence
Disposition Date
Dec 22, 2004

Dec 2, 2004 - Charges Filed - Tamper/Phys Evidence​

Charges Filed Date
Dec 2, 2004
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Tamper/Phys Evidence
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
132004CF0358050001XX
Arrest Date
Dec 1, 2004
Court Name
County And Circuit
Disposition
Conv And Sent
Disposition Date
Dec 22, 2004

Mar 25, 2004 - Charges Filed - Cocaine/Possession​

Charges Filed Date
Mar 25, 2004
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Cocaine/Possession
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
893.13(6)(A)
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F04009349
Arrest Date
Mar 24, 2004
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence Concurrent
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Mar 25, 2004 - Charges Filed - Cocaine/Possession​

Charges Filed Date
Mar 25, 2004
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Cocaine/Possession
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
132004CF0093490001XX
Arrest Date
Mar 24, 2004
Court Name
County And Circuit
Disposition
Conv & Sent-Concur
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Burglary/Unoccupied Conveyance​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Burglary/Unoccupied Conveyance
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
810.02(4)(B)
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F97004209
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence Concurrent
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Burglary Tools/Possession​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Burglary Tools/Possession
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
810.06
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F97004209
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence Concurrent
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Probation Violation​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Probation Violation
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
948.061
Case Type
Z 0
Case Number
F97004209
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Disposition
Probation Revoked
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Grand Theft 3rd Deg/$300+/-5000​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Grand Theft 3rd Deg/$300+/-5000
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
812.014(2)(C)1
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F97004209
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence Concurrent
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Grand Theft 3rd Degree/Vehicle​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Grand Theft 3rd Degree/Vehicle
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
812.014(2)(C)6
Case Type
Third Degree Felony
Case Number
F97004209
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Disposition
Conviction And Sentence
Disposition Date
Apr 14, 2004

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Burglary Tools/Posn​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Burglary Tools/Possession
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
131997CF0042090001XX
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Court Name
County And Circuit
Probation
001 Years, 00 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Conv & Sent-Concur
Disposition Date
Aug 21, 2002

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Burglary/Unocc Convy​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Burglary/Unocc Convy
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
131997CF0042090001XX
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Court Name
County And Circuit
Probation
001 Years, 00 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Conv & Sent-Concur
Disposition Date
Aug 21, 2002

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Grd Theft/3d/Vehicle​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Grd Theft/3d/Vehicle
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
131997CF0042090001XX
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Court Name
County And Circuit
Probation
001 Years, 00 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Conv And Sent
Disposition Date
Aug 21, 2002

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Grd Thft/3d/300+/-5k​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Grd Thft/3d/300+/-5k
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
131997CF0042090001XX
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Court Name
County And Circuit
Probation
001 Years, 00 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Conv & Sent-Concur
Disposition Date
Aug 21, 2002

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Probation Violation​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Probation Violation
Case Type
Felony
Case Number
131997CF0042090001XX
Arrest Date
Feb 5, 1997
Court Name
County And Circuit
Probation
001 Years, 00 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Probation Revoked

Feb 5, 1997 - Charges Filed - Probation Violation​

Charges Filed Date
Feb 5, 1997
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Probation Violation
Case Type
Misc Hold
Case Number
F-97-004209
Court Name
Regjb - Justice Building, Room No.:
Disposition
Probation Revoked
Disposition Date
Aug 21, 2002

Jun 11, 1994 - Offense -​

Offense Date
Jun 11, 1994
Charges Filed Date
Jun 12, 1994
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Operating Without Valid License
Counts
1
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
322.03(1)
Case Type
Second Degree Misdemeanor
Case Number
94013045TC10A
Arrest Date
Jun 11, 1994
Court Name
Lauderdale By The Sea
Plea
Magistrate Nolo Contendere
Disposition
Convicted By Plea - Adjudication Withheld
Disposition Date
Jun 12, 1994

Jun 12, 1994 - Charges Filed -​

Charges Filed Date
Jun 12, 1994
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Case Type
Criminal Traffic
Case Number
94013045TC10A
Arrest Date
Jun 11, 1994

Jun 11, 1994 - Offense -​

Offense Date
Jun 11, 1994
Charges Filed Date
Jun 12, 1994
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Fail Register Vehicle
Counts
2
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
320.02(1)
Case Type
Traffic Criminal Mm2
Case Number
94013045TC10A
Arrest Date
Jun 11, 1994
Plea
Magistrate Nolo Contendere
Disposition
Adjudication Withheld
Disposition Date
Jun 12, 1994

