ACTIVE SEARCH JAPAN - Patricia "Pattie" Wu-Murad, 60, US Citizen, on hiking trip Kumano Kodo Trail, didn't arr next stop Osaka, 10 Apr 2023

Update from daughter
New update from Murphy:

On May 24 I flew to Japan to meet with our fourth wave of search and rescue specialists from the US. We managed to find a five day window with little to no rain to maximize our time before typhoon season hit. Six of the seven members had been a part of at least one or more of our previous teams. Their familiarity with the terrain and ongoing knowledge of our case allowed for a precise and efficient trip.

During our time in Japan we worked closely with Mountain Works, our local SAR team. The American team focused largely on filling in the gaps around Miura-toge pass and exploring drainages off the main trail that had yet to be covered. Simultaneously, Mountain Works spent their time covering as much new territory as possible on an alternate route north of the main trail head. Both teams were out in the field for 9+ hours per day, tirelessly covering miles upon miles of ground, and thoroughly investigating numerous possibilities to unravel the mystery surrounding my mother’s disappearance.

Meanwhile, I was able to meet with the local police and gather information from different sources. The telecommunication companies have said they are unable to track Patricia’s E-sim because it is not a Japanese number. Both my family and the prefectural police have countered asking if the telecommunication companies are unable to track any foreign SIM cards which is highly unlikely and incredibly problematic. We are still pushing for this information through the National Police and the FBI.

The Gojo police confronted the man who had invited a New York native to his home on April 20 to practice English and he has been deemed unsuspicious. It turns out he was not targeting solo female hikers, and instead was confronting any man, woman, or couple that seemingly spoke English. His alibi on April 10 was confirmed and was relatively far from the village where Patricia went missing.

We were able to get in contact with the trail runners who were running the Kohechi route on April 10 and unfortunately their detailed report did not provide any new information or suggestions as to Pattie’s whereabouts. We were also able to obtain information regarding nearby construction along the Kohechi trail and there was no known activity conducted on the day of my mother’s disappearance. At this point, the police are unable to provide any leads regarding criminal behavior but will provide the family with biweekly reports.

At the end of each day, Mountain Works would conduct debriefing sessions with the American team and me, providing detailed explanations of their daily progress and engaging in collaborative discussions to strategize for the upcoming day. Despite everyone’s dedicated efforts, at the end of our five day window we were unable to find any new leads.

On our final night, each member of the search team expressed their individual perspectives and reflections regarding our collective search efforts: This is the largest search effort the Japanese team has ever seen. One of our American members said this is the most ground he’s ever seen covered for a single case and expressed admiration for the exceptional accuracy exhibited by every group that had participated in the search. Two members from the US said based on the extensive work that had been completed, their respective organizations would not have allocated any additional resources because of how well everything was organized and covered. If we had the time, resources and financial capacity to search every trail in the area with as much depth and precision as we did this one, we would. However, the reality is all search efforts have stopped as of May 30 due to the underwhelming amount of evidence found.

As heartbreaking as it is to have come up empty handed, all of these comments are thanks to you. The amount of work we were able to accomplish would not have been possible without the unwavering support of our family, friends, community, and the remarkable individuals we encountered in Totsukawa.

Any additional funds will be set aside in the event we find new information regarding Pattie’s case. Members of Mountain Works have agreed to continue as volunteers if any new leads arise. We will no longer accept new donations on our after June 10, marking the two month anniversary of Pattie’s disappearance.

To anyone who donated even a penny to our funds, thank you. To everyone who sent myself or my family heartfelt messages along the way, thank you. To all the communities that gave my family strength during this time, thank you. To our family friends who were in Japan at the time of Pattie’s disappearance and played a pivotal role in the initial days of organizing this entire ordeal, thank you. To the local police for bringing resources outside of their jurisdiction to help aid in our search efforts, thank you. To all of our local and international volunteers, thank you. To the men and women that put everything on hold to fly out and tackle the unforgiving terrain to help find Pattie, thank you. To our extended family that worked behind the scenes running social media, getting our story out, and helping us garner support from US government officials, thank you. To Mountain Works, Hora and Yamada, for putting the most substantial amount of time out on the trail over the past 50 days, thank you. To our new friends turned family in Totsukawa, who provided support directly to myself and my family, thank you. We are deeply indebted to everyone’s kindness and generosity.

And finally, to Mom, thank you. All these people came together because of the profound influence you have had on our family and the impact you have had on so many different people around the world. In a time of chaos, thank you for reigniting everyone’s faith in humanity. Thank you for instilling in us the strength and resilience to keep moving forward each and every day without you by our side. Thank you for bringing us together with such incredible people, you have shown us the true essence of why you love these trips so much.

We love you Mama. Thank you for being you.
This end of this post has me in tears.
 
Family of missing Storrs woman suspends search in Japan after almost two months

The Murads are still trying to get data from Wu-Murad’s cel phone, which so far they’ve been unable to do. According to Murphy’s post, “the telecommunication companies have said they are unable to track Patricia’s E-sim because it is not a Japanese number.”


“There’s got to be something,” Murad said. “Cel phones are always searching out the nearest tower even if you’re not using your phone. If her phone was on, up until the battery died, there should be a tower that we can reference and we could pinpoint the search a little bit more.”

============


IMO if the law allows, for the sake of the investigation, all cell phone activity in this relatively small area should be monitored, at least for the morning when Pattie disappeared.
If Pattie was taken and abducted by car, or if she simply hitched a ride, her cell phone might move in sync with the phone of whoever is involved. This is basic police work, why isn't it happening?
 
Family of missing Storrs woman suspends search in Japan after almost two months

The Murads are still trying to get data from Wu-Murad’s cel phone, which so far they’ve been unable to do. According to Murphy’s post, “the telecommunication companies have said they are unable to track Patricia’s E-sim because it is not a Japanese number.”


“There’s got to be something,” Murad said. “Cel phones are always searching out the nearest tower even if you’re not using your phone. If her phone was on, up until the battery died, there should be a tower that we can reference and we could pinpoint the search a little bit more.”

============


IMO if the law allows, for the sake of the investigation, all cell phone activity in this relatively small area should be monitored, at least for the morning when Pattie disappeared.
If Pattie was taken and abducted by car, or if she simply hitched a ride, her cell phone might move in sync with the phone of whoever is involved. This is basic police work, why isn't it happening?
What if Pattie had her iphone in airplane mode? Doesn’t airplane mode prevent the phone from making connections to cell towers? I think many people would put one’s phone in that mode while in another country to avoid battery power, plus cell phone charges.

(I admit to not understanding how these things work, but from my limited understanding, so MOO)
 
What if Pattie had her iphone in airplane mode? Doesn’t airplane mode prevent the phone from making connections to cell towers? I think many people would put one’s phone in that mode while in another country to avoid battery power, plus cell phone charges.

(I admit to not understanding how these things work, but from my limited understanding, so MOO)

If LE does not investigate the cell phone data, we will never know what Pattie did or didn't do. The family has also requested info from Google Maps - and Google maps does work in airplane mode. Maps uses GPS data from satellite.

From the update of April 17 2023 on the GF page:

Other information to note: the last known text message exchange with Pattie was with me, Murphy. I received a message on Sunday, April 9 @ 8:02 AM (JST) and responded 40 minutes later and the message sent through. The earliest known text message that was not delivered to her phone was from a family friend on Wednesday, April 12 @ 2:53 AM (JST).

Murphy also writes:

**If you were in contact with my mom and have had any message interactions that fall between these dates and times PLEASE CONTACT ME DIRECTLY!**

I haven't seen any other news about the phone contacts between Sunday April 9 (last known message that went though) and Wednesday April 12, (first known message that was not delivered).