Jan 17, 1990 - Charges Filed - Assault And Battery/County Ordinance​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 17, 1990
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Assault And Battery/County Ordinance
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
21-81(A)
Case Type
C 0
Case Number
M90000892
Arrest Date
Jan 16, 1990
Disposition
Conviction - Salvation Army Probation
Disposition Date
Jan 17, 1990

Jan 17, 1990 - Charges Filed - Assault And Battery​

Charges Filed Date
Jan 17, 1990
Crime Location
Miami-Dade, FL
Charge Category
Criminal
Offense Description
Assault And Battery
Case Type
County Ordinance
Case Number
131990CO0008920001XX
Arrest Date
Jan 16, 1990
Court Name
County And Circuit
Fines
$0.00
Probation
000 Years, 06 Months, 000 Days
Disposition
Conv/Salv Army Prob
Disposition Date
Mar 7, 1990

May 14, 1987 - Charges Filed - Prostitution/County Ordinance​

Charges Filed Date
May 14, 1987
Charge Category
Criminal/Traffic
Offense Description
Prostitution/County Ordinance
National Crime Information Center (NCIC) Code
21-81(A)
Case Type
C 0
Case Number
B87200225
Arrest Date
May 14, 1987
Disposition
Adjudication Withheld With Fine & Cost
Disposition Date
Jun 5, 1987
 

Andreee

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2018
Messages
2,772
Reaction score
12,799
LG history short version

Charges Filed Date​

Jan 15, 2022

Charges/Offenses​

Cocaine/Possession | Cocainepossession | Cocaine/ Possession | Battery/Aggravated | Battery/Aggravated | Tamper With Physical Evidence | Tamper/Phys Evidence | Cocaine/Possession | Cocaine/Possession | Burglary/Unoccupied Conveyance | Burglary Tools/Possession | Probation Violation | Grand Theft 3rd Deg/$300+/-5000 | Grand Theft 3rd Degree/Vehicle | Burglary Tools/Possession | Burglary/Unocc Convy | Grd Theft/3d/Vehicle | Grd Thft/3d/300+/-5k | Probation Violation | Probation Violation | Operating Without Valid License | Fail Register Vehicle | Assault And Battery/County Ordinance | Assault And Battery | Prostitution/County Ordinance
Prostitution/County Ordinance? Surely more like a 'seeker' ?
 

Laughing

Rarely Speechless
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
13,466
Reaction score
46,979
Prostitution/County Ordinance? Surely more like a 'seeker' ?

Maybe this county recognizes this as a two-part crime?
Was he involved in, ah, procurement, scheduling, pimping?

IIRC, unfortunately, women become involved in prostitution to fund their drug habits?

Although this guy does not have Distribution on his lengthy list.

jmho ymmv lrr
 

Vern

Well-Known Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2017
Messages
1,227
Reaction score
9,332
Argghhh, I have missed the developments with this 'treat' of a POI. I don't know why as I am 'watching' this thread yet got no notifications for it.

I am going to have to spark up my old laptop and see if I didn't save a copy of that photo from her crackbook way back when. I may have as I tend to do that when something really piques my interest and Dianne's couch photo certainly did.

I somehow think that if this is our guy -- he never served a day in Thule, Greenland as he doesn't seem to have an single iota of military discipline in his body. And, Thule's not exactly the kind of place where one can feed a nasty coke habit at the drop of a hat. I could walk the place end-to-end in 15 minutes. What a tool.

Vern
 

MadMcGoo

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Nov 1, 2018
Messages
8,096
Reaction score
26,859
Well I have arrived. Better late than never. I say in jest as I have nothing to add. :D

This is a riveting case and you all are rockstars!! I wish there was a way to have this thread in the Unidentified forum as well. Technically PRH is both missing and unidentified. Hmm. I may ask to see what, if anything, can be done.
 

Andreee

Well-Known Member
Joined
Sep 22, 2018
Messages
2,772
Reaction score
12,799
Well I have arrived. Better late than never. I say in jest as I have nothing to add. :D

This is a riveting case and you all are rockstars!! I wish there was a way to have this thread in the Unidentified forum as well. Technically PRH is both missing and unidentified. Hmm. I may ask to see what, if anything, can be done.
Welcome to our curious and lighthearted corner here on WS! We joke and jest, but we really want to know who this 'Harrod' guy really is! And our detective is on the hunt as well! :)
 

Laughing

Rarely Speechless
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
13,466
Reaction score
46,979
Well I have arrived. Better late than never. I say in jest as I have nothing to add. :D

This is a riveting case and you all are rockstars!! I wish there was a way to have this thread in the Unidentified forum as well. Technically PRH is both missing and unidentified. Hmm. I may ask to see what, if anything, can be done.