Pattie was last seen on April 10th checking out of the Mandokoro guesthouse at about 7am. We don't know if she left later in the morning the previous day, but it is also possible that she left around the same time both on Sunday and Monday and on Sunday was using her phone while on her way, sending a text message that arrived at 8.02 AM (JST). This might indicate IMO that she did not switch the phone to airplane mode (if she did that) until later. And hopefully also on Monday.

The other thing about cell phone data is that they may indicate what phones were near the Mandokoro guesthouse, the bridge and the crossing at the time when Pattie would have been there. And how they moved through the area.

It is so frustrating! The family do their best, they go every extra mile, they investigate CCTV (almost non-existent), they locate those trail runners, and all the while, the technology is available to generate far more and accurate information. But the phone company denies that this is the case. Perhaps they are being polite. I do hope the FBI can figure it all out. Soon.
 
If LE does not investigate the cell phone data, we will never know what Pattie did or didn't do. The family has also requested info from Google Maps - and Google maps does work in airplane mode. Maps uses GPS data from satellite.

From the update of April 17 2023 on the GF page:

Other information to note: the last known text message exchange with Pattie was with me, Murphy. I received a message on Sunday, April 9 @ 8:02 AM (JST) and responded 40 minutes later and the message sent through. The earliest known text message that was not delivered to her phone was from a family friend on Wednesday, April 12 @ 2:53 AM (JST).

Murphy also writes:

**If you were in contact with my mom and have had any message interactions that fall between these dates and times PLEASE CONTACT ME DIRECTLY!**

I haven't seen any other news about the phone contacts between Sunday April 9 (last known message that went though) and Wednesday April 12, (first known message that was not delivered).

Pattie was last seen on April 10th checking out of the Mandokoro guesthouse at about 7am. We don't know if she left later in the morning the previous day, but it is also possible that she left around the same time both on Sunday and Monday and on Sunday was using her phone while on her way, sending a text message that arrived at 8.02 AM (JST). This might indicate IMO that she did not switch the phone to airplane mode (if she did that) until later. And hopefully also on Monday.

The other thing about cell phone data is that they may indicate what phones were near the Mandokoro guesthouse, the bridge and the crossing at the time when Pattie would have been there. And how they moved through the area.

It is so frustrating! The family do their best, they go every extra mile, they investigate CCTV (almost non-existent), they locate those trail runners, and all the while, the technology is available to generate far more and accurate information. But the phone company denies that this is the case. Perhaps they are being polite. I do hope the FBI can figure it all out. Soon.
I think the family used WhatsApp to communicate with each other, and those text messages are sent over the internet, rather than through a cellular network. I believe one can make voice calls and video calls through it, as well.

I’m very non-techy, so my understanding of how it works is minimal, so throwing an eSIM into the mixture and I don’t know how that affects how Pattie would have her iPhone settings configured for this trip.

JMO from non-techy me! :p
 
I don't know exactly how Pattie had her phone configured, but I did previously work with computer servers--though I'm not verified as an IT expert on websleuths, and likely never will be, so I'll add the necessary IMO before I say anything else.

Basically, any time a computer (which is what a modern smart phone is) can connect to an outside system, be it a cell phone network, a WiFi network, a satellite network, a Bluetooth network, whatever kind of network... there will be logs of that on the systems that were connected to. Assuming Pattie's phone wasn't turned off, or out of range and unable to connect, there WILL be records. Any text would be logged. Any call would be logged. Any cell tower ping would be logged. Any GPS location would be logged. Any accessing of Google Maps would logged. Etc., etc.

It's a matter of getting the people who hold those records to share them with you. And as Pattie's family are finding out, that's easier said than done.

When the Japanese companies say they can't track foreign numbers, I genuinely think that might be more of a legal or even diplomatic issue than a technical one. Assuming they haven't already done so, if Pattie's family could get the US Government to speak to the Japanese phone companies and reach some kind of agreement, I wonder if that would help at all.
 
I think the family used WhatsApp to communicate with each other, and those text messages are sent over the internet, rather than through a cellular network. I believe one can make voice calls and video calls through it, as well.
Not quite. WhatsApp messages are sent over whichever data service you are connected to, be it your WiFi or your cell phone service provider.
 
I don't know exactly how Pattie had her phone configured, but I did previously work with computer servers--though I'm not verified as an IT expert on websleuths, and likely never will be, so I'll add the necessary IMO before I say anything else.

Basically, any time a computer (which is what a modern smart phone is) can connect to an outside system, be it a cell phone network, a WiFi network, a satellite network, a Bluetooth network, whatever kind of network... there will be logs of that on the systems that were connected to. Assuming Pattie's phone wasn't turned off, or out of range and unable to connect, there WILL be records. Any text would be logged. Any call would be logged. Any cell tower ping would be logged. Any GPS location would be logged. Any accessing of Google Maps would logged. Etc., etc.

It's a matter of getting the people who hold those records to share them with you. And as Pattie's family are finding out, that's easier said than done.

When the Japanese companies say they can't track foreign numbers, I genuinely think that might be more of a legal or even diplomatic issue than a technical one. Assuming they haven't already done so, if Pattie's family could get the US Government to speak to the Japanese phone companies and reach some kind of agreement, I wonder if that would help at all.
Reminds me of the Murdaugh case, where GM insisted for almost two years that data from his truck wasn't available - and then suddenly, towards the end of the trial, it was supplied.

I speculated at the time that someone at GM became fascinated by the trial, and went ahead and did what they needed to hack out the data. Once it was on record, outside the massive data system, GM legally couldn't withold it.

JMO
 
"Is she lost? Did she fall? Is she a victim of a crime?" Murad said. "All three are still being considered. My gut says she trusted the wrong person, but I have no evidence."

I've been thinking of this lady and I am wondering at what exactly she communicated to friends and family since her commencement of the trip?
Is there anything at all, even very subtle that is out of sync with who she is and what she was doing?
Even the slightest clue?

It's all probably been looked at already but might be an idea to publish every message she sent to every friend?
Grasping at straws here because she has not been found by very experienced searchers and that might indicate she is alive and held captive?

Long shot, I know?
 
So sad to read Kirk was going to go to Spain this year with Pattie, with Pattie wanting Kirk to experience the Camino de Santiago.
First I read about this
‘Her toe was giving her problems’
Was this to the point when walking might be painful so perhaps wanting a short day walking allowing the toe to heal hence the possibility of Pattie wanting a lift? I thought it was a few days before Kirk spoke to Pattie so I guess there was no updated condition of a Patties toe.
 
Last edited:
4 days planned on being off grid.
Sore toe.
He's probably right, she never got on that trail at all, did she?
I wonder what other tourists were in the area at the time?
Might be worth the time to interview all locals again because nobody can be invisible so if somebody suspicious was around at least someone would have seen them?
 
So sad to read Kirk was going to go to Spain this year with Pattie, with Pattie wanting Kirk to experience the Camino de Santiago.
First I read about this
‘Her toe was giving her problems’
Was this to the point when walking might be painful so perhaps wanting a short day walking allowing the toe to heal hence the possibility of Pattie wanting a lift? I thought it was a few days before Kirk spoke to Pattie so I guess there was no updated condition of a Patties toe.
Yet the innkeeper‘s perception of Pattie as she left that morning was that she was “full of energy”. If her toe was bothering her too much, JMO but I’d think she’d be walking with a limp, slower, and perhaps with a pained, wincing expression on her face.

I don’t know her, of course, but the impression I get of Pattie is that she took these pilgrimages seriously and really was excited to obtain that Dual Pilgrim certificate and status. So, I feel like she would have finished walking that Kohechi trail (necessary requirement for the Dual Pilgrim).