Glad to see you here! Fresh eyes are good!

Have we missed anything? Do you have any Air Force contacts from other threads? Indiana contacts?

We're listening!

(So far, I haven't added any awful poems to this thread. Maybe we're due?)

jmho ymmv lrr
 

MadMcGoo

Moderator
Staff member
Moderator
Joined
Nov 1, 2018
Messages
8,096
Reaction score
26,859
Y’all have done amazing work here over the past several years! Last night I spent several hours browsing newspaper archives for Diane/Diana/Donna Rae and marriage or divorce records, but every groom’s name I searched in yearbooks led me not to PRH. I don’t know why that seemed to me a good place to start.

I can’t think of any AF or IN contacts off hand. I’ll definitely tag them if I can remember one. I’ll keep poking around newspapers and see if I stumble across anything.

After reading through every post last night I came away thinking of Rasmussen. I wondered if maybe PRH was a chameleon of sorts for reasons such as his. Just thinking out loud a little.

And please Laughing keep the poems coming! :D
 

Laughing

Rarely Speechless
Joined
Jan 4, 2010
Messages
13,466
Reaction score
46,979
Our poster @MadMcGoo
logs on when there's something to do
with Google and keystrokes
chasing bodies and blokes
You're missing? They'll be looking for YOU!



You left Indiana: Thanksgiving.
Your wife didn't notice 'til May.
You claimed that you served in the Air Force,
Not-Paul, did you just fly away?

Not-Paul, Not-Paul, Not-Paul where can you be, you be?
Not-Paul, Not-Paul, oh Not-Paul, where can you be?

Nobody knows where you came from.
Step-son didn't like you a bit.
Someone sold your car off in Denver,
Is this just your big hissy fit?

Not-Paul, Not-Paul, Not-Paul where can you be, you be?
Not-Paul, Not-Paul, oh Not-Paul, where can you be?


Bad enough for ya?

jmho ymmv lrr
 
Last edited:

summergirl1

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 23, 2018
Messages
150
Reaction score
504
This is certainly an interesting case. Some things that stood out to me was the mistake about the name of his mother on the marriage license and also maybe why he might have had a false identity. He said he was Italian and Colletti is an Italian last name so while that is obviously not his real last name, perhaps his real name or his mother's maiden name were similar and while trying to recall his fake mother's last name which started with a C he put an Italian last name though the real Paul's mother didn't have an Italian last name. Or maybe he did that to support him saying he was Italian to his new wife. Hmm. And there's lots of Italians in New York State etc so that would fit with him really having Italian blood. Of course, some Italians are associated with the Mafia and crime families too..As to why he might have had a fake ID, he might not have been running from anything at all or at least nothing really bad. Two well known cases involving fake IDs are Lori Ruff and Joseph Chandler. Neither of them were running from anything really bad as far as is currently known. She had mental health and probably family issues, but that was all. She was just an ordinary woman from Pennsylvania. As for "Joseph Chandler" he also had mental health issues although he probably was using a false ID because he was running from paying child support to his family he left behind( when he was using his real name). This guy too may have had a false ID just because he had issues with child support or some other not really noteworthy debt. Fake IDs in these types of cases usually ended up being associated with more mundane issues than the Mafia or criminals wanted by the FBI or something or even anything really criminal at all. That's not to say this case maybe different but perhaps this guy just had mental health and child support or minor debt issues or some family issues he was running from or felt like he had to- in his perception. Perhaps his head injury at one time affected his thinking or it was just mental health issues. It's intriguing he didn't lie when asked by his wife about the scar on his head, but rather refused to discuss it. Why not just lie when he lied about so much else? He must have known his wife would wonder. It may have been an innocent injury and not from anything criminal, though. Hopefully this case gets solved one day. Those using the names of dead kids..was there somewhere they could get those names from other than on their own especially in pre internet days? I believe I have read there was. If "Paul Herrod" is still living, this case may not be solved until he dies and it's discovered he had been using or had used in the past fake IDs or a fake ID. This is a long thread, but from my reading through it, those were my impressions.
 
Last edited:

chaz

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 29, 2016
Messages
403
Reaction score
2,987
I first thought the fake PRH looked younger than he said he was but he could have been older.
What do you guys think of this man?


Maybe he's too old? Ithink there's a resemblance.
 
Top