There’s a Japanese word: “gaman”, which I think has a meaning similar to “just tough it out”. That’s how I imagine Pattie’s attitude would be. JMO
 
There’s a Japanese word: “gaman”, which I think has a meaning similar to “just tough it out”. That’s how I imagine Pattie’s attitude would be. JMO
SBM
From Wikipedia: Gaman (我慢) is a Japanese term of Zen Buddhist origin which means "enduring the seemingly unbearable with patience and dignity". The term is generally translated as "perseverance", "patience", or "tolerance". A related term, gamanzuyoi (我慢強い, gaman-tsuyoi), a compound with tsuyoi (strong), means "suffering the unbearable" or having a high capacity for a kind of stoic endurance.
 
Yet the innkeeper‘s perception of Pattie as she left that morning was that she was “full of energy”. If her toe was bothering her too much, JMO but I’d think she’d be walking with a limp, slower, and perhaps with a pained, wincing expression on her face.

I don’t know her, of course, but the impression I get of Pattie is that she took these pilgrimages seriously and really was excited to obtain that Dual Pilgrim certificate and status. So, I feel like she would have finished walking that Kohechi trail (necessary requirement for the Dual Pilgrim).

There’s a Japanese word: “gaman”, which I think has a meaning similar to “just tough it out”. That’s how I imagine Pattie’s attitude would be. JMO
she could have been refreshed after a night's sleep and toe might not have hurt again until she started walking on it.?
Someone came along in a vehicle, noticed she was limping or had stopped to address the toe issue?
I'm wondering at the nature of the toe injury?
Thinking possibly a cut that got infected? Tetanus? Anything?
 
The information about Pattie having a sore toe is the kind of information it would have been helpful to know two months ago. If Pattie had been struggling to complete the previous hikes, that's crucial information; a bad toe could affect balance on narrow trails, but would also be a good reason for hitching a lift or catching a bus.

It opens up a number of possibilities that might have previously seemed more unlikely.

I'd previously questioned how Pattie was ahead of schedule on trails with clearly marked day-by-day sections and guesthouses. If there's a chance she hadn't walked all of her previously planned routes (whether hitching or skipping sections entirely), that might explain a lot.

We don't know if Pattie had hitched a lift previously, but her family might know. And that's information they should have shared earlier, IMO.
 
Yet the innkeeper‘s perception of Pattie as she left that morning was that she was “full of energy”. If her toe was bothering her too much, JMO but I’d think she’d be walking with a limp, slower, and perhaps with a pained, wincing expression on her face.

I don’t know her, of course, but the impression I get of Pattie is that she took these pilgrimages seriously and really was excited to obtain that Dual Pilgrim certificate and status. So, I feel like she would have finished walking that Kohechi trail (necessary requirement for the Dual Pilgrim).

There’s a Japanese word: “gaman”, which I think has a meaning similar to “just tough it out”. That’s how I imagine Pattie’s attitude would be. JMO

Pilgrims on the Spanish Caminos will walk on with knees that hurt, feet that hurt, legs that hurt, shoes with a bad fit, broken glasses taped together, whatever. One toe is nothing in that respect. They will walk on.
Especially pilgrims from the US will take painkillers like Ibuprofen on a daily basis for weeks if they have to, like candy or even as prevention. Don't know if Pattie did the same, of course.

Often, the pain will disappear during the night, because rest is healing. So the person leaves refreshed and (almost) pain-free the next morning and during the day, the pain will return, and they'll grind their teeth until their destination. And repeat.

Pattie was half-way her pilgrimage on the Kohechi, with only two days to go. That one toe would not have stopped her.
 

Members online

Online statistics

Members online
209
Guests online
3,383
Total visitors
3,592

Forum statistics

Threads
591,828
Messages
17,959,741
Members
228,621
Latest member
Greer∆
Back
Top